No video :(

The biggest mistakes in mapmaking history - Kayla Wolf

Подписаться 20 млн

Просмотров 877 тыс.

50% 1

Travel through the history of mapmaking and discover what big mistakes cartographers made about the world’s geography.
--
For thousands of years, people made both functional maps and what are known as cosmographies, illustrating the earth and its position in the cosmos, often including constellations, gods, and mythic locations. These maps were meant to depict the world's geography, but weren't necessarily useful for navigation and contained some glaring mistakes. Kayla Wolf shares mapmaking’s biggest blunders.
Lesson by Kayla Wolf, directed by Serin İnan, Kozmonot Animation Studio.
Tabula Rogeriana image from Konrad Miller: bit.ly/KonradM...
Support Our Non-Profit Mission
----------------------------------------------
Support us on Patreon: bit.ly/TEDEdPat...
Check out our merch: bit.ly/TEDEDShop
----------------------------------------------
Connect With Us
----------------------------------------------
Sign up for our newsletter: bit.ly/TEDEdNew...
Follow us on Facebook: bit.ly/TEDEdFac...
Find us on Twitter: bit.ly/TEDEdTwi...
Peep us on Instagram: bit.ly/TEDEdIns...
----------------------------------------------
Keep Learning
----------------------------------------------
View full lesson: ed.ted.com/les...
Dig deeper with additional resources: ed.ted.com/les...
Animator's website: www.kozmonot.tv
----------------------------------------------
Thank you so much to our patrons for your support! Without you this video would not be possible! Sid, Kent Logan, Alexandra Panzer, John Hellmann, Poompak Meephian, Chuck Wofford, Daniel Erickson, frank goto, Jayson Hauschild, J D Wallace, Marq Short, Chen Jun Xiang, Adam Pagan, Paul Schultz, Behzad Farhanieh, Anders Sørheim, Wes Winn, Conder Shou, BrushReads, Matt Kennedy, Jonah Dobbs, ntiger, Noname, Hansan Hu, Cameron Burkle, Dhanwanth Varadhan, David D, Zuko Gameplays, Jonathan Bates JBZ, Aria Smith, Mac Hyney, Keith Ellison, robin valero walters, Camehira, Lynne Truesdale, Gatsby Dkdc, Matthew Neal, Jayson Gasper Ayson, Maxwell Ramsby, Dmitry Yuryev, Denis Chon, Julian Oberhofer, Monte Carroll, Eddy, Jay M, Constantino Victor Delgado, Andrea Galvagni, Andrew Tweddle, Laurel-Ann Rice and Fernando A. Endo.

Опубликовано:

26 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 617

@janmelantu7490 2 года назад

Honestly, a giant magnetic rock at the North Pole isn’t the worst explanation for magnetic compasses. It’s certainly more understandable than the electromagneto-thermo-hydrodynamics of a molten iron core to the earth

@markmuller7962 2 года назад

But it's wrong

@earthling_parth 2 года назад

Reminds me of the quote "Reality is stranger than fiction" 😁

@enacrt 2 года назад

"He's a little confused but he got the spirit."

@janmelantu7490 2 года назад

@@markmuller7962 Wrong, yes, but entirely rational. Say you lived in the Middle Ages. You know that compasses point north, unless there’s a magnet nearby. In that case, a compass points toward the magnet. You’re no dummy, you know the earth is round, and so it has a North Pole. Maybe there’s a giant lodestone there? Remember, you don’t have seismometers to tell you that the earth’s core is liquid metal. If neither you nor anyone you know or have even heard of has been to the North Pole, there’s no evidence this polar lodestone doesn’t exist. It’s like thinking the earth is the center of the solar system. If you don’t have telescopes, you can’t see the phases of Venus and you can’t measure stellar parallax. Your observations seem to indicate the earth is in the center of the universe. It’s not hard to construct a working mathematical model of a geocentric solar system. In fact, our planetarium projection equipment still runs on epicyclic gear systems

@KoiYakultGreenTea 2 года назад

They must’ve figured out there’s a strong magnetic force but not sure what it was 🧐

@l.n.3372 2 года назад

Mapmakers have always fascinated me. To tour the world by oceans and seas and land and also somehow map out everything they encounter into fairly accurate maps before things like GPS was invented. It's so difficult to fathom as we live in this modern century, as we benefit from the maps that exist already.

@l.n.3372 2 года назад

@@josephmagliocca3628 I agree for sure. It's very cool and impressive.

@romanski5811 2 года назад

I hate that it's tainted by all the genocide and violence against native people.

@sineadcarty7256 Год назад

You'd love the book "the phantom atlas"

@alphabulblax1649 2 года назад

4:09 Now I'm just imagining someone hearing about that and traveling to Australia hoping to find a paradise, only to find a nightmare desert filled with the most dangerous animals on Earth.

