The AI Music Situation is Insane 

I just want to be able to open a google doc in word and vice versa without the formatting getting messed up. And yet, here we are lol.

There was an anime about this on Netflix about 2 years ago. It's called Carol and Tuesday. And it's about two young kids that live on Mars trying to make music together in a world dominated by almost entirely AI generated music

I just came back from Lisbon Portugal and had dinner at a Fado music restaurant situated in an old 16th century vaulted house with great acoustics. No microphones, no amps, only acoustic guitars and voices. Beautiful live performance. And now seeing this video l have a lot more appreciation for music created by a group of human beings. Even with AI music, live music will always be there for us.

As a pilot I constantly worry about automation taking my career. Never did I think that basically every other job would be under attack before mine lol, we're so fucked.

I'm a music teacher at a high school, and a couple weeks ago a friend of mine showed me suno and asked my opinion. As I don't think it's the greatest thing in the world, I dove right in and I'm using it in the classroom. I use it for ear training and modern band ensembles. I, or my students, generate a song and then we try to replicate ourselves on our instruments and voices. We are finding it a lot of fun and a good ear training tool.

I really wish you’d reconsider making more music this year. I know I’m not alone in this request. The reason I subscribed to you, and became a Patreon supporter, is that I love to see you so passionate about music, and I love the music you create. Watching the pure joy you express when you’re really into a piece of music brings me joy.

Music sounded like AI for about a decade before AI

love this type of content, looking forward to more of this

I went and played with it a bit and it's scary how decent it is. Like, not good enough to make a masterpiece, but if someone wanted they could definitely generate a song and cover it, fixing any issues in the process, to make it their own.

This is how I felt about AI art too, as in visual art/digital drawing/painting. I spent years practising things like tone, light and shadow, composition, colour theory and anatomy and was happy with what I was making but dropped the habit for a while. I was considering picking it back up again when AI art started becoming a thing. Seeing all the incredible human-looking art it could make just sapped the motivation right out of me.

This whole situation reminds me of the line from the villain in the Incredables: "When everybody's super, no-one will be" It's a tool that allows any talentless person to "make" a song or a painting, taking away the superpower that artists have.

Great video, wouldn't mind other deep dives in the future!

Udio is INSANE. Didn't think there would be such an evolution so quickly after Suno V3

This is wild. On one hand, I have lyrics that I'd love to turn into songs even though I don't have the access/money for studio time or equipment. On the other hand, as others in the comments are saying, I find it upsetting that as a society we could benefit from so many quality of life upgrades that make soulless work easier or unnecessary, but we are instead outsourcing the parts of the human experience that would provide jobs that are better for our mental health. Seems like a huge misallocation of technology.

Great overview thanks!

Really good video, need more of these deep dives

I'm glad I've spent half of my life learning music production...

28:21 can't help but love Joel's intros in the middle of the video lol

I hate it when these AI companies say their shit is meant to aid artists. Aid artists in doing what? Making music? The AI can just do that. You’re not gonna make something that does the job of hundreds of people in 3 seconds and call it a “tool”. All of their language feels incredibly condescending. Like, “once you get better at it, it won’t be so scary!” I’m not scared because I suck at writing a three sentence prompt into a textbox, I’m scared because all I have to do is write a three sentence prompt into a textbox to get artificially generated music that’s indistinguishable from the real shit. The whole point of art is that making it can be just as fun as experiencing it. I want to be more than just a wagey consumer for the rest of my life. As if putting creativity behind a paywall is democratizing art, when realistically nothing was stopping you from going out and making art yourself besides your own work ethic.

this makes me so afraid of the future, as someone who dedicated so many years of my life studying music production, its just so scary to think that maybe I just wasted all of this time. I feel truly sad about this.

