Тёмный

"So, what is Old Norse like?" 

Jackson Crawford
Подписаться 281 тыс.
Просмотров 32 тыс.
50% 1

A short talk about what someone learning Old Norse is getting into. Featuring Luke Ranieri of @polyMATHY_Luke and @ScorpioMartianus
Jackson Crawford, Ph.D.: Sharing real expertise in Norse language and myth with people hungry to learn, free of both ivory tower elitism and the agendas of self-appointed gurus. Visit jacksonwcrawford.com/ (includes bio and linked list of all videos).
Jackson Crawford’s Patreon page: / norsebysw
Visit Grimfrost at glnk.io/6q1z/jacksoncrawford
Latest FAQs: vimeo.com/375149287 (updated Nov. 2019).
Jackson Crawford’s translation of Hávamál, with complete Old Norse text: www.hackettpublishing.com/the... or www.amazon.com/Wanderers-Hava...
Jackson Crawford’s translation of The Poetic Edda: www.hackettpublishing.com/the... or www.amazon.com/Poetic-Edda-St...
Audiobook: www.audible.com/pd/The-Poetic...
Jackson Crawford’s translation of The Saga of the Volsungs: www.hackettpublishing.com/the... or www.amazon.com/Saga-Volsungs-...
Audiobook: www.audible.com/pd/The-Saga-o...
Music © I See Hawks in L.A., courtesy of the artist. Visit www.iseehawks.com/
Logos by Elizabeth Porter (snowbringer at gmail).

Опубликовано:

 

10 май 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 198   
@polyMATHY_Luke
@polyMATHY_Luke 2 года назад
It’s a pleasure and an honor to be a guest on your channel. Thanks for the discussion!
@nikburisson9
@nikburisson9 2 года назад
Stanza 55 Hàvamàl is your friend, you are interestingly wise. Continue to be you.
@Lowlandlord
@Lowlandlord 2 года назад
Great episode, love the collab, and hats!
@bendthebow
@bendthebow 2 года назад
I''m amazed how similar Norwegian is to Scots. Quine, bairn, speir / kvenne, barn, spørre. Many examples. And Norwegian also has 'bra'- good, similar to Scots 'braw'. So I check and indeed also from bravo/brave. That word's fairly travelled
@ediwansilva7761
@ediwansilva7761 2 года назад
Why not an episode of the roman soldier Lucius meeting a Viking, in their original languages... it could be fun
@nnnn65490
@nnnn65490 2 года назад
Have you ever heard of Dr Joshua Bowen from Digital Hammurabi? He has a free lecture series on Sumerian. But I think he also has a degree in Semitic languages more broadly due to him being an Assyriologist.
@kelticsage
@kelticsage 2 года назад
What a crossover, now ya both have to go to Iceland and speak old norse on the streets
@BigHossHackworth
@BigHossHackworth 2 года назад
Hell yeah
@alphawolf122
@alphawolf122 Год назад
interesting thing is that most if not all Icelandic people would have no problem understanding old Norse because as far as I know and have learned, Icelandic and old Norse are really similar, and modern Icelandic is basically the same as old Norse with a few changes in pronunciation and construct
@kelticsage
@kelticsage Год назад
@@alphawolf122 very true, i can understand nearly all he says except a few words
@TunahTak
@TunahTak 11 месяцев назад
🫂💙
@Hvitserk67
@Hvitserk67 2 года назад
As a Norwegian, I can say that all Scandinavian children who learn English at school (which is compulsory) use this general procedure only the opposite way. There are so many similarities that "false friends" are what you should be most careful about (eg sky (cloud) -sky (himmel), at least until you reach a slightly higher level in English. The word "himmel" (sky) comes from German, but in Old Norse it was "himinn" which today has an English variant in the form of "heaven" (which has the same meaning as "himmel"). Pretty cool :)
@kevinstachovak8842
@kevinstachovak8842 2 года назад
Cognate with Gothic 'Himinam' if i'm not mistaken. I love languages!
