Tesla Model Y vs Porsche Macan GTS: ICE VS EV Shootout | Fifth Gear 

Totally agree, and for about the same 64k pound price.

@@ezekielsystems They just dropped the price to around $56K 😀

It still would've gotten beaten like Jesus during the sixteen stages of the cross.

Exactly

Yep espesh with TRACK MODE

yeah then you get a macan turbo though right?

@@wakkadakkaify As long as they're close in price

@@sur_face I didn't know this but apparently there's no Macan turbo anymore :s GTS is the highest spec.

@@wakkadakkaify oh, so they should be able to get the Per Y easily, especially that they recently dropped the price for it.

Model3 Performance vs Macan, SUV and race track nogo.if you will race, sedans and flat sports Cars are best.

Surely in full and not if full?😄 I had to reread it to spot it

These links are used by some scammer to cheat people

cheaper by $25K or more. Nobody buys base porsche macan GTS at $79,900. with options likely well over $90K.

@@joekim4345 good point🧐

Does the Performance with Track Mode cost more?

@@superspeeder about the same as the Porsche

@@superspeeder yes but still less than the Porsche

@@superspeeder Depending on options for the Porsche, yes it can somewhat higher to much higher in cost vs. Performance MY.

The YP goes to what 0-60 in 3.2 and he uses the 4.8LR..? So porche gets their TOP model vs Teslas lowest. Yeah great test

This GTS did not have the track performance pack ie corsa tyres ptv etc so would be quicker again

way cheaper now - the Y performance. it's all selling out due to price drop. better order one now before the wait times lengthen again.

Correct! It is the long range version

It is the Long Range. The Macan GTS isn't the top performance version either.

@Mr. Wolf it was, but the Turbo model is no longer available so GTS is now the top model.

@@renantlobo you think any Macan spec can outperform the Model Y performance on track? Not a chance. Maybe the Macan EV when it comes out next year

Because Porche would be humiliated instantly ! Costing double price than Tesla this Macan is totally “has been”. On the road and inside. Not even talking about the space inside (Macan is ridiculous compared to TMY) or the load capacity - almost double in TMY compared to this German dinosaur.

@@STP-777Maths clearly isnt a strong point of yours is it? How is £64, 470 twice as much as £54,990

@@STP-777 2 things: First, GTS isn't the fastest trim for Macan either. If you want a Performance Y, then compare to a Macan Turbo. Second, 2 seconds is is a lot for a small track like this; the performance Y probably would still lose.

@@STP-777 Then go and buy a boring box tesla "quality" ev. If that's the standard you need.

@@aroundthewicketchinmusic611 MACAN GTS starts at 94 000 € in my country, TMY RWD at 49 000 € without any “eco gouvernement bonus” ; for Macan you have to add “pollution tax” my friend. I’m not even talking about the funny thing that any little gadget as heated seats I.e. are optional in Macan ! You can easily double the base price of your Macan if you want some nice and practical equipments inside and outside. In Tesla’s case you’ll get almost everything with your car for the base price. There are 5 / 6 optional things you can change in your Tesla : outside paint, white inside instead of standard black, wheels size (19 inches are standard), trail hook is an option, and then we have 2 autopilot options and that’s it. Even TMY RWD, the entry level model, has premium sound system that is much better than optional Burmester high sound system in Porsche that will cost you extra 5 000 € here. Would be very surprised if it’s for free or included in your place. So please go to the Porsche site, configure your Macan GTS base version with leather heated seats, sport pack, led lights, more than standard sound system (level 2 “Bose” is + 1 200 € here) and than compare with TMY RWD. In my place Macan starts at 66 000 € plus 40 000 pollution tax = 106 000 € for the base of the base witch is even more than double compared to almost full equipped TMY RWD for 47 900 € with the minimum eco gouv bonus of 2 000 € included. According to your situation the eco bonus may reach 7 000 € here.

Macan gts starts from £68k+

@@SignoPanino what’s the price of the model Y Performance?

Will the brakes be up for it a whole lap with regen off?

Also M Y performance would have been closer to the cost of that macan too .. not a fair comparison best Macan taken but not the best M Y

@@Cloxxki the brakes are not as good as the Porsche ones ofc but they are better than the normal version

@@sudeeptaghosh exactly

@@Cloxxki its a small track anyways so I don’t think it’s a problem

Disagree. They are comparative in cost, weight and power outputs

Did you miss the part where they showed they have the same power? The long range is also the middle of the range not base as was the macan until they recently stopped selling the turbo. If this test was done 6months earlier it would be 2 middle of the range models. The GTS is meant to be a sportier version of the macan so it'll always do well on the track again the Y.

Because they want the Porsche to win!

@@kdz666 Plato will never give anything a chance against Porsche

@@gaycha6589 you must not have something called google or internet. in America Tesla model Y PERFORMANCE now costs almost $25,000 less than the Macan GTS , even less if GTS is optioned up like it's normally done.

And so will the Corsa tyres of the GTS track pack not to mention PTV as well

The GTS would eat it up. Why not just compare ev to ev. Porsche still wins.

GTS isn't the fastest trim for Macan either.

@@igortchelzoff3736 it is now, Turbo has been discontinued and now GTS uses the 2.9L and is considered top of the line

What do you consider barely? I'd give you a few hundred pounds. 1100lbs difference is quite a bit. The number isn't as big of deal with the teslas lower center of gravity. For me it's the pseudo prius tires that come stock on the tesla and the fact it's almost $20k cheaper. Hands down would take the macans suspension over the performance model y. (Edit below)

@@Clarkbait Did you miss hear the weights or something because the Tesla was 1979Kg(4362Lbs) and the Porsche weighs 1970Kg(4343Lbs) according to google .

@@Clarkbait See the actual video, genius :)

Matter fact slowest Tesla 🙄

or the depreciation costs....

@@gaycha6589 Or the fuel costs...

@@G-Cam1 no one spending £65k gives a toss about fuel costs.

Which one is going to loose more in lets say 4 years

@@user-su6gn1cm9u The Porsche I guess as it will be 2027 .. 3 years before the ICE ban.. you will be as popular as a smoker in a pub.. Younger folks dont want to burn stuff anymore.

Model Y performance should be against Macan Turbo, not GTS.

In Denmark it's 5x :D :D

That's because Norway is rich

DK has Hygge to compensate

@@gaycha6589 and cheap beer! :D

Or.. they could just bring a Model Y Performance which has the tires, suspension, brakes, motors, and track mode to actually compete on track instead of being designed for bringing the kids to school like the Model Y LR is

@@Jeddin boring. We know the MYP would annihilate the macan. There is very little mechanical difference between an LR and P, esp now that the rotors and real calipers are the same. It's more amusing to see the everyday car beat the top trim Porsche. Also, if you read the whole comment I said to test the P as well.

Don’t think so the GTS has a track pack with the latest Corsa tyres and PTV victory to the Macan easily

In Greece the Macan GTS is 143.000 without extras

You don't like tracks?

@@mcplutt Strange conclusion you’ve reached. Family SUV’s aren’t designed for the track was my point, so it would be better to compare them for their intended purpose, thought that was obvious.

I noticed the Panerai right away too and asked when do we get to see a review on it.

V nice watch

Not at all, both cars have the same power and similar weight, if you're gonna be objective then at least keep the performance attributes the same!

JP is a racing driver

You won’t want the maintenance costs that’s for sure. I’d cringe everytime I went to the dealer, my Cayenne was $2000-$2500 per visit

BS GTS is a mid range Macan, Turbo and turbo S not available now. Also 100% better feel, quality, joy, engagement....

You would not find 2 secs difference