Here's how I think Total Drama All-Stars would play out if Mal had never existed or at least was never summoned. Be sure to comment video suggestions and feedback. Thanks for watching.
Another Thing is Courtney should of been a finalist from the gate for this season, It would of been a nice call back from what she said season 1 first episode saying how she would win a season and her winning all stars would of been a good reminder of what she did say, Also the finalist should of been Girl vs Girl like how season 4 it was boy vs boy so zoey and courtney
If it makes you feel better, these days i'm working on my own version of "Total Drama All-Stars" called "Total Drama New Stars", where Courtney will be much more menacing, and she'll be a major part in the finale even if she won't be neither a proper finalist nor a helper.
What if lindsay never voted herself in action What if lindsay never voted herself in all stars What if dj wasn't cursed What if Scott never sabotaged his team
Low key like this version of All-Stars more than the actual one lol A video suggestion: What if Ezekiel joined Team Amazon instead of Team Victory He arrived together with Izzy when the teams were formed so it would've made sense if they were both put on Team Amazon
What if Sierra was the main antagonist of World Tour? This may seem like a dumb idea on paper, but I think it has potential. Sierra is called a "Total Drama Superfan," so her gameplan would be to use this knowledge to manipulate the other contestants. She makes one passing comment about how she knows Heather is manipulating her, so she's counter-manipulating her. It's this, but throughout the whole season with every character. A finale in this timeline would likely be Sierra vs Cody, I just think that makes the most sense
I really like this, that’s such a cool idea for a villain. Knowing peoples weaknesses and general game plans and having ready made counters would be fascinating.
@@frontful5698 I never said she would be better than him, I meant she'd be better than Mike, and so is Alejandro. They really did other characters dirty just to promote Mike and Zoey
I had an idea for a Total Drama season the other day. Even though it isn’t a what if, I figured I’d share the idea in case you’d wanna use it. I call it “Total Drama Pre-Merge” and it’s basically a season where the only contestants are the ones who never got past the merge. Characters like Noah, Tyler, Sam, Eva, B, Dawn, Topher, Rodney, etc.
Two ideas that I thought of were: What if Ezekiel never lost the divining rode in World Tour? And what if Scott didn’t frame Dawn in Revenge of the Island?
In the final five I think Courtney would convince Cameron to vote out Sierra easily. Also Gwen’s elimination would be sad since she and Courtney had unfinished business yet again but it would make sense for Courtney not to risk it. I think In the final challenge, Courtney would get Gwen and Scott, Mike would get Zoey and Cameron. Maybe if we want a third helper for each Courtney also gets Duncan and Mike gets Sierra.
I think Alejandro’s elimination would’ve been different. Knowing he’s the target of a 3 person alliance, he would 100% go to Courtney and friend to try to tie the vote. If he convinces them to vote Cameron, then he will very likely win the tiebreaker, at the cost of sierra going insane or heartbroken for the next episode. While I doubt Courtney particularly likes al, she probably could foresee Scott or her elimination the next episode. So I think it very likely they WOULD vote for the tie. As for the 2 possible candidates: Al would very likely beat Cameron in a challenge, but this would make sierra pissed. If they vote on sierra, then there’s a reasonable chance she beats al. So I think Cameron would be eliminated ep10.
Hey have you heard of the izzy isn't crazy conspiracy? What if that actually does come into play? What would happen if either A. "that theory is taken as true and she is just a master planner behind the scene for the season" Or B. "Justin never got his mojo back in action and got voted out instead of izzy"
The season would’ve been a lot better and wish the season had 18 contestants and 18 episodes like I wish Cody,Owen, brick,Tyler came back and Justin and leshawna
I think Alejandro would pick Cameron to get to Sierra because he sees that getting rid of Cameron would be the best pick to get the the alliances security
What if the Pahkitew Cast actually knew how to play the damn game (This is obviously more of a Joke one, but it'd still be interesting to see the Pahkitew Cast actually doing stuff)
Idk if anyone pointed this out, but in episode 7, the winning team voted out someone from the losing team. In your scenario I think it would've played out differently. I think the hamsters would've been more likely to vote out either Scott or Courtney. Scott cause half of the hamsters have a bad history with him from ROTI, and Courtney cause she's much more abrasive than Heather. Also Heather has an ally in Sierra and sort of relationship with Alejandro. I could see the votes playing out like this Alejandro - Heather Cameron - Scott Duncan - Courtney Mike - Scott Sierra - Scott Zoey - Scott
Instead of being sexist he’s a feminist(as in the non-protesting kind) maybe? Maybe he could change forms early and get an athletic boost while staying fully-sentient like Dakotazoid idk
That's how i see the finale in this "what if" video: Mike's helpers will be Zoey and Cameron, and Courtney's helpers will be Heather and Alejandro. It will be close, but after Courtney and her helpers will keep Mike away from the million, Zoey will pull out the sword and win. Mike will be glad for her, and being her boyfriend means he would enjoy the money too.