@spellandshield
@spellandshield 2 года назад
But heaven is a native English word and sky was borrowed from Old Norse.
@Hvitserk67
@Hvitserk67 2 года назад
@@spellandshield The word "heaven" most probably comes from Low German "heben" which is a variant of "* hibin" (proto-germanic). Old Norse was, as mentioned, "himinn". My point is that in Scandinavian languages today we use the same word for both sky and heaven ("himmel").
@spellandshield
@spellandshield 2 года назад
@@Hvitserk67 You are right about hibin but heaven doesn't come from Low German; it is attested in Old English (heofon) multiple times and stems from the same proto-germanic source but I take your point.
@PeterGaudiano
@PeterGaudiano 2 года назад
In Swedish we use ’skyar’ to describe thin clouds or veils of rain.
@thebad6246
@thebad6246 2 года назад
Can't wait for the future video when Ranieri, Crawford and Roper have a discussion while Faraji is playing music in the background.
@evenaskeladden
@evenaskeladden 2 года назад
Historical Linguistics: Infinity War
@jeremias-serus
@jeremias-serus 2 года назад
Too bad there’s no one on yt who specializes Old Church Slavonic. Old English is not nearly old enough comparable to Latin and Old Norse, not to mention it’s just downstream from Old Norse. Having OCS would complete the three major branches’ old language of renown.
@evenaskeladden
@evenaskeladden 2 года назад
@@jeremias-serus That would really be something. I'd just like to correct on something. Old English is actually slightly older than Old Norse by a few centuries. The oldest Old English literature is from the 7th century, whereas the earliest Old Norse poetry stems from the late 8th century.
@Ciiran
@Ciiran 2 года назад
When I , as a Swede, learned English and later German in school cognates helped me out a lot. A few easy ones: Father, Mother, Bread, Dead Vater, Mutter, Brot, Tot Fader, Moder, Bröd, Död You could of course add in Danish, Dutch etc in the same patterns. Lots of similar cognates out there, and by studying them, you get a "feel" for quite a few specifics of the relevant languages.
@ak5659
@ak5659 2 года назад
I agree and think you can apply that even more broadly. Most things English already had in 1066 stayed and today those English words will be very similar in all the Germanic languages TODAY. After a while you adjust how you 'see' a word because your brain realizes that d,t, & th are all the same and f & v are the same. So you see them as 'one' unit or word. So if you see father, vater, or fader it all looks the same and you'll insist the word was in English when it really wasn't.
@y11971alex
@y11971alex 2 года назад
I’m still waiting for a detailed channel like yours for Avestan. It’s a long term goal of mine to learn Sanskrit and Avestan, since I already have exposure to Ancient Greek and Latin.
@stevelknievel4183
@stevelknievel4183 2 года назад
Its an Indo-European language. You just have to learn what the patterns are in terms of sound change like Jackson suggested in this video! 😛
@romainvicta9793
@romainvicta9793 2 года назад
That would be really cool, it's a shame there isn't much attention for Avestan and old Iranic culture
@chadwickreno8499
@chadwickreno8499 2 года назад
Ilovelanguages and ABAlphaBeta have a few videos on the languages but no one's actually gone in depth into them, you'd probably have better luck searching for a channel in Persian though tbh
@DubmanicGetFlazed
@DubmanicGetFlazed 2 года назад
make one
@y11971alex
@y11971alex 2 года назад
@@DubmanicGetFlazed XD
@Pengalen
@Pengalen 2 года назад
Now if we can only find an Irish/Celtic scholar like you guys, the set of Ancient Language dudes will be complete.
@FPSIreland2
@FPSIreland2 2 года назад
Look up AnLoingseach, he does linguistic stuff for modern and old Irish. He has a bit if a tendency to go on tangents, hence the name loingseach (means wanderer) Edit: but said tangents are quite interesting
@Pengalen
@Pengalen 2 года назад
@@FPSIreland2 I will check him out. Thanks. As an aside, your nick means radically different things depending on where you put the fada.
