No wonder everyone who's had a heart attack around me has died. The funerals were awkward too as they had to cover the bruising on the faces where I slapped them. I really cheered loudly as I wanted them to come around.
I was operated on and they put on some music and asked me if I minded it before starting. I was so drugged and happy that I just said "no, put it louder". They did and it was a good experience all around. Turned out my growth wasn't cancer.
I want to see a movie where they remove the bullet, everyone cheers, then the patient dies, followed by "maybe we should have repaired the damage instead".
Seriously I'd love for you to bring her back. She's both funny and chill but also very informative. Her and Erik Singer are definitely my favorite experts you've brought on.
joseph santos It's interesting that her and doctor Mike happen to have different medical opinions tho! In his "reaction to House M.D" video, Mike watched that very same part with them cutting the throat open and said that the cut was way too big and unrealistic, whereas she said that it was perfectly done. I wonder which one is correct! 🤔
@@margaretteclaycomb1451 Why are the pre-op nurses tiny? Is this surgeon buying into a gender issue here? Or is there some other reason for her description?
@@joannaholland1928 I don't think the comment was that deep. I happen to be tiny 🤷♀️ lol but thats just a coincidence. If by stereotypes u mean most nurses are women, and we tend to be shorter then men, I guessss.
PLEASE, make Annie Onishi do this series once a month, at the very least. PLEASE! (By make, I mean offer her so much money, that she won't say no. She is wonderful!)
The actual reason why "The Knick" was so accurate as a show was because they had Dr. Stanley Burns on staff who is an actual surgeon and medical historian which ensured that things were kept medically realistic.
Yes, now all we need is for Wired and Dr Onishi to seek the advice of a learned person in medical error or doctor patient relationships, or patient journey.
@@musical_lolu4811 and the sickest... Especially our ED docs. Of course they always turned down my request for HVLT for someone who is TSTL. Don't know why. Of course I am still allowed to tell them I have a popa smurf or tell them the pt FDGB
I am an actor, and I played an ER doctor several years back. But before I reported to the set, I consulted a dear friend who was an actual ER nurse at Cedars Sinai. She had me alter my lines to make it sound more believable, and the director let me use it in the scene. Then, months later, as she was fixing a bed, she actually heard my words coming over the TV screen that was still left on in the room. Recognizing her own words she had given me, she looked up and happily realized that I had actually gotten the part. Nurses are the most unsung and important part of any hospital. Although the doctors are important, it is they who actually keep you alive. God bless them, every one.
@@talithasuya8908 I told her I got the part but I had no idea when it would be shown, until she accidentally heard me saying HER lines on the hospital room TV when it finally aired, months later. We're still good friends, 50-years later.
"Surgeons are one of the most competitive people on planet earth.... My personal time for a cholecystectomy is twenty two minutes" brushes shoulder 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 best line e-ver lmfao 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 this girl is a queen
@@jaspriest1997 you don't have any medical issues where you have to deal with multiple specialists or surgeries, do you? It's not a matter of being fun at parties (You need new lines. Even my medically complex, stuck at the hospital self knows that). Some of us deal with these people all the time and are a little sick of being dehumanized. I don't really really want someone racing to the finish on my unconscious body. That's how I end up getting something left inside me, or how someone misses something important. But let me make sure that I sound happy and fun for your comfort.
@@Raindropsinvalencia idk about you, but when I time myself, I make sure I'm doing everything things correctly as fast as I can, I repeat: DOING EVERYTHING CORRECTLY. Especially if it's a doctor, I'm pretty sure they don't just rush to get things done, it's people's lives on their hands.
@@ml2539 Um, OK? Ventricular tachycardia is still ventricular tachycardia, whether you experience only a few seconds, a few minutes, or longer. It's still v-tach, and you are either in it or you are not. It's a pretty simple concept, so not sure what your argument is, unless you just wanted be obnoxious and type something IN CAPS, in which case, good job.
"Rule number one of CPR is to never stop effective chest compressions in order to slap or shout words of encouragement at the patient. Yelling at the patient or cheering them on has never brought them back to life." Spent a good minute or so laughing at that one statement. XD
I agree. Even as a doctor, it's one of the most challenging trainings. (Generally, of course, it's tough to be a doctor.) In Surgery, it requires a lot of skill and knowledge. And that skill takes time to develop. In our country, (I don't know if it's the same for the others), the residential training of doctors for surgery is longer compared to doctors training as Pediatricians, Internists, and Obstetricians.