What would the elimination order in any of the series be if all the competitions weren’t vote based, but skill based like In the post merges. For example in the cliff dive DJ or Courtney would be eliminated since they didn’t jump, but since DJ did some work with the jacuzzi’s, Courtney got eliminated.
What if pakatauo(idk how to spell it) island happened before total drama all stars? Basically what if the first 3 generations were in total drama all stars
Why didn’t Heather try to work with Gwen? I feel like at the end she would have realized she’s at the bottom of the villains tribe if Courtney and Scott are in control, and if they’re voting out Gwen, Heather gets no blowback in going to a tie.
Now of Mal never existed, I think we all know Zoey would have more fans. But I do.have ideas: What if Katie and Sadie never stopped for blueberries? (TDI) What if Heather and Lindsay decided to join into voting Duncan? (TDI) What if Heather never kissed Trent? (TDI) What if Gwen never kissed Duncan? (TDWT) What if Samey managed to expose Amy for her horrible actions? (TDPI) What if Dave heard the "but" while talking to Sky? (TDPI) What if Dugar never scared Clucky? (TDPI) What if Lindsay never crossed the finish line? (TDI) What if Dawn exposed Scott? (TDROTI) What if Ripper got eliminated instead of Scary Girl (real name is Lauren)? (TDIREBOOT)
So who would be the most evil antagonist in this timeline since mal was never summoned? Also, what would the exclusive clips be with the different team swap, and the different ellmations?
Tbh, that's one of the problems with doing this what if because there isn't really a villain in this story anymore. The closest I can get to is Courtney, but that's a bit of a stretch.
@@LightningvsLightning I think it be nice if the villain of this timeline was part of the heroic hamsters and the main hero was on the Villanious vultures.
The season would’ve been so much better Mals existence but the heroes winning every challenge would get boring fast and Alejandro going on the hero’s team makes zero sense.
@@cormacmccarthy1889 I just think that Cameron would understand that he didn't do all of that willingly and that it isn't really his fault if they lost as he know his condition and he wanted to help him in end of the episode and as for Zoey i think she'll never be able to vote Mike as she also knows he didn't want to hurt Cameron and also knows Mike's condition.
If I’m being honest, it would’ve been better without Mal in my opinion, because with him it meant an automatic finale spot for Mike, don’t get me wrong I do like Mike, I just think the season would’ve been better without Mal and have Mike with all his usual personalities
I think that Alejandro would vote Zoey but Cameron would vote Sierra and Zoey can win the Tie breaker because Cameron is not in danger And Gwen/Courtney/Heather may vote Scott because they know that the only way for winning against a 6 persons teams is repeating the amazonics thing. But great video
I think that thinking of what the writers would do probably Alejandro would win against Svetlana in episode 10 and since everyone knows Sierra is crazy and annoying everyone would vote for her, also because everyone would have some sympathy for Cameron (just like in the pre merge where they voted out Sierra because Cameron wnated too)
How is it worse? (If you're saying that Hero's win the eating challenge, Sam hid pancake in his pocket just in case he went to boney island so they would still lose there).
I really like your videos because your analysis of total drama is very good, but I do wish you wouldn't call them "personalities" and act like that's Mike wearing a costume. I can't watch this video because of that and that makes me sad cause I would love this one
If Mal didn’t exist… Dude literally all stars would be more boring then pahkatiew Island (I can’t spell it 😀) Like dedasss bro is the best villain (so is Scarlett)
I’ve had this comment a few times and it’s a fair point, but at the end of episode 3 during Jo’s elimination she sees Cameron as Cody while they’re talking, and that’s before Mal breaks her phone at the start of episode 4. She also fixes her phone normally later in episode 4. This is why I assumed there would be no change with her obsession.
