The Big Picture : Centre - State Rights 

70% of the comments are just for praising Deepak sir...his explainations are so clear he deserves this respect. 🙏

I search in every episode " where is J Sai Deepak"

Sai is hope for future India...we need this kind of sane voices...

J Sai Deepak he is so clear crisp in his vision .. his art of expression is adorable. Gem. Can I as a law student have any chance of working under his guidance

J saie deepak = encyclopedia of indian constitution.

Sir J SAI DEEPAK u r true beauty....i request rstv to plz bring him in all constitutional and legel debates in big picture...so that we can be more enlightened.

plz don't bring any MP in discussion

Sai Deepak ... I mean .. Speechless ... Absolutely masterclass !!!

Satya sir, is our guest faculty at IIMC for media law and ethics. His classes are really gem for us. A lots of interesting things we have learnt from him. Thank you Satya sir

J Sai Deepak.... You are a Rockstar. Superbbb analysis and insights .... Mind blowing and wowww

Dr.L.HANUMANTHAIAH -> *LIVING EXAMPLE WHY POLITICANS HAVE ZERO RESPECT*

If it's constitutional debate please bring J sai Deepak and Satya prakash Economics related: Nitin Desai sir and Ajay dua sir

Before opposing,they must watch it but I'm afraid whether they would understand the insight 😅😂😂

Don't invite politicians.... Because that Will dilute the quality of the program..... Because the person in this episode itself says the center has to get the permission of states to make law on. Citizenship....

For the first time in my life I watched "the big picture" and I really liked it, going to follow all the episodes now onwards 👏

I m a simple girl. I see deepak sir and I click on the video.

I love frank saying at the end of panelists comment "ok alright"

J sai deepak nd satyaprakash sir r giving tough time to few ppl🤣🔥🔥🔥

As soon as that MP spoke...I thought i was watching AajTak Instead of RS tv

Stop inviting such stupid politicians. These nonsense politicians will not think beyond politics.

Sai sir ne to aag laga di.....this shows how he is dedicated for his profession.

A block blaster prime show Sai Deepak sir and sataya prakash sir with Frank Sir

Just wow!You nailed it deepak sir! Boom...🇮🇳💪

RIP earphones : when the MP started speaking

Sandeep Balakrishna should be on this channel. Will be great having him here.

Sai Deepak is asking why this much of pbm while including (CAA)which is not there while excluding (NRC). 1-NRC conducted in one state and CAA will be for every state. 2- Why gov conducted NRC and after several pbm in that it's coming with CAA. If you plan Correct you could have come up with CAA directly. 3) The biggest pbm with this govt is not Consulting with all stakeholders before legislation and after that it will blink without knowing what to do for implementation. This is happening from demonetisation to CAA. With your knowledge you can defend easily today but need a responsible answer from you as we are following you. 🙏

RSTV, thank you for inviting the right types of good, knowledgeable panelists who can speak precisely and concisely in an informed manner without shouting over each other (like on various private news channels). I actually learn the facts and valid views from your "Big Picture" and "Desh Deshantar" programs. Keep up the good work!

one more episode is needed regarding this CAA. How to determine who are religiously persecuted? why religious persecution & not other persecution, is the act actually violating FRs etc etc.. The unbiased insights from this show are excellent. we need more info.

Satya Prakash sir is surely underrated.

Deepak sir, your arguments are point blank range but it does give a insight that it is personal to you.

Good debate. Some points to be mentioned- Though parliament is sovereign in making laws on centers subject, Majority in the parliament doesnt mean 'Majoritarian Polity'.Govt is elected by mere 25-30 crores of indians,not by 130 crores of indians.Its moral responsibilty of the govt to take everyone in confidence. Shaheed Bhagat singh has said that the sanctity of the law can be maintained only if it the popular will of the people.

In the opening statements you can clearly see that the spelling of 'Federal' is wrong in the background. Government channel and such mistakes aren't forgivable. Please correct it.

Wow, Sai Deepak.... Music to my ears... what an orator !

Fairly and transparently consolidate the contents of CAA as well as Relationship between Union and States. Great job sir 🙏

kudos to Satya Prakash and J Sai Deepak. Repository of legal and constitutional machinery.

Satya Prakash Sir Thanks Aa.....👍👍 ♨️😅.....Thanks RS TV.....Jay Maharashtra.....😅♨️ Also J Sai Deepak , Frank Thanks.....👌👌

I want to see J. Sai Deepak and owaisi debate on same....

Hanumantayya's arguments are not constitutionally right.

It's a kind of joy to watch this kind of intellectual discourse.. thank u rstv

Sai deepak unofficial spokesperson of BJP

Deepak sir you fentastically delivered all points . how much clear you are about each and every points , I never saw any law personalitys speaking like this and delivering articles in the constitution such way.

