Тёмный

Taking a quick look at a Fractal Antenna 

andrew mcneil
Подписаться 66 тыс.
Просмотров 3,4 тыс.
50% 1

Had this fractal antenna for a few years. I got it because it was originally sold for 2.4GHz but has since been rebranded as a UWB antenna! I wonder why?
Help support this channel on Patreon: www.patreon.co...
Want a cantenna: tinyurl.com/4d...

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 37   
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
What do you think of fractal antennas?
@JamesGraingerJC
@JamesGraingerJC 9 месяцев назад
Extremely curious!
@urgtuiop5455
@urgtuiop5455 9 месяцев назад
Its snake oil. Paste over the detail in each triangular pane with silver conductive ink and see if there's any significant change at all.
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
@@urgtuiop5455 I agree but they do have a die hard fanbase
@jafinch78
@jafinch78 9 месяцев назад
"Fractal Antennas" are like "Metamaterials" designs literally where very specific design requirements have to be defined and the designs made to meet those requirements. The range of shapes alone can be overwhelming and at least is to me. They're great for reducing the size of antennas and have really enabled wireless communications to get so small without bonkers sized antennas. They're more-so a thing in the cell phone world frequencies on up, though does seem like there are some VHF and UHF capabilities that are successful, albeit not marketed anywhere I've seen. Kind of reminds me of a situation where stating traces are voodoo and no good and dead bug or breadboard or something other designs are better. There are definitely design considerations that need to be made to be effective. Might even be the designs have to be used to be effective in the situations requirements where size and weight are the limiting factors. However, well thought out and designed traces, stripline and or microstrip can create a whole nother world of potential. Similar with fractal antennas and metamaterials. They're insanely amazing IMO. One design that gets me amazed seeing, is the design where is like a sleeve that is a roll of fractal antennas on a sheet that goes over a traditional single straight wire element, say like an old fashioned car antenna. Last I knew there was a video on YT with the before and after effect shown on a VNA. Amazing change in band capabilities performance.
@nyeleskettes
@nyeleskettes 8 месяцев назад
Well if it is not tuned well you can scan it, scale it, print it on a PCB with toner transfer and have a tuned one in a few iterations. would be nice to see the radiation pattern.
@Superkuh2
@Superkuh2 9 месяцев назад
There's no use for fractal antennas, they just look pretty. A simple meanderline would do better well. Any space filling curve would. But this isn't even a meanderline type fractal antenna; all those little triangle gaps are just within a normal planar monopole conductive outline; they slightly increase the electrical length, that's all. "Fractal" antenna usually just means "scam".
@jafinch78
@jafinch78 9 месяцев назад
Like in this situation, where I do definitely agree, or in general? Are fractal antennas not used in cell phones all over the place successfully? Seems to me in generally stating "fractal antenna" or even "metamaterial" is a scam, is false. Again, I do agree for most being sold some generic product, is most likely maybe. The "fractal antenna" and "metamaterial" designs need a more detailed and subject matter expert understanding like I find analogous to dead bug, breadboard and PCB trace design to microstrip and or stripline designs. RF systems wouldn't be so good now days without the transition to PCB trace design and then for the higher frequency systems microstrip and or stripline designs. Similar speaking situation. Junk if not well planned design and for specific implementations. Maybe even can say like a different situation where like RF versus Optical designs for the transition from below to above the microwave range, albeit not really so far different in design carrier current and free air coupling methods.
@seavil1
@seavil1 9 месяцев назад
From my understanding Electro Culture society likes to use fractal antennas for receiving energy from the atmosphere and charging the soil to produce a much faster and bigger yield in their crops. Just lookup Electro culture and you will see what it is about. I believe if you can get into this field, you might find many knew things in the antenna world and even help the culture improve on their antennas. A lot of fractal designs were first seen in cathedrals. Some say cathedrals were a huge receiving station for energy to heal people or the society around the cathedral. There is so much to look at and research about. I hope you find this interesting; I would like your insight in this field.
@Phil659
@Phil659 7 месяцев назад
"Electro culture" is garbage. Plants dont grow with electricity.
@jafinch78
