Sherlock Holmes Chapter One - All Endings | Good Vs Bad (All End Game Choices)

Подписаться 107 тыс.

Просмотров 21 тыс.

50% 1

#SherlockHolmes #SherlockHolmesChapterOne #Gameplay
Game description
In this story-driven detective thriller, a young Sherlock Holmes struggles to prove himself as he navigates an exotic, dangerous island in the Mediterranean to investigate the mystery of his mother’s death.
Buy the game,
-
PC,
store.steampow...
-
PSN
store.playstat...
-
Xbox,
www.xbox.com/e...
Genre: Action-Adventure
RELEASE DATE: 16 Nov, 2021
DEVELOPER: Frogwares
PUBLISHER: Frogwares
Channel Description
Hi awesome people and welcome to my channel! I am a one woman army, I record and edit videos all by myself and I try to bring you the highest quality possible of guides, walkthroughs, gameplays, cutscenes from games, easiest methods to defeat bosses, lots of tips & tricks, and soundtracks from select games with the permission of their respective owners to encourage people to buy their tracks/albums. You can find the little things here you can never find on other channels, so please do subscribe! :D I also have a gaming page on Instagram with over 50k followers where I do game reviews and lots of interesting things if you want to check it out! For business contact and PR inquiries including review codes for games & gaming related products for sponsorship/Influencing 👇
Shoot me a DM on Instagram @rubajaiousy
or click on the "For business enquiries" email

Опубликовано:

12 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 70

@MrAvakstone92 2 года назад

3:21 "Otto Richter is Responsible, An accident" ending 14:51 "Otto Richter is Responsible, Deliberate murder" ending 23:16 "Jon and I are Responsible, Jon is the killer" ending 32:05 "Jon and I are Responsible, I killed my mother" ending

@pilipinospanishchinese 2 года назад

Which is the true ending?

@ramychaita3281 2 года назад

thank you

@redscul129 2 года назад

@@pilipinospanishchinese is a game with shelock so look for the logical solution, the doctor was trying different methods to heal his mother, but she was the same, so... between an accident and deliberate, it was an accident, because the doctor had many chances to kill her but he never tried. Sherlock kiling his mother makes no sense since he just wanted to have fun in his own way with jon

@kairo9084 2 года назад

Thank you kind Stranger

@gabrieliusstirna 2 года назад

@@pilipinospanishchinese First one

@MyNegroAcademia Год назад

The first ending is the only one that makes sense when you really look at all the evidence

@esmanuraslan 7 месяцев назад

Oyunu bugün bitirdim. Oyunun sonunda Dr. Watson'la tanışmasındaki diyaloglarının aynısı Sherlock Holmes kitabında da yazıyordu. Bu nedenle bir anlık istemsizce oyunu kitapla bağdaştırdım :D Oyun çok trajedikti ama sonunun güzel bitmesi beni mutlu etti.

@danielscheuer939 2 года назад

This was heart warming him and jon rip for jon a good friend and brother for sherlock

@crimsonhartman 7 месяцев назад

Gameplay was frustrating but the story was excellent

@Amillune 2 года назад

The portrait, is it inspired by L (From Death note)

@Artryom 2 года назад

Welp… That beginning turned around REALL quick…

@lonely_warrior Год назад

Loved the game, personally the real ending to me is a mix of the first and last version with some drops of other two versions, like, mold him into the person we can read about in the books or see in other games or even tv series and the picture that Vegner gives him is a fun plus since it represent well how twisted Sherry can be at times

@thelonetraveller 2 года назад

I played Chapter One a couple of times now but I only ever chose one ending (the in my opinion right one) and kept it throughout every playthrough. But it's interesting to see how they actually differ.

@josefsousek6551 2 года назад

Which one did you pick?

