SOUNDS OF SILENCE | DISTURBED Vocal Coach Analysis - DUMBFOUNDED!  

I’m a 57 year old US Army Cold War Veteran, I listened to Simon and Garfunkel in my youth, I also like and have met Disturbed. When I heard this cover the first time, I had tears streaming down my face, David really made me understand and feel this song in ways the original never did.

For me, David's version brings the angst the lyrics convey. S&G's version was a warning, and this version is, "You fools. You didn't listen."

The fact that he had the flu, and a 100+ degree temp when he performed this makes it even more amazing

Don’t worry. Every one gets their guts fully torn out by this performance. I don’t want to overstate it…but it’s a holy experience. Every. Single. Time. It’s an incredible gift. Thanks for sharing your reaction. ❤

I played this for my 83 year old Mother-In-Law. After the song was over, I looked at her and she was just sitting there in tears. It touched her in her soul as well.

I've been binge watching reactions to this song for a while and while many reviewers were able to analyse his range and technique, yours was the most genuine and honest reaction - you felt it in your gut and actually cried; he reached out and touched you . . . Exactly the same reaction as mine 😉 Thank you for your honesty 😊

You get it! Someone finally gets it!! You made the connection that I feel every time I here this song. So many reactions to this version and I almost didn't watch yours, but I figured why not one more. The emotional connection, the penetration of your being, you got it. Than you for taking the time for this. This is the best reaction video for this performance I have seen. You didn't just analyze it, you felt it, you lived it. You made the deep connection to it that I didn't think anyone else would get. Everyone needs to see this, so they can better understand what really happened.

You felt it... I cry every time... I get chills... it really fits the lyrics... the passion pain and emotions

I’ve never commented on anything in RU-vid. But your discussion of the emotions that this rendition evokes resonated so much I felt compelled to thank you for eloquently saying what my heart feels every time I listen to this song. It strikes me so hard that I go from one vocal coach review to another to see how others connect. I cannot even explain why it hits me as hard as it does, but I suppose that is all a part of the genius of this song… the lyrics, the composition, and most certainly David’s sharing of himself and his gift. Your review spoke my emotions. Thank you.

The narrative arc of how he sings this is pure masterclass. Yes, the technique, but above and beyond… From introspective sadness, to rising sense of urgency to communicate something important, a moment of contempt for the deaf ears, to rage, to bitter sorrow and final empty sense of spent sorrow. This is a thing of beauty.

Your ability to interpret and describe all of the emotional and lyrical nuances of this song are a joy to behold. Bless you.

Wow. This lady can really sing too. Intelligent reaction and I can see an empathetic soul there

I love that you really heard not only the quality of the voice, and the musicians....you felt the message. And David Draiman is classically trained. Probably my favorite song EVER.

Every hair on my body stands up every time I hear him sing this. He is absolutely amazing. I feel the depth of his emotion in my soul. His voice envelops me.😎🇨🇦👵

This is one of those songs where you get chills every time you hear it. And I love that Paul Simon enthusiastically approved this version even saying it was truer to the meaning of his lyrics. People have said that Paul Simon's version was the warning, and this song was the anger because no one listened.

It's not just one of the best covers ever, it's one of the best interpretations of a song ever. The song completely changes tone without changes the lyrics. Pure magic.

This is probably one of the best covers of a song EVER done. David Dramon's voice pushes so much emotion through this song, much more so than Simon & Garfunkel ever did. With the lyrics of this song, I honestly feel like the way that he sings it truly fits the song better than the original.

I feel the need to comment on your analysis! Don’t worry I loved it! I’m a middle aged man from Ireland that cannot sing and don’t know much about the the technicalities of singing. So you and I don’t have an awful lot in common you’d think.. But your reaction was precisely how I felt about this song since I happened across it about 4 years ago. Except of course you can express your emotions and technical analysis far more eloquently than I ever could! I’ve been obsessed with this song so much that I must have watched about 200 reaction vids on it at this stage, and I haven’t commented on many if any. But I feel, more than most I’ve seen, that you got this song the way it was meant to be got! FairPlay, you’ve earned my sub. Keep up the good work!

