Socialism or Capitalism? Which one is the best? I The role of Market & Govt in Pakistan 

Great Kaiser sahab yehe haqiqat hy es accidentally emerged country ki yahan k kiya educational institute aur kiya intellectual debate auqat nhi hy enki

Islam is the best way backwards.

Qaiser sahib's views are very much realistic and much appreciated. What I'd suggest here, is to promote our Economic and Financial system as per Shariah law (Islamic jurisprudence).

Sugar barons, automobile sector, real estate sector, paper industry, textile industry, stock market, banking sector and army are liable for state collapse wow Kaiser bengali

State responsible for food security, clean water, health care, housing investment to boost economic drive.

Amazingly explained

Very Very nice speach and excellent idea

If this is possible then why our political elite don’t want to implement this?

asal masla non developmental expenitures ka hai ? 83% of the gdp jehadfesabhiLila walas orha le ja rhe hai ? eske taraf bhe twajo dena chahei ta ?

wow

Is there any change possible in pakistan ???

Qaisar sahib is a respectable name in economic circle...I am disappointed to listen him criticising the fertilizer sector for getting gas at 13% of the national tariff. This is totally false statement... The gas provided to fertilizer is as feedstock used as raw material. The price of feedstock is around 30% of the normal gas price for the industrial use. This differential is not for fertilizer industry but the fertilizer provided to farmers. The Economist failed to mention that the price of urea provided by domestic industry to our farmers has been as low as one fifth of international market...it was sold @ 2000 per bag, when imported urea price was over 10000 per bag...Be honest, please

Qaisar bangaly ko surkh salamunas

But we have bad experience with government departments like SNGPL, Electricity , PIA etc. Their permanent employees are lazy and don't work efficiently So how will you justify. That's why privatization is a better solution for countries like Pakistan. At least we can have services in time without delay.

😂please upload whole debate

You are spending too much on defence than you actually shoud given your marco Economic conditions curtailed by higher imports, devaluation of currency, high fiscal deficit etc. Pak being an agricultural economy imports over $3 billions of food items a year🤦🤦

why sitting people clapping (this is time to be ashamed and think )

There are no words to me for kaisar bangali SB I always say hats off to him ❤

Dr. Kaiser Bengali the blessed, may he have a long life! Aameen 🤲🤲🤲

ریياست قبلہ درست ہو گا تو سب سیٹ ہو گا 💯🇵🇰👍🏻

sir dekheee capitalisim or socialis dono honee chahyeee jese dekheee bijli kaa sector hoooo 1-govt bheeee bijli bnayee sastee or private companies bhee bijlii babayeee jiskooo 24/7 bijliii chahee hooogee wooo private players see bijlii leegee or sastee bijli walee govt seee leengee

A great pro people economist. Respect and salute to him.

Why he can't be our Finance Minister.

Very bitter, but true realities.. he said quite right,, keh fauj aur sarmayah daaron k corrupt network ko torrnay k liye "baghawat" karni parri gay,, is k alawah koi option nahi hay.

execellent probes and analysis

Kaiserji explains so well.

If we replace the words "capitalism" and "socialism" with their Urdu equivalents, I think we can be more practical and effective. The principle of running the economy should be socialist, because socialism says that if there are four people and three loaves of bread, they should share them. On the other hand, capitalism says that the one who has bread should eat it, and the one who doesn't should pray. Therefore, we cannot accept capitalism in any form. Practically, the economy should be managed through the market because markets are more efficient. In my opinion, Pakistan has a significant budget deficit, and to reduce it, the government must cut unnecessary expenses. The defense budget needs to be reduced because it is dragging down Pakistan's economy. There is also a massive trade deficit, with imports being much higher than exports. This is unsustainable, and we need to restructure this imbalance. Domestic land reforms are also urgently needed, especially in areas like Sindh and South Punjab, where the feudal system must be changed. Currently, Pakistan is divided into two: one Pakistan for the elite and the other for the common people. The children of the wealthy have access to quality education, while those from poorer backgrounds are denied such opportunities. Market regulation is also essential because, without it, markets always create inequality, as seen in the United States with Trump and Brexit. China and Vietnam are excellent examples of state enterprises operating on market principles, but they are regulated by the government in the interest of the people. Similarly, the Pakistani state must play a role to ensure the development of underprivileged areas, as the private sector alone cannot do this. The privatization of the private sector has harmed the lower-income groups, as seen with the Karachi Electric Supply issue, where affluent areas receive power while poorer neighborhoods face 12-hour outages. The role of the state in the economy is vital, and it must act in the public's interest without relying on the private sector alone.

Well done Qaiser Bengali Sahib very correct very brave

❤️

Jab tuk foj ki ghunda gardi or politics me involvement khatam nahe hoge, Pakistan kabhi bhi tarki nahe karega.

Sir Bengali.....u are a real professional not 2 number as around you.God bless you.

بیل تو کوی اچھی لگا لو

Such a Great Man Dr Kaiser Bengali, he presented very Sensible & rational based view.

After such an articulate speech the continuous loud clapping tells that these audiences had no interest or understanding of the grave problem of Pakistan. Good luck

Mixed economy would be better with equal percentage.

Just have a proper spending and taxation system, free from corruption and mismanagement. Jitnay moo utnee batien.

Lagta ha in sahib ko apni zindagi pyari nai ha.😂😂😂

My goodness. These economist we have since long.

Excellent, Kaisar Sahib you are outstanding. Stay blessed.

Splendid sir

Kindly add english subtitles in it !

I agree with you Sir,you voiced such points which are much critical to discuss,,,capitalism is a leech which sucking the gareeb awam....ghareeb krta hai or beti phir b uski jahaiz ki waja se sari umar Ghar bethi rehti...or ashrafiya 50 shadio ke barabar apny ek bachy ki shadi pe kharch krta hai....lanat hai aesy nizam pe Jis ma adl nahi..!

Well explained, must be shared to civilized people of Pakistan.

When Government people that include politicians, Bureocrate and Govt employees eat all the taxes collected from public, consume major resources, the situation again become unacceptable. Most of the public sectors were eaten by government Bureocrate and govt. Employees in India. In such cases it's better to open such sectors to Private management, who can optimize the resources in most effective way.

Bumper productivity and marketing is your skills.

Explained in a very well manner

قیصر بنگالی تیری عظمت اور دانشمندی اور جرت کو سلام اللہ پاک آپ جیسے لوگوں کی حفاظت فرمائے ۔ ان نیک ارادوں کو پایا تکمیل تک پہچانے کی عوام کو طاقت عطا فرمائے آمین یاربالعالمین

Great dr sb

Nice

Great :Kaiser Bangali Sahib Great Speech...! I have 100% agreed with Kaiser Sahib... under Army More than 100 businesses, D.H.A, NLC must be closed