The Best and Worst of Disney Star Wars! 

Want to watch Eric as he plays Star Wars Jedi: Survivor for the first time LIVE? Catch up with the first stream HERE: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-C5cHQD-zGd8.html Watch the next stream when it goes live Wednesday Janurary 10th at 6PM EST HERE: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-u_rvTShjtzM.html

Andor is an amazing show in general. Not just an amazing Star Wars show. And that's just so refreshing and I loved it.

Oh, my, god, you made a clip of my question!😱 I'm honoured, thanks guys♥️

I would say the same with resistance. Enjoyed it, but probably my least fav project. Fav is 100% without a doubt Bad Batch. I just felt so close to them/ connected. I just felt like I was hanging out with friends. Love Mandalorien very much and Andor was really good, but bad batch just has my heart.

Rebels is probably my favorite Star Wars thing ever. Tales of the Jedi also did more to build a character in so short of time with so few words than pretty much anything i could think of so pound-for-pound that was probably a close contender.

Clone Wars Season 7 without a doubt for me is the best thing since.. well since The Clone Wars ended 😆

My favorite thing is absolutely Andor Season 1 and then Rogue One ironically enough for a movie and tv show. Andor Season 1 is my favorite single season of Star Wars television ever, I've watched it 3 times now. Rogue One is just fantastic! So entertaining and I could rewatch it all day. Least favorite is maybe either Obi-Wan or Mando Season 3. Only because of the fact that I don't remember as much from them. I think they are both just fine, not good or bad but something was definitely missing from them. For the most part I've liked a lot of what has been put out for television. I can't wait for Bad Batch to end with Season 3 and to get more Tales of the Jedi this year along with the new live action shows too.

I love Eebels! I agree with you about Mando. Probably my favorite project of the Disney era. And I agree about s3. That isn’t to say it didn’t have problems because it absolutely did. Ep3 still feels out of place and ep6 definitely had some cringe moments, but the plot threads from those episodes either came back later in Ahsoka or J’m sure will come up again in later projecgs. But every time K see reactions from s3 I’m reminded of how much there was to like about it and how many awesome moments there were. It doesn’t top s2 of course, but still. So yeah Mando is my favorite, but Andor is objectively the best. Seriously it’s not fair how good it is. Least favorite I’m not sure. I never watched Resistance or Young Jedi Adventures beyond the shorts. But maybe one of those or the sequels.

Andor & Obi wan are my favorite Star Wars shows

Wait you named your son after a character in Rebels Aaron? That's so cool! Might I ask their name/who they were named after?

Star Wars Rebels and Ezra Bridger🔥🙌

If I rank my favorite live action shows it would be this: 1) Mandalorian: this is what got me into real a real SW fan. I am a huge fan of western movies, so I loved the mood. Mando is an obvious reference to The Man with no name. I thought ''Baby Yoda'' would be an annoying sidekick made for toys, but far from it. Overall a mix of good writing, great characters, and almost always great action. I liked season 3 less though. 2) Andor: this one surprised me the most. When I saw a promo poster featuring Mando, Ahsoka, Obi-Wan and Andor together, I thought Andor was out of place and would be a weak link. Quite the contrary. The writing, especially for dialogues, is phenomenal. It's a real plunge into the peak Empire era. I understand why some people don't like it, as it is not adventure-oriented and does not feature the Force, but I loved it. It is very slow but has great payoffs. 3) Book of Boba Fett: pretty uneven, and they managed to get Mando in this instead of focusing on Boba (even though both Mando episodes were the best), but I loved the Tusken background. The last episode had too many deus ex machina moments though. My favorite scene is Cad Bane's entrance in a western standoff. This is what finally got me to watch Clone Wars to learn more about the characters. 4) Ahsoka: decent action, ok writing, acting no problem. But I am not a Rebels fan, I didn't like Ezra or Kanan, so I didn't care much about what was happening. Ezra's actor here was fine, the character was fine, but the real standouts for me were Thrawn (I liked him more than in Rebels), Baylan Skoll (RIP Ray), and Anakin. 5) Obi-Wan: very up and down. Some scenes like the last fight were great, but some others were horrendous, and the plot was very convoluted.

The things I’ve rewatched the most are Mando s1 and 2 and eps 5 and 6 of Boba Fet.

These opinions are why I look forward to hearing your thoughts on new Star Wars stuff

I think my favorite Star Wars projects during the Disney era is Andor, Rogue One, Mandalorian, Bad Batch, Rebels, Ahsoka, Kenobi and Visions. When it comes to least favorite projects it would be Rise of Skywalker and Book of Boba Fett. Never watch Resistance and don’t plan to, my choice lol. I liked Mando season 3 more than others. Wish though they saved the grogu and din reunion for season 3.

I agree on the Mandolorian Season 3 rewatch.

Even though I'm sure this is "controversial" amongst Star Wars fans, my personal favorite thing is the The Sequel Trilogy/Force Awakens. If it wasn't for Force Awakens I don't think I would be as big of a fan of Star Wars as I am now. I mean I went from just seeing some of the movies in passing and a Clone Wars episode here and there and being barley a fan to watching all of the OT and PT in 2015 and being such a huge fan coming out of Force Awakens. So much so that I went to Star Wars celebration with my Dad in 2017 for my birthday! As much as people rag on that trilogy online I still think it's my personal favorite Star Wars thing, with Force Awakens probably being the main thing.