I make music. I have spent years learning instruments and playing with other people, to be able to make music. I've watched hours on hours of tutorials and have had classes on how to produce music. How to use an EQ, how to properly compress, how to cut out bad frequencies and create bigger or smaller soundscapes. I have made fun songs, and I have made sad songs. And especially, I have made some really really bad songs. I have also gotten to meet wonderful people, that I have worked with and connected with through music. I rarely release anything, since I mostly make music for myself and my friends/family. But have made funny passion projects with people before, little songs and albums of just us having fun playing around. And I kinda think it sucks that all of these people I know, that have spent so much of their lives studying and working on something they love. Might no longer be needed. But tbf, thats how technology works. "The man made the synth and now who needs a band" some people said, as it could replace most parts of an orchestra or normal band arrangement. And the bands are still around. And so is the orchestras. So hypothetically speaking we might just be fine. Anyway, Im off to start study economics after the summer, so I guess I have to put my passion to the side nevertheless. But damn does it hurt a bit to have spent so much time working on something that just might die out in the end. And to all fellow musicians reading this. Keep up the good work ;)

"Bridge Over Troubled Water" is a beautiful song without any context. But it has so much extra meaning and layers if you know the history. You're listening to a song about being unquestioningly present for a loved one, with lyrics written by a man during a time when he felt he was being undervalued and abandoned by a friend who was supposed to be building something important together. Then the vocals are sung by that very friend who was doing the perceived abandoning, literally taking Paul Simon's voice away and getting applause for it. Powerful stuff. Music gets it's longevity from the human stories we connect to it, whether those are the personal stories of the listener or the stories of the writers. Hell, look at Fleatwood Mac's whole Rumors album, lol I don't think real art will be as impacted as we think, but a lot of filler pop will certainly suffer. I mostly feel bad for up and commers who were already dealing with a digitally saturated market being even more lost in the sauce than before.

You are still indescribable from anything but you. Its still a greatly awesome to see you like to do what you do. You been made for it and you been a inspiration for sure.

great video very informative

AI was supposed to do the boring and tedious tasks, not the fun ones. I'm scared Edit: please stop commenting lol, there's almost 90 of them you can't have anything else to say right? Edit 2: I SAID STOP WTH 😭

Imagine how i feel. Im studying to become an accountant. My job will be gone by the time i leave college.

Is it me or does a lot of the A. I. Vocal sound like something you've already heard before??? I'm getting that vibe a lot.

its the same in the art community (and in alot of other types of arts as well), like im seeing people posting their super rendered art just to get someone say its ai when its not. it also made me think "whats the point in trying hard" but at the end of the day art is way more than a product, its about the connection of the one who made it and the one who see it. just like you said tho, it gives us this 'aha moment' where we start to look for things that ai cant do and so thats gonna be fun to see whats thats gonna be like ig.

As a wise man once said "and when everyone's super ... no one will be"

when i heard the "face melting guitar solo". my first reaction as a guitarist was: "there is so much potential to learn from that". My gut feeling feels very intimidated, however i think there is a lot of possibility to grow as a musician from it. AI could show so many unseen and unknown to play a certain riff or a certain solo in the future. i could definitly see how it could be tool to grow from personally. besides this whole argument. i think there will always be a need for people to play music together, or to go to live events with real people playing. maybe this wil grow into a big niché for people that realise the true potential of music. in that is to bring people together. I think a big part of music listeners will feel find a feeling of meaninglessness, those people will find the ways music brings people together.

1:05 "who is to say that this is not real music?" oh, idk, maybe THE ABSENCE OF HUMAN SOUL

I don't want to listen to a generic music made by robots. Part of the reasons why music is touching or relatable is the fact that there is a real human thought, experiences and memories behind it. To me part of the reason why some songs are so impressive is that I'm in awe of someone's amazing vocals or skills in playing instruments or that the lyrics are so touching/relatable/clever. When it comes to art, I still want to hear and see what all humans can create with their own personality, intelligence, emotions, hands, vocals chords etc. AI can't experience life and therefore can't have real memories and those are the things that gives the soul to the art. I also still want to see live concerts with living breathing artists, so that's something AI can't replace. I hope that the geniuses creating AI would use their efforts and energy to solve problems in this world rather than trying to completely replace human connection from the art. I mean it is a great tool for music making to a certain extent, but what is the point in totally replacing musicians. And in my opinion there should be some payment given for the artist whose voice has been used to make a model. It feels like it's kinda like stealing part of someone's identity idk... I hope u won't stop making music, I already got excited when u said that u want to make more music this year ❤️😊. And btw none of those two AI generated "so selfish" songs came even close to the original, which is so much more original and better! I hope AI makes musicians become more innovative as u mentioned and that artists won't give up. It would be nice if there was a way of knowing if the music is made by humans, 'cos that's what I will choose to listen. Sorry for the long comment 😅

As someone who is interested in history of art i found very appealing the fact that every piece of art (call it music, visual arts or any other) reflects the life experiences of the author, their personal beliefs, emotions, historical and political context even. There is always a message, a piece of themselves they are trying to communicate with the world, that is so personal yet universally understood and that´s why art resonates with us, it feels just scary to think it could be replaced with AI.

