Тёмный
No video :(

Sherlock: A Cinematic Journey Through Autism 

Amy Ellen
Подписаться 54
Просмотров 17 тыс.
50% 1

A video essay exploring how the BBC series Sherlock uses cinematic language to portray the character Sherlock as a person on the autism spectrum.
Sherlock is composed of two flexible layers of visuals, one of which replicates the sensory overload Sherlock experiences as a (self-diagnosed) high-functioning sociopath. The dynamic lighting and rich cinematography have become a character that breathes with Sherlock, reflecting his moods and emotions.
The question is, however, is Sherlock really a sociopath?
Delve deeper into this discussion and the world of Sherlock with my accompanying blog: steppingbehind...

Опубликовано:

 

27 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 64   
@xabab
@xabab Год назад
In addition, he has very noticeable symptoms of ADHD, which is often comorbid with ASD He's inattentive, when he's not interested in something (like when he spoke to Watson for several hours, not noticing he has left many hours ago); his thoughts are often "bouncy", quickly changing to tangent subjects; he becomes maniacal (hiperfocused) when something strikes his interest (basically, the whole show); and the most subtle, since he's not taking any meds to contain ADHD, the nicotine, being an indirect norepinephrine and dopamine agonist, actually helps him *_a lot_* to think cleaner, which I heavily relate to. Being a thinker, he craves for it, often using nicotine patches to deal with analysis-heavy tasks and his relationship with cigarettes is a meme in itself etc
@ashleighe253
@ashleighe253 Год назад
this is so me
@somesaysofthands
@somesaysofthands 10 месяцев назад
He also struggles with substance use disorder almost as a self medicating action
@kenzgitz9884
@kenzgitz9884 7 месяцев назад
Honestly with the fact that he uses opium of some sort in the books which would release dopamine which he otherwise gets from working on cases, has cycles of hyperfocusing on cases and either depression or burnout, and only pays attention to things he considers interesting, ADHD makes a lot of sense and it does often co-occur with autism
@kaylacarpenter9658
@kaylacarpenter9658 5 лет назад
He even is referenced as having "Asperger's", in the "Hounds of Baskerville", when John and Greg walk out to talk at the back of the bar.
@4Ninjastarz4
@4Ninjastarz4 Год назад
Nah he doesn't present as aspergers, the manipulative behaviour he displays is typical of a PDA presentation of autism
@shirleynitka5030
@shirleynitka5030 Год назад
John is a lousy doctor. He'll say anything to put Sherlock down & build himself up. He's a fame junkie-john.
@ciel1083
@ciel1083 Год назад
It was confirmed at the end of the series. His sister reprogrammed him.
@emilia2647
@emilia2647 9 месяцев назад
@@ciel1083wait what do you mean?
@shadowz2959
@shadowz2959 2 месяца назад
​@@ciel1083How so?
@4Ninjastarz4
@4Ninjastarz4 Год назад
As a PDA autistic myself, look up PDA autism and you get a list of Sherlock character traits
@starboy3860
@starboy3860 4 года назад
Something else I noticed is when we are viewing through Sherlock's vision/memories to solve the case they are often more yellow. This is actually a lot like my vision. I tend to see yellows, oranges, and reds more brightly due to being autistic. As such I dont really like them and prefer cool colors, which I use in my art more. Sometimes my eyes just can't take a certain shade of red or yellow because it's too bright while others don't see an issue. Oranges are bad because, while the don't get too bright, they get super intense and painful. I use them if I want a color pop for me but I know nobody else can see the shades like I can because I've been told by friends that what I see is different to them. They say the same thing and I say someone different.
@Commie-Comrade
@Commie-Comrade 3 года назад
Um also autistic and experience the same, it's kinda fascinating, isn't it?
@ashleighe253
@ashleighe253 Год назад
same here...
@ladibyrd
@ladibyrd 5 лет назад
Great clip. It's a bit frustrating though, the world is changing, humans are evolving -Autism is not a mental disorder, it's simply a different brain structure, an adaptation.
@amyellen8392
@amyellen8392 5 лет назад
Autism is short for Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Technically speaking, it is a developmental disorder, however in saying that I do agree with your definition of it being a different way of thinking. ‘Disorder’ isn’t a bad word. It just means something that’s structured different really.
@smolopossummaxwell9624
@smolopossummaxwell9624 4 года назад
@@amyellen8392 I once saw a picture which pretty much summs This 'discussion' up. "Autism isn't a processing error, it's a different operating system"
@alexhamilton560
@alexhamilton560 4 года назад
The main problem is that the negative connotation attached to the word "disorder" blinds people of it's actual variance, that of an adaptation to the genetic variation and developed circumstancial differences. However, as the above phase is rather complicated, most don't continue to observe the word and understand the actual condition any further. Such a negative word makes people essentially stop thinking, as the meaning "disorder" is automatically attached (almost subconsciously) to words or synonyms like "mess" or "chaos." At that point, I believe people see no reason to think more on the word. Thus, it hasn't been changed. Highly ironic though, as while words like "retarded" are changed to "mentally slow," words like "disorder" continue to exist. Perhaps "disorder" isn't changed because despite the negative connotations which only serve to outcast certain members of society, the fact still remains that people with disorders are still viewed or looked upon as "like normal" rather than "mentally slow." Just food for thought.
