This one looks like it may end up a tad clumpy on my lashes. A lash primer could possibly make the most out of this mascara, but that’s too many steps for me. Lol. I would recommend the Tartelette Tubing Mascara. Tarte has a great sale directly on their website. They have a set listed that comes with a Maracuja Lip Plump Shimmer Glass AND a Tubing mascara! Thanks for the honest review.