I tried out Suno with one of my lyrics, wrote Rock, inspired of Dead By April, my mind is BLOWN. It gave me the ide for the song that was already in the back of my head, but now I heard it out loud, and now inspiration has taken control and a new song with the band is on its way. I see it like a ide, mind bump to give you a little inspiration to make great and catchy song ;)

Still playing around with them a bit, but with smart prompting, I feel like you have more control with Suno, especially with less common genres/hybrid genres which udio's been seeming to struggle a lot with.

Great video Roomie! I think the key here is that whatever music is used in the Ai's learning model, the creators of that music must "opt-in" for ai learning. Very much how Adobe Firefly models of the Adobe Stock library, all contibuters to Adobe Stock must opt-in in order to sell on Adobe.

While other advancements in technology we had so far were more geared towards replacing manual labour, or hard to perform by humans tasks, the AI revolution we are going through right now is so scary because it threatens something we considered to be the most human expression, art, which is what humans always did to express feelings, human experiences, a way to see the world. It is a little scary, even as someone who only consumes art.

They're all so good. Each one makes me smile, even the ones i've tried making so far.

Great video and introspection on the subject. I am learning guitar. I’m almost 38 and I work in engineering. My office has about 320 people in it and I’m our AI subject matter expert. My mom taught music for ~45 years. This stuff is both fascinating and terrifying!

Off topic, but i really like this more toned-down, mature side of you! Would love to see more of it in future videos

One thing I noticed browsing around Suno was that the best songs were the ones that clearly had hand-crafted lyrics. This is an obvious enough statement considering that ChatGPT kind of trash at songwriting. But one thing of note about this, and you can consider this a silver lining, is that these songs with good lyrics were probably made by people who had genuine songwriting talent but maybe didn't have all the other skills required to make a song. Tools like these helping people fill in those gaps and share creations that otherwise just wouldn't exist seems like a good thing to me, and points to a future where AI is a tool to empower human creators rather than replace them.

Well Done !

Ive tried both and I definitely like Suno more at the moment. Thats probably because I love long instrumental songs instead of lyric filled ones, (as you can see from my uploads). But I did have some success with udio. I agree with you that udio does a better job with the singing and the continuation of the song. (in Suno longer songs eventually build up a lot of errant noise and lose the intent behind the initial parts of the music). Even with that I like suno better because you can still somewhat control the direction of the song after you have started generating extended parts. Meanwhile Udio sticks with the first music prompts extremely tightly, so its much harder to "Drive" it than Suno.

It’s crazy how fast AI is developing, it’s scary to see as someone who wants to write their own music hopefully there will be a way to keep it from getting out of hand

That Carolina song you played at the start is absolutely outrageous. The inflections in the vocals were so realistic, i was googling trying to find evidence it was a real vocalist. The future is so sickening to think about, but i genuinely enjoyed that song.

There is already a tsunami of music coming out every day even without AI.

I think the easiest way to control the flooding of the market is that any song created on AI platforms are copyrighted to that platform. The platform then retains the distribution rights with the stem artist(s). Through "membership" to the platforms you can obtain the right to the song for youtube, spotify, itunes ect ect. When uploading your song(s) the platforms run a copyright check through these platforms.

that dial-up sound :))) where we've been and where we have reached!

Really really interesting video! I wonder if a kind of cooperative mode will be available. A human gives a prompt. Like a demo... The AI generates a song and gives not only the finished song, but also the instrument, harmonies, the possibility to export to different music programs The human can edit the melody and adapt the "demo" to something more unique. (Even if AI will be able to do this as well soon)

