the BATTLE (meteor garden vs hana yori dango vs boys over flowers) 

hana yori dango is really one of the best-loved mangas of all time. so beautiful that it had been remade over and over again, and yet one is unique from the other. :) thank you for making the video! i think it was well-made! ^_~ i actually watched all the 3 versions and i loved all of them! XD

Hana Yori Dango is the best for me. I loved the chemistry between doumyouji and makino and they had a lot of romantic scenes plus I absolutly love Matsumoto Jun's acting.

I feel like Hana Yōri Dango (HYD) is the best one because of the story and character development. All people talk about is how the other shows have good-looking actors/actresses. HYD makes it up with good character development and great story-telling. I feel more for the characters because the show shows me how each one has an obstacle they need to cross in order to grow. Even some of the scenes are pure genius. The characters are unique in their own way. Domyouji Tsukasa (Matsumoto Jun) may look and act like a rich, self-entitled jerk most of the time, but deep down inside he needs love like all of us. To add more, he's stupid when it comes to words. I'm not joking, but his soft side that he is hesitant to show us what makes him charming. I won't go on because because it may lead to spoilers. Overall, the show is a must watch. I highly recommend it to anyone who wants a good love story. It'll instantly become one of your favorites. Rank: 1. HYD 2. MG 4. BOF

HYD for me, over all criteria! actors, acting, plot, adaptation from the manga! I love it. I have watched HYD many times now and I am re-watching it again. This show never bores me. It still makes me cry and laugh. I love the F4 cast, Matsumoto Jun, Shun Oguri, Abe Tsuyoshi and Shota Matsuda! I like Meteor Garden next because of my love for Jerry Yan. Then last is Korean version. ]

for me is the best is meteor garden so kilig so lovable walang makakatslo sa meteor garden!!!! im so excited the meteor garden 3 coming soon!!!! in june 2017!!!

HANA YORI DANGO OF COURSE! The best romance comedy japanese drama I've ever seen with the greatest chemistry couple. Never get bored watching season 1, 2 , until the movie. Their best chemistry is what I can't find in other versions. It's been more than 10 years but I am still wishing Matsujun and Mao Inoue to be together. Please just get married both of you 🙏🙏🙏

Nothing beats the Phenomenal MG and F4 Taiwan enough!!!!!

Hana Yori Dango: The acting was really good and the love triangles were believable. The love Tsukasa and Tsukushi was really well done and the mother was evil (good thing). Boys over flowers: Had good looking characters.was really funny. was pretty good also, but the mom looked way to hot and pretty to be evil. Meteor garden:looks awesome.The girl was really pretty.The guys all looked the same

Hana York Dango is HANDS DOWN the WINNER! Great cast...beautiful boys...amazing story telling!!

Hana Yori Dango!!! From the chemistry, acting, plot, romantic scene, it is the best. Jun and Mao are the cutest couple ever... they are so natural

Boys Over Flowers for the second romance team (loved the Seoulmate couple, it was so believable, I had a hard time believing it in the others). Hana Yori Dango for the overall plot and acting, and Meteor Garden for the chemistry between the first love team. So I guess all of them? They all had components that worked for me.

I've watched them Meteor Garden, Hanadan, BOF.. i think Hanadan is the best version bcoz, it has the best chemistry between tsukasa n makino, the friendship. Well, i think u have to watch Hanadan in anime version first before u compare them :) And after u watch it, u'll see that Hanadan (japan) is thr best version :) The 2nd place i choose Meteor Garden, bcoz

I am a Japanese fan freak,but I kinda like the Korean and Chinese.But telling you honestly,Hana Yori Dango's story can definitely make you cry and laugh.Japanese version is more lively and you cannot skip any episodes because all re so lively,fun,dramatic and exciting to watch.I've watched Hana Yori Dango a 2nd time,and for the second time I cry.Worthwhile watching.Main characters and supporting characters have played their best part especially character of Tsukasa and Tsukushi... 花より団子大好き。。。

Hana Yori Dango is the best!!!!!

F4 taiwan, taiwan, taiwan,my best choice ever is meteor garden,,i love it,

Ji Hoo is the best . however I prefer HYD for their chemistry and i do not particularly like matsu jun but in this drama love him! XD

Hana Yori Dango.. I'm watching it again 😂 I don't know how many years past when I watched it on GMA channel.. Now I already watched it for 4x again..