@FPSIreland2
@FPSIreland2 2 года назад
@@Pengalen Is é an tuiseal ainmneach mo shloinne é
@Pengalen
@Pengalen 2 года назад
@@FPSIreland2 That's pretty beyond my scant and humble knowledge of the language, but fortunately Google translate exists. :)
@kevinstachovak8842
@kevinstachovak8842 2 года назад
@@Pengalen The Fada just lengthens a vowel, essentially. Try mandarin, where every syllable needs to be enunciated in one of four different ways in order to make yourself clear.
@lalc__
@lalc__ 2 года назад
My greatest RU-vid dream is for a channel like yours or like Luke's for the Hittite language
@silver6380
@silver6380 2 года назад
there's a hittite channel?!
@the_sad_wallet1553
@the_sad_wallet1553 2 года назад
Awesome crossover that I didn’t know I wanted. Cool stuff!
@mixuz91
@mixuz91 2 года назад
I've noticed a pattern from english to old norse to swedish. We dropped the i it seems :) Stone- Stein- Sten Home- Heim- Hem Bone- Bein- Ben
@HassenVEVO
@HassenVEVO 2 года назад
The heck with Dr Strange multiverse, these are real cameos.
@Teverell
@Teverell 2 года назад
Placenames in England are hella fun in giving you a hint of who the people were who named it, or who the area was named for.... I live in Gillingham in Kent, which is near Rochester. -ham denotes a Saxon settlement (hame, heim). -chester, -cester, -caster is from castrum - there was a Roman fort in the area. The name of the county, Kent, is from the Celtic tribe of the Cantiaci, whose main settlement was in or near modern-day Canterbury. As you head north up the east coat, you start coming across words with a Viking background - the hills in the Lake District and a fair amount of the Yorkshire Dales are called fells, for example, and you might wade in a beck and swim in a tarn (if you're feeling brave enough, anyway!) and I am reliably informed that those few words still have cognates in Danish. I have absolutely no background in Old Norse or any Scandinavian language whatsoever. I just find etymology fun!
@Hvitserk67
@Hvitserk67 2 года назад
Some areas and cities in England are named directly after the Vikings. A very good example is the city of York which is an anglicization of Jórvík. Cities that have an ending in "by" (which means city in Scandinavian languages) were usually established by the Vikings. A good example is Grimsby. In Norway there is a counterpart in the form of the city Grimstad (where the word "stad" means smaller city/town).
@neilog747
@neilog747 2 года назад
@@Hvitserk67 Cool. Grimstad would be Grimstead if it were in England.
@charlesbourgoigne2130
@charlesbourgoigne2130 2 года назад
What a magnificent cross-over! More of it! (please)
@ak5659
@ak5659 2 года назад
"Say the English word with Old Norse grammar" -- Granted I was in Hamburg so that was in my favor, but that technique really helped to make myself understood when speaking to people. I'd only had 3 years of German in college but I was pleasantly surprised at how well I got along.
@valhoundmom
@valhoundmom 2 года назад
Your Old Norse instruction actually is very helpful for me studying Finnish thanks! It's amazing how much Norwegian I can work out just because I speak English
@valhoundmom
@valhoundmom 2 года назад
@@user-tm8jt2py3d and those things that look the same, and oh wow they are not!!😄
@ak5659
@ak5659 2 года назад
Yes, all the Germanic languages are more similar than they appear when you first encounter them. What helps is that even 'false friends' are conceptually related. Or the meanings are the same but with a twist. Ex. 'flask' is a particular type of bottle in English but it's the word for a general bottle in many of the other Germanic.
