The Best of Tim Minchin as 'Judas' | Jesus Christ Superstar 

my favourites are all of his performance :)

Fav moment from JCS is any time he’s on screen. ;) But honestly I really like his I Dont Know How to Love Him Reprise and how much raw emotion he can put into his voice in those scenes like Damned for All Time. It really gives depth to his character and I love the way he actually ACTs the part in his voice and face.

The "i don't know how to love him" reprise

Every second of every part! But especially the sustained notes

I had to laugh when he first appeared with a tambourine in "Superstar". Absolutely chaotic, just perfect. I have to smile everytime I see it, no matter how often I'm watching it.

I agree!

Agreed my friend

preach honestly

A hard core "edgy" one too

I heard this show turned him Christian

@DadisDad then what are you doing here?

I don't want to be Frank, I like my name just fine, thank you.

@DadisDad does your nicname suggests you are a dad? I hope not...

@DadisDad I'm so sorry for your kids if you feel the need to invalidate strangers online. Pay attentions to your kid, touch some grass. Reconnect with whatever resemblance of a life you used to have before clicking on a video appreciating someone just to hate on that person and their fans.

@DadisDad You can't just say that someone's got shitty taste and that you're not hating anyone in one comment. "Good" and "bad" are probably the most subjective things in this world, saying that something's shitty is an opinion, not "merely pointing that out." If you want to be hypocritical, go ahead. It's entertaining.

EXACTLY

I don't think it was jealousy really, its desperation, the desperation to keep his closest friend and mentor alive. Because he had more understanding of the dog eat dog world that they are exposing their group into. ("Listen Jesus to the warning I give. Please remember that I want us to live. But its sad to see our chances, weakening with every hour") When it was just them being taught by Jesus, it was much easier to explain the nuances of his teachings to them and have a quick mutual understanding of its wisdom. But as they travel and their influence grew. It became much harder to control that misinterpretation. Judas and his fellow Apostles knew that Jesus' claim as the "King of Kings" is more of a spiritual "King" than a political one. But most people they've come across won't interpret it that way. The public saw Jesus as a political figure and saw his act of miracles as a "campaign" of sorts. ("All the good you've done will soon get swept away. You begun to matter more than the things you say") That's why when word got around and reached the Pharisees and the Roman Governor Pontius Pilate, those political powers felt threatened by this rumored "King of Kings" and had a watchful eye on him, waiting for a slip up that would give em an excuse to silence him. Judas was the only one who thought that all this was getting out of hand. If this kept going, the political powers will surely mark their friend as a Blasphemer and the public will mark him as a Liar. ("But every word you say today, gets twisted round some other way. And they'll hurt you when they think you've lied") There's a reason why he was Jesus' right hand man, he wasn't there to be evil. He was the smartest disciple. So Judas tried his damnest to convince Jesus that they need to keep their head down or lose it. That's why he also got pissed at his fellow disciples because they're just following blindly like they don't care what all this attention would lead to. And this is why he didn't like Mary. He wasn't jealous, in fact, the story implies that if the situation was any different, Judas would have just let Jesus and Mary be. Like I said awhile ago, Jesus' teachings were being twisted as they became more popular. The public won't care about nuances, only surface level examples. And Jesus being with Mary is a contradicition. And contradictions just gives the nay-sayers more ammo once sh*t hits the fan. ("It doesn't help that you're inconsistent, they just need a small excuse to put us all away") Judas wants to avoid stuff like that at all cost. At the end of his rope, the frustration, the desperation. He sold Jesus to the Pharisees to push the other disciples to act, and to show Jesus what his actions will lead to. Judas didn't anticipate that it will lead to the worst possible outcome. He tried to do everything right, but at his lowest point he made the worst possible decision. So no, it wasn't jealousy. Its desperation.

​@@ihaveaplan.ijustneedmoney.9777 Underrated comment

I think the biggest crime the production team committed on this run of JCSS was pitch correction on Tim. He captures the rawness of emotion and frustration Judas was written as having and it comes out in his voice. That little bit of pitchiness would’ve been amazing to hear. Petition for ALW to re-release this run without pitch correction?