@@VyseNodge I was wondering if you can do what if Mike didn't vote himself in tdpi, I think because sky getting out instead of her being a runner-up/winner would be interesting but some might not change who knows
I find it a bit interesting that, without Mal, Courtney would seem to become the major antagonist of the season, except this time she's there for the WHOLE season rather than just the later half, and Cameron would last MUCH longer even if its mostly just Sierra carrying him, since he wouldn't be eliminated due to his injuries at the hands of Mal. Plus this means we don't get the whole reset button ending where Mike just manages to defeat Mal and cure his condition by pressing a goddamn button, so that's a plus. I feel bad for Chester though, he rarely seems to get used, though given who Chester is, that's probably for the best he doesn't get used for most challenges, and he probably comes out before or after challenges just to give other contestants a piece of his mind anyways. I did personally like Mike, but All-Stars really dropped the ball with him and handled his whole thing VERY poorly, especially with the ending.
A bunch of suggestions: * What if Duncan never decided to blow up Chris’s house? (TDAS) * What if Bridgette decided to join Heather and Lindsay’s side in that one scene? (TDI) * What if Alejandro never found the immunity idol that Heather had? (TDAS) * What if Eva never lost her shit due to her music? (TDI) * What if Noah was an actual team player? (TDI) * What if the love triangle never happened? (TDWT) * What if Courtney NEVER debuted? (TDA)
a whole bunch of random theories: what if all of the elimination orders were reversed? what if everyone stayed on their original teams? what if roti, as, and pi were all 26 episodes? what if heather didn't steal eva's mp3 player? what if harold didn't catch the ball in dodgebrawl? what if noah competed in dodgebrawl? what if heather hadn't convinced people to vote for justin? what if izzy didn't get caught by the rcmp? what if eva and izzy didn't return in island? what if courtney/owen didn't return in action? what if geoff and bridgette didn't get out first in action? what if chris stuck by the "you have to sing" rule in world tour? what if ezekiel didn't lose the stick? what if ezekiel didn't turn feral? what if ezekiel returned to the game in i see london? what if blaineley never got in the game? what if sierra didn't blow up the plane? what if scott didn't try to throw challenges in roti? what if b talked? what if mike didn't have alternate personalities? what if owen was in all-stars? what if the pahkitew characters got character development?
If Chris Stuck by the "You Have to Sing" Rule in World Tour: Cody gets nowhere near the final 3. Sierra is likely booted early without her Cody-Kins around. That would mean The Amazons lose the tiebreaker in Greece, so Gwen gets eliminated there. The finale changes too. Heather might get booted because she loses out on Sierra and Cody as allies, but I think whoever takes their place in the final four (probably Duncan & Courtney, I see no reason why they'd keep Blaineley around after China) to vote Alejandro in Drumheller, and since there'd be no Sierra to blow up the plane, he gets booted here. I see Heather beating Duncan and Courtney to Hawaii, meaning they have to go through the tiebreaker, which I think Courtney wins. The finale becomes Heather vs Courtney
If Ezekiel didnt lose the stick I think this would be how it played out (Duncan Quits Like Usual) 18. Harold (Episode 3 Japan) 17. Bridgette (Episode 4 Yukon) 16. Noah (Episode 5 NYC) (Since Zeke didn't lose the stick, this episode would be an elimination episode and Noah was swapped in the carriage putting the blame on him for being asleep) 15. Leshawna (Episode 7 Germany) 14. DJ (Episode 9 Paris) (This time Zeke is still on the team with Lindsay and DJ, so Zeke and Lindsay vote DJ off for breaking the sculpture) 13. Izzy (Episode 11 Jamaica) 12. Ezekiel (Episode 11 Jamaica) (He loses a tiebreaker to Lindsay) 11. Owen (Episode 13 London) (Without Noah, its just him and Tyler trying to catch Jack the Ripper, and I see Owen and Tyler doing very bad together, Al and Tyler vote Owen) (Duncan and Lindsay join Team Chris) 10. Tyler (Episode 15 Area 51) (Al and Duncan vote Tyler, Lindsay and Tyler vote Duncan, Tyler is picked by Chris to be eliminated bc he is injured) 9. Gwen (Episode 16 Australia) (Blaineley Debuts) 8. Blaineley (Episode 19 Niagara Falls) 7./6. Courtney (Episode 20 China) (Cody, Sierra, and Courtney vote Duncan, Al, Heather, and Duncan vote Courtney, and then Lindsay votes Heather, Double Elimination) 6./7. Duncan (Episode 20 China) 5. Sierra (Episode 21 Tanzania) (With Heather and Al winning invincibility again, they decide to get on Cods good side and help him vote out Sierra) 4. Heather (Alejandro wins immunity, and Cody and Lindsay vote out Heather) (The Plane never blew up, so this is impossible to predict) 3. Cody 2. Lindsay 1. Alejandro
I’m glad you did this one. Mike is a guilty favorite of mine, so I love to see how flexible his character and stories can be. I say guilty favorite because I know MANY people genuinely dislike him, since him and Zoey basically become writers pets with any series they touch.