@cameronmcelwee5465
@cameronmcelwee5465 4 года назад
Society was not built for us. That makes it a disability does it not? I'm very confused: On the one hand we are often talking about de-stigmatising mental health and learning difficulties but we shy away from terms such as disorder or disability as if we're ashamed of them. Why? I am autistic, and I consider that to be a disorder, a disability, a condition. That doesn't necessarily make it a bad thing, it just acknowledges that in the present societal format, our existence is not catered for. Acknowledging this is more likely to bring about change, not less.
@alexhamilton560
@alexhamilton560 4 года назад
@@cameronmcelwee5465 to an extent I agree, but still think that by allowing words like "disability" to stay in place it affects the subconscious understanding of the word. Thus granting a continuation of stigma. I'm not PC at all btw. Call me whatever offensive name you want and I won't get offended. But the generalization of a term that's designed as a classification... And is possible to be subconsciously negative, that's a different story. I know that the world doesn't cater to us. Im completely aware of it. But I don't go around telling everyone I've got Asperger's either. Nor do I admit it on those papers we have to sign for job applications. Usually, whenever I did, I'd never get an email back. Or if I told someone at the job, then it would get worse in various ways. There are always loopholes around that law, to not discriminate against people with mental health issues in context of getting or keeping a job. And if someone thinks of us as a liability for the problem we face by assumption, all they have to do to avoid breaking the law is just not say the real reason as to why we are. But this general thought upon liability to a job is generally (if you haven't done anything bad, that is) subconsciously discriminatory. I don't know man. That's just how I feel about it. I know I'm very high functioning and that this thing is a spectrum, but its kinda messed up in a way to be called that. I'm not trying to rant over the rest of us. It's a problem for many of us. The only way that I can get along in society is to never mention what I really am, but I still feel like an outcast. People call me odd or eccentric, and while I'm sort of proud I am, I can never tell them why.
@ellamurray712
@ellamurray712 6 лет назад
Hi, this is just absolutely incredible work and deserves more attention. I love it so much!! Great job!
@amyellen8392
@amyellen8392 6 лет назад
Thank you!! That is wonderful to hear. I'm glad you enjoyed it!
@bteakgreen
@bteakgreen 3 года назад
Would like to second this rated comment, the density of knowledge, and flow of presentation in your work, pleases me
@corvuspika
@corvuspika 3 года назад
Wow, I really love this video of yours. The detail you explain really helps people to see in depth of Sherlock as a person, and understand why and how he functions. I love your analysis.
@fiveswithalightsaber26
@fiveswithalightsaber26 5 лет назад
Dude what only eleven subscribers? What? The editing in this is genius! And the voiceover is clean! Wow bro. I’m subbing just to show support.
@RuthOkeabia
@RuthOkeabia 5 лет назад
Loved this video. I watched all of the episodes and behind-the-scenes of "Sherlock" BBC.
@jiggerypokery8476
@jiggerypokery8476 6 лет назад
This is fantastic work, and so incredibly interesting! I was fascinated from beginning to end.
@astro_penguin_
@astro_penguin_ 9 месяцев назад
Thank you for this!!
@KA-uv8gq
@KA-uv8gq 3 года назад
Ok....now I may actually watch this show...
@kenzgitz9884
@kenzgitz9884 7 месяцев назад
There's also a podcast where Sherlock Holmes is explicitly written as neurodivergent called Sherlock and co
@planet_dawsey595
@planet_dawsey595 5 лет назад
This is so interesting!!
@dishachakraborty5854
@dishachakraborty5854 3 года назад
Beautiful editing. So very beautiful.
@yeah-wq2ho
@yeah-wq2ho 2 года назад
True
@shirleynitka5030
@shirleynitka5030 Год назад
he doesnt have it.
@cookiecat7759
@cookiecat7759 8 месяцев назад
realll
@kuziokundera
@kuziokundera 2 года назад
One shouldn’t confuse real life problems with a fictional character’s traits that are determined by a writer’s creativity. The Character of this Sherlock is closer to a superhero than a real person.
@xabab
@xabab Год назад
Yes, but this is not the point of this video. This show is a great representation of how a person with ASD sees the world around him, and is a great source for allistic people for trying to understand autistic people, if you know where to look. For example, in the pub of Baskerville, Sherlok's «I don't have "friends"» have two completely different meanings for allistic and autistic people respectively.
@kenzgitz9884
@kenzgitz9884 7 месяцев назад
Sherlock Holmes is based on a real professor of Arthur Conan Doyle's and while we can never know for sure Dr. Joseph Bell was likely neurodivergent
@its3amandilostmypassword
@its3amandilostmypassword 4 месяца назад
Yes but he does show off autistic tendencies. As an autistic person that’s why I like the chaater
Далее
Sherlock Is Garbage, And Here's Why
1:49:53
Просмотров 14 млн
Do All Autistic People Think The Same? | Spectrum
17:38
the infantilised spectacle of autistic representation
1:15:57
When an audition changed cinema forever.
11:55
Просмотров 7 млн
The Day Sherlock Died
15:59
Просмотров 1 млн
CHARACTERS YOU DIDN'T KNOW ARE AUTISTIC
11:30
Просмотров 205 тыс.
Is Sherlock autistic?
2:25
Просмотров 2,8 тыс.