The Last Jedi is my favorite thing in the new era. I’m not trolling, I’m not saying you have to like it, I’m saying it’s my favorite thing and it really speaks to me.

It's interesting because like how Eric highlights the finale of Kenobi, there are some shows where even if I maybe didn't like the show as a whole (like Book of Boba Fett and Mando S3) or I did but I didn't love-love it (like Kenobi and Ahsoka), it still had individual episodes that stand out as excellent and I wish the whole franchise could be consistently as good as them. My biases will come into play here but those episodes for me would include the second episode of the Book of Boba Fett, the Mayfield episode Mandalorian Season 2, the Crosshair and Mayday episode of The Bad Batch as well as the Season 2 finale, the Clone Wars Siege of Mandalore arc, the Anakin episode of Ahsoka, the Kenobi finale same as Eric and pretty much every second or third episode of Andor, with all its other episodes not far behind.

Couldn’t agree more about the Obi-Wan finale. The show in and of itself wasn’t necessarily stellar…but that single episode was just amazing. Again, I agree. So many rewatches of that episode alone.

Super Why! nation rise up

I feel like objectively, Andor is the best thing Disney's done with Star Wars yet. but for my favorite, idk. Tales of The Jedi, Clone Wars S7, Mando 1/2, The Bad Batch, Rebels (especially S3 and 4). As much as I criticize Disney SW, they've done some amazing stuff.

In my opinion, the latest season of Mandalorian wasn’t that good. There were things I enjoyed but it just never came together properly. Like season 2 ends in such an interesting place that it feels like we were cheated out of a more interesting 3rd season. Like them undoing that ending in the Boba Fett show was a really dumb move. I hate that The Mandalorian is suffering from the wider issues that Star Wars is facing so hopefully they course correct soon.

Ahsoka for me, but it wouldn't mean half as much without Rebels and Clone Wars S7.

There’s no “Disney Star Wars”. It’s still LucasFilm. Just like how Marvel movies are made by Marvel Studios, and Pixar movies are made by Pixar.

The only things I didn't like very much of the Disney era Star Wars is the Forces of Destiny shorts solely due to the animation (and I love almost all animation styles). Also, I liked the Resistance show, but it was probably the weakest of this era's shows imo.

Resistance is Disney era? wow lost track of time I guess

I've not seen Resistance or Young Jedi Adventures (resistance I plan on watching at some point but who knows when), so I'd say my least favourite is the sequel trilogy, which I don't hate but don't really like either. There are bits I like and bits I don't, so the overall result is very middling for me. My favourite is probably either Rebels or Andor, both of which are masterworks - the former being a masterclass in traditional Star Wars content, and the latter a transformative new take on the franchise.

You guys should review Harmy’s Despecialized versions of the original trilogy.

It's hard for me to pinpoint just one thing as the best, so here's a (release-order) top five: Rebels, The Force Awakens, Rogue One, The Village Bride, and Ahsoka.

hope they react to hello there ROTS Fan film

Rogue one, andor and first 2 seasons of mandalorian are the only projects I think Disney has done right. Someone can argue the sequels is subjective, but the damage the rise of skywalker brought to the saga is unforgivable

Andor is my favorite show ever, it’s so good it could be the exact same but set in the real world and I’d still love it. Better than greats like Breaking Bad imo

The Last Jedi was the worst thing about the Disney era of Star Wars. Rogue One, Andor & Force Awakens were my 3 favorites.

Guys, don't use the phrase "Disney Star Wars". It's only used now in negative context.

My favorite is definitely Star Wars Rebels, tailed very closely by Andor. Least favorite would have to be the Book of Boba Fett.

I'm sorry, but it's Andor and it's not even close. It's the best looking out of the Disney+ shows, the script is noticeably better, fantastic, instantly memorable performances, consistent quality throughout the entire season, which shows like Boba and Kenobi were sorely lacking in.

The sequels were so bad that I pretend they don’t exist. Andor is my least favorite. Just doesn’t feel like Star Wars. The “mandoverse” shows are Star Wars at its best. Dave Filoni is the only one the understands George’s Vision.

Best: Andor Worst: The Last Jedi

Like: force awakens (though the later movies pretty much ruined it for me), rogue one, mando s1-s2, ahsoka, clone wars s7, tales of the jedi, andor, rebels (if it counts) Meh: last jedi, mando s3, book of boba, Solo Dislike: rise of skywalker, kenobi (although the last episode was killer) Haven't watched resistence and visions

Best: Andor Half of cw season 7 Tales of the jedi Worst: Mandalorian s2 & 3 Sequel trilogy Bobf Obi wan Ahsoka The rest i can take or leave. Nothing special

they definitely coped out by only talking about the cartoons for grade schoolers for the negatives 😂

Objectively speaking, Andor is the best but as for my personal favorite of anything Disney Star Wars, if it wasn't for The Mandalorian, I wouldn't be into Star Wars at all. It's classic Star Wars and allowed me to get into the story without necessarily forcing me to watch anything prior to Season 1 - that said, it expanded my interest unlike anything else. While Andor was great, there is only two standout moments for me the entire season so it unfortunately its not my favorite show as a collective. My personal ranking is 1) The Mandalorian, 2) Ahsoka 3) Rebels, 4) Andor 5) Obi Wan Kenobi. Worse: The Rise of Skywalker - they didn't know what to do with that storyline and in the end, highly disappointing.