J Sai Deepak nails it everytime!!!

Yu are awesome, j sai sir, it's always a pleasure to to hear yu explaining various provisions of constitution.

My favorite j s deepk.. He has deep knowledge

Hats off for Sai Deepak sir for his straight forward answers 👌

Sai Deepak just awesome.

“Be there as it may” - J Sai Deepak

Saw full episode just to hear J. Deepak Sai🙏

J sai Deepak simply brilliant.

"Sai Deepak is synonymous to Knowledge, Courage and Articulation"

j Sai Deepak ji...pure knowledge❣️

Sai Deepak sir hat's of to you

There is some problem with the Mike from last few weeks. Because which there is some problem with the audio quality. So pls try to remove the noice and unwanted sound.

Thank you Frank sir and sai sir

j sai deepak sir great reply and well explained the whole matter, thank you

J Sai Deepak has nailed the Discussion as always..Such a Grit and conviction he has...Immense Respect for him...

Satya prakash sir explanation is like a child can understand what is the point. Thank you sir

Lets see what CAA says: "Provided that any person belonging to Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi or Christian community from Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan, who entered into India on or before the 31st day of December, 2014 ...... shall not be treated as illegal migrant for the purposes of this Act (Citizenship Act 1955)" By Implication communities other than above 6, that is, Muslims, Jews etc (who entered into India on or before the 31st day of December, 2014) will become Illegal Migrant Now, to be a citizen of India by Registration or Naturalisation (according to Citizenship Act 1955) one has to be a Legal Migrant Therefore, Muslims, Jews etc will not be eligible for Indian citizenship & will become liable to the proceedings of Illegal Migrants Now, if NRC comes in future, communities other than above 6, that is, Muslims, Jews etc (who entered into India on or before the 31st day of December, 2014) will be excluded from NRC because they now become Illegal Migrants by the virtue of CAA 2019 Lets see what Article 14 says: "The State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India" Now, because Article 14 talks about ANY PERSON (not only citizens), it becomes patently clear that the Indian State is blatantly discriminating against communities other than above 6, that is, Muslims, Jews etc (who entered into India on or before the 31st day of December, 2014) It is right that CAA is not for existing citizens of India but there are many who will not be able to prove their citizenship (though the are living in India from decades) as we can see from the Assam experience, in which 19 lakhs out of 3.29 crore were excluded from NRC. The main point here is that, it is not about giving citizenship (which is indeed a sovereign right of a nation) to those who deserves, it is about the process through which it's being done. Citizenship to deserving can be granted through other means, it doesn't necessarily requires to violate the BASIC STRUCTURE of the CONSTITUTION And what we are going to get from all this, if at all it will implemented? Large number of excluded population, who ultimately going to live in detention centres leaving their home in which the are living since decades. Which in turn, could lead to a more divided India, which could lead to more instability in the country Huge burden on the countries exchequer is another elephant in the room, given the precarious economic situation of the country Stability is the sine qua none for a country to become "World Leader". As India is aspiring to become one, it must avoid all things that will leads to instability in the country Instead of waisting its time & resources on things which could be done in a different way, India must focus more on ways to utilise its demographic dividend if it wants to prosper & to reach $5 trillion economy by 2024-25. PS: One must refrain oneself from hero worship & question everything

Sai Deepak sir legal views are always clear as water, but in this episode he lack the practical aspect of the matter. "He even said why should somebody has a problem for inclusion of other beneficiaries on the ground that some section has been excluded?" Well, that's because it is "DISCRIMINATION", the type of discrimination that is not allowed under the Constitution of India, at least in this case. Nowhere in the Constitution does it mentioned that citizenship can be granted based on religion (Art 5 -11). Also, the panelist had not considered the concerned of the NE states, especially Assam and Tripura. Their problem is not because of the exclusion of certain section, instead they just don't want any immigrants, irrespective of religion, in their already crowded and resource scares land where there are only limited opportunities available. The indigenous population and their identity are also being threatened in the process. Take the case of Tripura, the indigenous people there is already a minority in their own land. Fact: most immigrants that will be covered under this law will be from Bangladesh, therefore the fear that the NE people have are legitimate. If we really do have sympathy and concerned for people facing religious prosecution from our neighboring countries, why only these three countries? What about Rohingyas from Myanmar? Are they not our neighbor? Are they not facing the worse religious prosecution!! While it is not a bad law per se, the intention and motives, the political angle, the discrimination and lack of consultation and consensus is the problem. Our Federalism may be unitary based, but don't forget the spirit of "co-operative federalism".

