Tears of Hate (Christine Comparison)

Подписаться 289

Просмотров 17 тыс.

50% 1

in order:
1) Gina Beck
2) Katie Knight Adams
3) Tabitha Webb (alt.)
4) Sofia Escobar
5) Nicky Adams
6) Claire Doyle (u/s)
7) Leila Benn Harris
8) Robyn North
9) Katie Hall (uk tour)
10) Sierra Boggess (25th anniversary)
11) Sarah Brightman (original christine)
i'm not really as into the Phantom of The Opera Fandom, so I don't know much about the girls, but what I know I've written down. This is only from POTO in UK.
So yeah, talk, which one is the best? I know who my favorite is that's for sure!
All copyright goes to the rightful owners.
Any comment with disrespect towards any of the cast will be deleted immediately.

Опубликовано:

16 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 97

@meganpettys713 9 лет назад

Katie's "hate" gives me chills literally every time. Her's is so perfect - one of the many reasons she's on my top five Christines!

@KatieT97 9 лет назад

For this particular line, Katie Hall's is my favorite, I just love the note for "Hate!". Sierra's my favorite Christine and I love her for her powerful voice, proving that powerhouses can play Christine too.

@indiamarshall598 10 лет назад

Katie's was stunning. I got goosebumps from it. My other favourites were Gina Beck and Sarah Brightman.

@rebeccagallant1760 8 лет назад

Sierra and Katie I love them so much they inspire me so much cause when I'm older I want to be Christine

@ashlinraime9573 7 лет назад

Gina Beck first and foremost, very very good acting and emotional playing, very talented! Claire's was very convincing that she was upset. Leila actually sounded pretty good, it was very strong.

@kiratheusagiisworkshop5266 7 лет назад

I really love Sierra's version because you can really hear how it goes over to hate for him!

@amandae8437 5 лет назад

BS. she always acts like she secretly wants the phantom but just settles with Raoul. especially if she's performing with Ramin.

@전수빈-b5l 8 лет назад

Gina , Katie and Sierra are very powerful ! Love them

@IzumiHanjinozuka 10 лет назад

Gina Beck's version sends chills down my spine. My favorites are Gina, Sofia Escobar, Katie Hall, Sierra Boggess, Nicky Adams and Sarah Brightman.

@annemarie.l6443 10 лет назад

GOOSEBUMPS ON KATIE HALL!

@jordanthorstad 8 лет назад

like how katie knight adams cut off her hate, it sounds so powerful and hateful. but katie hall's is omfg so good! claire doyle's sounds really good as well. and i love everything sierra does so her too.

@apinkglitterunicorn 9 лет назад

Leila's use of dynamics is really unconventional for a Christine. Changes are abrupt and there's little to no crescendo, no warning. Might not be the most aesthetically pleasing choice but it's unique and I think it works for the Final Lair!

@flickymcbean 7 лет назад

Loved Katie Hall's obviously but Sarah Brightman's voice just intoxicates me. As Gillian said, it sounds like a dew drop, falling into a pond.

@kimberlychatman7132 6 лет назад

Katie Hall and Sierra Boggess💕💕

@victoriapontmercy1428 8 лет назад

Gina Beck is my favourite Christine, but Katie Hall's is the best on this list. I wish though that Sarah Brightman held her notes for longer.

@Whitleychic 9 лет назад

Claire Boyle, Katie Hall, and Sierra Boggess are my 3 favorites.

@ellierourke5065 6 лет назад

Sierra will always be my favourite Christine but I rlly liked Katie hall cos I’ve seen her twice in Manchester, UK and Liverpool, UK and she was sooooo good

@AimeeLouiseDaniel 12 лет назад

1st)Sierra Boggess (25th anniversary) 2nd)Katie Hall (uk tour) x

@SuperBlackky 12 лет назад

Katie Hall nailed it. Belting out that note made the hair on the back of my neck stand up.

@anyastuart7517 4 года назад

Is no one going to talk about Claire Doyle? She was absolutely incredible! Easily one of my favorites.

@HM-fx9mv 8 лет назад

Wow. Claire had me shocked. I wasn't expecting it to be so powerful I got shivers. Leila Ben Harris was on point too. Katie Hall's version of this line has got to be my favourite, though. So extremely powerful.