@thelonetraveller 2 года назад

@@josefsousek6551 I chose the ending that would fit my Sherlock best and which takes in account the decisions I made in every other case. The one where Sherlock decides that he and Jon are responsible and that Sherlock killed his mother. It's the one I think fits best considering everything we are told and we find out about him because to me it doesn't make much sense why Sherlock would repress the memory of Dr. Richter killing her. But I can understand if people see it differently.

@josefsousek6551 2 года назад

@@thelonetraveller oh interesting I chose that Richter did it and tried to save her as we know she was soaked and had hole in her neck , which I cannot explain how would that happen if she didn't try to drown us and I came to the conclusion that Cherry chose to forget because his mother tried to kill him.

@thelonetraveller 2 года назад

@@josefsousek6551 As I said, your interpretation is just as valid as mine as Frogwared does not specify who is in the right. I thought that Sherlock's mum was soaked because she tried to drown Sherlock but because of an allergic reaction due to the medicine or something, she began to choke and Dr. Richter tried to save her.

@josefsousek6551 2 года назад

@@thelonetraveller yes I get that For me it's kinda shame that all main cases have open solutions but it ads some mystery to them.

@midnightdimensions13 Месяц назад

I think I got so caught up in being Sherlock and going through his memories that I picked him as the murderer. I don't know if that's considered the bad ending but it didn't matter to me. It felt like it made sense in all that chaos. And it still does.

@laurenhawes7201 2 года назад

Was I the only one laughing at the portrait?

@kairo9084 2 года назад

i can understand. Cause the pictures remind so on a certain someone. But no...cause the story is to sad for that

@theeraphatsunthornwit6266 2 года назад

Unexpected😅

@snowdroppax2726 Месяц назад

It's really up to interpretation but I feel as if the 'true' ending of the game is a mix of the first and last endings. Sherlock gave his mother the medication (thus accidentally causing the allergic reaction that would kill her) he would of course blame himself but the real villain was Dr. Otto Richter who was giving Violet untested medications. He wasn't trying to help her get better he was just treating her as an experiment. By all actual means he himself was the murderer and Sherlock was unfortunately just a child who was involved.

@TheBicool123 2 года назад

What is considered the "good" ending or the canonical one? I mean, there are barely any differences between the endings

@seikoseikogirl2758 2 года назад

If I remember, it is the first one shown that, again I remember correctly, is the canonical one. But I could be mistaken. The real differences between the endings are how Sherlock perceives the truth and how that affects his relationship with his brother and Jon. Obviously, the good ending shows him leaving off with good terms of both his brother and Jon. It also shows how Sherlock meets Dr. Watson of course.

@TheBicool123 2 года назад

@@seikoseikogirl2758 I thought at first that the canonical one is the ending that you kill Jon in it because he confessed that he made Sherlock give those things to his mother... But all endings lead to the same outcome so I have a feeling frogwares doesn't have a canonical one

@laurenhawes7201 2 года назад

Honestly I think it depends on the playthrough. If you played sherlock as somebody who made hard choices (execution) then the self blame makes the most sense thematically to complete that route. If you were more apologetic to criminals or chose the lesser option then continuing to blame Otto made sense. Fully canonically I expected that you would need to blame Jon, but personally I do think it was Otto since he had the same thought process as Mycroft. "The ends justify the means" he was prepared to do anything to prove his thesis, his doctorate was flimsy, he was not making progress with her and if not for Sherlock's sedative tea (probably counting as manslaughter), it still would have happened at some point (murder with a motive so either 1st or 2nd degree depending on the stance on how severe it was)

@GAshoneybear 2 года назад

I don't think there is a canon ending. Even with all the facts presented, all of these endings could be seen as true depending on who's looking at it. And basically giving credence to the game's theme that not all truth is objective.

@seikoseikogirl2758 2 года назад

@@GAshoneybear You do make a good point. It is more like a what truth would you accept kind of thing.