Meteor Garden: the "original" (first to be a drama), best kisses, best storyline Boys Over Flowers: best looking f4 Hana Yori Dango: best actors

For me the best is meteor garden(taiwan version) i love there chemistry and sanchai fits the role. However, hana yori dango ending is the most wonderful scene among them all. I really love that his mother already accepted tsukusi makino. And they get married.:)

I've watched ALL THREE versions of this.. I've seen Meteor Garden, Hana Yori Dango & Boys Over Flowers... And I'd say I still Go for METEOR GARDEN all the way! It must be the lowest budget among all three versions but they portrayed the characters very well. It never gets old. I admire Barbie Hsu's portrayal of the lead female, Shancai is the toughest and strongest and the most believable lead female among three versions. Dao Ming Si is the cutest, most romantic, most innocent and most hottest F4 leader. My 2nd choice is Hana Yori Dango.. I like Matsumoto Jun's portrayal of Domyouji, he must be kind of short but he gave justice to the character. He's the most violent one, i'd say. Lol. But really, his acting is so good. Mao Inoue is the cutest female lead out of all three versions. As for Boys Over Flowers, they have the most expensive props. Lol. And most handsome F4 but the acting is just fine.. thats it.. Lee Minho is too gentle as an F4 leader..and I have nothing against Koo Hye Sun, but her portrayal of Geum Jandi is kind of overacting, she's too talkative and it doesnt look natural...

the most i like ..F4 leader -lee min ho(arrogant guy with the curly hair)the guy who plays the violin-kim hyun joong(his innocent face make him like a angel)the cassanova-kim bum(he really look like cassanova with his charming face)an adviser-kim joon(even in reality,he really a good friend)the women-goo hye sun (she an impressive actress,her character is successfully)the girls fells to player-kim so eun(she so pretty with the players,kim bum)a dictator mother-lee hye yeong(success 'olg hag')

I've watch them all and all of them is my favorite but the most unforgettable and has a very good ending was the Hana Yori Dango

I'm choosing boys over flower (bof) because : 1. F4 in boys over flower is so hot. love lee min ho, hyun joong, kim bum & kim joon so much.them are perfect guy. 2. hyun joong smile is the best. kim bum make me melt. 3. original soundtrack bof is the best especially song like " stand by me sing by my fav. shinee, because i'm stupid sing by killer smile hyun joong, paradise by t-max (kim joon) & starlight tears". so, boys over flower is the best among the best.

I love the story of boys over flower.

for beauty and song ill choose bof for chem. and GREAT acting ill choose meteor garden and hyd Also for most memorable for me, the type i can still remember scenes , ill vote for Meteor garden and hyd And lastly for my BIASED , HYD FOR THE WIN, hehe

I still prefer the first meteor garden ❤❤

Both They really deserve the best' When it comes from Unexpected enemies they really makes the real fight mauling Is it truly yes' because of their moves actions & feelings that they have'

4 me meteor garden is the best they bring more laugh and cried,,the famous f4 taiwan is the no.1 no one can beats them,,they can act,they can sing very well,,i love f4 taiwan forever,,,jai you..😁😁😁

1ST IS BOYS OVER FLOWERS 2ND METEOR GARDEN AND THE 3RD IS HANA YORI DANGO

Hana Yori Dango

all I read about the comments for F4 of korea they hot, and handsome. For me I can remember a actor who made me laugh, cry and amazed me. Face is one of easiest thing people can forget. Plus those taiwanese and japanese have grown beautifully after this..

Bof4, was 9 to 10 years ago K-Drama movie, but I'm still watching it until nowadays, oftentimes, again and again, I still cry, laugh, full in love with the casts and stories, I never felt tired, or boring or feel monotonous upon viewing this movie, it might not be the original making, but they acted and had given justice to every role they played, much more than, that of meteor garden.. BOF4 is a packaged, perfect.. the most handsome BOF4 actors and prettiest, beautiful, charming and lovely princesses within.. 👌👌👌♥️💖😍🔹🔹💗💞👑👑👑🙏💎💎♦️♦️💙👍👍💚💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹🌸🌸🌸🌹💐😘✈️✈️✈️

Hana Yori Dango FOREVER!!!!!!!!!

