Dude I haven't heard this song in a while her cover and as soon as I played it I thought the same thing like yep that guy on the piano again I don't know why he doesn't get recognition probably because it's a beautiful woman in front of him but he kills it he's a great pianoist
Honestly dont understand people here are saying she's "trying too hard". I mean? Is it bad that she made this song sound like it's her own? People calm down. Marina even follows Melanie on Instagram yall can chill your noses.
i both love marina and melanie AND SEEING HER COVERING THIS, JUST MAKES MY HEART GO BOOM BOOM p.s. please respect and support both of the artists, just enjoy the video and stop comparing them THEY'RE BOTH TALENTED OKAY?
It's just what I think, I don't like the cover, it's not comparing, I know, but j was waiting for real amazing voices....but no.... it's just Melanie singing in her tone.... She could do better, and if she couldn't, well, that doesn't change my mind
Are people seriously hating on Melanie for a COVER? And then comparing the two like Melanie or Marina are lesser than? Honestly, how old are some of you?
For all the people who used to compare Marina and Melanie... THEY ARE BOTH THEIR OWN ARTIST! Don't need to compare them. They're human beings for crying outloud. Not just props for entertainment. Doesn't matter if one has a bigger platform than another. They both make absolutely beautiful music.
shes fucking amazing at singing and when she sings especially like this its moving i just- shes so amazing and i hope to see a song where she uses her voice like this in the future maybe in after school you never know!!
I love this. The majority of these comments are saying it’s bad but I mean it’s being sung in a different style by a different singer. It gives it a different touch.
This is by far my favorite cover from Melanie. It just makes me cry, the fact that she sing it so emotional and I could feel her emotions. I just love her so much!
Regina George EDIT: I know now that Timothy’s allegations against Melanie were totally false but imma leave this comment here because it still makes a point. I personally love Hitler’s paintings, I think they’re beautiful. Of course I hate him as a person and I’ll never ever ever feel for him or like him, but his art is indeed separate from him and his personality so it’s totally fine to like his paintings.
Electric woflz ohhh I was just giving an example of how you can love someone’s art but still dislike them as a person. Thank you for this comment tho because I completely forgot that I made this comment and now I can edit it now that I know the truth.
@carmen del rey you can call her queen now! Actually she didn't knew why she was being called "queen" she thought like ppl were making her superior above all and she didn't like it. But now she's been using Twitter stan language lately so I'm sure she knows what we mean by calling her a queen ^-^
why all the hate ?? not only is this five years old and her voice wasn’t as good as it is now, but she also just has a really unique voice in general, no need to be rude lmao
I absolutely adore her. Personally, I think that even though some people dislikes her songs or her music in general, they should admit that she's a damn artist. Like, an artist isn't just defined by their art, but by the way they make it. Melanie feels each word, and that's what made my whole existence fall in love with her. She's unique and pure, and each time I listen to an original song of her or a cover, I get to fall in love a little bit more ❤️ La adoro completamente. Personalmente, creo que aunque a un grupo de personas no le gustan sus canciones o su música en general, esas personas deberían admitir que Melanie es una artista. Un artista no sólo está definido por su arte, sino por la manera en la que lo llevan a cabo. Melanie siente cada palabra, y eso fue lo que hizo que mi existencia completa se enamorara de ella. Es única y pura, y cada vez que escucho una de sus canciones originales o un cover, me enamoro un poco más ❤️
I have the same opinion. I also don't care what people say about her fans, how only 12+ years old girls listen to her, I love the way she does it, cause she f*cking does it right. So damn right. I prefer any of her covers more than original songs. Anything she touches, she turns to gold. I hate Marina, yet like this song, just bcs of her cover.
