Star Wars vs Star Trek- A Fan Film 

Those storm troopers are playing a 40k game😎🤣😂

😁

very true.....so silly

They brought everything BUT thrawn 😏

It would be awesome if Trek bad guys joined the Empire - Romulans, Xindi, Cardassians, Founders, etc. That would make a great sequel.

Same

Nah, just use Genesis. No more Death Star (I guess it’d then be the “Life star”) Same effect, no fancy trench run required!

😁👍

Starfleet gets sexy models, Empire gets basic ones and EVERYBODY ELSE GETS crappy un skinned ones....AND THE CHARACTER MODELS ARE GREAT😁

Agreed

Oh, and of course Aslan leading Delenn out through the wardrobe in the captain’s quarters, and the I.S.S. Enterprise realizing what the NX-01 was up to and turning to intercept, but too late.

I totally agree. This was conclusive and amazing

I agree. Towards the end of making this video I realized how much more I could do with this concept. I am working on a sequel that will hopefully be bigger and more surprising than this one.

Vader used force transport to jump ship🤣

It's the wrong size cause in the Kelvin continuity, Starfleet became paranoid of Nero and the klingons, so they beefed up all their ships to be bigger and more advanced then The Prime Timeline

Yeah, should've been just over half the length of an ISD.

To be fair, so are Kirk and Spock. (Unless Spock happens to be on the Discovery at the moment, in which case three.)

One additional point, you show Starfleet winning, you show Klingons being there, you show other ships too, however you only really show Federation ships firing upon the enemy. Depending on the time period, Klingons may have been alive with the Federation, or may have helped the empire since they our Federation enemies. And as far as the romulans who knows what they would have done. However there may have been other civilizations that would have aided the Federation. Having a vast multilateral organization like Starfleet, against the vast powerful Empire who knows who would have won. I think it would have been such a close thing that they may have both stop fighting before either won. Getting that many ships either Federation or Empire ships to a location have a chance encounter that quickly would have been impossible. Enterprise may have escaped a star destroyer only to return with reinforcements what the Star Destroyer to would have had reinforcements, unless the commander of that star destroyer was arrogant enough to think he could fight against such a puny ship. Which one you consider the Empire is not far-fetched oh, they wouldn't realize the size of the Federation as they have never encountered them before. Even saying that though once a few Empire ships were destroyed the Empire would have a mask forces and come back for a second go around.

You have a very good eye, first off thanks for taking the time to analyze my video. I hoped you enjoyed it. The ships are actually all to scale with each other, a galaxy class starship is actually the only one that is even half the size of a star destroyer. Worf is on two different ships because the anomaly (like the one in all good things) spans multiple periods of time, that's why nx enterprise and the la sirena are able to participate in the same battle despite being centuries apart from each other. As for all the other issues you pointed out you're right, the nx enterprise is too big to fit in the death star trench, the federation could definitely used have transporter technology and probably have won easier, data's hand would probably have been sliced off by a lightsaber, and klingons, romulans, ferengi and tholian ships all show up and are never seen again. I was aware of all of the issues but I decided the video and story worked better if I ignored them, who cares if the nx enterprise cant fit in the trench rum it's a cool visual, who cares if data should have lost its hand it's a cool visual. Anyway thanks for thanks for taking the time to watch and analyze my video

Size doesn't matter here, Walter. ST and SW use totally different technologies. 1701 alone taking down the Star Destroyer was quite correct. She would run circles around a SD with more advanced sensors and weaponry. The turbo lasers wouldn't even penetrate Enterprises shields while a phaser can cut through to a planet's core. Federation ships can fight at sublight AND FTL speeds. The Empire would be dead before they even knew they were in a fight. Tie fighters would bounce off the shields if they weren't picked off by computer controlled phaser strips capable of several vollies at once. In regards to NX01 not fitting in the trench, that's just not right. I know how it looked in SW during the torpedo run, but also take into account when the Falcon is being tractored into the shuttle bay of the Death Star. That bay is in the trench. I've seen calculations done that put the width of the trench at least 4,035 ft (1.23km). NX01's beam is only 442 ft. Room to spare, and then some.

@@RogueFilmsVFX my apologies. Great work on the effort you put in to this. Thank you very much. I enjoyed it!

@@WalterGreenIII Tritanium is 31 times tougher than diamond (while still being a metal) and since duranium is a tritanium based alloy, it's obviously more resistant in every way. Sorry but duranium puts mandalorian iron to shame.

Temporal anomalies. After all, Kelvin Enterprise and TOS were both there.

Star Wars fans also made some mashups, but they didn't watch even one Star Trek series. I've seen both Star Wars and Star Trek, and I'm sure that Star Wars navy is unfortunately slow and underdeveloped compared to Star Trek ships, and I'm not mentioning all of the anomalies, space animals that devour ships, the Borg, species 8472, etc, cause some that things would be okay even in Warhammer 40k.

Of all the fan films I have watched they have all been made by Warsies. How can you tell? In each film the Federation loses. Every Star Trek fan knows the true power of the Federation fleet. See how dumb your generalization is? Anyways, the force doesn't do much other than one feat pulled off by Palpatine at full power where he stops a bunch of ships, but I doubt in an actual space battle this would be useful. Every Trek ship since ENT was able to destroy the surface of a planet in seconds, while Star Destroyers don't have that kind of power.

@@homelessend8557 star wars lasers don't have computer controlled aiming either

I am working on a sequel however it is going to be radically different than this video

@@RogueFilmsVFX , cool! While it would be neat to watch a Jem Hadar warship tear holes with its phased polaron beam my money would be on the Husnock warship as seen in "The Survivors".

It's a fact that phasers are more powerful than turbolasers and Romulan disruptors. Disruptor weapons during the 23rd century were considered more powerful than phasers but at the time of Picard, they were pretty much scoffed at as antique weapons by a guy in what was basically a small freighter ship. Disruptors and turbolasers have different feats and behave differently, since turbolasers have never shown to output the same amount of energy as any Star Trek weapon other than phase cannons.

Picard and worf were both there from multiple times, and Kirk, Spock, Uhura, etc were there from a parallel universe.

Are u guys missing the fact that none of this makes sense? XD still fun to think about tho

They can: i.imgur.com/jUQAhr8.jpg Especially when Star Destroyers shields mostly work on stopping particle weapons rather than physical objects