Тёмный

Test 50 Pound 800 Watt Amp vs 17 Pound 6400 Watt Amp 

Подписаться
Просмотров 54 тыс.
% 1 795

Modern power amps are a fraction of the size and weight of older amps and have much higher power outputs. One of the aspects that has changed significantly is the methods used to specify output wattage as well as the way amplifiers deliver that power. Here is a test where I show and we can hear the differences between older power amp watts and newer power amp watts.
Band : Riarosa
Song: Better Than Nothing
Produced by: J.T. O’Neal
Mixed by : Brian Edwards
Mastered: Voyager Mastering
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-X8YKLwPK3Mg.html
ru-vid.com/show-UCG2K0fG2yXHTKIfqlwWCx1Q
open.spotify.com/track/2GFUihqFfRKvu3QfwX4UV9?si=s7uIF5dZSpK_HIPmmAp_bA
riarosaband?igshid=dandzd67g2mb
If you like this and other videos I do, please join this channel to get access to more videos, early access to videos as well as to be able to join my weekly zoom chats:
ru-vid.com/show-UC_nJM07b0k7C9CvcM-9OH6wjoin
Also check out:
www.soundymcsoundface.com
www.ratsoundsales.com/
ratsound.com/daveswordpress/
www.ratsound.com/
www.soundtools.com
00:00 Introduction
01:49 Test Setup
02:43 Crest 4801 Lowest Freq Test
03:27 Crest 4801 Highest Freq Test
04:16 Powersoft T904 Lowest Freq Test
05:40 Powersoft T904 Highest Freq Test
06:44 Crest Power Test
08:14 Powersoft Power Test
09:04 Short Term Power Test
10:39 Hear Power Differences wit Music
12:14 Hear 400 Watts vs 540 Watts
13:39 Outro

Опубликовано:

 

11 июн 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 546   
@johnwetmore1527
@johnwetmore1527 Год назад
I am so glad you did this demonstration! I have been using professional sound equipment for over 40 years and own about 50 Crown amplifiers, all of which are old technology. I suspect that is why my back hurts so much. When Crown came out with their later amplifiers and started to talk "burst power" instead of continuous RMS, I talked to their engineers and was told that in some circumstances where low bass was needed, the old systems were actually better. For example on the Katy Perry song, Dark Horse, there is a very long tone, around 60 Hz. that would send any burst type amplifier into low power mode. In addition to professional sound, I use amplifiers in industrial situations, driving test systems where continuous sine wave power is needed. One great way to determine the real, continuous power of an amplifier is to look at the power cord and the rated input power. You can never put out continuous power greater than what you put in. Recently I was looking at some amplifiers very similar to Powersoft and noticed that the maximum input power was only around 1000 watts despite several thousand watts of "rated" output. My Crown MacroTech 5000 has a 3/4" diameter rubber cord! Thank you so much for the clear explanation of amplifier power! According to Crown engineers, a priority in their designs is weight and size because road crews no longer want sore backs.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Very cool and wise and yes, continuous power out needs a big cord and breaker. Yes, burst power specs don't translate well to extended low frequency output. That said, newer amps like the powersoft will run on 120, 208, or 240 single phase or 3 phase, and when run at higher voltages the cable sizes can be thin and the amps tend to have increased duration burst power. In the amps I tested, the crest put out 400 continuous and the PowerSoft put out 540 watts continuos so even though smaller and lighter, the powersoft still has more output than the crest in continuos measurements as well, so that is another aspect to consider.
@johnwetmore1527
@johnwetmore1527 Год назад
@@DaveRat I can see using a high burst power for mids and highs after my RG dynamic expander since it can add up to 20 dB. If I was going mobile again I would also consider running modern amplifiers but I am all but retired and just have a nightclub with a 10,000 watt (Continuous RMS) sound system. In general, sound equipment today is so much better than that of the past. I have a pair of Altec subwoofers that require a fork lift to move and my JBL line array subs blow these away.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Agreed
@jttech44
@jttech44 Год назад
"You can never put out continuous power greater than what you put in." Say that again for the kids in the back. It's amazing how many people don't understand this, ultimately continuous power is a simple thing to solve for, and it allows you to cut through the marketing BS to see what an amplifier actually produces, power wise because they might be able to lie on the box, but they cannot lie on the spec sheet and retain UL certs.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Of course, we are way beyond that elementary concept for beginners. We are looking at the ability of amps to offer peak power profiles that more closely parallel the power needs of the music being reproduced and the ratings of the speakers that amps are connected to. The video shows 2 amps with similar RMS outputs and one amp that has a peak power 6db above the RMS. This peak power allows louder playback withoutsignificantly increasing ac power draw. And I demonstrate and you can hear how much louder the amp capable of processing clean 6 db peaks is. In the video. Or maybe watch the vid?
@kelainefes
@kelainefes Год назад
There's many people that are advanced in their field but can only explain things to their peers, but there's very few people that are so advanced that they can make very complex subjects easy to understand for people that are not on their level. Dave absolutely belongs in the latter category. Thanks you so much for your videos Dave!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Thank you and honored!
@janedoe6350
@janedoe6350 Год назад
Albert Einstein once said: (and i'm paraphrasing) If you can't explain your knowledge to a 10 year old... then you don't truly understand it yourself.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
I do find that researching and doing these videos helps me understand things better and I learn something every time
@FreeAssRecords
@FreeAssRecords Год назад
@@DaveRat That is the most amazing and awesome statement, Dave. My pride in my rat tattoo has only grown over the years. Thank you for what you've done and what you continue to do.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Thank you Dave! You rule! Saw a message on FB and will open and read soon.
@djp_video
@djp_video Год назад
This is the first time I've noticed the low frequency tones at the end of a video. Really gets the subwoofer going.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@ANATURALDREWSASTER
@ANATURALDREWSASTER Год назад
I love that you found a way to accurately record and demonstrate the difference with music, amazing!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙 ha! Yes I'm glad somebody spotted that. The coolest part of the demo is being able to listen to exactly what the amp is putting out at a reasonable volume and not just look at pictures and graphs.
@ArtVandelayLTEX
@ArtVandelayLTEX Год назад
I love these unique experiements you do to get to the bottom of what's really going on. Thank you!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Awesome thank you!
@theberndog
@theberndog Год назад
This is fascinating but I also appreciate the amount of editing you did to this video to make it clear and easy to follow.!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Awesome and thank you! Yeah these things do take some time to do. This was actually two separate videos initially and I merge them into one to solidify the concept
@IswanjanaHariAdi
@IswanjanaHariAdi Год назад
Very cool demonstration as always. Thumbs up, keep up the goodwork Dave. Thanks for the knowledge.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@dacharyzoo
@dacharyzoo 7 месяцев назад
You just answered so many questions I've had for years. Bravo, Maestro!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat 7 месяцев назад
👍🎛️👍
@SunilKaranjikar
@SunilKaranjikar Год назад
This is an awesome way to demo burst Vs. continuous power. Thank you Dave !!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@N0B0DY_SP3C14L
@N0B0DY_SP3C14L Год назад
Wow, Dave. I can say that this time you honestly schooled me, and I am grateful. Awesome demonstration.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@FreeAssRecords
@FreeAssRecords Год назад
Impressive comparison test, Dave. Thanks, man. I also appreciate that you presented it in a way that I understood. There was a lot of information digested and I didn't get any brain gas. 👍😁
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@sfsgcsvxcv
@sfsgcsvxcv Год назад
Dave, thank you for taking the time to do this!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Awesome and thank you!