Tbh, I have a sneaking suspicion I understand how they developed Suno, and most contemporary generators of a similar type. I'm pretty sure they're a relatively standard Transformer model, but is simply quite large, trained on a huge amount of music, similar to how LLMs were scaled. I personally don't agree with that strategy, and I'm pretty sure that something like a symbolic AI (classical AI, not trained, but rather defined by the developer) model to determine the progression, and potentially some combination of symbolic / Transformers to determine the rhythm, emphasis, and individual note placements...Possibly with some form of LLM tool use to use existing production tools like quantization (as seen in music production, not LLMs) should be fairly performant, democratic, and not require a lot of training data (notably, not requiring data in the sense of requiring it for the "heart" or "soul", but mostly just needing it to finalize the styling on individual notes. This might be doable with just sample libraries, rather than training on music itself). Music is significantly more mathematic than art, and the structure of music should lend itself much more strongly to AI music generation, at least in my opinion from someone who understands Transformers and music. I do mean this in the sense that it's more suited on a technical level, not in the sense that it's more ethically suited to be generated by AI. So, I don't agree with their technical strategy, but beyond that, is there anything I disagree with in terms of the application itself? Personally, for me, the coolest uses of AI aren't prompting to get a product. For me, the coolest uses of AI are in using it to achieve new things that weren't possible before. One thing I've been kind of interested in is something like a "tracker" as you saw before the 2000s, where you could do a live recording with musicians, but the song could be adapted to the situation (ie: in a game), to shift the tonality such as changing the original recording's chords to a vi -> II instead of a vi -> ii in a more heroic fantasy situation. It's worth noting that with some form of cross attention with a traditional LLM (or even just an Encoder block) the soundtrack could have a very strong semantic understanding of the situation.

I’ve been trying these programs out a bit and they seem to be much better at making samples than songs, also prompts don’t have as much creative control as other ways, also if they make an entire song they need to create it with stems and allow you to open it in a daw to make adjustments

I‘m probavly not a classic example of a music consumer, I more or less exlusively listen to music from a hand full of artists/bands i already know every album of, I go to their live concerts and enjoy everything around the artists. I almost never listen to radio or random playlists, so I don‘t really see me change my music consumption habits of listening to my favourit artists:)

Btw, please continue making music if you feel like to do so. I‘m sure that there will still be many people who will love to listen to it, both because they like the song and because it‘s you who wrote and performed it.

First they came for the writers, then they came for the illustrators, and now they have come for the musicians. Game developers and film makers who support these tools right now should pick their words wisely…

This is not replacing artists. This is augmenting the way artists are able to create, democratizing art. Previously people who had an imagination but no means to express themselves are now able to express themselves. And artists who were able before have now a lot more leverage to express themselves. This is NOT a threat. This is the future.

I love music, musicians and every role that goes into making a song!! Music is amazing ❤ Another amazing thing is watching your favorite artist or band live. Hearing the difference from the studio to the stage. AI can never do that as well as real musicians do. But I do think this can do proper damage to the music industry overall, unfortunately. I hope it won’t though 😊

I must admit, when I first heard about song-writing camps that some artists essentially 'shop' from for their songs, I got much more into artists who write their own stuff entirely.

all music we make these days is ones and zeroes. we were always going to have to deal with this, BUT one thing i've done, is used it as a jump-off point for songs i want to write on my own if i have writers block. a lot of people think it's just easy to do, but if you want a quality piece, it takes awhile to get it right.

I was also using chat gpt song maker and it was SO helpful writing my own music. Definitely helps to bounce some ideas when I have no inspiration

I like using this suff to bounce ideas off of. Helps to get the ball rolling

Future AIs will flood the market and make it even less likely that I, as an indie artist, will ever earn money with my music. But no AI can take away my joy when I write a song and at a certain point in the process everything suddenly fits together and it sounds (more or less) like a song. I LOVE music! ❤🧡💛💚

you can make the model generate copyright lyrics without prompting the actual lyrics. , you give then the first part of the lyrics, id changed the odd word to make a parody song, but when i extended it, it generated some of the rest of the lyrics that i hadn't entered

In an alternate universe, AI is a fun novelty and tool for greater good (like spotting cancer cells), rather than replacing the jobs of artists with soulless garbage.

The point about photography is better compared to portraits, who used to be painted by painters.

I should train this AI with my voice and make me a singer! Dang I just tried it and I can use it to generate no copyrighted background music for my videos! Maybe I should read the terms of service first...