@jenlulabelle
@jenlulabelle 2 года назад
@@user-tm8jt2py3d I’m trying to learn Norwegian too. As a Scottish person I’m finding a lot of similarities between Scots and Norwegian. So having English and Scots knowledge is handy for me :)
@LoisoPondohva
@LoisoPondohva 2 года назад
Finnish has nothing to do with old Norse though, I'm confusion
@valhoundmom
@valhoundmom 2 года назад
@@LoisoPondohva I never said it did. I said it helps me with studying Finnish. I did not say Old Norse was similar. Being fluent in Spanish and having studied Japanese has also been a huge help with my process of learning Finnish.
@c567591
@c567591 2 года назад
A pair of Cowboy Linguists... love both of you guys. Learn a lot from you guys.
@WaywardSon1
@WaywardSon1 2 года назад
There are actually courses in Old Swedish - my alma mater has had one for many years - but you have to know a modern Scandinavian language to be able to participate. Great video!
@korpskog8781
@korpskog8781 2 года назад
Guessing and extrapolating is how I became conversational in Italian in three days.
@jacobandrews2663
@jacobandrews2663 2 года назад
A surprise to be sure, but a welcomed one.
@stevelknievel4183
@stevelknievel4183 2 года назад
But umlaut and subsequent vowel loss is what makes Old Norse so fun!
@visserskarel
@visserskarel 2 года назад
Interesting how the "textbook" dialect for Old Greek and Old Norse are the dialects with most literature in it, while the textbook dialect of Old French is not the Picardian dialect (most Old French literature is in Picardian, and if it is in other dialects it is often influenced by Picardian), but instead the textbook dialect is the dialect of the Île de France, which only later became the dominant dialect.
@Allan_son
@Allan_son 2 года назад
Anglo-Norman has a comparable amount of "Old French" literature but who in France would teach anything with "Anglo" in its name. 🙂
@ninjadude971
@ninjadude971 Год назад
That’s rather interesting, why is that the case?
@stianharestad6601
@stianharestad6601 2 года назад
Its amazing how skilled you are in old norce, love and respect from Norway. I love your podcast.
@shruggzdastr8-facedclown
@shruggzdastr8-facedclown 2 года назад
Given the Old Norse root word "drifa" being the source for the M.E. word "drive", does "drift" also come from the same ancestral word?
@jorgeclaverie6752
@jorgeclaverie6752 8 месяцев назад
I am forever grateful to you for sharing these videos and your work/knowledge with us! Thank you!!! Tack så jättemycket!!!!
@aesir1ases64
@aesir1ases64 2 года назад
Thanks for the great work man! Keep it up!!
@kellimbt
@kellimbt 2 года назад
So excited for this series!
@myNamesTakin
@myNamesTakin 2 года назад
This is a series I will be fallowing great insights
@witchersilversteel3573
@witchersilversteel3573 2 года назад
This collaboration is such a joy to watch, both vids have been amazing!! Never knew i needed this until it happened, now i wanna see this more often lol
@TheBlimpFruit
@TheBlimpFruit 2 года назад
Great to see you two in person together!
@sushidawgz
@sushidawgz 2 года назад
Thanks guys. A very imformative video that has changed how I view old norse.
@DelphicLion
@DelphicLion 2 года назад
Two of my favorite linguist channels doing a crossover?! Is it my birthday?
@nobodyexceptme7794
@nobodyexceptme7794 2 года назад
Following this guy since the ign video has been so much fun. Especially for ppl who like language. I wish u more success and growth!
@ignasimontserrat
@ignasimontserrat 2 года назад
It is great to see you together. It is magnificent to see two intelligent people just talking about something.
@emom358
@emom358 2 года назад
Fascinating. Thank you.
@hakon_dlc
@hakon_dlc 2 года назад
What a crossover, informative and entertaining to watch. Excited to watch more of this series' entries!
@benw9949
@benw9949 2 года назад
Having seen videos from both Luke and Jackson, with great content for anyone who loves languages, it's great to see you both together! English is such an unusual fusion of Germanic and Romance (Anglo-Saxon, Viking / Danes, Norman-French) with Latin and Greek thrown in for technical words, then melded together before (during) when it borrowed from all across the world...it's fascinating. How languages change over time. So much good stuff!
