I cant imagine listing to kpop know that hes dead... i found Kpop back in 2008 i was apart of the SM era... as SM ruled the charts for a good while in the late 2000s and early 2010s
This is how you give the fans their money's worth. Seriously. I'd pay 200 bucks for this shit even with 25K other fans because of the super high quality of the performance/singing/dancing. They are earning their paycheck and it shows. This should be the gold standard for live performances in Kpop. WAYV stop lip syncing LOL. If you @ SM Entertainment and are lip syncing on stage, you are FAILING and need to watch more SHINEE. NCT listen up!
What's amazing about this video is that multiple members are having mic problems during Ring Ding Dong, yet they cover each other so effortlessly. When Jonghyun's mic goes out Onew sings in his place. When both Jonghyun and Onew's mics drop Key steps in and hypes the crowd so they aren't distracted. They are SO PROFESSIONAL. Tech problems happen in live shows and you just gotta roll with it but other groups can't seem to improvise with such grace. SHINee are kings!
Plus the fact that Taemin only made it to the stage at 1:25 and they covered for him so seamlessly. I only noticed him strolling in probably the 20th time I watched it 😅
the quality of 2nd generation group was really no joke. Shinee's song was one of my fav song when i'm new to kpop. Sadly they won't sound the same anymore. R.I.P Jonghyun , we'll always remember u.
I have every confidence that when they leave the military , they’re going to come back BIGGER and better than before ! True that Jonghyun will alas no longer be with them ,but in his memory , they will be GREAT AGAIN ! So continue to give them your love and support , as I will !
@@oliviaebeling2245 no problem ! - Jonghyun (Kim Jonghyun, main vocalist and lyricist) : 1:19 (leather jacket, red shirt) - Onew (Lee Jinki, 2nd vocalist, oldest and leader) : 1:04 (black white and red jacket, red shirt) - Key (Kim Kibum, 2nd rapper, sings too, speaks english) : 1:45 (white jacket, gold pants) - Minho (Choi Minho, main rapper and visual) : 5:45 (Black jacket, blue pants) - Taemin (Lee Taemin, maknae and main dancer, is also a member of superM and has an active solo career) : 4:12 (silver top and bicolor pants) They all have solo stuff too :) Actually Taemin had a comeback not so long ago you should check it out^^
Jonghyun had so many lines in just those two songs. We were so spoiled. That belt he had, like sir did you have the right to slay??? lol. Rest in power.
Jonghyun's "babyyyyyy" at the beginning of Ring Ding Dong has kind of become a meme now but his vocals are no joke, truly one of the most talented 2nd gen idols.
@@chriswebber2937😂😮😂 they look the same I'm also confused my mom is 67 she knows almost all the Korean singers actors names even treasure13 I get so confused with the youngsters .She introduced me to jonghyun 😢 sad songs makes me cry everyday for poor jonghyun wish I met this extraordinary singer end of days.But she knows onew and key very well too😅.
@@chriswebber2937and even Lee Taemin and Minho that loves sports I ask her does she want to go to Korea or China 😅 she's really a Asian fan even Zan hung fan I get so confused with the names really from SA.We have a little Asian background here in Eastern Cape South Africa 😅
It's a little bit of talent and A LOT of *skill* . Jonghyun was such a SKILLED vocalist that he could really make his voice do whatever he wanted. I could probably count on one hand the number of idols that could do that. His vocal prowess is forever unmatched
What an overwhelming, devastating loss to SHINee and the whole K-Pop industry, when Jonghyun ended his life. Incredible talent and he contributed so much to musical creativity. To this day, 5 1/2 years later, it is still difficult to fathom why. I have opinions that I will keep to myself, but how I wish he could have found someone or something that could have relieved the despair he was going through. SHINee is still a great group, and I love the music they have released since Jonghyun left us, but I will always feel the loss of his presence. 🩵
why isn't anyone talking about their impactful and powerful dances. how can they seriously sing so well while dancing like that!! amazing !! jonghyun and onew's voices have left me speechless
Because it was live at that moment they performed but if it's edited like this that means most of the time they already put synced vocals over the performance. It's easy when you know what to listen for for example, there is no way for any of the labored breathing not to be transmitted over the mic and also there should be some background echo captured if it's live but evidently none of it was in this recording. So this is not the live recording of the stage.