HYD definitely.. They really played the character very well and the story among the three HYD is more believable go matsujun.. :)

For me the best is Hana yori dango (japanese version) because it is really great and awesome. It made me cry and laugh whenever I watch it! Honestly, I'm obsessed with it right now. Especially Matsumoto Jun and Inoue Mao :D

Meteor Garden

Meteor garden is the best.then hana yori dango last the boys over flower i watched this three but for MG is the best

HANA YORI DANGO is the BEST live-action version.🏆 It is CLOSEST to the JAPANESE SHOJOU MANGA.👍 i'm not surprised that the JAPANESE LIVE-ACTION VERSION is the BEST. HANA YORI DANGO has the BEST CHARACTERS, PLOT, CINEMATOGRAPHY, OST, SCORING, everything!👏 Nothing beats the ORIGINAL!👍

For the chemistry and acting...i cant choose between meteor garden and HYD but the BOF nailed the production..the outfit, setting, and ofcourse they're more gorgeous than taiwan and japan F4..

BOF guys doesnt are good looking to me, matsu jun is way more beautiful and perfect actor, HYD without no doubt.

For me all of this drama is good. Meteor Garden was the one version and followed by Hana Yori Dango dan Boys Before flowers. MG was the best scene, and the best acting, HYD was the best chemistry and the best ending and BBF was the best looking and the best funniest moment

F4 from Taiwan are the best hunks!!!! Very manly!!!

Love them all. But HYD is the best because it had a satisfying ending!!!

METEOR GARDEN IS THE BEST FOR ME.....THEY ARE MORE GOOD LOOKING... FAMOUS,AMAZING,MOST OF ALL NATURAL AND DAMN HOTTEST GUY'S EVER...

hana yori for me it's good ending ever

Also, 10 years ago there was no youtube, no social media or the likes. Meteor Rain's success back then was phenomenal really. But I love BOFs too, even though the cast is years younger than me, dang they are real hot! and my favorite is of cuz LMH :)

solid meteor garden....

So Hana Yori Dango is the original title from manga then Taiwan made it first into live action with some revisions and "Meteor Garden" as the title. After a year, Japan took the full inspiration from the manga and put it in small screen series with the original title. Then, here comes South Korean's version combining the elements from both "Meteor Garden" and "Hana Yori Dango" with so much revisions and lacking of some cute scenes from both Japan's and Taiwan's version.

HYD! not only winning this battle but i guess, it's the best drama/movie i've ever watch

F4 who loves music: Taiwan - Hua Ze Lei Korea - Jihoo Japan - Hanazawa Rui

HANA YORI DANGO all the way... I love Meteor Garden and it will always have a place in my heart because that was the very first that i've watched... and i was a kid at that time.. but i picked HANA YORI DANGO because it was just EPIC.. even though it was pure fiction you'll feel that it was real.. unlike BOF i know it was a fiction but the plot they have somehow came from a child's imagination??(just my opinion) there's no much twist even if its longer..

Taiwan coz that's the first that i watched and the one that made me cry the most.

*BOF* 4EVER ...this kdrama first bring me to wacth so many2 times...they starring all are so cute2...when they are Smilling *Killersss* Lolll a specially Ji Hoo sunbae make me love this guy 😍😍😍... Fightinggg 😘😘😘

the guys and the girls of bof are super duper cute

lol I only liked Jerry Yan in meteor garden xD but Hana Yori Dango for the win bc it followed the manga very well!! :) I loved Makino and Domyouji so much together since you can really tell that those two are in love compared to the others. honestly, Tsukushi was the only one who really said "I love you" to Domyouji. like sure in Meteor Garden and BOF she said "I like you," but that doesn't really compare to love! plus idk Makino and Domyouji are just goals, okay? it's so cute that honestly, you'll never get tired of their relationship bc it's hillarious xD

HANA YORI DANGO IS THE BEST!!!!! MATSUMOTO JUN ACTING IS GOOD!! INOUE MAO PRETTY AND ALSO GOOD AT ACTING. THEY ARE SO SWEET!!!!

meteor garden and boys over flowers! daoming si shanchai and joon pyo jandi and jihoo! i love them!

Hana yori dango...

hana Yori Dango is the best movie ever

hana yori dango is the best!

hana yori dango for the win. the best love team among the three version. i love tsukasa and tsukushi. taiwan version is also good. i love jerry yan.

meteor garden aqo the best talaga wla yan

boys over flowers and meteor garden, is the best😄

BOYS OVER FLOWERS FOR THE WIN!!!! Even the music that you use... only proves that you are on my side bRUTHal2009 !!!!!!!

lol.. you're criticizing the face.. version means the "whole package" from the actors how they act up to how the story goes.. I've watched these three versions.. and i prefer Hana Yori Dango among the rest.. tho it is underrated.. still it is the BEST version. :)

F4's Casanova: Taiwan - Meizuo Korea - Woobin Japan - Mimasaka Akira

Meteor garden parin ang original..the best f4 in taiwan.

