SOUND BATTLE, GE, ALCO, EMD turbo & non-turbo, What's your favorite? 

EMD hands down!!

ALCOs ge6t my vote for sound all the way. Even their idling was like music to my ears!

ALCO for the smoke, GE for chugging, and EMD for the roar.

NON TURBO!! I ADORE THEM!!

Thanks for sharing

They all sound better than the stuff out there now!

Jack, I don’t know if I could pick a favorite. They’re all great run by’s. Thanks for sharing!

All of them roar

EMD Locomotives are without question my favorite!!

All of them are better than any of the current, modern locomotives! Real sound, nicely captured!

Thanh you

Turbocharged EMDs...!!! 👍👍

EMD's 4 me. Love them old beasts!

Those roots 645s in the sd38s take the cake here i think! Wow! Sounds incredible. The turbo emd is my second favorite

First class video. My vote is for Alco.

good stuff!

I can't help it. I like them all. Excellent video Jack. Thank you.

EMD, by far. The purposeful thrum gets me every time. In comparison the GE's and Alco's sound like they're about ready to fall apart. Roots-blown EMD's sound like untamed fury, but the turbos are more powerful and efficient.

Love the Alco/MLWs, will always be my favorites. The non-turbocharged EMDs sounded different to me. Not that I’ve never heard them before, maybe it’s the environment they were recorded in. BTW thanks for the runby of the NSM SDs. I’ve been looking for some good shots showing the side profile for modeling.

EMD

Awesome video and love all the sounds of different engines Jack!!!!

EMD, no contest!

Alco/MLW

I love all of the sounds, the burble of the old Alco, the turbo of the EMD, the roar of the nonturbo EMD,and the staccato roar of GE. Brings me back memories of watching trains 🚆.

Love the Alcos and early GM's, but EMD all the way.

EMD,nothing like the howl of three Mac's pulling a loaded coal in run 8 through town at 3AM ear splitting, but enjoyed every second!

Love them all! Great selection of power.

EMD Turbo, but GE is on a close 2nd place.

They ALL sound AWESOME to me lol I guess because I just love the sound of this kind of POWER! FOAMER from York Pennsylvania!👅❤🤘

It's great, how you opened it with those Deleware and Hudson GEs. Brings the viewer in, IMHO. When I saw that, I said to myself, "this is going to be interesting." Also, nice touch to end the clip with Boston and Maine blue - and an unusual set of engines, at that.

ALCO! all day, every day! But the non-turbo EMD's sing a unique song too, so that as second place.

I agree with Arturo. While the Alco's and GE's sound great there is nothing that compares with the EMD 567 and 645 throaty roar. It sounds so much more powerful then the GE or Alco's

It has to be the CP MLW M630's and M636's from the 70's and 80's just like the Cartier units in this video. That chug and the black smoke is unmatched. My 1st ever cab ride aboard CP #4707 at age 11 was one of the best rides of my life. They could out pull any EMD of the era and the ground shook as they went by. EMD's were more Cadillac, the MLW's were the blue collar lunch box units ready to go to work everyday.

Non-Turbos all the way. Those SD38’s on the Bessemer are sublime.

Hard to choose but I've always loved the sound of unturboed EMD 567s like those you find in the GP9s. Music to my ears. EMD 645s turboed or not come very close behind as do the old school GE chugs.

Alco!!!!!

The turbo EMD's are my fave. Jack's Cartier "MLW ALCo's pulling hard" are the best sounding 4-stroke Loco pulling vids ive seen on youtube. But for me, still, any turbo EMD notching up or #8 pulling hard is my fave sound. The modern GE's sound too generic for me, haha

My tops is the Alco, especially the C/M 636 then the EMD SD45, 20 cylinder beast of pure power, the C-36-7 is next. They all sound awesome In they’re own way, each has a unique personality, that has unfortunately been subdued with the modern engines with all the emission crap and mufflers. I definitely miss seeing and hearing the variety of the Santa Fe and SP of the 70’s 80’s and 90’s. Thanks for your great films, a true joy to watch and keep the good times alive. Funny how you take time for granted till they’re past….. I’ve never was a big fan of the F40PH, they were so plain and so many around here in the 80-90’s they were replaced with GE P32BWH and they had a great look and sound now they’re gone and I kinda miss the F40. Great show! Thanks

Love the Seaboard System SD40-2

I've always loved the sound of ALCO 251's working a heavy coal or iron ore drag, and a Roots-blown 567 switching. Especially when those 567's throttle down! About the only contender missing is that unique sound of those opposed piston Fairbanks Morse units.