My mom had a spinal surgery that she had to be woken up in the middle of and when she woke up the doctor was playing the Beatles' Abbey Road album because my mom's name is Abbey
@@stgeorge5862 I haven´t heard that before either, but it makes sense. If you have to concentrate and do everything perfectly and precisely for, lets say, 15 hours straight, then a bit of music to relieve the tension can probably lessen some of that mental exhaustion quite a bit.
When she said "something tells me these guys are not real doctors" at 1:40, I suddenly had flashbacks to Toy Story: "I don't believe that man has ever been to medical school!"
I've always wondered if these scenes are as accurate as possible or whether it was just made up to sound like they knew what they were saying/doing. Loved her explaining everything. Hope you invite her again.
Prior army medic and lpn. Yeah house is usually pretty good because they had doctors on staff and such. However they pretty well covoered every single one of the rarest conditions on earth lol.
+Jennifer A Same, I'm surprised she didn't comment on the stuff done in Dr. Quinn: Medicine Woman. That was a show I grew up watching and they had a lot of operations done in that, I always wondered if they were accurate. But this clearly proves a lot of stuff is just done for the "drama" of TV & Film.
I love her! I’ve talked with other surgery residents and many seemed so arrogant and difficult to talk to. She seems so down to earth, but also incredibly intelligent!
Funny you say that because I'm seeing arrogance in how she talks. It's not so bad because of her wit and humor but definitely there's arrogance in there.
@@navi1661 You bet, NAVI, I see it too. Her attending needs to step in, or Columbia, and vet the script. If this is as good as it gets, it's a pretty sad reflection of surgery at Columbia.
@Joanna Holland Not everyone is an angel. If she can keep her arrogance in check, get her job done properly and can keep healthy relationships, then it isn't a problem
I had surgery recently and was so nervous when they were setting me up on the table that I told the anesthesiologist that he was "the Bob Ross of Anesthesia" because his voice was very gentle and calming
Congrats!!! What specialties do you think will grab you?? I fell in love with ob/gyn, but a rotation I did on plastic surgery was amazing!!! Orthopedics was really interesting, too.
When I had surgery to remove my appendix I slightly regained enough consciousness to feel the numbing sensation around my abdomen and hear the surgeon announce finding my enflamed appendix. I told the surgeon that and she got PISSED at the anesthesiologist, who just rolled his eyes.
@@nickcarey4566 I don't want to be rude, but your channel is fully empty. Usually that indicates that the account is fake. Care to provide any evidence that you're not here to just simply cause panic?
I wish I knew a surgeon who would watch Grey's Anatomy with me! It really interests me and I would love to see what was accurate. I think you're lucky 😊
I clicked onto this video saying to myself "There's no way I am watching 20 minutes of this" and then all of a sudden I hear her say "..in conclusion". All of a sudden 20 minutes passed and I watch the entire video. There should be a video done on child birthing. How many times during a show or movie have we seen an entire gallon of fluid coming from a woman once her water mysteriously breaks?
A. K. H. I don’t have any scenes in my head so I don’t know how extreme it is portrayed but a woman can actually loose a lot of fluid during childbirth 2 liters is realistic for example. Not in a matter of a few seconds tho
Annie has great on screen chemistry. haha. I love her! And her comedic timing was on point! She should consider doing more hosting gigs or something, because she's a natural!
This is the kind of surgeon you want. No nonsense, no frills, just the truth, the facts, communicated very effectively yet kindly. She’s brisk, professional and exudes capability and confidence. I’d feel safe in her hands.
I love this! You guys should do one with a psychologist analyzing depictions of mental health. Because boy are there a lot of inaccuracies in tv/movie depictions of that.
Get a psychiatrist not a psychologist please for the love of god, Psychiatrists are the ones who actually diagnose and are primary carer for mental illness.
isabella milne lol that is false... Psychologists diagnose and treat all mental health disorders, and they coordinate with psychiatrists for the medication. Most psychiatrists don't provide regular, on-going therapy like psychologists do. And relapse rates for those who only take meds is 72%, whereas relapse for psychotherapy or combo therapy+meds is only 25%. Psychologists AND psychiatrists are essential.
As someone with two mental disorders, who has been in treatment for the last 7 years, I think I would be well aware of correct treatment for mental health disorders. Psychologists are not medical doctors, they do not and cannot diagnose mental disorders, only a medical doctor can do that, yes psychologists are a key part of treating mental illness through therapy but they are once again, not medical doctors and hence not legally qualified to give a medical diagnosis (which is what a diagnosis of a mental disorder is) to a patient.
isabella milne what are you talking about?? MDs are absolutely NOT the only people who can diagnose mental disorders. That is just false. It's simply not true, at all. All psychologists are therapists, but not all therapists are psychologists. Psychologists (PsyD or PhD) can and do diagnose and treat. All other types of therapists (with only masters degrees) can provide limited diagnoses and treatment, but legally would need the diagnosis confirmed by a psychologist in some instances (say, for a patient to qualify for autism resources or for school accomodations for ADHD or learning disorders). So maybe you're confusing the term "therapist" and "psychologist"? But yes, psychologists ABSOLUTELY diagnose and treat mental disorders. That is literally what they do all day. Don't spread false information just bc you didn't receive proper treatment yourself.
