Terry Stop Flop! 😳 Cop Kills Unarmed Man Trying to Catch a Bus! Immunity Toasted! $1.4M Settlement! 

2016.03.07 US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals Written Decision: cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2016/09/16/14-55184.pdf Great quotes from decision: "To determine whether Officer Villarreal violated clearly established law, we look to “cases relevant to the situation [Villarreal] confronted,” Brosseau v. Haugen, 543 U.S. 194, 200 (2004) (quotation marks omitted), mindful that there need not be a case “directly on point.” Gravelet-Blondin v. Shelton, 728 F.3d 1086, 1093 (9th Cir. 2013) (quoting Ashcroft v. al-Kidd, 563 U.S. 731, 741 (2011))." "It has long been clear that “[a] police officer may not seize an unarmed, nondangerous suspect by shooting him dead.” Garner, 471 U.S. at 11." Settlement discussed here: www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-police-immunity-variations/ Lose 2A Rights for Mean Emails!😳 Susan Bassi’s Emails That Disturb the Peace Are Domestic Violence! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-PKO6qQg-c2o.html Father Gets $$$ From Corrupt El Dorado County, CA: ru-vid.comi21jCcpJF7w?si=YiLrHHqIxxJcXp2j False Arrest Body-Cam One! 😳 El Dorado County, CA Obtains Warrant by Fraud & NV AG Participates!:ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-oJOtgCwh6OU.html Kidnapper Judge Cindy Hendrickson Revokes Illegal Order 😳 (2023)! Admits Denying Me Due Process! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-hRaX0g7rgS8.html Ring Camera! Kidnapping Coppers Exposed! 😳 Admit I Reported Corruption But Refuse to Investigate! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ONUR0GL9Voc.html Father Exposes Santa Clara Superior Court Complaint Shredding Operation: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-u4JCc4qO30o.html Another Interesting Case (lots more on my channel): Lawyer Cites Fake Cases! 😳 Parent's Civil Rights Appeal Thrown Out Due to Professional Misconduct! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1nmqZpPgfjE.html UNLIMITED IMMUNITY! 🙄 State Judges Are Supreme Beings! But You Can Win Declaratory Relief! 42USC1983 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-RFZCAdZeIso.html Gangsta CPS Loses Immunity! 😳 Demands the Right to Lie to Violate Citizens & Kidnap Kids! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-llXqlKB_AME.htmlsi=q974eNTgxew4MKqE ----- I'm just trying to be a dad after my kids were abducted. Why I am the Father in Exile: How to Fight Corrupt Family Court (Expose it!) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-pVgudZtNYiQ.html Voter Fraud and Abduction Admission Caught on Court TV in NV ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-J9FeWPKEFo8.html Judicial Misconduct & Rights Violations Caught on Court TV - Santa Clara, CA Judge Roberta Hayashi ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Zgog-NLFyC8.html Secret Judge Club Exposed 😳 at Corrupt California State Bar Meeting! (2023) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-LHRTQh0WTYk.html Santa Clara County California Superior Court Judges Who Deny Due Process and Participate in Misconduct and Felonies: Roberta Hayashi, Cindy Seeley Hendrickson, Brooke Blecher, Thomas Kuhnle. Transcripts and Filings Will be Released Publicly on this Channel.

If the perpetrator was not a police officer, he would instantly be charged with murder.

Immunity shouldn't cover murder.

Officer “take your hands out of your pocket” Suspect takes his hand out and officer murders suspect. Judge asks why he shot the unarmed suspect. Officer: “he took his hands out of his pockets” WTF?!?

I hate cop splaining lawyers.

i remember the media said cameras would absolve police wrongdoing, it only proved it

5:00 "Qualified Immunity allows police officers to make mistakes. It allows for the possibility that officers will make mistakes in judgement." - this is an insane statement. A cop took the life of another person on PURPOSE, that's not a mistake.

why wasn't the Officer Charged? It doesn't sound like any crimes were committed by the victim, they shot and murdered a man that did not break any laws, did not pose a threat. Take your hands out of your pocket is not a lawful order, but when he did do what he was ordered to do, he was smoked down, sounds like he was putting his hand up. This was not a reasonable mistake, this cop screwed up and should be in prison for murder.