@@deeharper1364 This is very clearly not overdubbed, 2:09 onwards to 2:25 is clear enough. 6:51 even more obvious, jonghyun is absolutely overpowering the backtrack, plus look at his and Onew's vowel shapes, and compare the sound from minhos part which his mouth is barely open and he sounds quiet compared to how loud onew and jonghyun are since they are projecting so much due to the wide vowel shape. Videos from the crowd show the same audio track. The chorus of ring ding dong is not live and 3:26 to 2:05 are not live, and chorus isnt live due to choreography. All verses are live and adlibs too. No group sings live more than SHINee in k-pop. Syncing vocals isn't widely used in k-pop as it would be in other genres. They opt for backtrack while singing over it, sometimes skipping lines if they are too out of breath, rather than using autotune like is more popular in western pop.
@@deeharper1364 clearly you are not SHINee’s fan. They practice singing while running, jogging, exercising, they sing live in rehearsal. This is very important they didn’t just pretend singing, they really sang live during **rehearsal**, it’s what Jjong’s request for members to do so, its special advice he gave Taemin when Taem was on Japan’s tour and just in cast you dont know, they’re terrible lip syncing. It cracks me up every time when someone pops in SHINee vids saying nahh this cant be real, their voice are too stable. Bitch plz, they’re veteran singers, who are in this industry for 15 years so why not?! .. maybe you also didn’t know this every time when they’re on music shows, some staffs would rush to the front stage just to watch them. Can your group hold that much power? 😂 Maybe you’re way too used to this new gens, acting all cute poses, focusing on how to look good on stage but cant sing live during performance. Even when SHINee recorded studio choom, Jinki sang his part live coz he’s not used to lip syncing. Taemin was sick during SuperM tour but still, he sang it live coz his hyungs taught him well. SHINee is a group consists with 5 members who sing live stably while dancing hard my dear. They’re idols of idols just in case you don’t know yet.
:( this is so sad tho why we gotta bring down other generations. We can praise these old times but is it necessary to bring down the generation now? Dont come to me I'm a multifandom and I stan many 2nd gens groups.
It's March 3, 2020 and I'm missing Jonghyun a little extra today, I don't know why. So I decided to watch this video. His vocals are truly unbelievable. I miss you terribly Jonghyun. I'm so sad I wasn't able to see you in person before you went to heaven. I love you always.
same, i have been watching all their old songs, he was exceptionally vocally and as a song writer, so sad he didnt get the support he needed, or 'heard' so he could still be with everyone today in the capacity he wanted
I love Jonghyun’s voice in this performance, he sounded so powerful and passionate. I still wish they did the entirety of Ring Ding Dong so we could hear the part near the end, it’s so good
Jonghyun’s voice brings me such joy and also makes me sad to know the world will never experience it again.I'm late to the Shinee party but he was such an amazing performer who clearly gave his all. *sigh* May he rest in peace.
Jonghyun! Whoooee his voice was the real deal! ALL of the guys are just a well-oiled machine! They work so hard and are so good at what they do! And I am SO GLAD that there are so many great videos of SHINee's performances.
this is one of the best shinee's live stage, but guys jonghyun He looks very tired here, as if he is sick, and yet he did the best he could. He performed a performance that will never be repeated in the history of Kpop
I've watched this performance so many times, I absolutely love the energy, singing, and the dances.... As a recent newcomer to kpop, I'm sad I didn't experience this all those yrs ago, Jonghyun truly was an incredible singer and performer
The fun thing is I found Minho, Taemin, and Onew independently before actually listening to Shinee, Minho and Taemin through their solo music, and Onew through "Descendants of the Sun"
@@koposart1489 i recently watched descendants of the sun and found shinee because of onew. even if i'm just finding them recently, i'm still glad i did. ♥
@@koposart1489I saw Lee Taemin dancing makes me think of Michael Jackson criminal and dangerous😮 and jonghyun Spanish sad song and end of days 😢 lonely, breathe I'm so crazy for him I wish I knew years ago I would have safe his beautiful life .Love him so much his voice body his so handsome 😢
I really love Onew. His voice is so unique & equally powerful, with an even tone and pitch too. As a person he is really unassuming, with a great personality. Visuals are no joke either. The package.