@@MJ-sy6kz Lol, you appear to know less about psychiatry than you do about psychology. Psychiatrists are able to discern the difference between medical and psychiatric/psychological conditions, decide when to detain a person against their will under the law (in Australia), ensure the medical and psychological welfare of their patients, and many provide ongoing care of their patients, and are trained in psychotherapy as well as psychiatry. Amazing. And as for the research - anyone can manipulate statistics on social media. So, please - promote psychology by all means. But don't put it on the same plane as psychiatry. The skillsets are too different.
James Hwang I was honestly bored and ichigo wasn’t here, so what else to do then to watch a surgical resident set straight some of my favorite shows🙌🏽🤷🏽♀️😂
Please do Law-related scenes! I've heard that Legally Blonde is so inaccurate and unrealistic. Also sports, I'd like to see if actors do the right stances or something like that. I love the series, even though you have only covered two areas for now! Edit: A lot of people like this idea! I have more; space related/astronaut, war/army (as stated by Kyla Yumang), music, and science. I think it would ruin some movies but it would give future filmmakers an idea on how to make movies as accurate as possible.
So glad she covered "get the bullet out." An intact bullet isn't necessarily a problem, and removing it solves little. The task is to repair the tissue damage.
A bullet, stationary and whole, in the body can't possibly do more damage than a pair of clamps, and people have had them sewn into them for a really long time without dieing. Don't dig the bullet out. There's no point.
if you insert it upside down peristalsis will do it just fine without breaking it, this is actually how many things are delivered up there! - med student
Dr. Onishi needs to be on more episodes whether or not it has to do with her field. She seems like a phenomenal teacher; I would love to be a student of hers.
Why do you have to comment on her appearance? She is a surgeon giving her professional comments. People like you are the ones who sexually harass coworkers.
Book Snake I don’t have the hots for her man. And i think she’d get most of this stuff right because she is in the field and has spent years in it. If you don’t find her attractive, that’s fine, but that doesn’t mean that if people do, they are immediately a pervert. Don’t be quick to make assumptions.
I remember watching medical shows with my mom while she was alive and she was always correcting it and that was always so fun and interesting having someone like that.
This was very enjoyable, it really didn't even feel like it was almost 21 minutes long. Another one of these would be great, or a lawyer one, or even a law enforcement one.
Please do a “chef breaks down cooking scenes in movies” I’ve seen so many movies where the “chefs” cooking don’t even know how to hold the knife properly etc 😂😂
Nobody actually cares about that, though. This is interesting. That would be painfully boring. Any idiot can cook and everyone has been in a kitchen; very, very few people can do surgery or have ever been in an OR.
Baum well that is your opinion, I care, it’s my profession and I think it’s annoying when they get it wrong. And I think the 250 people who liked my comment would agree with that. If you don’t care about it then don’t watch it if they make that video :)
There's actually a channel on youtube dedicated to this. It's called "Binging with Babish". I suggest watching the Il Timpano episode, or the Chef episode.
TozWozEar did you even read what she wrote. Binging with babish doesnt do that at all. He does the equivalent ot the surgeon recreating her favorite movie surgeries
I've watched about 5 of these types of videos with her and i'm falling further and further in love every time. Her sarcasm, fearlessness and realism are amazing.
The thing that I love about listening to Annie speak is that she (and my own doctor, for that matter) clearly loves the science. She's internalized it with her job of course, but while most people would make these topics dry and technical she has the passion and charisma to be conversational about it. If teachers were all this interested in what they teach, the topics would be more interesting to the listener and the world would have more knowledgeable people in it.
After watching several of WIRED's videos with this doctor, I have re-evaluated my view on surgeons - in that they truly do deserve that high six figure salary. The knowledge that must be learned (and retained), the skill of talking with patients, research that must be done for each patient, constantly learning new skills, and not to mention paperwork, laws, and also protecting themselves all justifies it.
I agree but I liked how "The Resident" tv show pointed out how the corporatization of healthcare has vastly inflated costs and how some surgeons lean into this trend and optimize their practice to be able to schedule as many expensive surgeries as they can.
