YES! IT WAS ABSOLUTELY THE RIGHT DECISION NO DOUBT ABOUT IT. & SHE GOT TO SPEND 10 WHOLE DAYS & NIGHTS WITH HER MOM BEFORE SHE PASSED AWAY & SHE'LL BE FOREVER GRATEFUL FOR THAT. SHE WOULD NEVER EVER EVER FORGIVE HERSELF IF SHE HAD CHOSEN TO STAY, BUT SHE WOULD HAVE NEVER DONE THAT CUZ FAMILY IS IMPORTANT & SHE WOULDN'T PUT A GAME OVER FAMILY NEVER IN A MILLION YEARS NOT EVEN FOR $100,000,000 & THAT'S WHY I RESPECT HER & IT COULD BE A REASON WHY SHE HAD PREVIOUSLY WON SURVIVOR HEY, YOU NEVER KNOW 🤷🏾
Quin Markus-Pawliuk which is a shame because ciera didn’t even play only until the rock draw thing, and Tyson played the best game by far so if this is true it would’ve been a shame
Tina, Rob C., Colby, Rich, and Ethan were all eliminated for their previous reputations. Rudy was sadly the weakest link on his tribe and couldn't help in challenges. Everyone else caused their own demise IMO. I felt really bad for Rob C. since he was on a tribe with no winners or big names to hide behind. Lex and Kathy were fools to get rid of Ethan, Rich and Colby. The 3 were stronger than Jerri and Shiann and were the perfect shields to hide behind.
+AJL At least Shii Ann won an individual challenge which saved that episode. She also did pretty well in that log barrel challenge. (please don't bash me)
Most bitter jury of all time and it’s a shame because they’re all returning players and shouldn’t hold grudges. I’m specifically referring to Tom and Alicia, I think Lex was justified because Rob totally fucked him over and lied to his face
Witnessing Amazon players Jenna and Rob go out back-to-back hurts. If only there were more players from that season and Pearl Islands on All Stars. My All-Stars cast would've been: Chapera: Cesternino (6), Big Tom (3), Sean (4), Darrah (7), Elizabeth (2), Sue (1). Mogo Mogo: Hatch (1), Colby (2), Lex (3), Heidi (6), Kathy (4), Shii Ann (5). Saboga: Ethan (3), Rupert (7), Rudy (1), Jerri (2), Deena (6), Tina (2). I removed Boston Rob because he went out pre-jury in Marquesas (however Shii Ann's still in because she was screwed over with the fake merge twist and was the best player of Thailand other than Brian). I removed Alicia because she was not that pleasant in Australia. I removed Amber because she was forgettable in Australia. I removed Jenna M only so she could've been with her mother and give her spot to Heidi. I removed Jenna L because well she wasn't very compelling in Borneo. I added Sean because he was a great character in Marquesas. I added Darrah to add more Pearl Islands players and because she was a challenge beast and underdog towards the end. I added Elizabeth because she was popular in Australia. I added Heidi because she was compelling in the Amazon. I added Deena because she played hard and was interesting.
The All Stars cast I think we shoulda got is. Saboga: Rupert, Brian, Ethan, Tina, Heidi, and Jerri. Mogo Mogo: Lex, Colby, Richard, Kathy, Jenna, and Shii Ann Chapera: Rob C, Big Tom, Fairplay, Elisabeth, Sue, and Alicia * Replaced Rudy for Brian cuz Rudy was just too old at that point and ended up kinda being a wasted spot. *Heidi was far more compelling than Jenna L. * Fairplay replaces Boston Rob simply becasue if were talking first appearances it's not close who should'a been on All-Stars * Elisabeth replaces Amber because she was everybodys sweet heart in Australia *Lastly, really is a shame Fairplay wasn't on All-Stars. Whole different season if you ask me.