The autotune scratches my ears every time here. That is a shame and really a crime. Tim has a great voice on his own!

THERE IS NO AUTO TUNE IN USE HERE. YOUR DEVICE IS ADJUSTING GAIN. Go pick on girl scouts. Ply your ignorance elsewhere.

I don't know if you're on Facebook at all, but if you are you should continue your clicking by joining Tim's Facebook fan group Minchkins. We are a lovely bunch of smart, silly, incredibly kind uber nerds and really it's just one of the best places on the internet.

@@allyson5380 awww thanks for the recommendation !

Same

Yeah. Judas is SUPPOSED to be in pain; the notes shouldn't matter as much as the emotion. And with every auto-tune they did on his voice, they took emotion away from Tim's portrayal of Judas.

Absolutely. My other favourite Judas is Drew Sarich (who also does a really good Jesus too, and has performed in both roles on Broadway, in the West End and all over Europe and the US) and he is just as painfully emotive, despite a more traditional musical theatre vocal quality. In the same way, as I love Steve Balsamo's Jesus, Drew brings that painful pleading and begging quality from Judas into Jesus for Gethsemane, and I love when it's more about the pain and the emotion than being concerned about hitting every single note absolutely perfectly. But nobody has caused the same emotional reaction to the suicide scene as Tim. I had to pause the DVD as I was having a full-on ugly-cry meltdown.

He mentioned that in an interview years ago. He'd always wanted to play the role!

I honestly think that it's perfect for an atheist to play judas, it brings so much more depth to the character

@DadisDad are you talking about my comment? If so then it's because the whole thing about judas is that he doesn't believe that jesus is really the son of god and instead of following god he goes more for action (confronting jesus in the beginning, selling him etc) a lot like atheists. And in heaven on their minds you can feel how he is disappointed in jesus for choosing in believing the whole "I'm the son of god" thing rather than listening to what he has to say about his group of followers

@DadisDad i actually didn't know who tim was before i watched this recording

@DadisDad Thanks, dad.

@DadisDad bro- what. Why you so salty over everyone complimenting Tim's Judas? Lmao, get a life

😂😂

Underrated comment

The other 20 are people who agree with him!

Plus 8 more, now 28 in total!

some of the autotune on the jesus is super distracting too

The autotune isn't even noticeable. Seriously, it's impossible to hear the autotune anyway, resulting in it ultimately making no difference. He sounds amazing with or without autotune. It doesn't affect the performance in any way.

@@lukebradford It's definitely very noticeable and it completely ruins the performance

@@lukebradford yeeee, no. It’s highly noticeable (especially in the Jaded mandarin bit and in the I don’t know how to love him reprise), it trully does ruin the performance as Tim’s vocals would be so beautiful raw, but with the autotune the rich emotions in the voice get hardly translated at all.

@@emdentaylor1110 agree, i don't mean that the autotune was needed for the rest of the cast, it shouldn't have been autotuned at all

I think i missed it, whats the time stamp?

@@itswherethecomedycomesin8864 7:42!

@@sophiamartinez3071 thank you so much!

I honestly have trouble understanding what he’s saying but I still agree. The sound itself fits so well

@@hierrikmedan6934 "my god, I saw him, he looks as good as dead"

@@cosmowhiskey1675 he actually says “he looks three quarters dead” instead of “he looks as good as dead” but either would work!

@@limelemons8735 thx!

He humanized Judas in a way I never considered! Brilliant!

He actually lost his voice after practicing for a few hours for this tour

@@b.d6642 then he must‘ve practiced incorrectly, bc that‘s not supposed to happen

@@vickyengler21 He didn't practice incorrectly just too much

@@vickyengler21 Me: *reads comment, immediately looks for vocal coaching videos on your channel* Also me: *fucking finds none*

@@stewiew1151 LOL

There is a sound without video, just look it up. I thought that too, but there actually is, a whole playlist

@@ogaoms8985 really? I’m definitely gonna find it now 😂

There is on RU-vid. I wish it was on Spotify though.