@peniku8
@peniku8 Год назад
It's important to note that speakers also handle power in a similar way: they tolerate high bursts but might burn up on long sustained signals, which is why the Powersoft amp makes much more sense in every way. If you hook up an old iron amp to a speaker, you're either giving up headroom for bursts or your amps will be able to put out way too much sustained power for the speakers. This is especially true for modern high density subs, with a lot of power in (relatively) small cabinets and drivers with high Xmax.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
True
@AragonDubs
@AragonDubs Год назад
Dave, thanks for other free MASTER CLASS. The noise traces in the powersoft for me are inadmissible, looking for hearing healt and technical dignity. This demonstration stand at same level of your others. Dont stop! Cheers from Spain!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes it's all about selecting the right tool for the job. And thank you
@patrickcarpenter6258
@patrickcarpenter6258 Год назад
Your passion is so refreshing.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Thank you and awesome!
@mikef3855
@mikef3855 Год назад
Dave, I love the insight you provide to the production community with all of your videos. I remember your early PA systems with Pearl Jam. I was touring with Spin Doctors and met you NYC. Loved your enthusiasm then and how it continues today.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Awesome so cool and yeah I remember doing spin doctor's gigs! Thank you and great to see you still rocking!
@Edwin-van-der-Putten
@Edwin-van-der-Putten Год назад
Really great test, Dave!!!! very nice! Thanks for your work! :-)
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Thanknyou
@mikeo5657
@mikeo5657 Год назад
Another excellent detailed explanation. Thank you Dave!!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@ChickyNYC
@ChickyNYC Год назад
Dave, I met you years ago at Coachella (I was FOH for OMD) and was absolutely over the moon with your system and your support. Then, recently, your videos came up in my recommended list and I started binge-watching. I love your videos. Just wanted you to know.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
So cool! Great to see ya here Charles and thank you!!
@davidclark3603
@davidclark3603 Год назад
That was a brilliant video Dave! I wish I had your knowledge!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Well you now have some and cool cool David!
@avh700
@avh700 Год назад
Thanks for the demonstration. Nice song!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@tylerkeeton17
@tylerkeeton17 Год назад
So stinking cool! Awesome way to show this data.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙🤙🤙
@dighawaii1
@dighawaii1 Год назад
The sub sweep at the end 😂😂Great video!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@fireball570
@fireball570 Год назад
Awesome video Dave. Been thinking about these sorts of things with my own system. Wicked Demo. Hope to see more creative videos like this. :)
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍👍
@emiel333
@emiel333 Год назад
Great and interesting video. The low frequencies and short sweep at the end of the video is a nice touch. Subscribed.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Welcome and thank you!
@emiel333
@emiel333 Год назад
@@DaveRat Thank you for your kind reply!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Thank you for joining and hope you get some cool and useful info here
@gavinlamp
@gavinlamp 6 месяцев назад
its crazy seeing this stuff tested. Make sme think deeper in my audio rabbit hole
@zordmaker
@zordmaker Год назад
Great demo. Real amps, Real figures, A/B switching. Thats what we need. Well done Rat.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@SoundBarrierEntertainment
@SoundBarrierEntertainment Год назад
been waiting for amp testing, do a whole bunch more
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Will do.
@williamrutledge2588
@williamrutledge2588 Год назад
Great job dude.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Thank you 👍🤙🤙
@Mr-Electronist
@Mr-Electronist Год назад
I did not taked my time to learn about decibels, after this video i did a quick read. You have a good video and provides good information. It is allot easier to make + 3dB by adding another speaker if the amp can take higher loads. Building a amplifier with 200 watts in 8 ohms is many times harder and expensive than a amp with 100 w / 8 ohms. Thank you for your video.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
That is less true in modern class d amps where watts are cheap and building high voltage amps is not any harder. But yes, with older amps, it was useful to run lower impedance loads to get maximum amp power.
@richmorpurgo5554
@richmorpurgo5554 Год назад
I love what you do!!!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@maticlee8535
@maticlee8535 Год назад
that song is so dope!!!! this is like the best college course
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@ericdeweese3748
@ericdeweese3748 Год назад
You should also look at the difference in power draw as well. I think that would be a very valuable metric to consider. Great video!!!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yeah, I will ponder an efficiency vid
@duroxkilo
@duroxkilo Год назад
i enjoyed this... they have these super small class D for under $50 that run on aprox 40Volts. the other weekend we powered a 400Watts Cerwin-Vega sub for our backyard darts games and it sounded just as loud as with the old and heavy Crown amp. now it makes sense :)
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@user-iq9iu1zh6w
@user-iq9iu1zh6w Год назад
Hey Dave, I'm an audio tech with a background in electrical technology and it was so refreshing to watch this video. I have done tests like this for that exact reason. I have found that class D is better toward the lower frequencies but I much prefer class H for mids and highs. As we saw in your test there is limited frequncy bandwith when amplifining high freqs. and distortion can be quite ear fatiguing as well as damaging to the drivers. A cool load thest is hot water heaters paired to the appropriate impeadance and submerged in water or oil. Starp that to your amp and observe the voltage just under clipping to get a reasonable real world RMS power. Resistive load as opposed to inductive but it will show you what balls the amp really has and what your AC mains needs to be in order to sustain the output. Keep up the great work. Much appreciated.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Cool, am building a new load with 4x 200 watt and 4 x 250 watt 8 ohm loads on a 1/2" thick aluminum plate. Mat sandwich a second plate on top which should give me the ability to power test in known precision resistive. Also I have a dead dishwasher that I will pull the heating element out of and see if that will give me a second option. Looking to do a test of actual power delivered using music. So I'm thinking of a combination of the loads plus a playlist and scope to right before clip while monitoring load temps over time with a thermal camera. Also monitoring input current to the amp Determine which amp heats the load faster. See if I can gain visible insight into various amp efficiencies and capabilities.
@user-iq9iu1zh6w
@user-iq9iu1zh6w Год назад
That should provide interseting results...I'm looking forward to the thermal cam images!@@DaveRat
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@MrMotoden
@MrMotoden Год назад
Current draw is also very interesting to test in a setup like this. Comparing different amps with sine wave signal at different frequencies and then music type signal plotted against AC current. Interesting to know when your venues might not have quite the power source you would like to have.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Very true and that's a test for a different day. Though I can say that when we switched from conventional amps to Class D for a large format sound systems, our current draw from the mains dropped significantly and output volumes increased. That said the differential between average current draw and peak current draw increased
@Anamnesia
@Anamnesia Год назад
I bought a Chevin Research A500 power amplifier back in '97. It's only 250W (at 8 ohms) per stereo channel, but while I could pay a LOT less for a large transformer based amplifier, the physical difference in weight of the Chevin Research switch-mode amplifier is what sold me! (Note: I'm aware that Switch Mode amplifiers also have "transformers" as a part of their circuitry)
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
We have a load of 4 channel Chevin amps that sound great and work well Good amps
@zolof911
@zolof911 7 месяцев назад
Chevin amps have a switch mode power supply with a linear output stage using mosfets instead of bipolar output transistors. Very fast slew rate and extended high-frequency response. Great sounding amps.