I've seen more reactions to this song, both live and the studio version than I can count. I have to say, THIS is probably my favorite reaction ever. You explained things in a way that I've never heard before. Your appreciation of David's technique and talent mirrors my own, and many others I'm sure. I knew once he hit the growl ("and the people bowed and PRAYED"... vocal fry? distortion?) that you'd have a strong reaction. Great job! 💖

You couldn’t have described any better how this song penetrates our being and it’s effect on the physical body. I’ve listened to this piece countless times and still find that it reaches into my soul in such a powerful way every time. I am 69 years old and was quite a fan of S&G in the 60’s and 70’s and have sung along with that song many, many times. However, the power behind each word in this version, completely penetrates to the core with no way of escape. The words and message have always been there, it just needed a new messenger. I am grateful for Paul Simon writing this prophetic piece and giving it a voice to be carried and shared throughout the world.

I've watched many reactions and analysis of this song. However, I literally watched this song hit you physically and emotionally. This has to be the best analysis I've seen. You put into words what I was thinking, or feeling, the first time I heard this cover. I was driving home from work and literally had to pull over, collect myself, then continue home.

I think everyone was left speechless by David's version. The first time I heard it, I literally had to replay it several times. I could absolutely not believe the way it hits you. I have yet to come across another song that does what this one does. Period. And I challenge everyone who calls themselves an artist to outperform David's Sound of Silence. I'll wait.....

I’m sure I’m not the only one that watches every analysis or first listen to this song they can find because I absolutely love seeing how I feel reflected in these videos every single time I hear this song. It’s like I get to experience the first time I heard it all over again.

I've watched reactions to this many times. You are the only one who's mentioned the audience. I am always amazed by the audience...they wait until the final musical notes to react at all. They had to be sure that it was over and they weren't going to miss anything. I would have too. I would think more than half the audience members had their mouths hanging open after that and many had tears running down their faces. Stunning, stunning performance.

David sings this song right into your soul‼️ He was ill when he performed this show, so imagine how he sounds when he's on top of his game. You MUST listen to the studio version. Blows my mind every time I hear it.

I came across this version of the song only a couple of weeks ago and since then have been listening to it everyday, including watching as many vocal-coach analyses that pop onto my YT feed as I can -- yours has been my favourite so far -- you perfectly described everything about it that I have not been able to articulate -- I will never be able to go back to the original Simon & Garfunkel version -- this is Disturbed's masterpiece now (even Paul Simon agreed) -- thank you for your beautiful, honest analysis.

Ok…. I am SO thrilled that there are multitudes of people out there that when they listen to the song, they feel like they’ve gone to church! This song is without a doubt a spiritual experience! It is so beautiful, it brings you to tears! This is absolutely a masterpiece! I have heard it 1000 times, and I will never tire of it! It’s my warm-up song every day at the gym! Thank you David, you’ve touched all of our souls…💖💖💖

This version by Disturbed is amazing and you can literally FEEL it deep. Her review was so beautiful and personal and made me cry when she cried. I listened to this over and over!

I wasn’t ready for this Bianca. I didn’t know what to expect either, but as it hit you my days it hit me double. Thanks for sharing this raw reaction

“What the heck do I mean by that.” We know girl, we all felt it and no one can describe it.

David Draiman’s voice is so powerful, yet has a very emotional softer side that penetrates my heart! He is incredibly talented!❤️

Your reaction it’s priceless. When I heard this version I cried too, I raised my hands, I praised! And listening you share your intake confirms what I’ve been feeling it’s the exact thing I should feel. Reading the comments that we all have experienced I even had to ask my son if he thought it was too dark. Rock it’s my jam; heavy metal not to much; English it’s my second language so I needed confirmation. I appreciate you taking the time and all of your amazing followers for commenting too. ❤❤

This is probably the best reaction and take on Disturbed's version of The Sound of Silence, and I've seen most of them.

Wow. I think your reaction was as powerful as the song itself. Great job!

I saw them live and they did this song, it was absolutely incredible, and the audience along with David were about all crying by the end of the song. Very powerful, even better live!!

I first discovered this song watching a reaction video a few years ago. I've been watching people discover it ever since. I had no words the first few times I watched it. It took me a couple weeks to realize how amazing the instrumentals are. For me, this is the definitive version of this song. Your reaction is one of my favorites. In one video, you called out things it took me weeks to identify. I especially appreciate that you called out the hope in this song. So many comments call out the anger, but I feel this is a call to action. The official video (which I saw later) confirms that for me. Thank you for the beautiful experience. I haven't cried over this one in a while. P.S. Your voice is beautiful as well. Thank you for sharing it.

Sharing tears with you from across the pond, Bianca... such a skilled, gorgeous, and moving performance. Thank you for your vulnerability & enthusiasm -- your video was a pleasure to watch!

