The Beatles - Goodnight (Explained) The HollyHobs 

I agree 100%. He had a bit of a "man's man voice" that none of the rest really had organically. Like born to be a good Grandfather or something.

The HollyHobs Beatles Explained yup, the ringo magic no other beatle had. And btw you’re awesome!

I thought Paul sang it? It sounds like him

Yes, I’ve always felt bad for Julian and wanted to feel John loved him, and this makes me feel even better about it

yep I totally agree, Julian Lennon was born at the worst possible time for John , when the Beatles became international stars. Of course he could have done more but at least he did right with Sean

I agree, although we can't pretend that John wasn't a terrible father. But if Julian's willing to forgive him, I am too.

Linda música que John Lennon escreveu para seu primogênito Julian Lennon 🥰

Back In The A.S.M.R

I feel like John "cracked" quite a lot too. This is one of the reasons why I hate the way autotune is used today. Those small "imperfections" are what makes singing a human endeavor. Being slightly off key from time to time or even fucking up an entire note isn't as bad as using software to turn you into some singing robot. In my opinion, vulnerability is the name of the game when it comes to singing anything with meaning.

The HollyHobs Beatles Explained Exactly, it’s what makes us human. I think a lot of the songs in the hot 100 now have lost the human element due to overproduction.

Nailed it! I come from the era of, as Harrison said, "...we had real people playing real guitars amps, recorded on tape. There is nothing high tech about it." (Or words to that effect). Music is by nature imperfect. It is human beings trying to follow a score perfectly. Think about that. Perfectly. That is impossible. A famous composer recorded Beethoven's 7th Symphony and someone declared it "perfect." When they played it back, they found 43 separate errors. As hard as they tried, they only could get it down to 11 errors. Now, of course, you or I would not recognize it. However, to the trained ear, it was like fingers across a blackboard. We are imperfect human beings seeking is some way, perfection. I loved Ringo's version of this, errors and all! It is beautiful in its simplicity and humanistic in its imperfections. All the tech in the world means nothing. It can give us a great deal of "new" sound but in our rush toward perfection, we have missed an important lesson. We are not nor never will be perfect. Truly enjoyed this! You truly add more content to your video's than you can imagine! Thank you and God bless you!

I was debating on adding a little "nasal" to mimic John but I thought it would derail the sentiment. I personally am happy Ringo did it but it would be so cool to hear what John had in mind.

You seem to be able to sing with the personality of Johns voice without it becoming an impersonation. Far more effecting. Yeah, I think John probably knew that it would be easier to digest 'Goodnight' coming from Ringo but I'm sure what the writer had in mind wouldn't be very far away from what you brilliantly captured here.... have a sugar-free black tea Sir Hollyhob, you deserve it!

Thanks, Both of those songs are great, can't wait to do Back in the USSR and get a bunch of political comments for no good reason. When I did "Taxman" I didn't even express my political opinions ( I am a firm believer in a more Cthulhu form of democracy) and people were getting a bit heated. It's hilarious.

There's gonna be a 50th Anniversary remix of The White Album, hopefully they add in John's version of Goodnight and the 12-minute version of Helter Skeltor.

Part of me wonders if it was some kind of guilt. John must have been aware he wasn't a good father to him, so maybe he felt he didn't deserve to sing it for Julian? Or something like that. Who knows

Having anyone who watches my videos and take the time to say something like what you said is honestly more than I could have asked for. Thank you.

Thanks, yea it always makes me miss my childhood. Things were simple.

Thats true.

That made me spit coffee on my laptop laughing. I wish I was kidding.

Not next but I'll add it to my timeline because of your comment. Thank you.

The HollyHobs Beatles Explained omg that's great!! Thank you 😁

The song is just sleep inducing in general, I could have it on repeat and fall asleep to it.

Ooooooo-Cean-Child.

Raunak Shikhar there's an altetnative version with just Ringo on drums and John Lennon (I think) on piano

I have heard about that track but have near had a chance to come across it.

www.dropbox.com/s/4nzfdlzsiwul169/oldclevelandboy53509_2010-11-27T11_17_36-08_00.mp3?dl=0 here you go buddy

Wow! Never heard that. Thanks muchly.

@@pleudumes thank you

Yea dude, I just finger picked the chords but check them out on Ultimate Guitar Tabs or something. There are a few.

Just random things I decided to get when I was a kid, more personal meanings than anything really. I have a lot at this point.