@JayBeBerg
@JayBeBerg Год назад
Very cool video. I can understand why some speaker manufacturers use class-D for the woofers and A/B for the tweeter.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes I can understand that and also modern class D amps from top end manufacturers have quite impressive sound. The new L-Acoustics amp that is two rack spaces and 1600 watts per channel and 8 ohms with 16 channels is amazingly impressive in its power output, power density add fidelity
@RWL2012
@RWL2012 Год назад
even Logitech did that in the Z-Cinema lol
@jaakanshorter
@jaakanshorter Год назад
Great video.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙thank you
@BlackenBurg
@BlackenBurg Год назад
Hey Dave, Great setup and demonstration! I remember you did a video demonstrating differences of amp clipping by nulling the signals. Do you think there is anyway to hear the differences in amp types by summing the signals from both the crest and powersoft? I’m just fascinated by how some genres of music might have different current draw characteristics and how that might change what sort of amp would be suitable. i.e. A class D amp struggling to keep up power with a really thick grungy guitar or a compressed edm track Love your work!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
I would like to do that I would need to find a class D amp that has no digital processing as the digital processor would cause a time offset preventing the null. I almost recall doing something similar to that with amplifiers I will ponder it
@soundman1402
@soundman1402 Год назад
I used to work at a small sound and lighting store. We sold QSC amplifiers, and our bread and butter line was the PLX with its switch-mode power supply and Class H topology. We compared it on a pair of JBL dual-18s to a Crest 8001 and found that, despite similar power spec, the Crest amp had a lot more "girth" in the bass. They both seemed about as loud, but the bass from the Crest seemed more... Powerful? Your demonstration of the Powersoft's peak power may explain what was going on. Perhaps the PLX amp's power supply could not sustain those power output levels, so we got a big punch from the kick drum, but any loud, sustained bass notes fell off, whereas the Crest amp was able to sustain that output. Despite these sound quality differences, we still only ever took the PLX amps out for shows because they weighed 25 lbs each to the 8001's 80 lbs.
@edtalktech
@edtalktech Год назад
PLX amps always seemed to have a reputation for not being ideal for bass. They were early innovators of SMPSU's and they have come a long way since then!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
I had the same experience with the qsc when comparing the Crest 7001 but it wasn't the PLX it was an older amp We AB compared The sound and the crest was punchy and full on the QSC kind of popped with no follow-through. I've tested numerous amplifiers over the years using a pulse and a block of four double 18 bins and had a wide variety of results. The first lightweight amp that performed well was the lab group in 6400 Now when comparing a Crest 7001 to a power soft X4, which of course is rated much higher power, The power soft dominates the 7001 and makes it sound broken. I think if you compare usable output level of a 1000 Watt Class D app to 1,000 w conventional amp, The conventional amp will win with anything that has low end to it. But if you compare the amps using metrics like equal weight equal cost, equal power draw from the wall, watts per pound, equal heat dissipation, and even Fidelity per dollar spent if you can measure that, you will find that the class D amp will win in nearly every way. I would say as a rule of thumb you want two to three times the wattage out of a Class D amp than you would want out of a conventional amp when used for subwoofers.
@edtalktech
@edtalktech Год назад
@@DaveRat It's an interesting topic. Since by design modern switching amps should have a much much lower internal resistance than their analogue counterparts, they should absolutely destroy the older amps in terms of power output. I have always heard however, but never actually seen until now that power soft are clearly limiting the current thought the PSU. What surprises me even more is this is a 4ch amp driving one channel. I was under the (incorrect) assumption that the available PSU power was available for all channels, so for example on a 4ch amp driving 1ch to the rails would be able to do so without current limiting. What's also interesting is it seems there is a recovery period as at @10.22 that power doesn't come back immediately. I wonder how it would behave with 4 ohm or even 4 channels at 4 ohm.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
They spec that out and list symmetrical output power with all channels driven the same and asymmetrical output power with two of the channels driven 6db lower level as would happen with bi-amplification. I believe this symmetrical output is 1600 watts per channel all channels driven and the asymmetrical output is 1800 watts on two of the channels with the other two channels driven at 450 Watts. For my test I didn't really focus on getting the exact power measurement and I'm sure there was some power drop in the long extension cord I had running the amp reducing its output
@Oogadoog
@Oogadoog Год назад
I had the great pleasure to apprentice under Walter K. Dick (jbl, Alesis, Event, etc.) who has a great story about rated “watts”. There are so many ways to measure wattage output (peak, rms, blah blah). One day he was telling me that everyone originally agreed on a standard until the marketing team at Carver introduced their ratings that everyone tested and found they were inferior, so they started calling them “carver watts”. I don’t know for sure, but I think that was the origin of “peak watts”.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Well car Hi-Fi had a big impact on those super high pequat ratings from small amps that didn't actually deliver more sound. Then cheap PA kind of jumped on the bandwagon. If my memory serves
@lazygazzzer
@lazygazzzer Год назад
Great video, glad you did this demonstration of the differences between class D and old school amps. I think the old heavy weight amps have suffered badly in recent years due to misinformation about output wattage on the newer class D amps. People see an old amp rated at 400 watts output and think it's no good because they have seen some Chinese-made amp in the local electrical store with a claimed output of 5000+ watts. But if you look round the back of any of these amps you can bet you will find a 2 amp fuse on the mains input. If it's drawing so little current from the mains then where is it finding all this extra power for the 5000 watts output? Meanwhile if they powered-up the old school 400 watts amp, it would blow their ears off. Having said that I was quite impressed that the Powersoft amp went down to 3 Hz. Certainly a well designed Class D amp with good build quality and decent components would be the one to choose if you needed to power some earthquake inducing subs.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes the same issue existed with class A B and older amps, crappy amp sounded bad no matter what they are rated at and good amps performed well.
@Rhythmattica
@Rhythmattica Год назад
Incredibly insightfull..... or inearfull. Brilliant .
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@soniclab-cnc
@soniclab-cnc Год назад
The Crest amps just sound great. I used a rig that was all Crest power and it had very musical low end, tight and punchy mids...nice easy to listen highs. Beautiful sounding with a ground stacked EV festival rig. 20 subs and 6 mid hi per side.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes, agreed
@TriAmpHiFi
@TriAmpHiFi Год назад
Ah, that feels good............... 🔈🔉🔊
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@TimpBizkit
@TimpBizkit Год назад
It's nice being able to hear the relative maximum loudness differences between the amplifiers, and that the 300 millisecond duration of full power is plenty for most music (apart from ghetto rap and some EDM, but then it may protect the speakers not having that sustained sine wave potential anyway). Cranking them up through speakers would be in most cases too loud to notice much difference unless in a field and the speakers are tough enough to handle both without power compression.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Agreed.
