The Aiki Dojo Podcast - Authenticity in Aikido  

Having recently revisited this episode, I'm compelled to share some reflections, particularly from my perspective as an Aikido teacher with over thirty years in the art. First, I commend your deep dive into the nuances of authenticity in Aikido. The distinction you make between "true" attacks and the pursuit of a more realistic Aikido practice is both intriguing and vital. In my experience, exploring diverse attack forms and theoretical applications in Aikido opens up a crucial dialogue about the essence of the art. This exploration raises a pivotal question: as we evolve the practice, at what point does it transform into a different discipline, and how does that shape our understanding and approach to Aikido? Moreover, the discussion on executing real attacks while maintaining a balanced level of intensity was particularly thought-provoking. It's a critical point that strong attacks can and should be effectively integrated even with less experienced practitioners. This approach should be balanced and slowly integrated to avoid the pitfalls of people merely "blocking" techniques that can lead to increased frustration, potential injury, and the likelihood of students quitting. It underscores the importance of adapting our training methods to accommodate a range of skills and experiences as well as experienced instructors leading the class and watching the interaction between students. A notable example of this is the dynamic between lower and higher kyu-ranked students. When higher-ranked students, with their deeper understanding of Aikido principles and controlled strength, engage with lower-ranked students, they sometimes try to challenge the lower rank to flex their ego and then provide instruction. This type of interaction can be a negative side of this topic and where balance and good process and mentorship of the dojo leadership. Again, this can be related to how some people go to train at seminars to show how strong their Aikido is, and can be subjective in eagerly wanting to find strong Aikido. However, this balance is indeed a dynamic one. Relying solely on seminars for skill testing and exposure to different styles has its limitations. It suggests the need for a more holistic approach that evolves through maturity, regular dojo practice, and exploring various training methods and styles. I find these discussions on Aikido, its techniques, and the diverse perspectives on training immensely valuable. They not only stimulate thoughtful discourse but also significantly contribute to the growth and understanding of Aikido across the community. Your podcast serves as a platform for these insightful exchanges, and I eagerly anticipate future episodes. Keep up the fantastic work.

Well I could say something about authentic Aikido when I'll see attempts to do techniques for example from Budo Renshu or from Noma dojo pictures passed down from some teacher not recreated by own fantasies.