I love that you feel this and understand the emotion of this 1000%

Thank you @Vocal Nova Academy for posting your reaction. Thank you especially for allowing the last two verses to play uninterrupted while you bravely absorbed Draiman's emotive connection, angelic tone, and raw power. I respect that you gave in and allowed the tears to flow. The head nod at "... people bowed and prayed" in recognition of how big this was getting. The giant, deep breath during "to the neon gods they made", looks like to try to recover some emotional balance, and then the overwhelmed look up and to your right at "... flashed out it's warning", looked like a way of saying, "Wow, this is just getting more powerful." For my part, I first heard this song while conducting business in a local bike shop. I literally had to walk to a quiet corner of the store and sobbed - face in hands, shoulders heaving. Been a professional musician for 35 years and never moved like that.

Finally, someone mentions the arrangement! The exquisite frame for David's perfect vocals. For me, it doubled the pleasure. Very imaginative, too -- who would have thought of tympani for a S&G song? Yet they formed a perfect deep floor for the voice and strings to rise against. His voice made me weep, too. Perfect pitch, perfect enunciation, with just enough distortion to emphasize the passion. It was a gift to us, and I am grateful. And thank you for your honest reaction. Well done!

OK. Couple of minutes later. Not only was that a wonderful visceral reaction, but your words were absolutely outstanding. I have watched dozens of reactions to this track and yours is the most complete, intelligent and appreciative yet. Bravo! That tear near the end showed true appreciation.

Sometimes it's things that you don't expect to affect you that do,just brilliant 👍

David's voice is a roller coaster ride for our senses. Starting out slow, then climbing up to the highest peak. We're then plunged into raw emotion. Chill bumps, heart beating fast. You're reaction left me misty-eyed. I love to see the wonder and awe in people's faces when they hear it for first time. I watched.the video, and it instantly became my favorite song ever. This live version is even better. I will live a very long time, to watch and listen to my song ❤

This song, for me, is like a blanket of darkness that cradles my wounded soul 🖤

David trained as a Cantor, from a very long line of accomplished Cantors, when he went into metal music he also trained to do distortion and not harm his voice . Disturbeds version of SOS is a master class. You need to go see the original music video as well .

In your intro when you mentioned your delay in addressing this version of the song and the fact that the S&G ordinal version was one of your faves I was so excited to see your reaction. You, as other comments have mentioned, felt it within the very fibers of your being. In your struggle to vocalize your reaction I was watching you being truly overwhelmed with the pleasant surprise that this long hesitated introduction brought you. The one word that kept coming to mind that I thought you were feeling was "genuine". The genuine emotions this reincarnated composition brings to an already marvelous lyrical message is simply undeniable. David Draiman is the perfect vessel through which to deliver the meaning of these lyrics. His vocal diversity allows him to genuinely address every well-written illustrative phrase that Paul Simon birthed with the variety of skills that those messages each deserve. I am glad to see another owrson so moved by this brilliant cover version of the song. Paul Simon admitted after hearing this himself that the song is no longer his. THAT, IMO, is the highest praise that Disturbed could ever get for this song. As to Draiman's training, I can't speak volumes about it but I do know he was raised in a devoutly Jewish home and was trained in the music of that faith. In fact, if my memory serves me, his parents never heard him sing any music outside of his religious genre until after Disturbed had already been signed to release their first album. While I am not a religious person myself, I truly believe David Draiman's vocal abilities are an absolute gift from the heavens and I can't think of a modern song that could demonstrate that any better than Disturbed's brilliant version of S&G's already powerful song.

The Sound of Silence has always been a song that plugged at my feelings, but when I heard this version the first time I was floored and a mess. And to this day it all ways brings a tear to my eye.

Thank you for this reaction video. You brought the heart and soul of my experience watching Disturbed with David perform this song and you did it justice!!!! I've watched the Conan video and watched SO MANY reaction videos, because this is probably the most moving performance I have EVER SEEN, and I really want to understand WHY! this paritcular performace was so powerful?!? I have ZERO musical background. YOU explained it perfectly. So thank you...please keep doing what you do!

He was trained as a canter when he was young and he's been classically trained and continues training

Beautiful analysis! You should watch the official video to see the imagery they put together to go with the music and voice. I'd love to see you discover that masterpiece! Even if you don't react to it, you should watch it for yourself. And David was trained as a Jewish cantor. He continues to train with a vocal coach to this day, but that was his foundation. He and the band are simply magnificent!