@Purwapada
@Purwapada 2 года назад
amazing discussion love it
@evolagenda
@evolagenda 2 года назад
I needed this today
@remen_emperor
@remen_emperor 2 года назад
Two of my favorite RU-vidrs starting off with an awkwardly scripted ad for the video I'm already watching. Perfect
@ksbrook1430
@ksbrook1430 Год назад
I'm enjoying this series. 😊
@lelyanra
@lelyanra 2 года назад
OH YEAH, loved the crossover
@user-eq8ww1gr6v
@user-eq8ww1gr6v 2 года назад
I deeply respect your efforts to show case cross-discipline experts and deepen our understandung of our cultural, linguistic, and historical roots and how they interact
@buddharuci2701
@buddharuci2701 2 года назад
Danish glottal stop: where does it come from and how does it relate to old Norse? Tak!
@jockeberg4089
@jockeberg4089 2 года назад
It comes from the potato that got stuck in the throat of every Dane
@collectorduck9061
@collectorduck9061 2 года назад
@@jockeberg4089 this is true. It’s actually quite sad. If the new world had not been discovered, Danes might still be able to communicate.
@stefanjasovic2311
@stefanjasovic2311 2 года назад
BEST CROSSOVER EVER
@artawhirler
@artawhirler Год назад
Good rule there! "Don't start with what's easy. Start with what's frequent."
@overratedprogrammer
@overratedprogrammer 2 года назад
"I wish I knew how to quit you.."
@melissahdawn
@melissahdawn 2 года назад
Where is this quote from. I like it. 👍
@juliamann9253
@juliamann9253 2 года назад
I hope you were referring to your upcoming textbook!
@Alvedrotten
@Alvedrotten 2 года назад
Wow, those are some big hats 😅 Hei fra Norge.
@arthurmoran4951
@arthurmoran4951 2 года назад
Best collab ever
@Fridrik-
@Fridrik- Год назад
Damn, it is "Trukkur" in modern icelandic. Minute 13:10 or so. "Er þetta trukkurinn þinn" = "Is this your truck".
@Kylbir
@Kylbir 2 года назад
hey man, was wondering about the names of greenland and iceland; if the sagas or other source material mentions anything about why they were named what they are named. i've heard conflicting stories about either the "propaganda" of the names or maybe that the climate was different back then. anyway, just wondering if you know anything about it. thanks
@mrkdrage5044
@mrkdrage5044 2 года назад
I have a question, How do you say explore in old norse? And if it is regular or irregular and strong or weak
@cerberaodollam
@cerberaodollam 2 года назад
Best crossover ever ❤️
@tmann986
@tmann986 Год назад
These two gentleman have me wanting to learn Latin and Icelandic haha 👏
@Fummy007
@Fummy007 2 года назад
Most ambitious crossover of the decade so far
@LaFayVerte
@LaFayVerte 2 года назад
Nice shoutout for Simon Roper!
@lunda2222
@lunda2222 2 года назад
Bear in mind this is from the perspective of a native English speaker. If your first language is, say Spanish it may be different. And much different if you're native Icelandic.
@ak5659
@ak5659 2 года назад
Right. Jackson made a couple of references to inflections (ex. case endings) causing a problem. But If you've had exposure to the Slavic languages which are much more highly inflected, inflections are easy.
@amalkatrazz
@amalkatrazz 2 года назад
As a Russian who speaks German and Icelandic, I indeed had no difficulties understanding the inflections of Old Norse when studying it.
@ak5659
@ak5659 2 года назад
@@amalkatrazz If Russian is yourfirst language maybe yeu can appreciate this problem. In German you have basically a half dozen case endings, right? But if you count up M,F,N,Pl nouns * 4 cases + the same for der words and again for ein words you have like 48 'boxes' that need endings. In the Slavic languages you'd have about 30 different endings, right? So can you explain how 6 endings can cover all that? It's like the endings can't do their 'job' as endings because there's so much repetition! Yes, I know I'm grossly oversimplifying, but do you see my point? So, in my German 101 class in the US a few of us had some Slavic language background and we're asking the professor where the rest of the endings are because we need more. Meanwhile the rest of the class is saying,"what am I supposed to do with 6 endings? There're too many!".....