@Thepixiebella 6 лет назад

Gina Beck and Katie Hall! Love it!!! Sierra's is not my favorite on this part.

@nelmuppet 11 лет назад

i can't stop listening to katie hall

@sohillsvettech1624 10 лет назад

sierra get my vote! gina is second for me

@broadwaymike92 2 месяца назад

That line overall is soooooo emotional and intense. It's that break free moment of "Christine" saying to "The Phantom" saying "I'm done with you", "I hate you", "You're dead to me", "Get out of my life", "You LIED to me all these years"!! Every Christine so anger and the moment of THAT'S IT!!

@crazyguy98456978 6 лет назад

I really wish that Katie Hall was chosen to be Christine in the 25th anniversary that way her performance could be immortalized.

@amandae8437 5 лет назад

Gina beck number 1 Katie Hall number 2

@tiffanystewart9265 8 лет назад

why isn't Emmy on here?

@terezahanzova7656 8 лет назад

only UK Christines are there... it's in the description

@acatcalledronald 11 лет назад

KATIE HALL. I saw her playing Christine last Wednesday and she was phenomenal!

@still_your_zelda 11 лет назад

OMG I love them all, but Katie....GET IT GURL!

@amplitudehertz17 6 лет назад

The best Christine on this line imo is Celine Schoenmaker, who came in 4 years after this video was here, in the Phantom 30th anniversary production She wasn’t the most refined one in terms of singing skills (which is a good thing as it fits Christine’s character even more), but is by far the most dynamic one, and she's the only one that doesn't need to breathe before pushing the 'hate' out ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-iNQWiURzdNk.html Listen to her version of this line at 45:30

@anarute1823 12 лет назад

this is one of my favorite lines of the show! when i get to this part, i sing it like 20 times! :)

@dreamersprosperx3 9 лет назад

claire doyle was my christine! i saw her when she was the understudy of the understudy. i think it was her first performance. We waited for her at the stage door and we asked someone to see if she was going to come out, 5 minutes later, she came out with sopping wet hair and she had got out of the shower just to come and see us. Shes incredible, such a beautiful woman

@leafpool4480 6 лет назад

I would've chose Sierra if not for her pronunciation

@zoeennis1971 6 лет назад

GINA AND KATIE HALL

@thekermitkid1992 9 лет назад

Katie Hall!!!!! =D

@nevaehhorst-wade5163 7 лет назад

Sierra Boggess is the best in my opinion. Closely followed by Katie Hall.

@nickjonasgrl100 11 лет назад

Gina Beck and Sierra Boggess are the best!!!!

@mchakraverty 12 лет назад

Katie Hall a million times over

@Aphrodite791 12 лет назад

Sierra Boggess followed by Katie Hall :)

@harshmnr 7 лет назад

Yeah I say Sierra then Gina... ~:~

@honeyariiforlovve2703 5 лет назад

I got goosebumps this is so good

@thebrideinthemirror2030 7 лет назад

My favourites: 1. Gina Beck 2. Sofia Escobar 3. Sierra Boggess 4. Tabitha Webb 5. Sarah Brightman 6. Leila Benn Harris 7. Katie Hall --------------- I debated a bit putting Leila and Katie on here since I don't really like when Christine's belt out their notes (safe for a few expections ofc) but they executed it so well that they deserve their spot imho

@alizrdiz6111 6 лет назад

"The tears I might have shed for you dark fate, grow cold and turn to tears of hate"😪

@jillianvicic3282 2 года назад

I think Sofia Escobar is perfect vocals for u I love u sound so good and I your notes I will hit that one from you my first highest note ever

@dolphinanimals19 11 лет назад

How can you sing this line like Sarah Brightman?!?!? Sierra Boggess is so much better

@Flickymcbean825 6 лет назад

dolphinanimals19 sarah’s version is from the OLC recording, not how she sang it in the show.

@girl_offline1203 11 лет назад

I LOVE SIERRA BOGGESS, KATIE HALL and SARAH BRIGHTMAN'S one.

@ennaphillips8619 10 лет назад

Lol @ Sarah Brightman....

@Mshottie6 11 лет назад

Katie, Sierra, Leila, and Claire.

@LabyrinthTsubasa 11 лет назад

Gina Back held that note for so long....