I am 56 years old and I have heard 100's of amazing Artists sing their original songs and then have those songs covered by other amazing artists but this song is one in a million, the best cover I know I will ever hear in my lifetime. I listen to it at least once a month and it still gives me the most amazing roller coaster of emotions. In regard to the comments concerning the audience being so quiet I believe the performance of the song was recorded the day before with no audience and then shown during the show. I truly feel that if the performance would have been live the audience would have been so blown away that you would have been able to hear a pin drop after the performance while the audience composed themselves after hearing David's performance, I know the first time I heard this song I was speechless.

I went through some emotions after listening to this song like never before, a absolute masterclass

Sapnin Bee 🐝 First off I have to say, you are welcome, this is hands down my favourite live performance ever, everything you said I agree with, when you said about the darkness in his initial tones, I felt the same but like it was hidden and he was holding back. I hadn’t heard his voice until this was shared with me and I had to share it with you. I did cry with you, but what hits me hardest about this particular performance is that, literally every single tone you can imagine a male voice having, is hidden somewhere within this performance and he just keeps adding layer upon layer until the metal crescendo at the end. Literally perfect Great video JD

Nobody ever expected this song. This cover has so many amazing things about it. It's so many feelings combined. It's a nostalgic feeling, then piled on is this feeling of doubt and surprise like seeing someone on one of those talent shows pop out some crazy talent or voice or act they've created, and then it's just an awstruck feeling of his actual voice and the orchestra and the build up. And throughout there's the message of the song that makes you think and feel and in the end it's like you just got done watching a full movie with a twist and a climax and a satisfying ending and you're left there not sure how to unwrap what the fuck just happened. But you know you feel good in the very pit of your existence.

People think music is meant to be heard. This is the perfect example that Music is meant to FELT. In your heart and soul 💜

This song is an emotional journey that transcends generations, genres, and time. David is brilliant and this cover is a masterpiece.

I've been a Distubed fan since the beginning. David is a classically trained vocalist and knows how and whento use grit. His voice gives me goosebumps. Love it! When he did this performance, he was sick.

Your reaction is as beautiful as the performance itself. Just as I listened to the song numerous times to savor the moment, I also watched your reaction many times to savor the moment. Bravo, Bravo, bravo👏👏👏

I've listened to this song hundreds of times and still blubber. I always liked the Simon and Garfunkel version but David's singing takes it up to surprising level.

I usually poo poo cover songs, but this hits hard! The original version always got me emotional, and I have listened to it on repeat. I feel as though this version intensifies that emotional state. I noticed the tears. It's happening here my dear!

David Draiman ....I think he's one of the best male vocalists on the planet. Beautiful. A powerful yet soulful voice that can go from warm baritone to angelic tenor, from clear as a crystal to vocal fry/distortion and back on a dime. He has a timbre in his voice that I've never heard before.....just hauntingly beautiful tonal properties to it! Was loving your reaction Bianca.

This was my first introduction to Disturbed. SOS was my favourite song for so many years and now/still is with this version. It affects me anew every time - chills, rocked back, tears. Thank you for the respect for this yes ‘masterpiece.’

My favorite part of all these analysis/reaction videos of this song is how differently each reviewer reacts. Every one of them is unique. Some of them wear their emotions all over their body language, others describe it as "colors" and I saw one lady looked like she was almost in ecstacy. They're all different. It's awesome.

We get slammed and guts ripped out. Absolutely! Obliterated by this song. Don't worry, you're one of us.

He brings the reality of "the struggle is real".

Best reaction I've seen to this song 🧡 I can't get enough of them. Due to my musical snobbery, I've never been Down with the Sickness nor said "Oh, ah ah ah ah". So I refused to listen to this. Recently I *did* listen...and actually cried. I felt this ☝️ way. I was an arrogant, ignorant ass. No more. I thank David Draiman...how could I not? Paul Simon did.

You have had The Best! reaction to this performance!! Hell Yeah!! Loved it! 💖💖💖

Out of all the reactions to this song out there, (and I’ve watched many of them) in my opinion this is 100% the one that does the best job of not only analyzing it vocally but more impressively the powerful EMOTION it brings out. We’ll done!

I get chills whenever I watch that version. When I saw your head go down and begin to shake, I began to cry with you. It was beautiful to watch you experience this for the first time.

You described the essence of this song interpretation perfect! Beautifully stated!