Who ever says negative comments about this totally brilliant performance doesn't know shit about anything. This might be one of the best i have ever seen in this kind of setting. She is not, I say again, she is not overdoing anything at all. Its about as good as this setting will ever get. Beautiful👍🏻😊
this is my favorite song. ever. i can’t even begin to explain how much it means to me. and since i’ve loved melanie for years i freaked out when i saw that she covered it. she sounds so amazing i love her sm
my friend showed me this and i won't regret listening!! we both love Melanie and IMO she made her version incredible. this is one of my fav covers by her.
I love that people are finding this video cause I used to watch it religiously when I first found Mel in 2016 and I always come back to watch it now and then
Yes me too and I’m a guy not that matters but stating the facts lmao. I had a crush on her and I always found it interesting how the pianist looks at her… amazing video. Glad this exists because now I know what it feels like to sit in a room while an angel sings. Beauty
@@zyla13 when she’s like “ when you’re in my heeeeead “ lord. I was like 16 I believe , it was that phase as a teenager where you are sad because you want a love life and don’t really relate to the song but would kind of sit their pretending to know 😂😂😂. When you are now the starring role in someone else’s heart ! I haven’t watched the video in so long and those of my memorable lyrics so I know when I play it imma have an EARGASM
Yoonmin Lover-okay so I’m pretty sure you are saying that you, like the piano man, are in love with Melanie; in that case you should have used me too* rather than “to”.
i havent seen this video in years since i left the melanie fandom but im glad that the comments here arent full of fanwars and hate! back in the day most of the comments were from marina fans hating on mel and im glad that things have changed with the passing of time
they were doing it cause they saw melanie of portraying crybaby like electra heart so basically they thought Melanie was copying marina but i think she just got the idea from her but idrk
@@EclipticRaisin as a marina fan, her fans really just don't like a lot of artists in similar genres😭 but marina herself has stated time and again that while she hates being compared to other female artists, such as lana, she loves their music
I'm a fan of Melanie and marina and I've noticed that in the marina fan base they have so much hate for melanie!? Why? They are both incredibly talented artists who shouldn't be compared. If you don't like the music that's fine it's probably just not for you but you don't need to waste your time hating on Melanie
There’s only one reasonable explanation here, they hate Melanie because they believed the accusations/allegations where Melanie was highly anticipated/involved.
I miss her so much, it makes my heart ache knowing she’s stop singing Guys I meant because Melanie had a break for awhile because of the incident with Timothy Heller
She may have removed the video for the obvious inspiration she got from marina's own alter ego, don't get me wrong Melanie did an absolute different one but the comparison is there
@@ThisIsLoveXLust its not that I dont like Marina and that I'm biased to Melanje but maybe just maybe it git way more views and/or likes to the original song?
It strikes ne how much this makes me think the lyrics talk about my past relationship.... and it even hit a nerve when I wasn't even aware of this whole situation. Pure emotion for me... brings them all back
You're hard to hug, tough to talk to And I never fall asleep, when you're in my bed All you give me is a heartbeat I've turned into a statue And it makes me feel depressed 'Cause the only time you open up is when we get undressed You don't love me, big fucking deal I'll never tell you how I feel You don't love me, not a big deal I'll never tell you how I feel It almost feels like a joke to play out a part When you are not the starring role in someone else's heart You know I'd rather walk alone, than play a supporting role If I can't get the starring role Sometimes I ignore you, so I feel in control 'Cause really, I adore you and I can't leave you alone Fed up with the fantasies that cover what is wrong Come on, baby, let's just get drunk, forget we don't get on You're like my dad, you'd get on well I send my best, regards from hell It almost feels like a joke to play out a part When you are not the starring role in someone else's heart You know I'd rather walk alone, than play a supporting role If I can't get the starring role I never sang for love, I never had a heart to mend Because before the start began, I always saw the end Yeah, I wait for you to open up, to give yourself to me But nothing's ever gonna give, I'll never set you free Yeah, I'll never set you free It almost feels like a joke to play out a part When you are not the starring role in someone else's heart You know I'd rather walk alone, than play a supporting role If I can't get the starring role The starring role