I don't want my tax dollars paying for police violating my COUNTRYMEN rights!!! Let the police pay it themselves!! Let our money benefit us!!!!

Why the F is this person presenting justification for murder when the victim was unarmed? Our justice system is a gd joke. Revoke qualified immunity doctrine. Revoke Terry vs Ohio.

Police behavior has been becoming MORE DEPLORABLE. ABOLISH QUALIFIED IMMUNITY!! UPHOLD INTEGRITY, ACCOUNTABILITY, TRANSPARENCY!!!

She keeps talking about strange behavior. Is strange behavior a misdemeanor or a felony????

Reasonable mistake? A man lost his life.

3 minutes in I could tell by the looks on the judges faces they were disgusted by what happened

Terry v Ohio needs to be abolished

Abolish Police Unions & Qualified Immunity! “The tyrant will always find a pretext for his tyranny!” ~Aesop "There is no crueler tyranny than that which is perpetuated under the shield of law and in the name of justice!" ~Montesquieu "When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty!" ~Thomas Jefferson

Skipping backwards in the street is a reason to stop someone where is the victim in that crime the street.

Cops mindset. Taking out the trash. Given the green light by qualified immunity.

"Qualified Immunity allows for Officers to make reasonable mistakes". That is the problem. When an officer makes a mistake someone often ends up losing their freedom and or their life. Abolish Qualified Immunity now.

my only issue is these lawyers Can sit there with a straight face and lie to a judge about about the murder of an innocent person

When I was 9 years old and my grandpa was teaching me about guns the first thing he taught me is there's no such thing as a mistake with a firearm

Remember this coward cop initiated this confrontation for absolutely bs

One of the only professions in the world where you can make the ‘mistake’ of killing someone, use that as the excuse, and still keep your job and avoid prison time.

Bad enough have cops who kill but for a woman to stand and lie for him is disgusting no one should lie for a killer

“May have”, “Possibly”, “was potentially”… these are all excuses cops use to DEFINITELY end a person’s life, based on “officer safety”

They're all missing the elephant in the room; Being taken into custody FOR WHAT CRIME? At no point, anywhere, does anyone even attempt to elucidate that an actual crime occured.

Killed because of suspicious behavior. Outrageous. Suspicious behavior is NOT criminal!

“He can testify to whatever he wants to testify to but I’m telling you his camera proves he didn’t see it” I like that middle judge a lot lol

Qualified immunity was pulled out of thin air to defend officers in their unlawful acts. Change my mind

Abolish qualified, judicial and prosecuratorial immunity....

The lawyer lied off the bat “he saw everything “

She said Qualified immunity gives them the right to make mistake.thats crazy.

I realize that an attorney must make all attempts to prove the innocence of their client. With that said, this lady is absolutely insance to think that ANYONE would believe the shit she's spewing. What a disgrace.

Police in America..."I (only) thought he had a gun so I shot him 5 times"--Mesa Arizona as an example. Our troops in a war zone..."Don't fire unless fired upon" Abolish police qualified immunity and/or give our troops qualified immunity in a war zone! P.S...let's not forget officer safety against unarmed civilians!

Catch 22 situation, damn if you take you hands out of your pocket, damn if you don't !

occifer safety isn't a law nor is having ones hands in their pockets.

Nobody is above the law, PERIOD. The Constitution specifically outlines government officials and officials of the government are in fact to be held in check and subject to citizen oversight and control. Qualified immunity is unconstitutional in every way.

The "we got a call" law clearly states you are guilty of every statute know to man and then some. SHOW ME YOUR PAPERS.

I appreciate the consistency of the judge in the middle; he remains the same in all of these videos.

Abolish Qualified Immunity in its entirety.

More to the point, where is the criminal prosecution?

So officers are allowed to make a mistake like killing somebody and qualified immunity protect them, unless you're a regular citizen then you go to jail for life

Its disgusting hearing this woman lawyer speak.