@danmaertens7872
@danmaertens7872 2 года назад
Awesome crossover! The indo-European language mothership buffet!
@craighughes536
@craighughes536 2 года назад
Yes, Just Yes ..🎉
@Fuk99999
@Fuk99999 2 года назад
One of the most ambitious crossovers ever
@bnic9471
@bnic9471 2 года назад
Great video! I've been reading a lot of 100 y.o. Norwegian-American bogmaal, and the English borrowings are common. That's no monkeybisnis!
@Bjowolf2
@Bjowolf2 Год назад
Luke: "So what is 'Romani ite domum' in Old Norse, Jackson?" 😂
@AimeeVignes
@AimeeVignes 2 года назад
Ok, I didn’t expect this 😳
@LeoPlaw
@LeoPlaw 2 года назад
Two language nerds for the price of one! Bonus!
@jay5467
@jay5467 2 года назад
i have a question for both of you linguists, what is the closest living language family to the IE language family?
@kratos692
@kratos692 2 года назад
Dr Crawford, which Norse language should I learn Norwegian, Danish or Swedish that is closer to Old Norse? I know Icelandic is said to be the closest but I want to learn from either of these three. Also I know a little bit of German too.
@Philoglossos
@Philoglossos 2 года назад
Norwegian, and of the two standard forms Norwegian Nynorsk would be the closest.
@40bc47
@40bc47 2 года назад
Don’t rule out the Time Machine scenario, you never know😁
@Purwapada
@Purwapada 2 года назад
now we need a sanskrit/pali youtuber. I don;t know if anyone does that but would be cool.
@raifkolbjornson
@raifkolbjornson Год назад
These vids are such fun, thanks. Ease of ON vs Greek: Results may vary. Me, I found ON decently easy (for a reading knowledge) but I cheated since I'm basically native in both Swedish (for vocab) and German (for grammer, especially the firehose of subjunctives). Whereas Greek, no way baby. Been there, did that, backed away slowly.
@Jumpoable
@Jumpoable 2 года назад
2 handsome men in cowboy hats talking about ancient languages is my jam.
@ak5659
@ak5659 2 года назад
Thank you for saying that! I agree 1000%. The language geek part of my brain was battling with another part of my body for a limited blood supply. To make matters worse I stopped breathing at several points in this vid.
@Jumpoable
@Jumpoable 2 года назад
@@ak5659 LOLOLOL.
@arturoaguirre8469
@arturoaguirre8469 2 года назад
i follow both , Dr Jackson Crawford do you speak old english?
@JHaras
@JHaras 3 месяца назад
On a less serious note, "En truck"/"Trucken" is perfectly acceptable in modern Swedish. Albeit it's a modern loan word, and primarily referring to a "forklift" technically speaking, it can also be a slang word for an actual truck/lorry.
@supremerevelations
@supremerevelations 2 года назад
The best crossover
@Artehenis
@Artehenis 2 года назад
OMG, you both were here in Colorado, too?
@evenaskeladden
@evenaskeladden 2 года назад
So Luke is, like, staying in Colorado for a while?
@FuelFire
@FuelFire 2 года назад
Oh my, old norse is damn similar to german. Let me show you with some words in a "EN ‐ DE" template. Stone - Stein Home - Heim (or Heimat) Sword - Schwert Wind - Wind (W in german is pronounced like V in english)
@Bjowolf2
@Bjowolf2 Год назад
You guys must be great fun at parties 😉
@user-um1tj5nm1g
@user-um1tj5nm1g Год назад
If you learn basics of any slavic language you will get a full image of the languages map. Old norsk have a lot of slavic structure, but in latinic it looks broken a little
@janyceviero6026
@janyceviero6026 Год назад
Yep, thats how i read german, old norse, Norwegian, and most of the germanic languages. To me is just like English. In portuguese we also pronounce W as V, and some words in portuguese have germanic roots and borrowed from germanic.