I don’t understand why people hate this season so much. When I first watched it, I really enjoyed it. However if I had the power to cast the season, here’s how I think I would. Saboga Tribe (AKA, Winners Tribe) - Richard Hatch (Borneo, Winner) - Tina Wesson (Australia, Winner) - Ethan Zohn (Africa, Winner) - Vecepia Towery (Marquesses, Winner) - Brian Heidik (Thailand, Winner) - Jenna Morasca (Amazon, Winner) Chapera Tribe (AKA, Almost There) - Susan Hawk (Borneo, 4th) - Colby Donaldson (Australia, Runner-up) - Lex van den Berghe (Africa, 3rd) - Kathy Vavrick-O’Brien (Marqueses, 3rd) - Rob Cesternino (Amazon, 3rd) - Sandra Diaz-Twine (Pearl Islands, Winner) (Yes, I know Sandra won Pearl Islands, however since she would not have known she had won at the time of filming All-Stars, I put her here.) Mogo Mogo Tribe (AKA, Wild Cards) - Gervase Peterson (Borneo, 7th) - Amber Brkich (Australia, 6th) - Jerri Manthey (Australia, 8th) - Rob Mariano (Marquesas, 10th) - Shii Ann Huang (Thailand, 10th) - Rupert Boneham (Pearl Islands, 8th)
Isn't Alicia insufferable? She's always angry. Like, *always* . What's with the threat to Shii-Ann as she leaves? She is sincerely my least favourite contestant of all time.
S M she sucks at the game and bitter for no reason. She thinks she is badass, but she is just abrasive. She didn’t make any moves but she expected to slide through to the final easily, and then acted like she didn’t deserve to be voted out. The facial expressions when she was sitting in the jury were so annoying and unnecessary. She was unlikeable in both of her seasons. I’m so glad she didn’t get called back for another season. Terrible Survivor player.
@@BarryBondsSzn I dont think so! At least sue goes on to winning 25,000 on dog eat dog survivor addition lol what's funny is Richard was one of the losing contestants!!!! So shes not a total Loss lol
Jenna Lewis must have felt like a stupid ass placed in the final 3 with a potential married couple! And this is the reason I hated this season. All of the people sitting in the jury and Amber are bottom tier players. Flip the other side of the game and you wouldn’t see Miss Amber near the final 2. Every single one of them in the jury stupid to play with a couple and thinking they were going to reach the final 2 with either of them. Unfortunately the same thing has happened on Season 40 except the winner was hella deserving. I wonder if Rob would hypothetically vote for his wife’s quieter style of play vs someone with a more fuller gameplay. For someone that wrote a book, the answer should be the latter. I’m sure deep down, love feelings aside he admits she rode his coattails and he was dealt with a bitter jury. And Amber doesn’t respect Survivor. She only likes it because the show gave her, her husband and kids.
@Tix Studios Okay dipshit. I said POTENTIAL marriage which they did end up getting married. Married or not, the point is they were in a serious romantic relationship and everyone knew it and it was stupid for them to think they were not going to take each other to the final 2. Jenna Lewis is a bottom tier All Star. Amber was only selected because Colleen and Elizabeth TURNED down the offer. The point is Jenna and Amber were not priority selections which you have admitted.
It doesn’t matter if they got rid of Jerri or Amber - the original Mogo Mogo still didn’t have the numbers. Lex, Kathy, Shii Ann (and Jerri if they got rid of Amber) would have been voted out first post-merge anyway. And Big Tom, Rupert, Jenna and Alicia were just way too obsessed with going to the end with Boston Rob that they would never jump ship to work with Mogo Mogo
She’s really the only person to have quite the difference in how she played. She was the sole survivor then was the first voted off then was in the final 4 basically so close to win and could won.
I feel bad for Jenna Morasca because her mom died :(. I think Jerri getting voted out was the saddest cuz she was backstabbed by her own tribe to save Amber
I would like her back once again. She was very good at the game she just needs to be in an alliance to better her protection and she could have gotten to the end.
Ryan Ferry yeah. She had good one liners also she’s not fond of Rob but respects his gameplay which is why I liked her. She didn’t take the game personally and knew it was just apart of what needed to be done unlike Alecia who was a bitter sore loser.
They need to give Jenna M another chance. Sure she quit, but it was totally understandable. Her mom was dying and she just wanted to be with her. Bring Jenna back!
