She Finds Her FAMILY MURDERED When She Walks Through The Door 

Who’s wanting Peyton to do an extra long episode 🙋🏻‍♀️ 🙋🏻‍♀️

As a mental health therapist I recommended social media breaks to all my clients of every age. I have not had social media for multiple years and the overall benefit it has had in my life is beautiful. There are so many layers to our society’s addiction to social media and, I commend you for bringing the topic to your audience. Screens, technology and such easy access to a “reality” with no rules and simulated human interactions has had and continues to have a profound impact on humanity. Be present and as your detox continues pay special attention to changes in your mental health and internal dialogue. Be Well♥️

I love the little cut scene at the beginning. The feel of this show has shifted but you seem so much happier and enthusiastic!!

The natural movement to open a social media app is insane. I’ll open my phone w the intent of sending/responding to a text, but instead will open TikTok or Instagram. It’s so annoying and has sometimes caused me to forget why I opened my phone to begin w

I'm glad you shine a light on the unsolved cases. It might get someone who knows something to say something. I almost need a trigger warning for the unsolved cases. So I won't be so disappointed when I find out.

Your social media reflection. So aligned with lessons I’m learning currently. It’s giving “and I hate it”

Thank you for this video, Payton! I lived in Tallahassee back then and was 14 years old when this happened and remember it well. I was even a member of the First Baptist Church but didn’t know the Simms family. Yours is the first video I’ve seen about this case and you actually answered some questions I’ve always had, so thank you. You do such a great job telling these stories and I watch them frequently, but this one obviously grabbed my attention. Yes, we were a terrified community back then, and life changed forever after that horrific night. P.S. You might also want to highlight the murders of two high school girls at a place called Blue Sink in Tallahassee not too long after the Simms murders. The case was solved so you won’t keep viewers/listeners disappointed. 😮 Make my day, Payton!

Love you Peyton! Love MWMH and Into the Dark! You and Garrett are so adorable!❤

Great (sad) case! Thanks for putting your brand of respect on it! I love how you treat the people and the story!

I’m so happy I discovered both of your shows! You’re an amazing story teller!

Payton, I love watching both of your shows. I watch and listen every night am addicted to listening to your stories 😂😊

Found you recently and you’re one of my new favs

So happy to be here!!! Can’t wait to hear you tell us what happened! I totally agree about socially media. I FINALLY dropped out of ALL social media 3 whole months ago and feel like an entirely new person 😳 I was soooo afraid to do it!

I completely agree with being addicted to social media. I will just pick up my phone and open an app in the middle of doing something with out even thinking. It's crazy

Literally love your channel been binging youuu 😊 please , do more longer yt videos love you though 🎉

I love your channel! I’m trying to catch up by watching all the past videos!❤

Wow thank you for covering this case Peyton, this is the first I’m hearing of it! I got chills when you said 911 wasn’t a thing at the time, I can’t imagine. Like I’m a 27 year old adult and if I walked into a scene like that I wouldn’t know what to do besides call 911. I hope the two daughters were able to move forward and live happy fulfilling lives after such a tragedy! ❤️‍🩹

Love listening to you. Came here from MWMH. I actually got my dad to start listening to both podcasts.

Waiting for a post is torture I love this show. Apart from listening to podcasts I haven’t been on social media for a month. One of my friends even called today to find out because she has been tagging me on stuff and getting no respond.

Love MWMH. My wife and I watch your stuff all the time. Keep up the good content! Tell Garrett to get to training for that marathon!

Yes yes EXTRA long episode!!!! 🎉❤ ⭐️ 🌟

Hello Payton! Love the direction your solo podcast has gone☺️

i have been seeing clips of mwmh on tiktok with those satisfying videos stitched to it and i feel like that’s how you know you’re successful

Yes! I literally have the same problem 😂 my fingers automatically swipe and click on my social media folder without thinking. It’s honestly so wild lol

I’ve been waiting for this video all week long!!!!

Love your channel. From Glendale, Arizona.

Peyton, love your show. I always wait to listen to your shows when I have time to really pay attention.

Never miss an episode of your podcasts. ❤

Uuuu i love the vibez of the set today💜💖💜💖💜 love the blanket and the cactus 🌵

I’ve been enjoying all three of your podcast thank you!!

I tell all my friends to watch or listen ❤️❤️ love all your shows

Thanks for the upload ❤

Thank you!

peyton does it again! you are such an amazing storyteller. keep it up🩷🩷

Wow! My city made it to an “Oh No Media!” podcast. Yes, I know its a terrible true crime story but it still cool to me! I definitely shared this episode with everyone I know😂.