SHINee is untouchable, their level is insane. We can just praise them without bringing down the newer generation or other groups. I bet you can't do what idols do even just 10% of it. If you love SHINee, just support them. They're still active and we're waiting for their comeback in 2023 😭😭
I've never been to a SHINee concert before. I feel sad that I will never get a chance to see Jonghyun perform live anymore. He's an astounding performer and has that kind of aggressive and powerful aura that I think other rookie idols lack. I think even if you're not a shawol, it is obvious that Jonghyun had something that is hard to find or replicate. What a legend.
SHINee, my gateway into kpop, my first and probably my forever favorite. Love them all but Jonghyun was always so special to me, and watching this today, did he not always give it his all? Every moment he sings, I get chills. A true star.
I came here because I wanted to hear Jonghyun's long and high tone voice again. I think this is one of Shinee's best performance videos. I don't know anyone else who sings and dances so hard. Jonghyun, please rest in peace.
I met SHINee 6 months ago. I first saw the video of Jonghyun's funeral and started looking for information about him. Then I found their performance and it was Everybody. I am amazed and addicted to their live performances. This is a very high level, such energy, such voices and atmosphere. I have not seen any group in the K-pop industry of the same level. I'm so sorry that I found out about these 5 kings years later... I didn't become a shawol during Jonghyun's lifetime. Our dear Angel Kim Jonghyun, I watch your videos over and over and rest assured that I, like billions of people, will say that you did a damn good job!
I love some of current KPop songs, but i rewatched some of Shinee songs, must admit there are something more powerful in this KPop generation. The songs aren't easily forgotten and the performance is Extraordinary
Jonghyun's vocals oh my god!! he literally gave his all on stage. Onew's high notes as well. Shinee will forever shine brightly. Such great performers.
I'm a baby Shawol. I've known of Shinee only from my then-teen kids some years back, but I never proactively listened to Shinee's music nor tried to know more about them. I just knew Minho was from Shinee when I saw Hwarang. Later, I happened to watch SuperM's kdrama challenge. Taemin was significant and I remembered his face and name. Still, I didn't know he was from Shinee, let alone the maknae. Just weeks ago, I was helping a friend put together a kpop playlist. As I explored artists on my own, I came across this and it was this specific live performance that got me hooked. And a new baby Shawol was born! Sorry I'm late, but I'm here to stay!
Jonghyun made me feel like he is a danger monster that I want to risk my life to be with him base on his face and facial expressions. I will always remember him in my heart ❤️❤️❤️❤️ RIP
*I adore how does each one of them give their all in each performance as if it the first & last one. But tbh, although all of their are no joke but Jonghyuna's vocals are in a different level.*
I don’t think there will ever be another band like SHINee. These boys are so passionate about their performances, you can see the energy just bursting out of them. Every single member has insane qualities that compliment each other so well. I’ve been a fan for over a decade and til this day they keep surprising me and making me more proud every single day! ❤️
Live vocals! And you can hear their powerful voices! Especially Jonghyun’s. He’s such a powerhouse! Their performance was a bomb! 2019 and I’m still here.
Even after all this time, this performance still gives me goosebumps. Jonghun's voice was so rich, he had such power and threw every ounce of himself into every note. He had that real rock and roll voice that had theatrical technique. Such a loss.
All these men have golden voices🔥 Let's always remember SHINee as a group with amazing singers not just for Jonghyun's suicide. Very good singers, catchy music and nice people 🤍
I've said "I have yet to find a SHINee song I don't love," but honestly, this here is the real reason I love SHINee. I don't like to use the phrase "gave me chills," but this performance had my heart pounding by the end of it. Even through a screen, years after the fact. If you wanted to put together a team of 5 people, with the goal of creating the best possible group of performers, then you don't have to put in any effort, because SHINee already is that.
I never stanned SHINee but I’ve been listening to their song and albums lately, they were so good and now I’m kind of sad I didn’t listen to them sooner. 😭
