Should the White Sox trade Luis Robert Jr. and/or Garrett Crochet? 

The Cubs have "wait till next year" we have "wait till Jerry is gone" 😔

Trading Robert Jr and Crochet for more prospects will not help all the great prospects they already have reach the majors sooner. Robert Jr and Crochet are guys you build a team around. Fire Pedro Grifol and get a good manager and coaching staff.

So trade robert and crochet for Prospects and then if those Prospects make it to the show, trade them away for more prospects? What a great organization plan

Chris Getz in love with royal coaches

No. My reason for the answer is that this organization has been trade happy but to no avail... I do not believe we have the evaluators in the house to make that call... Give me back the Chris Sale deal that was a fail! When I say organization I'm not excluding the Bulls from that notion either... The Jimmy Butler give away still sucks! So Trade Robert who looks like he has a good 7 years of prime baseball ahead for what... a roll of the dice.... No Thanks! Same with Crochett.. I'm tired of watching our guys pitch great elsewhere... The sox need to cut bait on what doesn't work well JImenez, Yoan, ect... Bennitendi, Vaughn.. What's up with Colson Montgomery? The way they run this thing please do not trade away the two best players with a bright future ahead.. Wrong trade!

I want Chicago White Sox trade Luis Robert Jr. And Garrett Crochet to PADRES Now

Vote for Maldy for the Allstar game. Anyone on the Sox should be traded if someone calls I do not care who it is.

PROS of trading Robert: 1) Injury prone 2) Sox will not resign him as he's a Boras agent 3) The prospect return could accelerate the minor league rebuilding of talent by two years CONS of trading: 1) Club control and $$$ 2) Free agents won't sign here as we are the laughing stock of the league and need to build around a star. Solution: Sell the the freaking team, Jerry. PLEASE! You have held this city hostage for way too long.

Maldonado and Kopech are both a waste of a roster spot. After Monday night's game, I'm ready to give up on both of them. Grifol too.

Holy SHIT is pedro for real?? Saying maldonado stays in the game for his defense asa cope? Doesnt he literally have one of the slowest pop times and korey lee has one of the quickest?

Pedro's, his "liking him (Maldo) in these types of situations" with fans like me yelling "Pinch hit for him!" being okay with him, meaning screw us, he knows better so expect more of the same, being reason enough to fire him right now. Before he personally blows another ballgame with his stubborn mismanagement. I mean, a space alien knowing nothing about the game, given a brief explanation of the rules and Maldo's statistics, so being informed that Maldo's coming through "in these situations" with his next to zero batting average and the teams history of run scoring in close games, would certainly have made the obvious to ET and everyone else (but not to Pedro) decision.

Honestly it doesn't matter if they trade Robert, Fedde, or Crotchet....when it comes time to pay them, they won't and they'll leave. If they trade them, they'll bank on the assets having primes before they're due to be paid. And Jerry won't pay them. Not after he let Kenny Williams (who shoulda been canned 12 years ago) wreck the roster. If the moves work, and it comes down to needing only a few missing pieces, Jerry will half ass it like last time. We needed a RFer, a 2nd baseman, and a left handed arm to replace Rodon, and Jerry said no to all of it. Unless it was La Russa's love child Leury Garcia. Reinsdorf flat out sucks.

He was injured in college too, there is a reason he didn't have many innings. They started building him up and he went down with Tommy John.

You guys always speak my language-COMMON SENSE AND LOGIC. I’m sick of rebuilds, the future is NOW!

No. Not even a question. Shouldn't even trade Fedde. Fedde and Crotchet would be amazing guys to be around next year for Thorpe, Schultz and Iriarte. Replace Maldy with Quero. Dump Vaughn and Make Sheets 1B. Call up Montgomery to play short. Sign a free agent 3B. And all the sudden this is a very watchable baseball team. Not necessarily competitive. But it's what an org who's worth a damn would do this vs nuke

They want to build a team with all minor leaguers That NEVER WORKS. You have to have a few stars on the team like Roberts, Crochets and othets or youll NEVER WIN CHET

dont trade either one.

I trade the whole team because they are horrible

At a certain point you need to keep people to build around. Colson Montgomery is hitting .222 at AAA. Every time I look at a stat line lately on him it looks like 0-4 with 3 k’s. Do you really want to trade proven still young talent for lottery tickets like Montgomery?

No no no

Clean house. Everyone that has the stink of this rot should go if the price is right. These players don't know how to be a team. Robert can't stay healthy for this team, we need stars that can stay on the field. Crochet has oft been injured too, and his value is at its peak. Trade him while the going is good. We need players that will arrive together at the same time as the others from AA and AAA. Then fill in the holes and add veteran that are proven winners and team guys.

Hows your passive, defensive mindset paying off Pedro?

For what?! Is this a farm system for the MLB or an actual team?🤬

Martin Maldonado ain't talking the bull pen thru the hard innings. AJ was the best as an extra set of eyes. Martin sux you'll send Bryan Ramos down cuz he ain't hitting. Y'all are fucked up!

I mean if you can get a good deal for Robert Jr then move him. But Crochett?! hes been a stud and is only like 25 years old. You need good pitching, especially when you only get 3 hits a game.

Robert is NOT gonna change this seasons outcome, if the prospects are worth it trade him ! He may get hurt again at anytime

How easy it is for this manager to just throw his young players under the bus but vehemently defends his unaccountable veterans 😮

The White Sox must learn to do things the Tampa way , Trade stars for good prospects because the owner doest want to spend money in free agents..Gentz must get creative until Jerry opens his wallet..a wallet that's full of money but he has ten locks on it..

I’d trade this whole team they all suck ! How you gonna rebuild this team with a two dollar budget ?

Predo, you are so wrong to Maldonado! If you still put him, we can feel to win games.

Korey Lee also has the best pop time in the major leagues

First move before anything else, fire Pedro. Those two winnable blown ballgames to the Cubs being the final straw. Then having the bases full with two outs and allowing Maldo with his slightly higher than zero batting average to bat for himself in another blown by one run game to Boston, being the clincher. Keep Crochet, trade Junior before the other teams catch onto what a delicate flower he is, and that getting a hundred games out of him is as likely as being struck by lightning while cashing in a winning lottery ticket. Let him sit on some other team's injured list. Like the other two members of The Three Disabled List Amigos, Eloy and Moncada.

They should extend them but Jerry is a cheap miser, so whats the only other option

The bigger problem with all of this you both are saying flat out there is no chance at resigning either one cause the team is to cheap. It's true until the big guy in owners office goes away there is no chance for this team

Yeah trade away an all start cf and the guy comes back and still hits bombs. Let’s get prospects for these guys and pray that their “potential” will carry us in three years. Gtfoh

You’re insane. No

Robert looks uninterested at times and can look horrible at the plate between his home runs … trade him !

if i was a sux fan, i would want to keep them. Who are they gonna want in a trade, a good center fielder and starter ?? THEY ALREADY HAVE THEM !! allabammy, the pathetic CONFEDERACY..thats all i need to know..bye

If Robert and Crochet are traded, the loss column will only inflate. Trade Maldinado for a bucket of balls and a jump rope. Make Pedro sit and suffer this season right to game#162. Thorpe looks really decent. Build around what we already have. Dump Pedro in the winter.