Blue line supporters: "Just comply! Then you won't have any trouble with police!" Countless numbers of innocent citizens: *complies and gets hurt* This is why compliance isn't the answer. Compliance often assures your injury, disability, or death. Nothing will save you from a man intent on punishing you for the crime of not seeing them as a god. It is not the citizens job to appease unstable government dogs. Progress will not be made while citizens are idle, the government has incentives to keep the status quo. We must demand change from our government, and it cannot be done while a significant number are asleep at the wheel. This is the crux of the issue. Compliance with the orders of government officials should AT MINIMUM not result in injury. Until police can guarantee compliance will not result in injury or death every citizen has to do the math of balancing the risk for themselves. This would likely also increase safety for officers, considering the alternative would involve likely injury. However, it's not about their safety, nor your compliance, no matter how much they repeat it. You must recognize their inflated authority and hold them with the deference they think they are warranted. Though today, they've continually demonstrated they deserve only derision.

"We dont want jury's second guessing the very very difficult life and death decisions that officers have to make" But that's what jury's are for, hearing the facts and deciding if the decisions that were made were necessary, reasonable and lawful. Excluding cops from the process a civilian would endure if the roles were reversed shows in plain view the two tier justice system.

This is s Tragic case: BUT! The Judge made it clear from the Off he wasn't in the Mood For Lies and Cop BS! Skipping NOT ILLEGAL! Hand in a Pocket NOT ILLEGAL! What could the Victim have Done To NOT be Dead? He kept His Qualified Immunity (And the Judge said its a Case of Wrong Place Wrong Time!) He's Paralysed in a Nursing Home for the Rest of his Life

This is not a normal country. Unbelievable. And this female lawyer trying to justify murder!

It's amazing how judges think human life is worthless by the little amount of settlements

Very nice way for judge to say that the officer was lying.

looked like a heavy object was in a pocket? A coke can? a wallet? Fear of every human by weak pubic servants who do not take protective cover is ridiculous, dangerous and deadly.

Let me get this straight. Even if it is ruled that this murderer lost his qualified immunity, "his employer" pays the settlement. That is, The People pay the settlement based on a decision made by someone who is not elected and is not accountable in any way through the so-called justice system. Why do we even bother with costly court proceedings like this? It appears that ending the unconstitutional doctrine of qualified immunity won't even matter. These thugs simply cannot be held accountable via any means except those provided in the 2nd Amendment.

Ah yes the old hand in pockets, acting weird defense.

She needs to locked up too. What ifs are not law

Backing away from armed cops is now "weird".

They want to defend the undefendable, he was shot because he removed his hands out of his pockets after the officer told him to do so and their defense was that Qualified immunity allows for mistakes?. The wanton disregard for human life by these traitors in blue is disgusting, his action was unreasonable and the only one who paid the consequences was the victim and this officer is not the victim.

I don't think I would like to have that lady for a lawyer

The only way to keep this from happening again is to outlaw pockets on clothes. Yeah right

Skipping backwards is scary. Got it.

I don't understand how an attorney can make materially false and misleading factual statements and the Court points out that the video clearly contradicts the attorney's statements, then they just continue on as if it didn’t happen-without the slightest admonition.

Take too long to take your hands out of your pockets? Threat. Take your hands out too fast? Threat. It's a lose lose for the person with guns pointed at them.

Skipping backwards is dangerous and suspicious enough to deem a person armed

Shot for compliance, for officer safety.

When this judge started telling the lawyer what he saw on the video, you can tell she’s thinking, “yes, but you’re not supposed to say anything about that”

I love how the judge called that attorney out based on the dudes camera 😂

This is a plain case of murder imo

I don't know how she sleeps at night. The dude follows orders and is murdered for it. Absolutely unacceptable 😡

And tax dollars are paying for all these proceedings. Everything except for the plaintiff's attorney.

Make mistakes??? Oops, your dead, my bag....3rd mistake this year sarge.....how many more can I put on my tally, oops. Skipping is an absolute deadly threat.

Let's talk about the elephant in the room- the cop will not pay a fkn dime. Our judicial system is a broken, corrupt mess and crime within it, is rampant.

"he had to make a split second decision"... "one officer fired towards the suspect ".. "the other would have had to fire towards civilians but chose not to" .... . so they had time to decide, and he decided to end the suspect..

So he took his hands out of his pocket too quickly , and then gets you shot ? Great work cop

If that cop was that scared, he has no business having a gun. Going into that situation that afraid was absolutely vain ignorance.