@maroa4981 8 лет назад

Claire Doyle, Sarah Brightman, Katie Hall and Gina Beck are the best. They aren't my favorite Christine (Kaley Ann Voorhees is) but their "hate" is AMAZING!

@christine-nc9ib 8 лет назад

Love Claire but her 'cold' sounded like she suddenly coughed.

@NinjaKittyRules1 11 лет назад

Sierra of course!

@russellsmith2245 6 лет назад

Sierra🖤🖤🖤

@Alexia3220 3 года назад

Κatie Hall and Gina Beck

@Alex1995june22 12 лет назад

Tabitha webb :) X

@LNDPOTO1998 11 лет назад

katie hall is amazing nad im going to see her play christine when i go to see phantom in march cant wait

@greatslytherin 9 лет назад

Sierra 👍

@arzumahmudova6992 5 лет назад

Sierra bogges❤❤😍

@bluegreenred5 12 лет назад

Sierra is by far the best, but I have to say, I really liked Gina Beck as well. :)

@whjk11b80 8 лет назад

Leila, Katie Hall and Sierra are my favourites. So powerful :)

@meganhart6549 10 лет назад

Robyn and Katie.

@melandonedirection5 9 лет назад

Sierra will always amaze me with her voice!!!

@lasatiuchvil 11 лет назад

Gina and Katie

@teganmcdonald661 9 лет назад

my favortite is Sierra Boggess because i love her voice and her pasion she's just awesome

@geninamonaghan6019 10 лет назад

Gina Beck, Katie Knight Adams, Claire Doyle, Robyn North and Katie Hall particularly struck chords with me.

@TheTokyoToys 12 лет назад

whoa! they're all great, but I think Katie Hall is the best, closely followed by Sierra :)

@arzumahmudova6992 5 лет назад

Sierra bogges

@1707apple1707 11 лет назад

1. Gina 2. Katie

@Abby-km6vr 6 лет назад

Katie Hall then Sierra :)

@wycfe 12 лет назад

CLAIRE DOYLE

@kyoshi505 10 лет назад

I love Claire and Gina so much!

@therandomwriter 12 лет назад

all of them were very good, sofia escobar, sierra, katie and gina were all great too!

@yuta_666 4 года назад

#SierraBoggess

@MouseHouse52 11 лет назад

Kate Hall has the best HAAAAAAAAAATE ever!

@danielthomas1221 10 лет назад

Katie by far!

@sunnyholey5670 6 лет назад

Tears of Heat?

@Mattyma1998 12 лет назад

Katie is the best by far. Love her

@ethannicholas 6 лет назад

Sarah Brightman and Katie Hall for me.

@Roccarocks 11 лет назад

3:16

@Elbarto623 11 лет назад

Katie hall. goosebumps each time I hear her hate.

@chenograndedonnell 12 лет назад

Katie hall 100%

@scotthamp384 4 года назад

Katie Hall sounded better in the UK tour than in London

@jeniahl 11 лет назад

The reason that Katie's "hate" got everyone was probably because, she chose to sing that note more with her throat like a pop singer, than with the head voice a operatic singer does... that way changed her tone color immediately, caused a big contrast... my opinion ;)

@carefreeconfusion 12 лет назад

Katie Hall by a mile.

@MrGlittergirl554 11 лет назад

Katie halls was Awesome

@DGokeys1fan 11 лет назад

Katie Hall. She's not my favorite Phantom (Sierra is) but Katie's hate... No one can beat that.

@ghostofthespire 12 лет назад

I've heard better from Gina. Of course Katie Hall's tour hate is amazing.

@rhblake 12 лет назад

Sarah Brightman compared to Katie Hall. Cya then Sarah.

@Flickymcbean825 6 лет назад

Rhiannon Blake It’s not a fair comparison in fairness. Katie’s was taken from a live performance whilst Sarah’s is from the OLC recording. You couldn’t really have Sarah belting it out on there for fans to listen to at home/in the car. She does belt it out on the live versions I’ve heard, albeit not fantastic quality given the age and method of recording

@arzumahmudova6992 5 лет назад

Sierra bogges😍❤❤

@arzumahmudova6992 5 лет назад

Sierra bogges

@arzumahmudova6992 5 лет назад

Sierra bogges

@arzumahmudova6992 5 лет назад

Sierra bogges

@arzumahmudova6992 5 лет назад

Sierra bogges