Shelter Island: A Long Island Vacation Destination 

2 of my ancestors died of starvation on Shelter Island when they escaped religious persecution from the state of Massachusetts. There is a memorial there, not for each individual, as they weren't the only ones who died there. Would have been nice to hear about that. But I guess that doesn't sell million dollar homes

My great grandfather was the governor of New York and he made a giant mansion on Shelter Island I go to it every year, it’s on a creek near the bay

We were never allowed to talk about Shelter Island when I was a kid. Social media is ruining everything.

correction ....by boat.. ferry ..or private plane