@thizzyglider555
@thizzyglider555 Год назад
Thanks Dave
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍👍👍
@kevinpetit9886
@kevinpetit9886 Год назад
Great Video. 😃👍♥️
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@catherineescol7852
@catherineescol7852 Год назад
Dave is the Most Reliable, Fact Based Audiophole Reviewer out there Some people whoe Review amplifiers and preamplifier, and Speakers are Ghost hunters and Alien Hunters, who hires 3 Writers to make their channel sounds good. DAVE knows the Physics of Audio Stuff, Speakers , HIfi Amplifiers , Dave is the real Golden 👂 Ear. Always delivers Facts , not hype
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Epic and thank you! I do try very hard to share info I think will be useful that is unbiased
@zambotv8150
@zambotv8150 11 месяцев назад
Smashing
@ww6156
@ww6156 Год назад
Man i wish someone demo'd that for me when i was a student, that was great
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@avnut5517
@avnut5517 Год назад
What a well thought out test rig. I was surprised you could see the switching power bleed thru so much on the Powersoft.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Agreed
@x5-acousticguitarstuff.2
@x5-acousticguitarstuff.2 Год назад
GREAT VIDEO. tq
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@brandonmoore7797
@brandonmoore7797 Год назад
Hey, ​ @DaveRat , I'd love to duplicate this kind of testing to look at my QSC amp, and compare it to some of the receivers and AVRs I have laying around, in the hopes of finding the one that's best as an amp for speaker testing (so I can avoid impedance dependent frequency response). Where do you have your oscilloscope probe attached? I'm assuming you just have the probe running in parallel with the 8ohm load (ground to negative on the amp output, probe on the positive on the amp output). And same goes for your multimeter measuring the voltage (and after a calculation, power). Is that also in parallel with your 8ohm load? Thanks, and fantastic videos man! PS. The QSC RMX1450 I have is driving a DIY sub in my home theater. Good for the long, deep rumbles, but you've definitely got me thinking about getting a smaller class H or class D for some burst power!
@janm2510
@janm2510 Год назад
Thanks!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@josiahberry8743
@josiahberry8743 Год назад
One of the best demos I've seen online! Ironically, modern EDM music (trap, dubstep, and drum & bass especially) has much more sine wave content, especially in the subwoofer range, compared to a live band. Burst power ratings should be almost meaningless for that type of sine wave bass music. With sine waves having a 3db crest factor, I imagine modern DJ music has a crest factor closer to 6db at most whereas a live band is easily closer to 12db+... Getting the rights to play music on RU-vid is not the easiest thing in the world, but I wonder how this exact experiment would look/sound with an actual EDM bass music song vs just a raw 50hz sine wave... I imagine the Powersoft amp may be a hair louder but I would expect the difference to be less than it was in this experiment using a track that was recorded with live musical instruments... So cool to see this either way!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
If you do the math there a 6DB crest factor would mean that a 500 watt amp would need a 2000 w peak because 6dB is four times the power. The apps that I measured show the class D having more continuous power and more peak power and fully capable of meeting the specs you propose
@josiahberry8743
@josiahberry8743 Год назад
@@DaveRat Yes, I use all Class D. The weight savings and efficiency is a must in the modern era. I remember when I had boat anchor QSC RMX and Crown CE2000s amps as a kid when first getting into audio. My how time flies when you're having fun! Thanks as always, Dave!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Awesome thank you Josiah!
@kyle_neuron
@kyle_neuron Год назад
Funny thing about crest factor is that it's affected by bandpass filtering. Guess what every loudspeaker on earth is, even before you add extra processing? A simple sealed box is a second order high pass filter, and that alone can make your 6 dB CF content suddenly look like 9 dB... What actually hits the speaker is rarely quite so dense. That is of course, unless you've not brought enough rig for the gig or don't have amps with sufficient peak voltage swing to handle the 12 dB CF side-chained kickdrums that sit on top of the rolling sub...
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Interesting
@harrissoundlighting
@harrissoundlighting Год назад
I would love to see you test the Admark K30 (which is what we use on our subs) They claim 3000W @ 8 ohms. They are killer little amps, but I'd like to see them benched to know the exact numbers. I'd be willing to send one to you, if you'd be interested.
@haldorasgirson9463
@haldorasgirson9463 Год назад
Class D amps are amazing. Especially for subs where you really need the power.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@zambotv8150
@zambotv8150 Год назад
Cool cool... I still have a pile of old school amps, they sound great but, my back gets sore just looking at them.... Shame there's no Vz5000,s anymore, they were terrifying beasties
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@user-zm7up6eb8l
@user-zm7up6eb8l 7 месяцев назад
COOL!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat 7 месяцев назад
🤙🎛️🤙
@wwlittlejOfficial
@wwlittlejOfficial Год назад
I am such a geek. thank you for your content, Rat!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙 as we should be
@laszlosokolai2858
@laszlosokolai2858 8 месяцев назад
I had to take out the IEC power connectors and hardwired cords of the proper guage into all my amplifiers. I haven't had an amplifier failure since then. The IEC power connectors are THE number one cause of amplifier failures as they are only meant to carry 10 amps. The 20 amp IEC only carries 15 amps. The power lights don't dim on my amplifiers any more. If you don't believe me, put a volt meter between one of the lines and the corresponding connector in the amplifier and drive it at full power - 20 to 30 volt difference and drop between wall receptacle and power switch inside the amplifier!. I have 3 dozen Cerwin Vega CV-5000 amplifiers rated for 5,000 watts each. They came with 20 amp IEC's - i could not get the amplifiers to put out anything past 2,925 watts bridged at 4 ohms. When I hardwired 8 guage power cords into each of them - 6,600 watts bridged at 4 ohms, pulling 60 amps peak each amplifier.
@timobthie
@timobthie Год назад
Hey Dave! Thanks for the demonstration. so due to the more linear continuous output of this older analogue gear could one say, that it is better suited to drive subwoofers for dance/soundsystem music with long standing basslines like dub or dub influenced music? In my imagination this powersoft amp would basically build a kind of long transient.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
For that to be true you would want to have equal amounts of usable output capability. For the amps I tested the old app was 400 Watts and the new amp was 540 Watts, so the new app was louder for continuous power which would benefit the dance systems and it was louder for peak power which would benefit the dance systems and all systems. And it was smaller lighter and more efficient generating less heat. That said if you were to get aClass D amp rated at 400 Watts and compare it to an older app also rated at 400 Watts The older app would be preferable but cost more, be larger, generate more heat, use more power from the wall, and weigh more
@artysanmobile
@artysanmobile Год назад
That’s what some very enterprising manufacturers liked to call “music power.” It’s perfectly valid in almost all cases. Almost. EDM subwoofers beg to differ.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Agreed and the question is, would an EDM subwoofer perform better on a Class AB amp rated at 1,000 Watts RMS that can do 1200 watt peaks or perform better on the Class D amp also rated at a 1000 watts RMS but can offer 4,000 w peaks? The class D could be lighter, smaller and draw less power from the wall due to efficiency and deliver the same power to the speakers RMS and offer the peaks as well. I don't disagree that having longer duration power delivery is important for more consistent signals. What I debate is whether Class A B amp is actually beneficial or just a larger more powerful yet smaller and lighter class D amp would do equally well or better
@raygunsforronnie847
@raygunsforronnie847 16 дней назад
@@DaveRat The last question is the pondering point. Doing a dubstep gig a dozen years ago on JBL 4880a with I Tech 8K power we could smell the VC heat at ~500W/ch continuous. Peaks on dub are mostly a matter of performer fader position choices, so from a genre standpoint the smaller, lighter, tastes great, less filling Class D amp *should* suffice in my example. For a rock show with lead kick drum, the time it takes the output power of the class D to taper down isn't an issue until the double kicks; having that 6dB of extra output for 250ms is just right. Big stiff power supplies are big, heavy, and expensive making that extra transient headroom even more resource consuming. Your demo of the Crest just on the edge of clip sounds very compressed compared to the PowerSoft at the same long term (clip) point. That makes me think the folks who advocate for the Crests have rosier memories and less painful backs than myself.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat 16 дней назад
I can fully relate to the skepticism of the claims from many amplifier manufacturers. Clearly audible issues will often not show up in specifications. At rat sound we used to do tests when any amplifier company came to the shop by running their amp bridge mono into four 16 ohm rat subs wired in parallel. Then we would use a pulse test and compare their amp to the amplifiers we were using which were Crest 7001 at the time. This test would clearly divulge any issues with the various amplifiers. I remember a QSC amp rated at 4000 Watts sounded like a wet tire compared to the 1800 watt Crest 7001. The lab group in FP6400 was comparable but only with three subs in parallel bridge mono. Adding the fourth sub sent the amp unstable. Putting a PowerSoft X4 on the subs clearly was more powerful and clear than the crest 7001. Developing a test that allows you to easily hear the difference is wise and I probably take that for granted more than I should as I have much experience in that realm. I will try and do a video down that line of testing so people can develop tests that work for them
@ladjkaoz
@ladjkaoz Год назад
🤘😉👍great video... I love my old crowns power base 1 and 2 but I rather use the digital ones still crown. K2 Itech and Mtech.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍👍🤙
@mojoemurphy
@mojoemurphy 2 месяца назад
It's amazing how much more efficient the new amps are. I'm a big fan of the new light amps, with a mobile rig, the old iron just doesn't make much sense for me
@DaveRat
@DaveRat 2 месяца назад
🔧👍🔧
@ralmslb
@ralmslb 9 месяцев назад
Could you share some more details regarding the load you are using? How did you achieve an 8Ohm load that can't handle all this power? Also, is the lamp just a standard AC LED lamp? Won't the lamp add also resistance to the output? Lastly, is it dangerous to measure the amp output voltage while driving a speaker if the speaker is rated for at least the same as the amp?