I like Alco and GE and EMD it all comes to CSX YN2 Colors

Like all 3. Fairbanks morse had a unique sound all their own. I do prefer the non turbo emd to turbo.

This video reminds me that a Chicago record company call veejay records released an album the Four Seasons vs. The Beatles and you could vote on either group I never voted and as far as the locomotives here I'm not going to vote here either the one thing I would vote for is for you Jack posting more good stuff like this.

The chugging noise of the GE's are great! But the EMD are my favorite because of the turbo.

I’ve always liked the 710’s at full throttle.

EMD SD80 MAC is my all time favorite sounding loco. V20 710ci per cylinder turbocharged 2 stroke diesel, they sound sooo mean💪🏼😎

Alko engines, Good old smokey! They have their own sound.. The good old classic GE chug! And that EMD roar!, The song of The Roots blower of the EMD 567, 2, or sounding like a distant tornado siren in the case of the 6:45 E3 turbocharged. Not sure about the 710 yet. I grew up with that good old GE chug, so the 7F DL and h series, even the gevo sound fantastic, so it's up there with the 567. Nothing quite like waking up to the good old thunder of a GE! So as far as which one is your favorite? That's a tough one, an EMD, it's kind of like a series 71 Detroit, it has a unique characteristic sound. The EMD 645, quite literally roars, it and a 567, sound very interesting when listening to their valve trains. Another note about a GE, they sure do growl. But I'll have to say, there's something nostalgic about the giant sound of an EMD 567. Thank you Mr Kettering.

Non turbo it has to be the EMDs and for the most unique alcos always could tell how they were working by the smoke

All have special places in my memory and heart, still never have I wavered in my belief of the symphony of metal that was and is a GM EMD Turbo-charged 645 or 710. It is still the sound of wonder and power and adventure. Even today, I can still hear in my mind the sound of GM EMD's on the Alleghany Sub of the CSX on their knees pulling coal trains up by White Sulphur Springs, WV and on to the Allegheny Tunnels four miles further up the line. Sound of sounds! Sight of Sights!

Baldwin ?

All

I love GE and EMD Respectively

All have their good sounds, but I’m going with ALCO to break up the EMD meat riding that’s going on in this comments section

Bestest sound ever is the SD45 in full tilt. That long drone as it cycled out 20 cylinders was so distinctive. a close second would be EMD non turbo's. Most of the last MLW's, like the Cartier's always sounded more like GE's. the "true" Alco sound is the second group, the CP's. When Alco's sounded like the bolts on the pistons were a couple turns loose at the cam shaft. The old U25-U30 series boats sounded so much better then later models. They were choppy as f**k when working hard.

The EMD trains sound impressive on video, but I'd say my favourite was the CP Alcos, they sounded gorgeous

I'll take GE for the win! The turbo whine and throbbing from an EMD is hard to beat and a smoky Alco units are a sight to see but IMO nothing beats the GE Chug in notch 8 and the spewing of black smoke.

I vote for CSXT/WM 6573. I was awakened by 6573 as she passed thru Morgantown West Virginia on her way to Fairmont, not long before she died. I lived across the Mon River from the B&O line, and she made a horrible/beautiful racket causing me to look out the window to see what was up. Never having seen a locomotive in WM livery, I hopped into the car and headed down to Fairmont to get some photos. I still have a digital copy of one photo. The rest being lost to a flooded basement. Anyway the WM is dead - Long Live the WM!!

Emd first , ge 2nd , alco , 3rd

Well, I think they all sound pretty great, I do like the throbbing GE/Alco, maybe just because that is such a different sound... My favorite catches because of great angles, and AMAZING paint schemes, were # 3 # 5 and # 7! I have always really liked the Chessie System, Southern Pacific, and Santa Fe schemes. I caught a Southern Pacific AC44CW a few days ago, if you want to check that video out, it's the newest one on my channel. Great video = )

Alco 6 R 251 Flo 1500 sau 3000?

GE and ALCO any day over EMD’s in sound. EMD’s sound good, but not as good as the chugging. Not a huge fan of the EMD scream.