I am 75 y/o and studied at the feet of Simon & Garfunkel as a teen and beyond. I absolutely LOVE this treatment of The Sounds of Silence. David Draiman drew me in with his vocals and your reaction was priceless. I watched 20+ reaction videos and nobody had put words to my emotions..... BUT. YOU. DID. I was like you. I was transformed. The words from my youth, which I so lightly regarded, have now become my warning to a preoccupied generation. And yet, I am oddly comforted by the warmth of Draiman's voice, his tones. I am somehow feeling safe because HE is sounding the alarm. Alas.... who doesn't love a good paradox?

I knew I loved this version of the song but I couldn't put it into words. You did that. Thank you.

Fantastic analysis! Thank you. This is one of my all-time favorite performances.

Thank you! Your analysis and moving reaction was unsurpassed. David’s voice and the accompanying orchestration create a seamless masterpiece.

I've listened to dozens of responses to this and you are the first to match my true response and emotion to this.

First, his voice is wonderfully emotive. Second, that is pure masculine energy there. Third, there’s the sadness, and the warmth, and the lyrics - his voice gets right into your soul. Tears are appropriate.

This was always amazing. This was a time where musicians put their soul into their music. Today's music doesn't compare

I've heard this song countless times and I was tearing up right along with you! This song just does something to me. A great example of the power of music.

Bless you for your reaction ... I STILL cry EVERY TIME that I hear this !!! ❤😭😭😭😭

Oh my goodness! You are the first person that I have heard who analyze this song David sang that got it. You felt how I felt when I first heard this. Every note every word he sang penetrated your heart your mind and your soul. You’re the only one who ever felt it when they analyzed him. Thank you for this

When he did this performative. He wasn't in the best of health. But he did to to prove that he had the strength to sing this outside of a studio environment.

Notice how you never heard the crowd until the end. That's how engrossing David is. He is a great story teller with his songs. There are many more to delve into, hard and melodic. Awesome review! ❤️

One of the coolest thing about RU-vid reactors is the knowledge that I'm not the only person on the planet that is touched so deeply by music. I scream, cheer, cry, bounce, etc to passionate music. This song stirs me deep inside.

So, thanks to your two responses to my comments, I came back for another look. You are so erudite and accurate in your analysis, I am in awe. I have seen dozens of reactions to this track and you really take the biscuit. That tear that dropped from your chin showed just how powerfully this rendition hit you. Bravo!

This version of that song gives me chills every time. His voice starts out so deep and haunting, it reaches right inside and touches you. Awesome version!

Your semblance, is startling. I love it.

I have never connected more with anyone's breakdown of this song that I am utterly obsessed with. You nailed it! Thank you.

This song by David is extraordinary. This is my go to song on repeat, if I have to sit in stop and go traffic on the way home from work. Blasting, windows down, sunroof open, it gives me the adrenaline not to fall asleep, yet gives me the calm and relaxation to not be irritated by rush hour traffic. Powerful and calming all at the same time.

David was classically trained as a cantor. This is my absolutely favorite version of this song. Disturbed has a knack for finding songs that need some righteous anger and covering them extremely well.

I thought I could do it having listened hundreds of times but I could not make it through the first verse without crying watching your reaction. This version as you stated so well hits at the core of my being.

I cried too, it flushed out all the angst, hate, worry, and filled me with love, hope and kindness

I feel like I'm having a deep spiritual experience when I listened to this. It's amazing,beautiful, and so powerful. The review was amazing as well. Thank you.

I like many others I'm sure have watched many reactions to this wonderful performance. I think your focus on the emotional value of the performance is what makes your reaction so genuine. You strayed away from hitting on the technical aspects like so many others have focused on and instead told us how it made you feel which is so very important in terms of musical performances as a whole. Its obvious the original song is something you hold near and dear to your heart. Your decision to focus on how you felt after hearing the first few lines of the song is so refreshing.

Transcendent...and utterly sublime. I think those are the words for which you were grasping.💕

The way David sings this brings out all the feelings in your soul.

This version by Disturbed hit us all like a tonne of bricks. Still gives med the chills. I adore his voice!

Paul Simon really likes Disturbed's cover, and that means alot, and it shows. Seeing interviews of David talking about this show how much respect he has for the song, and that shines through to this performace. It sounds like he internalised the lyrics in his own way, and projected it so clearly. That's why this cover feels almost mystical to me, he does everything so incredibly right

Wow, honey, I felt that way too when I heard it the first time. I love the way you explained the emoting. Never heard that before. Thank you for allowing yourself to be vulnerable. Lots of love your way.

This is exactly what music is for. Pure beauty

It's amazing he sounds the same live as he does in the studio recordings.