The first guy doing the accent breakdowns was so great, I thought that this series was over until 5 more years of bad movie accents came out! Annie is great, super knowledgeable and fun too. For a long video like this, the presenter is super important, so keep finding these awesome professionals!
Technique Critique is quickly becoming one of my absolute favorite things to watch. Hearing people who are experts in their field critique Film and TV is so interesting.
It's actually pretty funny how Film and TV get almost nothing right with any profession, even ones you don't think of. My dad was an elevator mechanic, and he would always laugh at how badly elevators would get messed up in Movies and TV.
That's probably not inaccurate. I think that anything that isn't directly obstructive and helps focus the surgeon is a pretty good thing to happen, and in that particular scene it was definitely something he was using for focus. That said, I'm not a surgeon, so don't take that as fact.
That was a great watch! I don't get why people complain about having their fictional entertainment "ruined" with facts. This is just more entertainment, but I learned a thing.
I for one think it's cooler if a show tries to be as accurate as they can. And it terms of more simple first aid treatments, like CPR, or dealing with a stroke or bleeding. Being more accurate can be educational to viewers. But CPR is pretty simple in comparison to some of more complicated procedures. So it's frustrating if they don't get the CPR right, lol.
people think fiction has no effect on reality but it really, really does. like the amount of things people believe bc they saw it on tv/in a movie is.. astounding. i’d definitely prefer it if they tried to make things more realistic
It's also a little more jarring or perplexing when they get the simple stuff wrong. For the average person who has basic first aid knowledge. I immediately know if they're doing basic first aid procedures wrong. Especially if it's something that only takes a quick google search to read up on how to do it right. It's a little more forgivable if it's something more complicated. Because the average person most likely won't catch or notice those mistakes. However, it's far more impressive when a show attempts to make it accurate just for the sake of trying to be a great show.
Interestingly, Dr. Mike reviewed the House episode with the tracheotomy and she did too (at 10:15), but they differed on their view of how the procedure was done. Still, I would love to see these two do a video together!
As a nurse I relate so much, especially when watching greys anatomy. The amount of things the doctors do when the nurses are no where to be found is so bothersome. For example, 3 surgeons trying to ambulate a post op patient would absolutely never happen. It’s always the nurses who take that responsibility
Rockin818 as a fellow nurse I have to agree. Doctors would never start an IV or ambulate a patient...or at least I've never met a doctor that would. It's infuriating- nurses never get any glory on TV.
even then, it's usually Nurse Assistants helping ambulate :/ but you know more than me since I was only a student Patient Care Assistant (I say student because I was a senior in high school and had a 6 week internship at the hospital trying to get my PCA certification). But yeah, I agree, in Grey's anatomy, whenever the doctors would do Nurse and Nurse Assistant jobs, I would be rolling my eyes
Know that i would be interested in that! In my experience for the most part it's accurate but I can't really say a specific scene where it obvious that what they are doing is not right.
My mother actually woke up in the middle of procedure, she had her 2nd heart attack, and while the doc was trying to clear one of two blood clots in her right coronary artery she popped up and asked what was happening. I guess the anesthesiologist didn't knock her out as much as they needed haha. Glad to say she's doing alright but what a trip ya know.
"that guy would have been trackled about six tiny preoperational nurses" best part :D Thank you for the video, I love this series, first the accents now this, please more!!!
While she was talking about music during surgery, I kept expecting her to end with "...no, I'm just messing with you. We obviously don't want to create any distractions, so we don't listen to music," but she never did. They ACTUALLY LISTEN TO MUSIC! Jesus holy Christ.
Oh yeah - and music can actually help people to relax and concentrate more - have you never put music on to help when you're doing something that requires you to concentrate but isn't super demanding technically? Not all surgeries are as complex as others. It's also recently been discovered that music can actually help the PATIENT too. It really is going to depend on the surgeon, the surgery and a whole lot of other things but music isn't fundamentally a bad thing.
but surely the volume cant be high nor can there be bass, the bass could cause jittery. also listening something you dont like over and over.. over very long surgeries can be annoying. your brain wants to tune it out, but when it does that, you no longer register the normal talk either..
Juju Tatalamino Yang would be much more sarcastic, and probably leave halfway through the video because she’d much rather be doing bad af heart surgery then dealing with this. And I say this as a Yang fan 😂
So am I and I was surprised at how accurate they were in general on scrubs. The personality quirks they made fun of were so spot on that I figured they had a consult. Lol.
I’ve been binging these videos the last couple days and she seems like like SUCH a cool person. Her sense of humour is impeccable, and I love how she explains things