@blormpf1740
@blormpf1740 Год назад
nice video - Crest all the way for me. Quality over Quantity.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
I do love the old crests and also when we switched from Crest to the modern class D amps our sound systems sounded dramatically better. That said when we first started switching to lighter weight amps many years ago, we tested everything and found some amps were rated very high wattage and sounded like crap and other ones sounded much better and there was no consistency. I believe that's still the case as it is with the older style amps as well.
@mistersmoker7443
@mistersmoker7443 Год назад
Great video, might be worth comparing the costs of these amplifiers, crest produced much more powerful amps than this back in the day for probably the same or less cost than a powersoft will cost you now? I would be interested in seeing a crest 8001 of another seriously heavyweight old amp 5000vz vs powersoft T602. Are we getting better value vs power / listening quality from newer amps ?(of course they are much more practical and have more features) but in a situation such as an install where weight is less of an issue what advantage would upgrading to a more modern amp be if we are just concerned with quality and output power.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Not as extreme as the cost of hard drives and computer memory, The dollar per watt cost of audio power amps has dropped tremendously over the years. As has dollar per pound. What has increased is dollar per rack space. Switching to modern high quality amplifiers can add new life to an older sound system by increasing available power to the speakers as well as enhanced protection of the speakers utilizing the multiple programmable limiters and compressors available in many of the top amps. This will also increase reliability and reduce power draw from the grid as well as lower the heat dissipation and reduce overall size. I have done several upgrades to clubs where I replaced full racks of older amps with just a few new class D apps and made those older sound systems sound better than new.
@andygibson8143
@andygibson8143 Год назад
The powersoft t904 is a class D type amp. They do not have any heatsinks on the transistors because they are switched on and off entirely. Therefore don't need much space, and make more use of the power coming from the supply. If you put 1000 watts in you get 998 watts out !
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@dylandylan11731
@dylandylan11731 Год назад
Wow that powersoft has a pretty funky & fuzzy waveform - as you said; likely switching frequency psu doing what they do - It’s supposedly out of hearing range… But can it be accumulative ? Can it be compounded under certain conditions ?
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
It's not ideal and be better if it wasn't there. You look closely there's actually two frequencies floating around on those waveforms. One appears to be in the 48K region and the other is maybe 500k or something. Being that the amp is the last thing in the signal chain and nearly all audio high frequency drivers are incapable of reproducing anything over 30k, and the audio cabling we use does not transmit those high frequencies very well, and the impedance of the voice coils tends to go very high for high frequencies pretty much blocking those out completely anyway. Additionally class D amps have pretty strict low pass filters at 22k or so so they won't regenerate those frequencies if they get back into the input somehow. And yes it'd be cool if they weren't there and also the amount of electronics and filtering needed to make sure they're not on the output is probably more detrimental than leaving them
@ionstorm66
@ionstorm66 Год назад
Will the powersoft push more watts on average without themal throttle/protect? It was driving the fans pretty fast with single channel loaded, thats a lot of power density to keep cool.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
The fans were ramping up not because of the load as much as the pure high frequency I was driving into it. The class D amps have a hard time with long-term high power high frequency energy. Which is rarely a real world scenario as the high frequencies tend to be the least continuous and most transient. We've been using the smaller t604s on monitor rigs like the EAW microwedge systems we have and they perform very well for that. Classy amps tend to be very efficient and don't normally run much hotter when under full load than they are with no load.
@ScottGrammer
@ScottGrammer Год назад
How many times did I carry Phase Linear 700's and Peavey CS-800's in and out of gigs? Wow. That was a long time ago.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍👍
@TriAmpHiFi
@TriAmpHiFi Год назад
Yeah, about 1982. And "Daryl Martini the Cosmic Weenie" was on-air for WBCN Boston. My word, yesterday was a long time ago now. 🔈🔉🔊
@ScottGrammer
@ScottGrammer Год назад
@@TriAmpHiFi "I was so much older then, I'm much younger than that now."
@Audio_Simon
@Audio_Simon Год назад
Cool experiment! I'd love to know what internal voltage these amps are running. I.E. is the powersoft/crown voltage or current limited? Id guess the powersoft is running very high voltage internally but relies on capacitors to provide the current. When the capacitors empty out after a second the amp clips.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
The powersoft has built in processing that is set to protect the amp and prevent clipping from ever occuring
@AlexJoneses
@AlexJoneses Год назад
I miss my 60 pound qsc isa300ti's. They were a bitch to lug around to smaller gigs but frankly they outshone my 2kw peak power amps while retaining more quality from less distortion, and never ever broke, even though they were 15 years old and absolutely covered in dust rust and grime. This however is not to say all new amplifiers suck, I am particularly interested in the rise of the ultra tiny class D amplifiers as they seem to be doing some crazy stuff for the size, but as of now, and maybe wont be for too long, if you want that clean reliable power, the heavier that transformer the better it's been.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
I we saw the opposite. We had louds of issues with the Crest amps. We now deploy literally 100s of L-acoustics LA48 and LA12x amps with very low failure rates, improved sound quality and volume levels that make the Crests sound broken
@valentinomiori605
@valentinomiori605 Год назад
So on the new one is like the signal is passing through some sort of expander, that's a form of distortion. The old one on the other hand was very impressive to me, staying almost flat for that wide range. Also the new one has not a good reconstruction filter, the noise may be outside the audible range but it's not guaranteed to be inaudible as it can be distorted back into the audible spectrum, by the speakers for example.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
The new one is not an expander. It's more like a limiter where it lets all of the peaks through but the longer duration signals get compressed That said with normal music nothing gets compressed it just is louder lighter smaller and more powerful
@darine.3145
@darine.3145 Год назад
Nice job. I would like to know how long those typical spikes in music are. A 250 ms burst is 25 cycles at 100 Hz. Did the class-D amp meet its peak power rating in those short bursts?