A debate having J Sai Deepak and Satya Prakash is a must watch video....

Very intelligent Depak. India needs talent like you. Raise your voice, we are with you.

jai sai sir you have fully precise knowledge of constitution 🙏🙏

j sai deepak ji is gem of india

Thanks RSTV ND Frank Sir nd Salute to Deepak Sir nd respect for Satya Prakash Sir

All I understand is, CAA and NRIC are like giving solution first and then creating a problem. Why create fear, panic in the country. As if everything else is fine, these were the only last issue needed. We were better before all these started.

Dear RSTV, I have a complaint regarding the voice editing. Every time anyone speaks, the sound of mic(not the voice of person) is heard and then it stops. This is a bit disturbing and reduces the attention. Request RSTV to kindly look into it. Thanks

J sai deepak sir you always amaze with strong facts. You are definitely right here.

It's treat to the ears to listen s. Deepak

J sai Deepak sir u really command respect through ur knowledge not demand it...a great admirar of urs.. Even Satya prakash sir was very relevant...

Satya prakash and jai sai Deepak two gems of India 🙏🙏🙏

My all time fav j sai Deepak ND Frank sir also focused in Deepak sir

@Rajya Sabha TV, Please provide subtitles. It is very hard to actually listen to Mr. Seceratry, which leads to disturbance in the flow of the debate.

the hypocrisy between both the parties when either of them are ruling the centre and states, is my take away from this discussion.

🙏sai ...

Thank you sai 🙏💐

Respect to you J Sai Deepak. Very balanced view and showing the other aspect too. Media only shows hue and cry not the positive side. And absolutely NHRC should chip in for these refugees. Why don't they see Delhi refugees camp and surrounding area they are living in abysmal condition.

Thanks...RSTV plays tremendous job!!

In one voice WE WANT SAI Sir in every panel!

Mr.Sai Deepak you are the diamond

Worth watching episodes 👏

Great discussion with clear perspectives.

Jai sai Deepak sir is simply outstanding 🙏🙏

Completely elated with sai's insightful narration. Yet another clear and pin pointed presentation. I think, BJP govt.should find bureaucrats who could present bill with clear information on first hand, like how Sai did to avoid such political discourse in future.

Awesome point by Sai Deepak at 22:00.

J SAI DEEPAK IS ROCKSTAR ALREADY I HOPE HE GETS INTO REAL POLITICS NOT DOING FENCE SITTING . WE NEED MORE SUCH MAN

OnlyJ Sai Deepak sir explaination is the best.

All of us talking around the CAA but NRC is major concern which was not address in this discussion..which is part of the protest..better if this discussion was carried out in holistic manner

J sai deepak you are impeccable

Deepak sir ..extraordinary... points...

As per the Bill, citizenship can be granted to persons from certain religions, from the three countries, who have faced religious persecution in that country and fled to India. Now on what basis is the government very sure that all of them have illegally migrated to India on the basis of religious persecution? Is religious persecution the only possible reason for a person to migrate illegally? There could be other reasons as well (lack of opportunities, poverty etc. Possible!). How will the government prove that all of them have faced religious persecutions in the three countries? In case they were really persecuted, that is of the past now. Does one carry any document with them or have any proof to say that they were persecuted?

After hearing this I would say this law is good for country.

J sai and satya prakash: deadly combo.

J Sai is brilliant guy..... N had enough thing to talk about

Deepak bahi.. U said- 1. NRC fall primarily under the Foreigners act and under the citizenship act also. 2. Then u said NRC falls under the Citizenship rules. I may have understood it wrong. Sorry for that in advance. But which one is right.

I was in a dilemma regarding this NRC, watching the quint and NDTV and the wire has been frustrating because they site all self- imaginary consequences and mislead their audience. but with this everything is crystal clear

I'm a fan of sai deepak sir now. best regards sir.

Thanks

the bill was passed via constitutional means. I agree the LOk Sabha had majority and it was smooth sailed , BUT in Rajya Sabha( House of elders) there wasnt any majority. The MP had the right when the bill was tabled to counter the arguement and to overturn the Lok Sabha verdict. instead some chose to walkout and some flipped over. The opposition is in shambles. People have problem, there is a process, file the damn PIL in SC. And wait for the verdict, no satisfied, file review plea ask for a bigger bench. Destruction of public property isnt a way forward, The exclusion is based on the recommendation by IB,NIA, A country has a right to protect its stratgic interest. It can't be run on emotional rhetoric and human rights hullabaloo.😒

22:40 Cottrell salute to. Mr. Sai Deepak

Sai Deepak who are you man?? No chance..I will make my child a great lawyer...Extraordinary speech...