@@kdeggraham895 same! Or just on any music service. This cast is too darn good to not have a cast recording

I mean...I have the movie and could turn it into a audio if you want 🤷‍♀️

"Stop being so damn dramatic"

L. C

lol right, I love those tiny bits of acting

"This is my blood you drink." 🙄 "Dude, I swear if you keep this up..."

And then when he's handed the wine bottle and Jesus starts ranting. "Oh shit! Better drink".

i remember reading somewhere that it was actually killing his voice, but i cant remember the exact details on it now

The fact is isn't easy I like honestly. But yeah he was ripping his throat apart. But he went to lessons to make sure he wouldn't damage himself permanently. It's the fact it's hard for him, that adds to that emotion and desperation.

Yes. I understand the use of a bit of audio tweaking for a DVD if the performer messed up a few notes badly, but this is very heavy-handed and makes him sound downright robotic

​@DadisDad To each their own. Carl Anderson is good but not a favorite to me. Tim gives strength in many parts when he sings. He wanted to play this role for a while and when he got the chance, he did amazing job!

@DadisDad To me a great example to strength that Tim gives as the character Judas, is the Last Supper Scene in this video. His anger in his face and voice when he sings "You sad pathetic man..." and as the scene continues. The emotion how Judas feels about the situation with Jesus is very strong. That Judas himself feels betrayed by Jesus because he feels used and doesn't understand that this was supposed to happen. That is one reason why I like Tim. He attitude and he put is all into this role. What is so great about Carl that makes him good? Everyone has their opinion and what they like. But, sometimes people can just like someone because they believe an actor brings forth more emotion and power to the character then how other's portray that same character.

@DadisDad people don't need to "back them up" that the point of opinions one actor/singer can just connect with people on an emotional or personal level.

@DadisDad Obviously i wasn't the person you were talking to but anyway: I think Tim has mountains of charisma and brings a more sympathic tone to the character making you think more about the subjects at hand. As for the voice, Anderson has a great voice but thats all it is just great. It feels more controlled in my opinion whereas Tim's feels like it comes from his acting and the personality of Judas. I also think his dynamic with the other members of the group, Mary and Jesus is more realistic and interesting. I suppose the style of the show also leans in his favour (costumes, set etc).

@DadisDad Diferent people, have diferent taste ☺️ I respect people who likes another version, so please respect, that I like this one 😊

@@natasjaolsen637 hello pretty How are you doing

I'm glad to see this clarification, I was wondering why his voice sounded a bit digital in this recording

He has a lovely voice and they've made him sound like an angsty robot. What a disservice to him.

@DadisDad I grew up with that version. Tim kills it. Good luck with your trolling.

ikr, that was ICONIC

Ikr when he just whipped out a tambourine I just sort of went WOAH WHAT HUH YES

Correction: that's the best part of the whole musical

I just love him in this role. He is perfect for this role. Wishing him all the best in the future.

Yeah. His voice fits this better than the ‘73 and 2000 did.

@DadisDad I have to disagree with you there he is good but Tim minchin with his Rocky voice sounds better and do not call him a loser!

Yes!

YES

YES PLS

Or king herod's song

7:25

Yes, this! His whole performance is mesmerising from start to fiish.

@DadisDad Carl is very good but Tim is awesome

They just did, last week.!

@@brianaustin5467 Yes! It was the best thing ever! And Minchin was amazing as Judas 😍

@@brianaustin5467 that was the first time i watched any version of jcs and since then I'm OBSESSED with it

@DadisDad show us on the doll where Tim hurt you

@DadisDad Tim naturally has a rock n roll voice. So like, why watch this if it hurts your ears?

@DadisDad : Tim Minchin is an unexpected genius. He writes, acts, plays the piano, sings, and educates . Everything he does is done with passion and intelligence.

@DadisDad we get it, you hate his judas and think other people are better than him and probably dont like his other stuff either, don't keep shitting on people who disagree with you and think hes talented and want to call him a comedy or musical genius. This is a guy performing his dream role, and it connects with people in a way that your favorite Judas connects with you, and that doesn't make anyone wrong or deserving of the vitriol you're spitting out all over this comment section.

I did the same thing last year! As soon as I watched it I was on Amazon and Ebay hunting down the blu ray of it!