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
A full 1/4 second is pretty long for a kick or snare spike. Also, it's important to know that the duration of the burst power rating increases when the amps has better input power. I was running it in worst case scenario with it on a longish 16 ga ac power cord plugged into a wall outlet. The amp can power from 120, 208, 240v on single phase or 3 phase ac. Better Ac will increase the pulse power durations. Also the amp harvests back EMF from reactive loads like speakers, so there's even more energy available in real world use. The amp works great in real world but I would not use this tiny singe rack space 4 channel amp as the optimal subwoofer amp. I would get it's beg brother, the X4 that does 5000 watts per channel x 4 in a single rack space
@wilcandou
@wilcandou Год назад
You would think with the Powersoft Amp that what was represented as a bit of fuzz on the scope would be heard when the music was played, but apart from the output volume changing, it sounded ok. If anything is to be "considered", would it be a fair call to say that the Powersoft Amp would be a better choice (according to the scope) for bottom end sound? As the Crest Amp was far cleaner at the top end? Thanks Dave.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
That high frequency fuzz is in the 50 kilohertz region I believe so it's neither audible nor can speakers reproduce it
@grantturley8600
@grantturley8600 Год назад
Super interesting how much the instantaneous power headroom helps with preserving transient info. I wonder how the Class D Powersoft would compare with a class G or H amplifier. Idk if those are even made as pro audio amps though.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
That 4801 is a Class h
@grantturley8600
@grantturley8600 Год назад
@@DaveRat I had no idea. Thanks for letting me know.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@matthewseymour8972
@matthewseymour8972 Год назад
The small rig I used to run used all class D amps. I'd always get people telling me how inferior they were and they couldn't keep up with the old tin... True in very specific circumstances, but I had to move these things around so I did not care.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes it's difficult to buy any gear at this point that doesn't have class D amps. All the self-powered gear and all the top end professional gear is based on Class D
@jameslawford4057
@jameslawford4057 Год назад
48kHz internal processing in the Powersoft, hence filtering at Nyquist.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙👍
@AdamGotheridge
@AdamGotheridge Год назад
Super cool 😎 and extremely well presented. I do wonder if the old tech "sounds" better when staying within its limits. Any thoughts on that part? Forgive me if you've answered this in the comments, I didn't have time read them all! And that sine wave on the new amp sure looked funky.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
I've been trying to do tests and get more clarity on that. And even if I do gain headway the variations between manufacturers blur the outcome. What I found so far is that class D amps can sound really good and all things being equal in cost size weight, including the fidelity, you'd be hard pressed to find a class AB amp that outperforms Class D amps. I guess the question is with an unlimited budget buying the most expensive class A or Class A B amp, would you end up with something that sounds better than the most expensive Class D amp. And for that I would say yes. But as soon as you add in any other metric like size, weight, cost, efficiency, output power, or fidelity per dollar spent, everything seems to point to Class D being the winner Add in things like cool factor, aesthetics, and simplicity, and the outcome tilts more towards Class A or Class A B
@AdamGotheridge
@AdamGotheridge Год назад
@@DaveRat Thanks, and totally agree on all points. The "sounds better" thing is just so subjective to begin with, but wanted to hear your thoughts regardless. I've kind of come down to the conclusion that when the differences are small, I can't really tell what sounds better by a quick a/b. But I think I can tell something when I've lived with it for time, like say an hour, do I still think it sounds good, or is there something bugging me and I don't want to listen anymore. If I'm happy with something after say an hour, it sort of becomes a clear winner to me, but that is so subjective to any subconscious impulse, you can't really quantify why it's better or if it even is better. That's what I've arrived at these days, and obviously you've experienced a huge gamut of experience with not only different gear, but just time and different situations. So I pick your brain because I trust it. 😎 And thanks again. It's really interesting how you use your knowledge and imagination to teach and prove or disprove concepts. You should probably be the whacky professor that everyone loves. Anyway, really appreciated. 🙏
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Agreed on the "over time, awareness to subtle differences can increase" these are the aspects I love to test!
@zolof911
@zolof911 7 месяцев назад
@AdamGotheridge My experience is that the old-tech linear amps sound better in the upper mids and highs, but modern amps can sound better on the bass. Unless the bass is composed of sine waves... Perhaps oversampling will help class D amps rival linear amps high-frequency sound quality.
@teodorzimta748
@teodorzimta748 Год назад
Cool video , but as far as I remeber either the 4601 or the 4801, it's optimized to run high mid frequencies rather than fullrange.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
It was the 4601 that was designed and optimized for high frequency applications. The 4801 was the small brother to the 7001. The 8001 is the three rack space version with even more power and weight
@willmanJohn
@willmanJohn Год назад
I use electrostatic speakers, which can have very demanding impedance loads, both high and low. Is there a difference between these amps with, let's say, a 2 Ohm load or a 60 Ohm load? (Yes, I have one pair of speakers that have these impedance extremes, depending upon frequency)
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
It'd be interesting to try a class D app on those. I know the PowerSoft amps can run loads as low as 1/2 ohms and have the voltage swing to run high impedance loads and still deliver a good amount of power more so then class A B apps. It would seem the class D would be better suited for those complex loads but would we worth testing
@clicks59
@clicks59 Год назад
Hey Dave, Would if those class D amps were driving a sub or a bass cabinet? I have class A/B GK bass head and an Acoustic Image class D amp. I have run them through the same 8 ohm cabinet. It seems the GK has tons more headroom, especially when I am playing on the Low B. Any thoughts? Thanks for the cool video. I purchased the Riarosa tune after watching one of your other videos. Great song and performance!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
For bass you want more continuous power so class ab performs well. But, getting big class D can still out perform the class ab for less weight and size. You just need a bigger class D amp if you're going to go that way but one that's still lighter than the class a B
@clicks59
@clicks59 Год назад
@@DaveRat Thanks Dave. Good information. Despite the weight of the GK, I still like it’s tone shaping qualities more than the Acoustic Image amp. Modern Technology is a good thing!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
So many variables and yeas, for a bass amp I would thing conventional would be more desirable. Better overload character as well
@liarschair10
@liarschair10 Год назад
Dave is the bomb! I love watching his stuff!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