Love from Cambodia 😊❤ loving these stories.

I like your videos. Always interesting.

Love the new iteration of this!

Hahah loved the Avatar in the beginning...super cool somewhere between mortisia and Wednesday

Heyyy Paton! Love listening to you nightly.

Thumbs up always!! Love getting the notifications from you!! ❤

Great episode!

Thanks for the new upload ❤

I agree with you about social media.. I also try to stop!

Omg the way you made it highlight the like button was amazing 😍

Love all you’re videos x

I'm from Iceland 🧡 and hon you can make my day 🥺🧡

I love this podcast as well as MWMH ❤❤

Hi I love your podcast, not sure if you will see this but I noticed episode 17 wasn’t on Spotify anymore. Is there another place I can listen to it? It’s my all time favorite episode, the Lesley sisters are so incredibly brave and I love listening to their story. -also this is for Murder with my Husband, not Into the Dark/Binged

I love you and your story's Peyton!!❤

Very interesting and frustrating case!

Always waiting on the next video

i could listen to you talk all dayyy 🩵

❤❤❤❤❤love all ur shows 🎉🎉🎉🎉

Aye! I’m never this early! I’m so excited 😊

love the podcast peyton keep it up! ❤

Love this show!!

My husband is a first responder and I believe originally/historically the ambulance was also the hearse for the funeral home…maybe that’s why she called them? So sad!

Love you and these videoooos❤️

I love the new intro!

much love to you! Love your shows! 🍑💛😊

I love your shows Peyton

I CLICK ON TO THE VIDEO AS SOON AS I GET A NOTIFICATION FOR ANY OF YOUR OR YOUR MOMS VIDEOS. LOVE Y'ALL

Love the episode!

I spend way too much time on social media during the colder months, during the summer I take my daughter camping, hiking, canoeing etc where there's no signal.

Extra long episode... YESSSS

Your amazing!

Love this!

Wow a real life sims family dang!!

Love your videos.

Great story teller. Love this podcast and murder with my husband 💯🫶🏾

we love you payton!

Omg! The new intro is so good. I like your 10 seconds more 🤍 don’t tell Garret!

Thank you for your 10 seconds. ❤

Love it Peyton!

This case was sooo good

Those poor girls, I hope they were able to have a somewhat nor.al life after losing their parents and sister. The world was a different place back then where people didn't lock their doors because they just didn't think they needed to lock them. I look forward to this podcast and the MWMH podcast. ❤😊

I just have to say, where are the cameras? Ha ha ha.

In my opinion you are the best in the true crime. Your broadcasts are succinct- no long unnecessary words no dramatics like some other females I could name. And thank goodness no long false nails and heavy makeup.

I'm not a tiktok, Instagram, or Facebook person. I have them but rarely use them. I go straight to RU-vid 😂 Wow, the dad looks a lot like Liev Schreiber

COME TOOO CHICAGO ON UR NEXT TOUR PLEASEEEEE😩

Howdy from Texas!

The dad kind of looks like Liev Schreiber

Good episode.

Hey Payton! Just starting the episode! Just wanted to say hey and I appreciate you & your content as always 🙏🩷

I literally deleted tik tok & Instagram about a week and a half ago, and I finally been sleeping earlier. I been getting to sleep more, been less stressed and getting more stuff done.

I’m confused! If she couldn’t call the cops because that wasn’t available yet, how were neighbors able to call the cops to report a peeping Tom four days before the attacks?

A detox sounds like something I also need 😅

I like the ones by yourself so much better

I close TikTok and immediately open it 😂

Hey Girly, just listened to this opening in the podcast and you should look into muscle memory. This could explain some of your subconscious movements with tapping.😉

Mean while, there’s been one murder in my town in Canada in 65 years and that was 65 years ago lol

Love you Peyton I think you are awesome ❤

That’s how I feel about Instagram. I go to it often because I’m bored

Peyton can you do a video on Gerard John Schaefer

Because we love you - here’s a comment and a like 👍🏼

One thing that helped my social media addicted fingers was moving the apps around.

I am on day two of no social media apps on my phone at all. No Facebook no tik Tok no Instagram I deleted myself off of all of it. Yesterday was rainy so I was really bored. But I feel better today

your little avatar is so cute!

There is an actor that looks just like him! Present day actor. Idk his name, but crazy doppelganger!