@historicalheathen5058
@historicalheathen5058 Год назад
I think runes are an essential study. They give a lot of clues to how things were pronounced different by looking at the spellings.
@droops63
@droops63 2 года назад
This reminds me of the Liga Romanica group, which I follow because I'm re-learning my Portuguese and they're a fun group. Speaking of which, would be fun to see you both with Simon Roper and speaking ancient languages together. Dang, makes me want to get out my Homeric Greek texts, but I don't need that headache right now as my mind isn't as good as both of your minds in working through Indo-European languages. I know just enough to understand what you all are describing and otherwise get myself into trouble thinking I could learn this stuff. :) Regardless, fun collaboration. Hope to see more.
@NeonCicada
@NeonCicada 2 года назад
The hardest thing for me was learning to make the different 'r' sounds.
@oaknthyme4508
@oaknthyme4508 2 года назад
How about if I already have German as a second language?
@artawhirler
@artawhirler Год назад
Luke: "There's ONE regular verb in Ancient Greek." Only a slight exaggeration! lol
@pierreabbat6157
@pierreabbat6157 2 года назад
Do you get comments from Icelanders about your pronunciation like the ones Luke gets from Greeks?
@Ggdivhjkjl
@Ggdivhjkjl 2 года назад
Why is it unlikely that I'm going to get in a time machine and go back to Iceland 900 years ago?
@Thulgore
@Thulgore 2 года назад
Languages are THE parallel I use to explain evolution to people. Sadly it has the same problem, we have "fossils" though we will never know exactly how it sounded. (actual fossils we don't know exactly how they looked) In both cases we have a skeleton and current comparitives.
@robertoluigipagani1626
@robertoluigipagani1626 2 года назад
Interesting take on the difficulty, as an Italian who studied both Latin and Greek but specialised in Old Icelandic, I have to say that the latter was a piece of cake to learn compared to Latin. Jackson refers only to morphological intricacies (which Latin doesn’t lack anyway), but he forgets the syntax: Old Icelandic sentences are more often than not quite linear and simple. Latin sentences can be insanely convoluted and have to be read over and over to work out what is referring to what. I would personally switch the order between Latin and Old Icelandic
@spellandshield
@spellandshield 2 года назад
It must be an interesting experience to learn Latin as a speaker of modern Latin (Italian); it is one thing to learn it with German or English as a native language but in your case you can recognise so much of the quotidian vocabulary that is lacking in Germanic languages.
@robertoluigipagani1626
@robertoluigipagani1626 2 года назад
@@spellandshield a fair amount of vocab, yes, but so much has changed, so many words have a different meaning, that most of the links between Latin and Italian become obvious only after one has mastered both to a degree. I still find Old Icelandic much easier
@Allan_son
@Allan_son 2 года назад
What i have never figured out is whether all the covoluted structures in latin are a basic function of the language or of its literary writers? English would be a whole bunch harder if it were taught based on the pretentious literature of the Victorian era! Admittedly Latin is far more open to this type of abuse if one wishes.
@robertoluigipagani1626
@robertoluigipagani1626 2 года назад
@@Allan_son a combination of both: the morphology at some point was as complicated as in the literary language, though it got simplified starting very early until it evolved in the morphology of the Romance languages; the syntax on the other hand was of course not so complicated in daily speech as it is in texts of authors like Cicero or Tacitus. Problem is we don’t learn Latin to study the daily speech of the romans as much as their literature
@Philoglossos
@Philoglossos 2 года назад
I would tend to agree, but I wonder if your perception would change if you used more CI based/active methods for learning Latin. I speak Latin but I learned through LLPSI and found it pretty intuitive. That said I'd still tend to agree with you, having studied Icelandic I think it's overall gonna be easier despite Icelandic morphology definitely being harder than Latin morphology.