💣🤙🤙🤙
@bms13
@bms13 Год назад
Thanks for this great A/B comparison. Can you comment how the different amps handle the load of a real crossover + modern drivers vs the resistive voltage divider for this video? Maybe no one uses passive crossovers in pro audio anymore 😂
@peniku8
@peniku8 Год назад
Powersoft can do energy recycling from reactive loads (idk if all amps but the only I ordered does), so you'll get more power out of the amp than on a purely resistive load. Keep in mind that real power delivered to the speakers will be lower than apparent power (V*I). Some amps might get unstable at various low impedance/weird angle loads, but idk much about that since nobody really tests that and I haven't seen much data on that.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes, I will ponder a test for that
@RWL2012
@RWL2012 Год назад
A/B comparison lol
@jdrissel
@jdrissel 7 месяцев назад
Any possibility of getting a lossless audio version of this? I would break out my good cans and a DAC to listen carefully. I thought I could hear some differences in the midrange but having RU-vid in the audio path is only a little better than kite string and soup cans... I really wish they would allow those of us who pay for it to hear and see the full uploaded signal. Even 4k gets less color resolution than the camera likely recorded - I sure can see a and hear the difference between the local file and what RU-vid streams back to me even for 4k captured on my phone with its tiny sensor and tiny mems mics. How much more is lost when a real video camera and real microphones are used? The audio difference is huge because I can hear it even over Bluetooth (though I have to be on LDAC to hear it over Bluetooth). This makes me think that RU-vid is cutting audio quality down to at best APT-X HD quality.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat 7 месяцев назад
That's the kind of thing that I post for channel members on the channel member Telegram account. I've got other files related to videos that I've posted there and if I get an ask from that side I would gladly post it
@sim82
@sim82 Год назад
what would happen if you run the same signal through all four channels of the Powersoft amp? Would the highly correlated peaks in the signal hit the overall power limit quicker? I'd assume that part of the calculation with the modern amps is that the signals are not uniform (e.g. delays being used on some channels)
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Here is the data sheet. I trust PowerSoft to release accurate data as they have always tested to spec and I know the designer Claudio. Look at the symmetrical and asymmetrical power specs to see how it performs with multiple channels driven www.powersoft.com/wp-content/uploads/datasheet/PS_TSeries_DS_EN.pdf
@sim82
@sim82 Год назад
@@DaveRat Thanks for pointing out that detail!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@davidkent2804
@davidkent2804 Год назад
I wonder if the extra dynamic range helps or hurts heavily electronic material as compared to acoustic. Clearly, it enhances vocal and instrumental music.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Having enough dynamic range is important. Anything that exceeds the capability of an older amp tends to manifest as clipping which is undesirable. That said having an amp that too much exceeds the speaker capabilities can result in damage to the speaker or undesirable sounds from the speaker. In general a class D app can offer more power, less weight, generate less heat, draw less power from the wall, while being smaller and outputting the same or more energy than conventional older amps
@JeyGifford
@JeyGifford Год назад
Thanks for the video Dave. So, since it takes 10dB to double volume, but you only get 3dB per doubling of watts, then it’s sort of a logarithmic scale? 3 1/3 X watts is 2X volume?
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
3db double watts, 6db 4x watts 10 db is 10 x the watts and 20 db is 100x the watts 10db is said to 2x the perceived volume level. Or 10x the watts to double the perceived Volume
@JeyGifford
@JeyGifford Год назад
@@DaveRat ohhhhh. I missed that detail. I would be really interested to learn how we measure perceived volume.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yeah, I am not convinced it is as simple as they say. Adding 3 db to a system running 115db sounds significant and adding 3 db to a system running 90 db sounds irrelevant
@TimpBizkit
@TimpBizkit Год назад
@@DaveRat also frequency. Going from background dinner levels to cleaning levels I notice a significant increase in bass, so at least initially the bass grows louder first, though it levels off at very high volumes and is overtaken by the rest of the sound. Perhaps it's the level of tactile feel increases faster than the loudness of the tone due to the increased energy beyond the rate of increasing loudness. Although I tend to think those frequencies around 3kHz get louder the fastest. Adding 10dB to a 3kHz note sounds a much bigger change than adding it to 150Hz. The fletcher munson loudness curves are an interesting look up.
@DeadKoby
@DeadKoby Год назад
Personally, I like the Class AB amps better, BUT I can understand why the Class D amps are popular. If you've got a BIG rig, it's much less mass to move around.
@ANATURALDREWSASTER
@ANATURALDREWSASTER Год назад
Efficiency as well I think. Large class D amplifier clusters can get louder for the same power consumed vs class AB.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
They each have their advantages. Crusty amps can deliver really beautiful fast transience at very high levels and can also struggle with long extended bass notes. Class a B can sound smoother but they tend to fart and you need a lot of back muscle to move them around, they generate a lot of heat and use up a lot of power from the wall
@meandmyarrow
@meandmyarrow Год назад
It would be interesting with your demo music to measure dB in the room at the edge of clipping with the 2 amps (with your dummy load setup, running into another amp/speaker).
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
The dummy load was running directly into a speaker and there wasn't really a need for an amp. You can just put a speaker across part of the load and the speaker will play the voltage drop that's showing on that load. So that's pretty much what you heard in the video
@meandmyarrow
@meandmyarrow Год назад
Ok I grabbed 2 sections of audio from the video with music playing through the 2 amps (not ideal with RU-vid but worth a shot). Looks like about 7dB difference over the sections. Does that sound about right?
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes that sounds about right. The Crest amp puts out 400 watts and I was running it right near clip and the power soft amp puts out around 1600 Watts which is 4 times the power which is 60b.
@stevendenmon9557
@stevendenmon9557 Год назад
I understand the peak power and music duration. Question asking is how, dose the two work together? I’m thinking about a driver. The response of peak power handling. Is the powersoft continuous in control of the two or the driver?
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
The signal tells the amp what to do, the amp then tries to send it and the speaker then tried to do it. All is good until the signal exceeds the amp's capability to deliver. And amp with more peak capability will deliver the peaks, and amp without the peak capability will clip/distort. Same thing sort of with continuos except the powersoft amp has built in protection so it will never clip or distort, it just turns down things that are too much to deliver
@stevendenmon9557
@stevendenmon9557 Год назад
Thanks. Didn’t know the body of the 3 paragraphs. That’s an ah ha moment. 🔊😁
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Awesome!!
