My Dr. Squatch order with the Bronco Bricc somehow ended up in New York City, so that guide and the Squatch ranking may be delayed awhile, but in the meantime I thought I’d go ahead and make this reranking.
I haven't tried all the bars, but to me, there's only one bar so far that I truly like. I didn't care much for Old Glory, as to me it smells like mothballs, and blueberries and cream didn't really stick out to me as I thought it would from all the reviewers. To me, the best bar from Sudsy Bear is the reformulated Icy Eucalyptus. That bar is great for cooling you down in the summer time. Smells great, and has a crazy amount of menthol crystals, that gives off a great tingly effect.
Awesome ranking! Just started working in Sudsy Bear into the rotation. Neither bricc is on your list I am currently using. I always take your suggestions as gospel. Can’t wait for a complete list!
Playing around with the Sudsy Bear reviews and combined a few together. Its hard knowing how to judge things when only one person has a ranking on a bar like you have on Old saint nick on vacation. When you doing a Community ranking on Sudsy Bear like you did Dr. Squatch? New England Soap Reviews skewed some of these because he isnt a fan of say pumpkin rated some of them really low like Twisted Pumkin(as well as Gary828). Somehow i missed Artic Aloe(which i have) and Barbershop on this: 1 Blueberries and Cream 2 Swamp Dweller 3 Icy Eucalyptus 4 Smokey Mountain Fog 5 Fresh Clean Aloe 6 Old Saint Nick 7 Big Woods Buck Hunter 8 Florida Grove 9 Twisted Mango 10 Petrified Wood and Honey 11 Ghostly Ale 12 Old Forest Pine Tar 13 Twisted Grapefruit 14 Raspberries and Cream 15 Milky Beehive 16 Dark Side of the Moon 17 Old Glory 18 Hunt Camp 19 Old Saint Nick on Vacation 20 Arctic Peppermint 21 Cool Mint Julep 22 Grinch Rinse 23 Living Easy 24 Bear Rum 25 Scrooge Scrub 26 Twisted Pumpkin 27 Backwoods Brew 28 Wild Cherry Goats Milk 29 Wild Caribbean 30 Getting Lucky 31 Peppermint Sage 32 Fright Night 33 Charred Cinnamon Bark 34 Woody Maple Bourbon Scrub 35 Jurassic Earth Arctic Aloe Barbershop Grandpaps Oak Aged Bourbon Still playing around with my favorites. My Artic Aloe, Smokey Mountain Fog(hardly any scent to them at least the ones i got) and Grandpaps Oak Aged Bourbon smells great just not strong enough. I'm in love with the Icy Eucalyptus. 1 Icy Eucalyptus 2 Big Woods Buck Hunter 3 Twisted Grapefruit 4 Old Forest Pine Tar 5 Swamp Dweller 6 Bear Rum 7 Blueberries and Cream 8 Grandpaps Oak Aged Bourbon 9 Dark Side of the Moon 10 Twisted Mango 11 Old Saint Nick 12 Florida Grove 13 Smokey Mountain Fog 14 Arctic Aloe 15 Grinch Rinse 16 Hunt Camp Well not to bored added the other ones and tweaked my highly scientific formula to end up with this: 1 Blueberries and Cream 2 Icy Eucalyptus 3 Swamp Dweller 4 Old Saint Nick on Vacation 5 Big Woods Buck Hunter 6 Fresh Clean Aloe 7 Smokey Mountain Fog 8 Old Saint Nick 9 Florida Grove 10 Ghostly Ale 11 Twisted Grapefruit 12 Old Forest Pine Tar 13 Dark Side of the Moon 14 Petrified Wood and Honey 15 Grandpaps Oak Aged Bourbon 16 Twisted Mango 17 Barbershop 18 Summer Raspberries & Cream 19 Old Glory 20 Arctic Aloe 21 Milky Beehive 22 Bear Rum 23 Twisted Pumpkin 24 Hunt Camp 25 Arctic Peppermint 26 Living Easy 27 Cool Mint Julep 28 Scrooge Scrub 29 Grinch Rinse 30 Gettin Lucky 31 Backwoods Brew 32 Wild Cherry Goats Milk 33 Wild Caribbean 34 Pepperminty Sage 35 Woody Maple Bourbon Scrub 36 Charred Cinnamon Bark 37 Jurassic Earth 38 Fright Night
I do love your rankings. I agree with the Blueberries and Cream. That one, Twisted Mango, and Raspberries and Cream, and Icy Eucalyptus are the only ones I tried and definitely the best soaps I used. I want to try Old Glory and I ordered the Barbershop today. I hope you do a reranking Sudsy Bear deos soon.
Twisted Pumpkin definitely my #1 god tier To me the blueberries down a tier in the absolute Titans but not quite omniscient tier like the twisted pumpkin
It wouldn't be a Frickcast video without a bit of menthol simping. Really though, I agree with most of your takes here. Especially the Hunt Camp. People seem to talk about it a lot, but every time I use it, I feel more and more let down. Ghostly Ale is my current fave.