Carl Anderson better

Cool profile picture 📷😎

@@martinrosen7408 Thanks! Same too you ;D

@DadisDad Hi! Tim Minchin was my first Judas, and after I watched this production, I watched every other one I could possibly find, including the one with Carl Anderson. But every single one I watched or listened to, I just went right back to Tim. I think it may be the edge he puts into it. And I also love the emotion he brings to it. He's a wonderful actor. I don't find any of the other performances lacking. I think every other actor brings something different to the character and I just adore the way Tim adapted it. I hope that answers your question!

@DadisDad I wasn't going to reply to this comment, but I just feel like I have to now. After reading some other comments on this video, i see you took the time to reply on those as well. I answered your comment and questions very politely, and gave you my opinion. Then you answered with another opinion that invalidated mine. It seems you did the same with every other one I saw. Everyone is entitled to their own feelings and opinions. No need to be rude to say you did not like this performance. Just because you feel that way, does not mean anyone else has to. Maybe try being a bit kinder in future.

@DadisDad @DadisDad The difference is, I listened to your opinion but didn't invalidate it. You just proved me right again in your last reply. You are saying my opinion is WRONG. I never did that to you. Carl Anderson being your favorite is your OPINION. An opinion can be many different things. So just because I said Tim Minchin is MY favorite Judas, does NOT mean my opion is wrong. You can simply disagree with it without being so incredibly negative about it. You also go completely against the first question you asked me, which i answered politely. You clearly are not genuinely curious about why I feel the way I do because you are completely comfortable in just telling me I'm wrong. You're commenting on people's postings and outright saying they are wrong and crazy. That is rude. If you want to talk to people about analyzing music, by all means, go for it. But please, do so in a less rude way.

@DadisDad I never said I know anything about music. I don't. I was saying if you want to discuss music (with people who are knowledgeable about it), go for it. But don't just outright drag the other person's thoughts. I know my opinion and what I like. I happen to love this performance. I didn't come here to try to convince you of anything. I'm not trying to make you like Tim Minchin, or believe something different than when you commented on my post. Im not trying to give tell you critisms, if that's what you're looking for. I came here stating my honest opinion that I just love his performance and he happens to be my favorite Judas. If I can't pinpoint exactly why, that's okay. I wasn't trying to start an argument. You're favorite is Carl Anderson. That is entirely valid. You don't like Tim Minchin's Judas. That is also valid. But please, the problem I have with your comment is that you hopped on my post to purposely just drag Tim. That's not cool. Let's just leave it that you don't like this performance and you adore Carl Anderson. I like Carl Anderson, but Tim is my preferred Judas. Just leave it at that. Have a good night.

This is somehow the most polite argument I have read on a theatre Comment.

I feel like he was having such a blast, and that one damned smirk, when he says Jesus.

@DadisDad I mean Tim Minchin didn’t need autotune either

@DadisDad Tim doesn’t need it either

@DadisDad Why can't you just let people like what they like? It's just a matter of preference. I love Tim Minchin because of his intensity, I like his acting better, and I love his interpretation of the character. I prefer the rawness of his voice also, but I think he's extremely talented and he gives his voice more of a rough quality because that's his style. Your reasons for liking Carl Anderson are totally valid, but why would you waste your time making people feel bad for enjoying something?

“To let her stroke you and kiss your hair.” Whoops

Hey how are you doing today??

@DadisDad a response to my opinion was not needed 😂

@DadisDad Carl Anderson was absolutely amazing that’s pure fact, but it’s all about personal opinion and in my opinion Tim Minchin is the best. That’s ok if you don’t agree with me, we all have different opinions, just grow up and don’t call me crazy.

@DadisDad Hey, can you shut up and let people have their own opinions? Carl Anderson has a good voice but his acting in the show is honestly terrible imo and tim brings more depth into the show. I've seen you commenting on every single fucking comment on this video that mentions Tim minchin and its fucking annoying.

@DadisDad shush

Hey how are you doing today??

Maybe he was persuaded to wear shoes when he saw all the steps and thought of all the stubbed toes he might endure (particularly while running up them) otherwise 😂

@@ezrawells2924 hahahahahaha GREAT!