@syabilaazri7834 2 года назад

Maybe that how dragon is made. With how Kangaroo look like and with how many dangerous animals on Australia, that might explain the dragon

@anushk7157 2 года назад

Most of their original inhabitants died because of these travellers.

@GThe-su9kl 2 года назад

There's a book exploring this very concept, but for South America. If I remember well, it's premise is roughly that the paradise is very close to the hellish.

@plantbro1239 2 года назад

THERE be dragons.

@JP-br4mx 2 года назад

I mean that's still Australia, so they were not totally wrong

@DrewHengy 2 года назад

"Here be dragons": the greatest "fill in the homework while the teacher isn't looking" excuse in history.

@roguishpaladin 2 года назад

Y'know, I've been musing about it and...what if it wasn't? What if someone miscommunicated the concept of, say, dragon boats to Middle Eastern and European mapmakers? I know the assumption is that the mapmakers were just superstitious idiots, but perhaps there's a seedling of truth from which their depiction arose?

@tpilot_error404 2 года назад

I believe they found remains of dinosaurs. Footprints , weird creatures .Some today Crocs are still impressive.

@komiks42 2 месяца назад

I always understood it as "we have no fucing clue whats there" but it looked better for the mapmaker to put SOMETHING there.

@DB-me7ol 2 года назад

There is something extraordinarily flattering about the mapmakers believing our ancestors coexisted with dragons and beasts.

@l.n.3372 2 года назад

Either they assume our ancestors tamed the dragons and the mythical creatures. Or the dragons tamed the humans into thinking they were the top dogs xD

@DB-me7ol 2 года назад

How to train your local human 💀

@l.n.3372 2 года назад

@@DB-me7ol "Remember that there are different types of humans. The flogpuff is very gentle and likes to play with animals. But beware the snovbo, because they think they're better than us dragons."

@jimmytimmy3680 2 года назад

People still believe in imaginary deities today. Think about what future humans will think of today's humans.

@l.n.3372 2 года назад

@@jimmytimmy3680 Well there's stuff like the tooth fairy, etc.

@vido7027 2 года назад

"There weren't really dragons anywhere on Earth." Komodo dragons: Am I a joke to you?

@mikelor84 2 года назад

LOL

@robertfaler1947 2 года назад

I think that they are a joke. It's funny to see a komodo dragon vomit, poop, and then run away when they sense danger.

@whyiseverysinglehandletaken2 2 года назад

@@robertfaler1947 wtf aren't they like the apex of the island why would they just run away

@robertfaler1947 2 года назад

@@whyiseverysinglehandletaken2 They are apex predators but they are scared of humans, according to a National Geographic article I read years ago.

@jakepullman4914 2 года назад

@@robertfaler1947 Clever girls. Even if you're the most badass thing around, it's wise to be wary of something you've never seen before.

@kaydubsthekoifish 2 года назад

This also raises an interesting question. What maps did said cultures have, and how did they look? Cause I doubt the Native Americans, Australians and other cultures didn't use some form of mapmaking themselves, just in a different format than the Europeans did.

@Username-le4eq 2 года назад

I know polynisians used bendy sticks and shells to map constellations for their travel i think

@kaydubsthekoifish 2 года назад

@@Username-le4eq That's actually a really cool idea! I didn't know that.

@floralfemme4700 2 года назад

I think ted ed has a video on Polynesian way finding that can answer your question.

@joermnyc 2 года назад

Depends on the people… there’s a culture in the Amazon that doesn’t have words for north, east, etc… their sense of direction is entirely based around the river, they know “down the river”, “up the river”, and “away from the river”.

@thadsul 2 года назад

Like writing, cartography is something that is extremely useful but not strictly necessary, as locating yourself and places can be a knowledge passed on and learned orally or by experience. The peoples on the coast of Brazil knew how to get to the inca empire on the other side of the continent, there were known paths and a knowledge of a continental expanse of land (look up the Aleixo Garcia expedition). Same for the huge area on the north, were people would know which river on the amazon basin led where. (I have heard the story where in the Spix and Von Martius expedition, one of the scientists asked a amazonian indian how he knew where he was, and the guy kept explaining and drawing in the sand the outline of the major rivers, from the Andes to the Ocean)

@adriank8676 2 года назад

Went from calm map analyzing to “oh yeah there was genocide” so frickin fast.

@Mystixor 2 года назад

Yeah right?

@blossomentrails3398 2 года назад

I know right? Shocking. Imagine how the people experiencing it must have felt.

@uanime1 2 года назад

Got to shove the woke ideology somewhere. Though I can think of somewhere else they can shove it.