Of course!! I love BOF4, South Korea or Boys over flowers 4..they are perfect together and in many ways, and places.. The story is very interesting, beautiful, a rare but in reality stories.. and very, very handsome 4 leading actors, with their pretty, lovely, charming and beautiful princess jandi and everybody are excellent in acting. love you BOF4, wish for a BOF4 part 2 someday 🌸🌸🌸🌸🌹🌹🌹🌹💐💐💐💐💚💚👍👍💙♦️💎🙏🙏🙏👑👑👑💞💗🔹😊😍💖♥️👌

I gotta admit i didn´t saw meteor garden (need to do it soon). But i love Hana Yori Dango. I dislike the ending of the Korean version. But the OST is really good. Love it *_*. btw Hana Yori Dango got better rates at DRamasites than the others. But each and everyone got to decide on their own.

Boys over flowers 5ever!

in mangga comiks the story really fit to the cast of HANA YURI DANGO... OK some of the story that of the other version, they just like the story longer.. in the last movie RUI he will be a priest.. i chose HANA YORI DANGO because they are really good in acting..., if you see the major characters they are super good looking like MAKINO, RUI & TSUKASA.. i really love it.. TSUKASA and MAKINO forever^^ !!!!! Hana Yori Dango Japanese version and original!!!

Hana Yori Dango Its Just PERFECT , Its Simply THE BEST

For those who don't know it's bof's songs in the bgm

METEOR GARDEN

Dao Ming Xe's Mother is the scariest :D

Meteor Garden le gana a todas!!! Taiwan!!! Taiwan!!! Taiwan!!!

love meteor garden 1st in my heart

Kung papanoorin mo to sa year nila maganda lahat, pero kapag magbabase ka ngayong 2020 parang yung Korean Version mas bet ko.

meteor garden is d best..

meteor garden

Meteor Garden Boys Over Flowers Hana Yori dango

meteor garden and boys over flower

Meteor garden is the best because meteor garden is the original

Hana Yori Dango the best

Taiwan version for making it a hit first. HYD for an intricate and well structured story. MG for having really yummy actors.

F4 Leaders of 3 Countries: Taiwan - Dao Ming Si Korea - Go Jun Pyo Japan - Domyouji Tsukasa.

I've seen every version except the anime, and every single time I have 2nd lead syndrome! I especially love Kim Hyun Joong, Vic Zhou and Darren Chen (in that order).

ok, i love all of them, but the best to me is Meteor Garden. I like the characters, they are charming and i'm in love with Jerry Yan as the leader :)

Hana yori dango is the best

I LOVED HANA YORI DANGO! hanazawa rui!!! but for me i loved kim bum/yijung and kim so euns charater in BOF, i basically watched it only for them. for the taiwanese one..i couldnt finish it...i got bored of it...

it's a land slide win! boys over flower is the best! the whole cast are perfect!

You should not choose them just because their kinda cute and handsome,you should pick the ones who played their part best and if their ones version is fun and dramatic,okay!!!!! 大好き花より団子。。。

the best ? well, i'd say : All Of Them ! cz each of the movies has left different touch and colors in my life.....^^ I LOVE THEM ALL. mIN hOO Looks like Jerry Yan in some angle. hahaha. ^^ NIce work, pal !

..Hana yori dango is the best ,,, forever and ever i i

Can't compare something that's like 10 years ago with something from last year. Cuz the style and trend and scripting style is different. Years ago koreans shows are very draggy too. But compare the Taiwan F4 at their current age, with the exception of Ken Chu who has went behind the scenes, Jerry, Vic and Vanness are all still damn hot! In fact Lee Minho looks like Jerry Yan's younger bro :)

Meteor garden is the most iconic 😂😂😂

hana yori dango is the best!! actors, drama,everything meteor garden is great because its the one thats looks like the manga! boysss bf .omg his actors are soo hot(kim bum) but jan di was annoying and that fuck up everything sorry if my english is bad, im mexican =)

I think most people dont like hana yori dango beacause the lead character is not that attractive but if you watch it more, you will get used to it and you'll see that domyuji is very attractive. I like HYD the best, so much better than the attractive f4 of BOF. I like the season 1 of meteor garden so much but i got bored on season 2.

Hana yori dango👍💜 The best

@tampamahkota glad that google translation is around so i was to understand what you commented.. thanks