Sp "acting strangely " is a death sentence

Anyone skipping down the road backwards is obviously carrying a weapon? Did i hear that right?

Having your hands in your pockets and "skipping backwards" gets you killed when they scream at you to get your hands out of your pockets ...

1 minute in and she's already lying. I can't stand lawyers.

The victim had NOT COMMITTED ANY CRIMES

Judges. This is all caused by the misuse of the Terry stop ruling, Mimms ruling, this officer safety over public safety and training issues. Not to mention qualified immunity which has literally caused the public to be at risk.

Lawyer argues: 'As a matter of law if we accept cop facts - hands in pocket and walking in street - its reason to pew pew any human being'. Despicable DA's who ignore gov criminality prove why they're despised even worse than bad cops. 'Legal scholars and advocacy groups have repeatedly petitioned the Supreme Court to abolish or reform qualified-immunity doctrine created out of thin air in 1967, “qualified immunity smacks of unqualified impunity, letting public officials duck consequences for bad behavior-no matter how palpably unreasonable-so long as they were the first to behave badly.” Justice Sonia Sotomayor criticized qualified immunity for “sanctioning a ‘shoot first, think later’ approach to policing.” Supreme Court of United States decided back in 1980 that, "Officers of the court [police] have no immunity, when violating a Constitutional right, from liability. For they are deemed to know the law!” (US Supreme Court, Owen v. Independence, 100 S.C.T. 1398, 445 US 622.) In fact the Court clarified, "The knowledge that a municipality will be liable for all of its injurious conduct…should create an incentive for officials who may harbor doubts about the lawfulness of their intended actions to err on the side of protecting citizens."

“It allows for reasonable mistakes”. You killed him!!!! REASONABLE?

Since when is it a crime to have your hand in your pocket?!? Wtf?? And then you take it out like your told to and they kill you!! That’s insane. This man was murdered period.

He had to make a decision based solely on what he knew at the time... which did not include any indication of a threat to themselves or others.

Acting erratically is a capital offense???????

Hmm. What basis was there for taking anyone into custody?

When cops gives an order, this person needs time to react to an order. Here they didn’t give him time. No immunity.

From 3:33 to 3:45 is exactly what this case is about and why they lost their qualified immunity

Love how Law & Order has turned to Privileges, Office Powers and if all else fails turn to Immunity! Normal 2024

The theory that the people (the jury) should have no place in determining whether an officer's actions were reasonable is profane. I'm curious as to what tone did the officer use when they ordered he take his hand out of his pocket. If he said it calmly, a rapid movement _might_ be a factor of concern for an officer, but if he screamed the command as two or more officers are pointing guns and corraling him, rapid compliance is mandatory, not suspicious or threatening.

Does she realise that she's attempting to justify the unlawful killing of a highly distressed individual? What chance do we have?

Former US Army, served in the 1991 Gulf War. If we "made a mistake" which resulted in a civilian being murdered like this, our asses would be fragged with a dishonorable discharge and likely prison time. The military does not believe in qualified immunity, the military believes in accountability in the form of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). The UCMJ basically means "Fock around and find out!" Cops don't have a code of conduct, nor rules of decorum to follow. And evil deeds like this is the result of having zero accountability. How many more citizens are going to be murdered and the tax payers pay the price before we make changes?

Forgive my ignorance, but isn't there some sort of rule (law) that says police (or anyone for that matter) have to tell the truth to the court? It's obvious the cop lied if his deposition doesn't match the camera footage...

The fact that their even thinking about it shows citizens how little they think of us...anyone else would be under the jail

Abolish qualified immunity!

I appreciate all three of these judges asking hard questions & demanding how the officers' actions made any sense, if any!

This lawyer wants us to believe that officer safety would stop an officer shooting based on surroundings?? Really?

When Qualified Immunity is what you are disputing. You Don't Have A Dispute.

11:30 interesting that being a suspect opens you up to execution by cop.

Cop had in his hart and mind already that he was going to shoot the guy because of his weird behavior.

Within 2 min judge os already calling out obvious perjury! This one going to be good. Guaranteed not one ounce of accountability for said perjury tho!

This happened back in 2011!!! Just deferred is justice denied!!!