New sub here, cool video

You sir have now sent me on a wild rabbithole on this site that I had no idea existed. This stuff is WILD

i still remember the day more naturally sounding vocaloids were introduced. (half) a year later ai music got introduced to the mainstream. vocaloids/utau voicebanks were spoken by real people, are used like instruments(just like the ai voices) and thanks to tuning them you can make them sound more natural. now we have these ai voices, which is honestly a vocaloid but in extra steps. every "ai" music has existed before too, they weren't called ai until now tho. (SynthV = Synth Vocaloid) i'm conflicted About using ai. 2 things: 1) it isn't ai but is rather spitting out what you want. like how you train a dog to not shit inside the house. 2) as long as people are fine with being trained on, no problem - but we all know "ai"s were trained without permission. i hope both can exist side by side, because vocaloid has always existed, but seeing how they evolve like this with ai idiots feeling superior, it's a whole cringe festival. i have seen good use of ai music. i can understand the fear of jobs being taken away at the same time. that's why i hink having them side by side is a better solution. but it can end up the same way ai art is facing right now. some people are respectful, but so many are dumb and and just an ugh. the minus brains said "pencil is a slur for ai art artist". another reason why ai art is bad, but mainly bc are sh!t. people have been always the main reason why things are bad. it can be a good thing, if it weren't in the wrong hands nor trained on no-permission people. but _no_ of course not.

As a person with writing and music as my passion, I feel like my talent is not as precious anymore when anything can be generated by a Robot

honestly hopefully it will come back to live shows and community. As we disconnect in general to reconnect to eachother.

What's funny about the first song is that I've been recently listening to the Stamp song from Final Fantasy 7. It kinda reminded me of that.

Thank you for informing us!

This is scaaary man

Amazing 👍

@roomieofficial imho is right: AI can remix already existing styles, patterns, ... perhaps innovation beyond that will happen - I am thinking of contemporary Post- classical music with crazy effects, new instruments ...

I am very conflicted about AI in the arts. It is fun and scary. Music can make us feel. Music is a creative outlet for artists. Should I have an emotional connection to music that was created by a machine? I did play with Udio before this video and was able to come up with some interesting songs and I have no understanding of music. I don't want people to lose their jobs but the world changes and there is no going back. Confused, excited and terrified.

It's rather daunting. Auto Tune became not only a tool but a musical instrument in its own right. Time will tell.

As someone who grew up in the '70s, I would know instantly that the first one was not a song actually *from* the '70s because of the tonal qualities, especially the bass beats. But there are other nuances that give it away as well, which only someone who grew up around that music would hear. Still, it's scary that A.I. can "create" this stuff in a few seconds like that, and no doubt a lot of people would be fooled. Star Trek warned us about all this way back in 1968 with the M-5. We humans are all becoming Captain Dunsel.

I love it! There are so many song writers out there whose music IDs never heard. As an introvert song writer, I thoroughly enjoy hearing my lyrics come to life with the musical ensemble I could never personally gather. It’s h hard to find the music I want to hear out there. It’s either good lyrics and bad music or vice versa. I’m tired of hearing what the industry wants us to hear. Music with no depth and full of sexual innuendos. Gets redundant.

I'm pretty depressed by all of this. Idk what we're going to do for meaning if AI just colonizes everything we love

I understand you being discouraged by how good this technology has gotten, songwriting will be a challenging thing to be soon. I think that the future of human made music is linked to live performances, where talent and showmanship is still very much needed and appreciated.

A.I. music has been around for decades, they called it pop in the 90's...

Honestly, this made me more interested in music in general. And I can totally understand the worries, however, the level of control both AIs provide so far lean way more on the side of entertainment than commercial viability. It's fun to play around with prompts, but professional requests tend to be way more specific. But yeah, the cat's out of the bag and the effect on small musicians is undeniable.

Meme songs with Suno is so good. Been having a good laugh with my friends bringing back 2007 copypastas to life, LMAO.

I feel so bad rn. I used the Suno AI to just add a melody to theme song lyrics I kinda had sitting around in my head for a bit, and because I’m TERRIBLE, and I mean ABYSMAL at trying to come up with melodies, I just tried to see what the AI could come up with so that I could kinda come up with ideas. But the AI ended up creating the literal DEFINITION of what I was thinking of the whole time, the melody was perfect. But I’m so on the edge if I should just take the melody the AI made for me, repurpose it into my own, (such as playing actual instruments and in general tweaking it to my liking) and call it a day but it also feels so wrong…No matter how much I tweak it and physically play the melody with my own hands, at the end of the day I didn’t create the melody AT ALL, a machine did. It would feel so wrong and distasteful to “release it” (for context it’s a theme song for a project I’m making rn) and be like, “yea guys I did the lyrics and tweaked the melody but AI made it lolllll 🤪🤪!!” Like, there’s people who GENUINELY pour their heart and soul into making melodies and probably take a while even trying to come up with them, meanwhile someone like me, who has 0 EXPERIENCE/ knowledge in making music can just easily have a melody generated for me in 10 seconds? Idk man…I don’t know if I should RESTART and try coming up with my own melody which will probably never reach resolution due to prior evidence of me being terrible at making songs, or just use the AI’s melody…I need opinions from musicians, do you guys think this is ethical?