@worst: I've watched OT some 50 times. I've seen the prequels some 10 times maybe. But I have never, ever, even thought of re-watching, even once, the steaming pile of sh*t the sequel trilogy was. It's a dumpster fire that pissed on Lucas legacy. I would wholly embrace Disney if not for that, as all else is better. @best For favs, Andor, period. That said Rebels is amazing, a close second. Mandalorian is third.

There is SO much since 2014 I’ve loved. Trials of the Darksaber, Jyn and Cassian dying, Luke vs Kylo, Andor, Cad Bane’s intro in Boba Fett, Grogu and Ahsoka, Grogu saying goodbye to Din, Thrawn’s reintroduction in Ahsoka,

The siege of Mandalore is simply the best thing done in the Disney era. One of my favourite Star Wars things ever.

Mando movie Mando movie Mando movie

Tales of the Jedi, Rebels, Kenobi, Ahsoka - that's my list!

I acknowledge that Andor is great TV, but to me it did not feel like Star Wars. It was its own thing, with a Star Wars setting. So for me, that doesn't count. If I want something that felt like Star Wars, I go to Rogue One, which tied itself so deftly into the original trilogy, and introduced characters and settings that fit in so neatly and satisfyingly, it ticks all the boxes.

Disney Star Wars gets way too much hate. Maybe try what Eric suggested. Give some of it a rewatch. Think more about it.

Least Favourite: Sadly Kenobi (I love Obi Wan, Vader and Leia and Leias actress was amazing. The last episode had some really emotional stuff that was handled beautifully, but there was so much stupid stuff in there. And it looked really shitty a lot of the times, was produced very badly imo...i always remember some of the person-starship ratio, for example Vader when he pulls the ship down or the Rebel hoth thingy at the base, the sizes are just so off) -- I have to be fair tho, Kenobi really disappointed me, because I was so excited, it was supposed to be the return of one the best characters ever, suprisingly even two with Hayden, but they made such a mess of it and im still so disappointed, Book of Boba Fett (except the Luke and Mando episodes, especially the Luke episode might be one of the best star wars content ever, because we finally saw our true Luke, Jedi master luke, the Luke we got denied by the trainwreck that was Last Jedi), everything with Boba just didnt sit right with me...they made Boba into something he clearly never was supposed to be, but to give them credit, it looked really great) Favourite: Andor, Rogue One and Mando (Mando Season 1 and 2 was amazing, 3 was ok but nothing special), Rebels (especially from season 2 till the end)

I hope that they check out that fan made Clone Wars battle of the heroes.

Are they going to react to the Battle of the Heroes fan film that everyone else has?

Idk if I can count just the final arc of the clone wars in season 7 but that is my favorite thing Disney Lucasfilm has done. Least favorite would probably be resistance as well because I can’t even bring myself to watch it and I consider myself a very hardcore fan

Is that a white chewbaca in the middle? thats cool

Rebels, Fallen Order, Rogue One, The Mandalorian, Andor, Clone Wars Siege of Mandalore with a budget we could never have dreamed of pre-Disney, and High Republic era novels. We've gotten some good stuff over the last few years.

One of the reasons that no one likes season 3 is because you have to watch The Book of Boba Fett to understand why Grogu returned? It’s pretty much season 2.5 and no one asked for a Boba Fett spinoff. The good things that happen in this spinoff doesn’t even reflect on the main protagonist of his own series. “The Book of Boba Fett (featuring Mando)”

Sometimes I just think, they just like everything. There's really never anything they dislike or hate, it can get annoying and suffocating sometimes. Like about how much they're just happy about it. I know they do mention the flaws, and stuff about the show, and that they just wave it off as something that's just part of the show, they aren't they're intended audience, or it's the audience fault for missing some things. Like they are just tip toeing around it, so not to prevent any future sponsors, or stay on people good side. It's only what I think at least.

Andor is the best Star Wars project since Empire Strikes Back. It’s a f*cking masterpiece!

Easily the worst Mando season 3 (so disappointing) and Book of Boba. Best is Andor hands down

Please react to the clone wars battle of heroes fan animation by hello there its absolutely AMAZING!

Andor was the best. Mando S1-2 also good. book of Boba was watchable. The rest, not my thing… oh, Rogue One also good.

algorithm comment

Somehow, they ranked Resistance worse than Rise of Skywalker.

The Last Jedi is easily the worst of Disney Star Wars that I've seen, and the best is The Clone Wars Season 7

I’d be interested to see Eric and Aaron “debate”/talk to SW Theory and Mauler on a stream about new canon.