@CABohol
@CABohol Год назад
The waveform of crest amp is nice, I'm still a fan of old topology amp like Class AB or Class H. I built a DIY Class D amp before with infineon chip but the high frequency response is very harsh unlike the old school class AB the response is very clear.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
For home hifi, the fan less class ab is the way to go. If you need to move or transport it, or it needs to be small ao draw less power, class D all the way
@CABohol
@CABohol Год назад
@@DaveRat true, class d is for outdoor use for its efficiency and weight.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
👍🤙🤙
@Bill_N_ATX
@Bill_N_ATX Год назад
It’s amazing the technology that has brought us these lightweight but powerful amplifiers. In the old days, amplifier manufacturers built huge power supplies so that the output devices had ample clean power available on their power rails. Then along came switching power supplies and their fast, clean, and efficient ICs that made huge heavy transformers and capacitors unnecessary. Finally, someone made the intellectual leap to in effect just modulate the power supply and the modern amplifier was born. I don’t think they sound as good for critical listening but hell a lot of modern music sounds like bad distortion and audio processing artifacts to begin with. So, I’ll still be over here with a nice warm sounding tube amp with the kinds of distortion I like and the kids can use the type they like and we will all be happy. All kidding aside, having humped more than a few old Flame Linear, Crown, and “modern” QSCs, the new amps are awesome. Not only are they lighter and much more dense, they take a fraction of the power supply. Add in the swap to modern lighting with moving effects, color swaps , and LEDs, you don’t need to run the massive cables to a couple thousand amps of 208 for lighting and a 100 plus amps for sound in an arena gig. Much less hang thousand of par cans. Vari-light won.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@JRo250
@JRo250 Год назад
Bottom line first: music is not about how loud you sound, it's how good you sound, loud. The main difference between these two amps is the amount of snake oil used by their respective marketing departments. Lookup the Crest PDF manual and you'll see fully disclosed technical details. In the manual, Crest will teach you the theory behind their design, how and why things work like they do, and show you in depth troubleshooting procedures (including schematics). The other amp has a bunch of asterisks showing what they *really* meant with their quoted figures.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
As a close friend of the Claudio Lastrucci, look him up, who is the designer for PowerSoft, holds many patents and is an absolutely brilliant innovator, I can say that there is no snake oil involved with the powersoft designs. I've learned much from him and one of the challenges with amp design is helping people understand that they don't need a dump truck to run an F1 race. The concept that an amp must have the capability of delivering full power continuously over long periods of time in order to reproduce a signal that has a four to one or 10 to 1 peak to average ratio, is a challenge indeed. That said I too love old boat anchor poweramps for their posterity, simplicity and coolness. And also know that having switched from those boat anchor poweramps to modern class D apps we have seen astronomical improvements in sound quality, amazing reductions in weight and size, reduced power draw, reduced heat generation, increased reliability, improved sound quality and the ability to reproduce much higher volume levels than we were able to before. For a deployment like we do when supplying sound for Coachella where we have over 800 large format boxes and well over a million watts of power, it's incomprehensible in this day and age to deploy older format amps. As you may or may not know, All the top world class sound systems for concerts events and festivals all use Class D amps at this point in time with the exception of a few esoteric EDM companies that have cool sound systems powered by older amps
@JRo250
@JRo250 Год назад
@@DaveRat I'm sure the designer is brilliant. It's their marketing department calling it a 6kW amp that are not. I mean, it could be, for a millisecond, and so can many other amps.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
I don't think you can draw such a distinct line. The statement that the amp does not deliver 6,000 watts is an incorrect statement. The question is time frame. Perhaps using a car analogy may be helpful. If a dragster can't travel a hundred miles at its top speed is its top speed not valid, Even though it can reach the speed and it can be measured? Or is the only valid speed for a dragster the speed at which it can maintain for an extended period of time even though that is not how the dragster would ever be used? Since amplifiers tend to reproduce music which has short period bursts and are rarely used for long-term continuous signals, why would we hold the long-term continuous signal spec to be the valid spec rather than the short-term burst spec? That said not all short-term power specs are not equal and some manufacturers use very short periods of time while others use longer periods of time and there can be drastic sonic differences between the two. My experience is that powersoft does a very good job of using realistic parameters. And this is the crux of the test I did here. The amp claims to have 6 db more output power, and the test shows that it is 6 db louder and a conventional amp using music
@JRo250
@JRo250 Год назад
@@DaveRat >The question is time frame. = which is exactly what I said. You can deliver a lot more power given a short enough time. The Crest will deliver it's claimed power all day long and will have headroom to handle peaks beyond that. I'm sure the other amp is great, just not at 6K Watts. The IEC C20 inlet connector on the amp is spec'd to 20A. The amp can operate from 90-250VAC input, but even at 250V@20A, that's 5kW. You can't output 6,400W for very long with a 5kW input. I appreciate the analogy and the rest of the comment.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
And yet the PowerSoft amp is 6db louder with music than the 400 watt crest.. so the music is playing at 1600 Watts but not 1600 watts? Hmmm The Crest hand no more output at 8 ohms without clipping as ithe 400 watts matched it's supply voltage. But yes, at 4 and 2 ohms, the crest had has additional peak power to offer
@richardbelisle4807
@richardbelisle4807 Год назад
Your a lot of fun Dave….
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Awesome thank you
@TheMaddoxfam
@TheMaddoxfam Год назад
I loved watching the experiment but you never did a peak measurement for the crest, only the power soft. What does that crest spike at? When I did training for installed sound systems we were always told that a “good“ amplifier has a peak of at least double RMS.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
At 8 ohms the crest continuous measurement and peak measurement were the same because the 400 watts into 8 ohms matched its power supply voltage. At four ohms and two ohms the crust had additional power capabilities When I did the peak power test I brought both amps to clipping in the same manner so we saw the peak power of both amps
@TheMaddoxfam
@TheMaddoxfam Год назад
@@DaveRat that’s what I was looking for, I missed that. Thanks!
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
That said you bring up a great point, at four ohms and two ohms the voltage supply rails of the crest remain the same because the voltage rails are the same. So the theoretical peak power limit of the crest is 800 w per channel at 4 ohms and 1600 w per channel at 2 ohms. At those lower impedances the output of the crest is more similar to the power soft and that it can deliver much higher power than its RMS rating for short periods of time.
@TimKaseyMythHealer
@TimKaseyMythHealer Год назад
Based on what your saying about peak power (not average power) the peak power will help a kick drum to thump better. I guess you can factor this into how you purchase a sub speaker power amp. I’ve always ignored it, but considering how a kick drum is only 50 to 60ms in duration. If the peak power is 2k watts, that would be something that should be considered when purchasing a sub speaker power amp.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes the peak power rating if it lasts long enough duration is the rating that matters. That said, if it only lasts 100 milliseconds it's not going to work as well as an amp that has a peak power rating that lasts 250 to 350 milliseconds. Also for long extended bass notes the continuous power rating of a higher level can be useful
@StephenTack
@StephenTack Год назад
Fun test! IIRC Powersoft amps also have supply power sharing between channels. Would that mean that to get the most total output from them you would send each amp's four channels material that didn't peak at the same time? So maybe mids/highs and subs or differently delayed fills/subs on individual channels of one amp? Instead of putting multiple identical subwoofers on one amp. Maybe even just pairing a more power hungry output (subwoofer) with a less demanding output (monitor/fill) could enable more power to be continuously allocated to the demanding output? Does this jive? Also (at least sone) Powersoft amps can run on 240V mains, and the manual says they run a bit cooler at higher input voltage. Have you seen benefits in this arena? I did one installation with Powersoft amps and used 208V power, cause it was readily available, and "why not?" It only cost some NEMA L6 cables.
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes we run amps on 208 or 240 regularly. We run three phase to all our amp racks. Power sharing and harvesting back EMF into the power supply is common amongst power soft amps. In this demo since I only used one channel it demonstrated the maximum power. I do know that the limiting factor on the T-Series amplifiers is the power supply and with a bigger power supply it would be able to supply even more output. If memory serves, I recall powersoft telling me that the duration of the peak power is increased with a higher AC input voltage
@zbx909
@zbx909 Год назад
that's exactly how these amps and other modern 4ch amps (e.g. lab fp10000q) are made to be used ;) their individual channel capability far exeeds that of their psu for all channels. But it's the ideal solution for small setups (e.g. 2 subs, 2 tops) or larger active multiway systems per side (e.g. sub/mid/hi/fill). also no one is playing pure sines, average crest factor for music is 12db+, so it becomes all about pumping out the peaks, not sustained load (except maybe subs in heavily compressed eectronic music) for full throttle sub uses there are beasts like the x4l
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
🤙👍🤙
@kyle_neuron
@kyle_neuron Год назад
It's really fun when you use the Powersoft X series in the EU, where they hook directly to 415V 3ph mains 😎
@DaveRat
@DaveRat Год назад
Yes!