'That was a BUTCHERING of the highest order' - How did things go so wrong for Carlton? I Fox Footy 

Carlton had a 25 point lead with 15 minutes left in the 4th... Collingwood is the epitome of "it's not over until its over"

They say Carlton have made strides forward, yet they bottle the games that matter most, what is it they lost their last 4 in a row? Up 20 in the 4th v Collingwood and lose? That's not Progress, that's Carlton being Carlton.

Speaking as someone who hates both teams and is therefore unbiased, that was a dead-set thriller.

I work in an underground mine. One of my mates at work got a message over the radio that Carlton were up by 24 points at three quarter time. Driving out of the mine, he thought they were finals bound. Spare a thought for my mate Jason

I don't even follow Collingwood and I still get overwhelming joy from watching this!

That Durdin kick is the dumbest thing I've seen in football.

Post round 10 Carlton were $1 to make finals. Bottled it. The whole season. Clearances mean nothing when you bomb kicks like Cripps does from the centre. Means nothing.

I am speaking from a neutral position and I thought Collingwoods foward entries were sloppy in the first half.I thought their sloppy disposal kept Carlton in the game.

Only needed a point to draw but Cripps tried to barge his way through the pack when a handball into the open could have given them half a chance instead of holding the ball and turning it over. That wasted kick into forward pocket was heartbreaking to watch when a kick into the goal square may have been forced through for a point. Did no one tell them a draw would have been enough. Carlton lost the game rather than Collingwood winning it, but bloody hell Collingwood deserved the win they were sensational.

Outcoached and outsmarted when it really mattered.

If Carlton believe this was a succesful year then they are delusional. 3 extra wins than last year and another finish outside of the eight. How many more coachs and how many more rebuilds must we endure.

Carlton missing finals from 8-2 is unforgivable

Stats are good for supercoach.....

Kingy spot on. That peel off man leaky defense drives me mad, was how we play amateur footy.

Seeing SOS cry has made my year. Go Pies

As a neutral, watching Carlton celebrate like they were winning a premiership…only to collapse like this, was immensely satisfying

Earlier in the season , I always knew Carlton's ability to let sides back into a game would come back to bite them when it mattered most. Something to build upon next year - they have everything in place to be a good side. I doubt they would have won it from eighth spot anyway.

You have to remember carlton had a defence of plowman and durdin at one stage. Literally wouldn’t even get into norths vfl those players. Compared to last season this is a massive improvement

The turning point was when Cripps took a clean mark in front of goal, but it was overturned because the Umpires didn't see Silvagni pushed into a Pies player and the Umpires called blocking....Bullshit. That would have put Carlton back out to a 5 goal lead but the Pies went up the other end and kicked a goal. 12 point turnaround. The Blues will come back bigger and better in 2023, watch out.

Not team oriented enough. Just look at all those easy short passes they did not take in the last quarter in the forward line. They don't take the correct easy team option and then they kick it to a opposition player or a pack. To many individuals. A champion team will beat a team of champions, Richmond proved that. Carlton is not a team of champions so they need to work really hard on being a champion team. Does it reflect the culture of the Carlton football club. I bet it does.

Fucken disgusting umpiring. Carlton deserved to lose that game, but the umpire that doesn’t blow the whistle for Moore falling on McKays back should also be out of finals. Can’t be accepted.

great analysis

As a Saint's supporter pain is in my immune system, if that was St.kilda going out today, no problem business as usual. They finished up 10th my immune system wasn't even needed to kill any pain remnants.

It was 24 scoring shots to 20! Carlton kicked zero goals 9 behinds in two quarters and kicked 8 goals 3 behinds in the third quarter to 1 goal 2 behinds. Also Carlton had 65 inside 50s to 44, So the wobbles were lucky.

Elliot's been farking us over for 20 years.

Whether Carlton finished 8th or not doesn't matter much for this season, but it heaps so much pressure on them for next season. If bad luck strikes and they somehow miss out again next year what will the Carlton board do? Knowing them they'll probably sack Voss and hire Lyon lol

This ones for Wayne Harmes, take that ya bum.

Were Carlton arrogant enough to believe they could play finals from 9th position twice in a decade.

Last time it happened was 2013 when Essendon was removed. That year.... Carlton replaced Essendon.

Luke Sayers after Carlton kicked David Teague to the curb: With this playing list, Carlton should make the Finals series in 2022. Urinatingtree: Conglaturations Carlton, you missed out on the Finals by 0.6% to the Western Bulldogs. Close, but never close enough. What a choke job.

Let's all take note of how EVERYONE talks about Coll/Carl games. It's like the rest don't matter . That's the influence the mighty magpies have on everyone. You just have to talk about them folks .