@@adamturek210 I’m pretty glad Mal existed too for a couple reasons. But I see what you mean, without him it’ll basically be up to the villains to carry the season, the Heroes would be infinitely more boring since Mal ain’t stirring anything.
@@Duval-In-The-Wall That was the most oh too perfect couple and got together almost too fast which is why that ship sucks. And Zoey being that capable and yet crying like a baby for Mike all the time is annoying.
Great video! Crazy to think Mike would make it to the finale in both versions. Here are some future video suggestions... Easier Suggestions: What if Cody wasn't mauled by a bear in TDI? What if Gwen came back instead of Blaineley? (Mainly cause Duncan and Cody bring it up in Niagara) What if TDROTI or TDAS had no immunity idol? What if Lindsay didn't vote herself out in TDA? Harder Suggestions: What if all stars had actual all star contestants? What if everyone came back for action? What if Sierra and Alejandro didn't exist for TDWT? (You could choose whether to bring two more contestants in or not) What if the Geoff's rescue party didn't exist in Celebrity Manhunt? (Essentially, what if everyone [and Dj's mom] was in TDWT?)
With no immunity idol, a few things change. Dawn doesn't claim to have the statue at the end of "Backstabbers Ahoy!" Scott gets eliminated in "The Treasure Island of Doctor McLean." The first person to tag the totem pole after Scott was Cameron, who I believe would cut Jo here. Dakotazoid likely can't build her device in episode 10, and I believe the remaining four campers (Mike, Zoey, Cameron, and Lightning) would vote her out. Cameron wins in "Eat, Puke, and Be Wary" originally, so I see no reason why he wouldn't here. The three vote off Lightning. I believe Mike would come back with the flower first, utilizing Svetlana to do so, and would close to eliminate Cameron, turning the finale into Mike vs Zoey. The changes in All-Stars start in episode 6, "No One Eggspects the Spanish Inquisition." Alejandro gets voted off here. Suckers Punched changes only slightly. I believe Heather's opponent on the board would be a sumo wrestler and she defeats it just like she did in season 1, and Sierra still gets cut here. The regatta is difficult to judge. Mal still sabotages the boats, with Heather taking the boat Alejandro took originally. So Heather wins, but it doesn't matter because Duncan is eliminated for destroying Chris' house. Cameron is eliminated in episode 9 due to injury. I think Heather would get booted in episode 10, "The Obsta-kill Course" because no one likes her and it's the first chance they've had to vote for her since the fun zone. The rest of the season occurs as normal.
I enjoy your channel so much because you’re unique. You’re the only person who does their videos like this. If one thing different things didn’t happen, how drastically different things would be
Ideas what if Izzy didn’t leave of injury? (TDWT) What if Beth debuted instead of blaineley? (TDWT) What if there were two teams instead of three? (TDWT) What if the teams were actually team A and team B? (TDROTI) What if Ella wasn’t disqualified for singing? (TDPI) What if penalties didn’t exist? (TDRR)
Pretty good video overall. I'd say the finale would be tricky though. What you said for Courtney's reasoning to eliminate Sierra could also be said for Mike too. There is no way Courtney wouldn't see Mike's personalities as a threat, especially if Mike is in full control of his personalities. Also, perhaps in your finale Courtney gets Gwen as an ally and the two can make up there?
Another vid idea: What if the Toxic Rat’s cabin didn’t blow up in episode 1 of revenge of the island? If that didn’t happen, they would have won and the maggots would’ve had to vote someone instead
I’d love a what if revenge of the island is 26 episode season! Although that might be a little bit hard and you’d definitely have to be a bit creative I think it could be interesting