Oh they have tried. I believe they asked her for South Pacific with Ethan Zohn who was her boyfriend at the time but they didnt wanna compete against each other.
Mike Mena the controversy around did cost Hatch his spot in S40. However what actually happened in the incident is debatable as well as whose fault it was. Hatch has uploaded a video describing his side of the story and to me it is rather compelling.
@@LDK447 his side isnt proven whatsoever if we havent heard much at all about sue’s side of the story. I definitley think that rich did something to violate her
It must've been so weird at the time to see Rob who was pre-jury in his first season dominate against former winners and finalists. We now know that there are too many variables in Survivor to judge a player by a single season.
AJL even back in Survivor Africa he was relatively just as terrible. Never forget the time when he got so pissed off after receiving one vote (from Teresa Cooper) and he mistakenly believed that it was Kelly Goldsmith who did it, so he rallied against her.
@@thefourthversion That's true. If he didn't have such a good relationship with Brandon or if Brandon hadn't been an idiot, Lex would have cost himself the game by turning Kelly against them.
AJL exactly! I wish things would’ve turned differently. Kelly seemed to have a lot more to show as a player. I would rather believe that it was Brandon’s stupidity that cost Samburu + Kelly the game, instead of Lex’s social skills.
I like Lex but he was a horrible decision maker. Kind of wish Clarence or even Frank had been in All-Stars. I think Clarence especially deserved another shot.
LL H yeah, Jenna was unbearable. Most of the past contestants that played with her said that she was the worst. I don’t understand why people didn’t like Alicia though.
LL H she stayed in the game because she was a stronger physical player over Rob Cesternino. She also had an alliance with Rob M and Amber early on in the game. She also hardly had to go to tribal council so it doesn’t make sense that people are upset that she made it far. She made the top 7 by winning challenges and by being on the dominant tribe. Happens a lot on Survivor. In many interviews, others have noted that Alicia was only voted out last minute as Jenna Lewis and Rupert were almost kicked off before Alicia.
LL H well whatever she said, she was still in an alliance or agreement with rob and Amber because they promised each other not to vote for one another. Alicia was an All Star and deserved to be there as she was super memorable in Australia. She was wayyyyy more memorable than Jenna Lewis, Shii Ann, or Amber. Alicia was apart of the main cast and wasn’t on because others backed out a la Jenna or Amber.
Lmao I still think it’s funny that when a season is being shot, they don’t know about the season before theirs. So basically Rupert came into all stars and no one knew who he was💀 so glad he was brought back though
The first two episodes of Pearl Islands had aired before the All Stars cast left for filming, so they knew a little about him. That's why everyone was elated to see him in the first episode's challenge.
So did Rupert play 4 times? Pearl islands Blood vs water heroes vs Villians and this one right? Well he didn’t win but atleast he made it far here and all stars though in blood vs water he was out first bc he wanted his wife to play the game what a great kind hearted player
Yes he has played 4 times and All Stars is his best placement. He didnt win at all but he won a fan vote that gave him 1 million dollars so hes like Survivor's unofficial winner
yeah. winners at war basically had the worst streak in survivor history. 7 or 8 old school fan favorite and legend back to back. should have brought more old schooler. we dont need every single person from 31 until 37
My son was a huge survivor fan and his favorite player was Colby when he got voted out he became angry and also became angry when James didn’t play his 2 idols
Rob lost because of one simple factor: He seriously hurt the people who thought they were close to him. It’s why Lex, Alicia, and Big Tom voted for Amber to win.
@@RandomizationE lets be honest tho alicia and lex were little whiney bitches especially lex. Lex backstabs colby and votes him out then he votes out ethan telling ethan that its just a game and its nothing personal and its just business when they were close on africa together then when rob basically says the same thing to lex he starts losing his mind and starts acting like a baby
Rob lost because they hated him more than Amber plain and simple Amber said in winners at war she won because they hated rob more than her and if Rob won i think Amber would have not made winners at war my guess
Was anyone else so annoyed by how pathetic everyone was when they swapped tribes and Amber was sent to the other tribe? Jesus I felt like I was watching the end of Titanic! They acted like she had fallen off of a boat and never seen again!