Nothing warms my heart more than seeing the look on those Carlton fans when the final siren went. Sack the coach, time for another rebuild boys 😂😂

Just like the last 10 years + not good enough no guts and no mongrel we keep believing in this group but it’s a clear message we are not good enough Coleman medals is for individuals No toughness to be knocked out by a rival club that only played for a top 4 finish we can’t even finish the season with 1 final game Carlton is no threat to any team anymore there’s no culture left at the club Voss and Hamill are not your answers at Carlton we need a self level headed teacher that knows how to prepare young boys into men and simplify the game plan Ross Lyon is a mentor and a great coach for the young The next 6 months is just another reflection in the mirror of what I could I have done better for my teammates Believe in this group going no where

i wonder how drunk i would get if i drank everytime someone mentions the corridor

Leigh Montagna in the same seat where he hated on Jack Ginnivan all year failing to reflect on Kim Duthie - hypocrite

Carlton choked against Adelaide 3 weeks ago, away from home, to be fair, but that set them up in a negative mindset to predictably lose to Brisbane and Melbourne, which set them up to choke and give away a 20 point lead and miss out on the finals. You have to feel for them, they have some great players in their team, but they needed a big game player to step up and lead in just one of those last 4 games and nobody did.

Oof that's some grim footage. 2 weeks in a row just enormous mistakes to lose the games. Have to be the dumbest quarter of football I've ever seen

losing to the crows cost them

As a neutral yes, Carlton butchered it!

They have been showing signs but still inconsistent Carlton will only grow from this looking forward to the next few weeks

Apparently its still hurting them cause they r playing poorly

Carlton should not be too hard on themselves, they lost close games, against last years premier, and positions 2 and 4 on the ladder, while finishing ninth. Collingwood have won how many now by very close margins, against lowly sides. Carlton are not far off the mark. A solid player or two, and a years further development. And they will probably be a top four contender.

When the pressure is there to win the game carlton make simple mistakes because they dont play with football smarts, they dont handle the pressure well.

Herr Voss - Um , um um um um um um um after match

Wait! We thought Rutten's treatment by Essendon was the highest order of butchering? The media have become such drama queens in search of their clickbait.

2023 . After that end of a season ....pfft they fail when playing quality sides. Carlton are Show Pony's.

What’s better, Carlton losing by 10 goals or a point....or .6 percent, all are good.

Collingwood = Efficiency

All very well,but you’ve gotta put it thru the big sticks, right?

I remember 1977 pretty clearly, 1978 we won a final and finished 4th. Lost to Collingwood in the First semi Final. Then we dominated for the next 4 years winning 3 flags and were not far off in 1980 as well. I am upset now but know our best is ahead of us. This will hurt but what doesn't kill ya makes ya stronger.I think they will turn it around next year.

Pies go out in straight sets

How does the song go The team that never lets you down bullshit

28 years and counting

The umpires brought them back in the 3rd..50m penalties cerra got pinned holding dropping the ball and he got a freekick and kicked a goal no one talks about that. Umpire put the whistle away in the 4th and collingwood won simple as that

The biggest butchers of the game were the umpires and Collingwood received the choicest cuts.

We might not have played at our best. What all you Collingwood haters are forgetting is the Pies were all over Carlton for 3 of the 4 quarters.

Who cares. So they missed out. Well teams have faced that for decades. Grow a pair and get over it. If a team is good enough it wins, if not, they lose. Better luck next time.

I woulda backed brayden maynard for best on i reckon.

Durdin

They're too hard on Carlton. They're a young side, still learning their craft, were struggling last year. They'll learn from it and be better for it. They don't know what they don't know. If you want to point fingers, maybe look at the coaching staff for not training and directing them for these clutch moments.

yes Carlton have been Dumb

What is great in footy?

Pfft.. imagine if the pies put this effort in against the swans.. lol..

hahaha pretty funny hey. The blues blew it (again)

A couple copying another commentator ? Check out Robbo. lol

Of course it was a free kick to Harry, not maybe! That aside, Carlton and its coaching panel were hopeless in letting this game slip because of poor intellect, structure and composure! Collingwood will go out in straight sets because the quality now in Finals will not make these basic fundamental errors!

Carlton were never as good as they thought they were. Their fans were carrying on like they won the flag back in April! Still an incredibly limited side when you're giving a massive spud like Jack Silvagni regular games. They've overpaid a lot of players over the years to join them too and their cap space is very tight. Looking like they will be another middle of the road side for the next few seasons as a result.

Carlton’s choke is a classic example of why Collingwood are a faux and why Geelong will pummel them first week. 104% just speaks of an average team. North Melbourne inexperience and inability to put Collingwood away when given the chance or Carlton inability to ice the game or Essendon inability to defend the last 20 seconds are examples of chokes, not because Collingwood are world beaters. Lose these 3 games and Collingwood are the ones missing finals. Collingwood wins against Melbourne were impressive, let me preface by saying this. They have had our measure and just like how we match up against Brisbane, Collingwood match up on us extremely well, so taking nothing away from what they have actually achieved to this point. Carlton handed them the win, Collingwood didn’t win it.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Micheal Tosser

The last time Carlton were in finals was in 77 mate hahah

Carlton has some great players but still too many fillers it’s a below average team. As a Carlton supporter I don’t like Voss he was no good as Brisbane coach and now here at Carlton where he doesn’t belong.

Carlton should just leave the AFL and join the VFL :D

3 men on a panel ? Disgraceful . Get a female on the panel .

Hate both teams, But Collingwood won the lottery, not the game, Carlton was robbed by Rafferty rules

And the Lady blues persist in playing SilVAGni.