Actually I have to add something after hearing the frank sinatra estate signed that letter. Whenever i do see the AI mashup songs or meme songs of frank sinatra, i really enjoy them and sometimes it leads me to go click on officially licensed songs too! So it was like a free advertisement if anything after they generated at least my traffic on the official songs.

It's very telling that you can't put a specific musician's names in the prompt, but every AI image generator relies heavily on using artists' names in prompts to create a particular style.

AI in generation needs human input (to train on). It can't go way beyond as it generates in the same domain. So, creativity will still be very important. It just fights with people who themselves produce derivative music.

I'm fully against using AI for art/music, etc. But on the other hand, I've yet to hear a plausible solution that isn't just "ban AI"

It reminds me of the changes studio musicians, bands, orchestras etc had to experience when they were replaced by audio libraries... But I'm pretty sure live music will always have its own value.

I used to not care so much about the human story of/connection to the songs I listen to, partly because many of them weren't primarily written by the performer(s). but for the past few years, my favorite artists have been a band whose music is so heavily tied to _them._ they each have their own recognizable songwriting style. they have a song about dogs because the member who wrote it is scared of dogs but LOVES them. they have a song about rain because it frequently rains when they perform. one member wrote a song inspired by his fear of drowning. another wrote a song to say "I'm happy to see you again" to his best friend who had recently been discharged from the military. they have a song inspired by a crush one of the members had when he was like, FOUR. _a good chunk of their discography heavily references outer space and the band as a whole is now heavily associated with space simply because one of them loves space and just kept writing about it!_ a lot of people would be perfectly content with filling their playlists with AI generated music. heck, if copyright weren't an issue, I probably wouldn't mind listening to a few. but I've become _very_ attached to the human aspect of music in the last few years. I pay much more attention to who writes the songs I listen to, and what other songs they've written. a few years ago, I would have never said anything like "heck yea, a new song from that producer!" regardless of the performer. but I pay more attention now. and it's _fun._

The thing about creative humans is that they will still be driven to write poems, stories and draw, paint and create music. The experience of standing in front of a human being playing an instrument and singing songs created from their lived experience will become more valuable. We are at the start of our digital AI journey and we will work it out. The AI is recreating songs from existing samples. It is similar to my English classes when we were asked to write in the style of Shakespeare or Conan Doyle. It isn't reflective of the individual lived experience. This isn't creative it is mimicry. Humans will still want to have a singsong with guitars, ukeles etc at an outside event; watch orchestras at full throttle; enjoy a local band at the pub; and go to concerts to see talent live. Bob Dylan, Queen, Inxs, Eurythmics, Tina Turner: all fantastic experiences.

Here from your schmoyoho cover days...I'm noooot a wiiiiiiiiitch!

This also makes me think of the early 2000s when everything was boy bands and pop princesses, etc and then the White Stripes came along and we needed that breath of fresh air bare bones, blues based rock.

It will replace all of the restaurants and workplace music stations they have to pay for, they'll just have custom AI make music for the moment depending on the face scan of the person who's in the room. Creepy

“Cause you got baggage, I got room” BRUH why is that such a good line. As a self proclaimed tech guy my whole life, AI and wearable AR/VR are ushering in a new world that I wish didn’t exist.

I think that AI generated music is fun to play around with as a way to get inspiration or to shitpost (like that 1940's sounding song about Superglue), but I can definitely see a bunch of ethical and copyright concerns with passing off generated content as your own work.

So cool. I made One with my lyrics. It is fun. Thank you for sharing this. !!!

I never thought this would happen. Third comment on same video. You are a musical genius/treasure. So needed to keep the industry in check.

I love this for pre-production. Brainstorming, ideas, chopping and reassembling it all on the DAW as a sketch, to later rerecord it on a studio