@UnforseenReturns 2 года назад

TL:DR, The first ending in my opinion fits the story the most. Based on evidence that was learned throughout the game. I had received the first ending. After watching the other endings, I would say that the first one is the best one. Yes the treatment was causing her harm but she had been having fits of rage before the event occurred. I also thought about it and back then there wasn't much for medical treatments for a mental illness like Violet had. It wouldn't be wrong to suggest that he was kind of making things up and tested things on the fly. Some treatments had more adverse effects than others. Is it possible that while she was drowning Sherlock that the medicine kicked and and knocked her out into the pond is a good explanation of why her throat was slit open. It is in the doctors intention to try and save their patients. If Richter wanted revenge on Mycroft, he would not jeopardize his name by killing the patient he was treating. With the ending being that Sherlock get's to meet Jon in person does fit the story moving forward. I thought it was really weird that Jon was a mere "part of his brain" when the rest of the games and other stories include him as a real person. Also talking about their place on Baker St. I do have one question though. Are all of FrogWare's Sherlock Holmes games all in the same timeline? (Chapter One, Crime and Punishment, Devil's Daughter, etc.)

@GAshoneybear 2 года назад

I was under the impression they were.

@UnforseenReturns 2 года назад

@@GAshoneybear I have contemplated this as tried to look things up and did not find it.

@TheWassupholmes 2 года назад

@@UnforseenReturns They all reference each other, and they seem to kind of be continuous, but not clearly (in DD they remade the characters, but still continued the story from Testament) what you got wrong is that Jon is not the same person as John Watson.

@UnforseenReturns 2 года назад

@@TheWassupholmes I understand where you got that. But it’s something to point out when the same character model is used for two different people.

@thelonetraveller 2 года назад

I know my comment is late but if you're still wondering, after some digging around, I found that all these games are in a way in the same timeline. Leaving out the games that were published before The Testament of Sherlock Holmes that timeline would be: Chapter One (1875), Crimes and Punishments (1894-1895), The Testament of Sherlock Holmes (1895), The Devil's Daughter (1896). Although one might want to ignore the character models because Holmes and Watson would age backwards as they look younger in DD than they did in TToSH and C&P ^^ Hope I could help.

@shnyia50 6 месяцев назад

I rather this Sherlock Holmes any day❤❤❤❤

@perunthegreat554 2 года назад

What is with picture Sherlock get from Vogel ?

@blackla5570 2 года назад

I think Vogel sees Sherlock act like Jon off camera moving in crazy positions. That painting is probably an example of catching him in the act, and why he’s so interested in Sherlock because he thinks he’s insane

@emmanewton8017 2 года назад

@@blackla5570 That painting is an Easter egg of the character L from the series Death Note. It has no meaning behind it other than L also being a phenomenal detective, and also probably the original inspiration for Sherlock’s character.

@alexgonzalez4001 2 года назад

@@emmanewton8017 I am sorry are yyouj saying Sherlock Holmes is based off of L? It would. e the other way around since Sherlock Holmes is much older......

@emmanewton8017 2 года назад

@@alexgonzalez4001 I’m talking about Sherlock IN THIS GAME his personality. Not his skills. Sherlock the character is so much older, but there are millions of iterations of him, all with different personalities

@herusolares5320 2 года назад

Because it not only depicts a paranoid Sherlock contorted in both body and mind, but the shadow of *Jon* peeking out behind him. Vogel SEES Jon.

@MLP1594 2 года назад

No entendí el significado de la pintura que le regaló el man ese.

@MrAvakstone92 2 года назад

es solo una referencia al personaje "L" de Death Note

@laurenhawes7201 2 года назад

Imagine that's what he looked like whenever he met him.

@lonely_warrior Год назад

Bastante tarde pero... la pintura representa como Vegner veia a Sherlock, como alguien con serios transtornos y problemas mentales que podian equilibrar o llevarlo mas fondo en su abismo personal como dicen en otros comentarios, tambien es una referencia a L de Death Note, quien tambien esta basado en Sherlock aunque diria que es mas una representacion de las peores caracteristicas del gran detective