I just realized everyone now a days hates the kucha tribe from Australia: People didn’t like Alicia because she was to bossy, anyone who’s democrat doesn’t like Elizabeth, some people didn’t like Kimmi, and Jeff and Skupin for obvious reasons
He could never come back now with the massive target on him now. The only season he’d be able to be good on would be one that has like Tony, Sandra, Boston Rob, Parvati, Cirie, and Idek who else you could do. If he ever did a game changers like season, he’s like the first vote out of here. And winners at war just in general has shown that old school players have a hard time playing in todays world.
@@theggamer2824 that’s a different scenario. Tony had friends on the season pregame, game changers lessened his threat level, and he literally made sure to be utr because they would target him otherwise
People robbed this season Rich Rudy Rupert Tina Jerri Rob Shi Ann Big tom Alicia Ethan This was a good season with a terrible boot order Who was the most robbed? Like Rudy Reply rich
Replace Amber and Rob with Big Tom (was a loveable big character in Africa) and Kathy (She was loveable in Marquesas) and I agree. Lex was also a true All Star and made merge. But yeah Jenna L, Alicia, Amber, and Boston Rob should not have come back for All Stars as they were either forgettable (Jenna/Amber) or didn't make it far enough to make a big impact on their seasons (Alicia/Rob). The ONLY exception would be Shii Ann (she was by far the best character from Thailand and while she wasn't a true All Star I think she deserved to be on the season because she was screwed over by the fake merge). Boston Rob would've suited Survivor: Second Chance better. Sean from Marquesas should've been in Rob's spot. Jenna L, Alicia, Amber had no business to come back ever tbh.
I wish we could see an alternate version of this had Amber got voted out premerge instead of Jerri. I think Rob would’ve been super mad but he still would rally to kick Lex, Shii Ann and Kathy out first anyway since the original Chapera still had the numbers.
I think part of the reason why this season sucked so bad was because the majority of the cast were from seasons 1-3, which made up 12/18 of the cast. Seasons 1-3 were the earliest seasons with the least strategy; they were mainly focused on friendships and surviving the elements. People like Tina, Rudy, Ethan, Colby who were from these seasons didn't do too well in All-Stars due to not being strategic enough to save themselves, and most of the jurors (Lex, Big Tom, Alicia) were also from these seasons and either were goats or made really stupid moves, and they didn't adapt to Boston Rob's cutthroat gameplay, hence they felt hurt from him and didn't vote him to win. I guarantee you had the cast included more people from seasons 4, 6 and 7 (Thailand was bad so we can forget about it) like Sean, Neleh, Vecepia, Heidi, Deena, Christy, Fairplay, Christa, Darrah, etc, which were the "newer" seasons at the time with people that were able to be a bit more strategic and were able to handle blindsides, All Stars would've been better and less dark of a season.
Sue quitting is sadder than Jenna quitting i know Jenna left do to a family emergancy but Sue was sexually assaulted on that challenge sexual violate is a no no
How I wish the elimination order went 18th Shi Ann 17th Jenna L 16th Rudy 15th Big Tom 14th Alicia 13th Jenna 12th Ethan 11th Sue 10th Kathy Merge 9th Lex 8th Richard 7th Tina 6th Colby 5th Jerri 4th Rob C 3rd Rupert 2nd Amber 1st Rob
Im episode 5 during the immunity challenge, which involved moving past people on platforms to grab flags, Richard (who was Naked), walked past Sue but in the moment, was intentionally rubbing himself on her. It was brushed off at first and Richard was voted out (for completely different reasons). Over the course of the 24 hour period, Sue processed it more in her head and couldnt take the thought of what happened and the having to go home and everyone see it so she lashed out and quit.
Why did they let him be naked in the first place? He wouldn’t have been allowed anywhere else. That was stupid on Survivors part . So glad he isn’t on the 40th
Though this season was super over the top dramatic, I kind of feel bad for Amber. To know you only won because you were slightly more likable than the guy that should’ve won kinda sucks. Not saying she’s got a crappy life or anything, but that’s gotta kinda sting knowing all that