@jafinch78 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the detailed assessment. Very particular little buggers from what I've seen. Reminds me of the worlds of designs like I noted in the comment replies below. Love how you noted requires more a mathematician versus and RF Engineer. Probably is like a closed circle of subject matter experts that may be more open about what they're doing than most know, though most get lost in the complexity and very specific design situations. Definitely a design frontier, with some interesting decades back observations and applications somewhat I guess if thought of like I do from the thinking like a fractal antenna is a metamaterial in 2D more so, even though there are 3D fractal antennas that I think are a metamaterial from my observations.
@TheElectronicDilettante
@TheElectronicDilettante 8 месяцев назад
So as I’m trying further my knowledge of Radio and related topics, I’ve been trying read everything I can find on the subject. As I was just reading an antenna design book I came across this passage that made the use of fractal antennae make sense. “As we decrease the wavelength (increase frequency), we decrease the model size in the same proportion. To build wide-band antennas, we need structures that can be their own scale models. One approach is to remove any characteristic length by specifying the antenna only in terms of angles.” -V. H. Rumsey, Frequency independent antennas, 1957 IRE National Convention Record, pt. 1, pp. 114-118.
@MrJeffschefke
@MrJeffschefke 9 месяцев назад
I feel like im miss reading something here, a 1.2 SWR is like 1% loss isnt it? Is this a different scaling or something then im expecting?
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
Its return loss its not the same as VSWR
@gammaleader96
@gammaleader96 9 месяцев назад
@@andrewmcneil I'm with @MrJeffschefke, I understand return loss (normally in dB? for a logmag diagram), SWR etc. but I'm not totally sure how your setup is scaled so I don't think I understand the absolute values of your measurements (the relative shape is clear of course) Maybe you could do a short video on your setup and how you calibrate it, etc. I think I'm not alone at enjoying a testgear video. :) Otherwise a very interesting antenna design, I always thought this kind of "regular" fractal design is more of a theoretical thing but it seems to be used after all.
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
@@gammaleader96 Will do
@Masirah1
@Masirah1 9 месяцев назад
Thanks, consider me on the same group of audiences.
@kevinrtres
@kevinrtres 9 месяцев назад
@@andrewmcneilThanks, I was wondering about it myself.
@Sonex1542
@Sonex1542 9 месяцев назад
I really enjoy the fact that you actually measure the antennas you have on thos channel. What good would it do to just flash them on the screen without putting them on the analyzer.
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
I think this is the reason why they won’t send them to me to review!😁
@railgap
@railgap 9 месяцев назад
Someone found a way to build an antenna with worse response than a discone! That's an achievement, of sorts. XD
@catalinalb1722
@catalinalb1722 9 месяцев назад
Hello Andrew, thanks for measuring it! I have it too laying somewhere... For a log time I was wondering if a PCB Fractal Antenna Minkowski style could be made for 13.56 MHz (NFC) as a Loop. Dimensions around 20x20cm. What do you think?
@jchowdyovi
@jchowdyovi 9 месяцев назад
13.56 Mhz is an interesting choice for a home hobbiest. ;)
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
Please tell us why 13.56 sounds interesting
@user-ub8nv7wv3m
@user-ub8nv7wv3m Месяц назад
Hi. I'm interested in designing & building a Minkowski fractal loop antenna for 14 & 28 MHz. Jack
@jeffschroeder4805
@jeffschroeder4805 9 месяцев назад
Is there any way to fine tune the effectiveness for various frequencies" You don't have an easy way to shorten the antenna or modify the ground plane.
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
There is no easy when it comes to fractal antennas. I think to truly understand them you have to be into mathematics more than RF engineering
@bradthelad3000
@bradthelad3000 3 месяца назад
Does anyone know is there such a thing as a fractal antenna for 5g LTE..I would love to have a series of flat antennas on the inside of my top floor window to suck in mobile internet. Appreciate any thoughts. I only ask about fractal antenna as its flat and would be easily mounted on a window pane..thx
@TuttleScott
@TuttleScott 9 месяцев назад
that's not a fractal antenna, its just an antenna that looks like a famous fractal geometry.
@andreamitchell4758
@andreamitchell4758 9 месяцев назад
it's actually the tri force of power
@tedmead465
@tedmead465 7 месяцев назад
Experimental Ground plane with a Fractal design of radiator
@Dr_Wrong
@Dr_Wrong 9 месяцев назад
Try a Fractal Rusty Nail!
@andrewmcneil
@andrewmcneil 9 месяцев назад
😂😂
@Dr_Wrong
@Dr_Wrong 9 месяцев назад
This. This is exactly why I can't figure out wtf antennas physically do!
Далее
Что думаете?
00:54
Просмотров 735 тыс.
I BUILT A RADIO AT HOME
14:53
Просмотров 219 тыс.
Yagi Prototyping What have we learned?
18:55
Просмотров 3,5 тыс.
How To Receive And Decode L-Band Weather Satellites
27:43
The Coolest Radio You've Probably Never Heard Of
11:54