@sebsanchez6064
@sebsanchez6064 2 года назад
this is my multiverse of madness
@jacobklunder8552
@jacobklunder8552 2 года назад
I already speak Danish, English, and German, how hard would it be for me?
@aesir1ases64
@aesir1ases64 2 года назад
prob a thousand times easier than to me who only knows portuguese and english lol
@longuevalnz
@longuevalnz 2 года назад
All three will help with vocab and German will give you a big head start on the grammar!
@lidyseinen
@lidyseinen 2 года назад
Try dutch ..
@ulfdanielsen6009
@ulfdanielsen6009 2 года назад
" I cod a ball?"
@beepboop204
@beepboop204 2 года назад
👍
@BerishStarr
@BerishStarr 2 года назад
As a Swede, I understand more of old Norse than I thought I could 🤔😁
@Artehenis
@Artehenis Год назад
The same thing happens for English speakers who learn German then read Old English.
@livedandletdie
@livedandletdie 10 месяцев назад
One day I want to understand how the f, the East Danish Dialects got so freaking messed up, but by then they might be long gone. All 3 dialects might be gone in 10-15 years.
@hollish196
@hollish196 2 года назад
Sounds like it is just more difficult than Polish.
@greywuuf
@greywuuf 2 года назад
Old Norse always sounds to me like English spoken by a German.
@SAVAGE308408
@SAVAGE308408 2 года назад
You live a bit south of me I believe, I would love the chance to come cowboy for you and maybe pick your brain on some old Norse from just the view of a Ole Wyoming cowboy
@Bjowolf2
@Bjowolf2 Год назад
Even today the three very similar Scandinavian languages are to a large extent like parallel worlds of an older simplistic (Middle) English at their basic levels, so once you discover all these predictable correspondence patterns, you will find them everywhere. Fortunately all these deep similarities in much of the basic vocabulary and the most important grammatical features ( case free for nouns and their articles as in E. , same word order as in E. (mostly), similar formation of tenses, many parallel irregular verbs, verbs conjugated the same way for ALL grammatical persons, sing. & plur. like E. nearly has it ) make it fairly for Scandinavians to learn English - it's as if we already have a crude core English in our brains in advance and an intuitive understanding of the essentials of English, so that we just need to fill in the gaps - often without even having to think very much. 😂 D Skal vi [ve] gå [go] ud igen [ee-gain] for at finde min [meen] ko og min kalv nu [noo*]? E Shall (OE sceal!) we go out again (for) to find my cow and my calf now? D Hvad vil du ( orig. "thu") give mig [migh] / ham [hAm] / os / dem efter din tur [toor] til England? E What will you (thou) give me / him / os / them after your (thine) trip (tour) to England? D Jeg [yigh] kan høre [hoer-e] dem komme - se, de er [air] allerede her(e). Kom, lad os møde [moeth-e] dem ude i(n) gård-en! E I can hear them coming (come) - look (see), they ("dey") are already here. Come, let us meet them out in the yard! And so on and on 😉
@joelm33
@joelm33 2 года назад
So, I can actually learn Old Norse!?
@Nomadicshieldmaid75
@Nomadicshieldmaid75 2 года назад
Where is this nature? Can swap it from norge
Далее
Living an Ancient Language (with Luke Ranieri)
1:13:42
Просмотров 33 тыс.
The Order of Elder Futhark
15:09
Просмотров 13 тыс.
Big Mouse 😂
00:13
Просмотров 100 тыс.
Learning Finnish: My First Steps
44:38
Просмотров 58 тыс.
How do we know what a dead language sounded like?
22:43
Q&A with Dr. Jackson Crawford and Dr. Luke Gorton
1:03:58
Old Norse vs. Proto-Norse (Elder Futhark Language)
21:45
The Old Norse in "Vikings"
20:12
Просмотров 21 тыс.
The Havamal: 15 Stanzas to Live By
26:31
Просмотров 35 тыс.