@adriank8676 2 года назад

@@blossomentrails3398 yeah but sometimes I just want to learn about maps. Everyone knows what happened but it loses its value the more you bring it up.

@JP-br4mx 2 года назад

just like those colonisers. from wanting spice to commit mass genocide

@damedesuka77 2 года назад

I'm curious about how people of the past created these maps. How can they predict/guess the shape of a continent? They only had ships and could only see limited length of an island's coastline from it. No photography, no air balloon, so how did they do it?

@antonioscendrategattico2302 2 года назад

Maths, mostly. Using accounts of sailors and explorers and computing travel times, positions of stars in the sky, notable landmarks and even direct observation they could approximate the shape and position of lands. Needless to say, they often got things wrong, but that's just how it is.

@Cin9999 2 года назад

Well this video answered your question lol: They could not. All the maps back then were really really bad. Very educated ppl could do approximations based on math and overlay of different maps of different perspectives (i.e. maps made by ppl from different countries) but even that was terribly inaccurate.

@enacrt 2 года назад

If you take maps of this period (1400-1700), you'll see that the Mediterranean is quite accurate, being traveled and chartes over and again since the Phoenicians, and that it gets progressively weirder and wonkier from there: the British Isles are deformed, Scandinavia is often shown as an island, and much of Africa south of the Sahara is just plain wrong (some maps show the Niger flowing into the Nile through Lake Chad!)

@maxithalo7796 2 года назад

I know theres a LOT of math involved, but I'm not nearly smart enough to know how lol

@gantoniopatriarca9520 2 года назад

The first iteration of maps were just drawn as they look from the ground, if the lake looks round, draw it round. The second iteration we learned how to use sextants and the sun and stars to accurately measure latitude. These maps were accurate north and south, but east and west were a hot mess. The third iteration did not come until timekeeping had been invented. Finally east and west were accurate. Today we have refined the process, and we now have an airplane/satellite top down view to go off of.

@angrygoose23 2 года назад

Imagine a medieval mapmaker talking to someone from today: “How do you guys deal with the dragons in Asia? “Uh… there are no dragons.” “Wha- seriously? What about the sea serpents in the Pacific Ocean?” “No sea serpents either.” “What about sirens? There’s gotta be sirens!” “Nope, never heard of them.” *”my whole life is a lie…”*

@enacrt 2 года назад

"What about Australia? I heard it's a paradise with fairies and cool stuff." "Well, actually..."

@angrygoose23 2 года назад

@@enacrt haha, dreams crushed forever…

@Kisamon 2 года назад

"The same goes for this whole conversation."

@Paul-A01 2 года назад

I would have told them they're real but a lot smaller than we thought

@suzannepottsshorts 2 года назад

Plenty of sirens here in Iowa, it's the tornadoes you have to worry about.

@youtubehistorywonjae 2 года назад

I am Korean translator of this video, and I had some very meaningful time with learning about what was strength and weaknesses of mapmaking progresses. Thanks to TED-Ed team for giving me an opportunaties to translate this awesome video!

@greatthings1956 2 года назад

بالفعل، إنه مذهل

@youtubehistorywonjae 2 года назад

@@greatthings1956 شكرًا لك! Thanks :)

@alperkures5268 2 года назад

I think the video should have included Ottoman admiral, navigator, geographer and cartographer Piri Reis. His maps were inspiring for history of cartography.

@syneffo9942 2 года назад

This is eye-opening, I'm surprised on how far cartography has gone and how maps became more accurate as time passed, if only this video existed when I was doing a project about it ;-;

@stuartsaint4581 2 года назад

Probably most accurate to describe most of these as "history's best possible maps given current context and knowledge."

@alexginger1948 2 года назад

“We are the middle children of history. Born too late to explore earth, born too early to explore space.” -Anonymous

@runswithraptors 2 года назад

Spoiler: ain't nobody exploring space besides our probes

@phuonganh149 2 года назад

Internet be like, "and where did you discover that quote, biatch?"

@DiMadHatter 2 года назад

Born just in time to explore tge internet

@sakshamsrivastava2178 2 года назад

Omg!! This literally blew my mind!!!!

@iphoneUser564 2 года назад

We can explore the ocean

@aarspar 2 года назад

Southeast Asian here. Want to know why Southeast Asia isn't really well-known in the world stage today? The answer is in the first part of the video, here be dragons, and we're doing our best to keep them a secret. Those early Europeans knew too much.

@angrygoose23 2 года назад

*is that where the plague came from?*

@nunyabiznes33 2 года назад

We keep our's locked inside mountains to keep them away from the prying eyes of the foreigners.

@taosamundo Год назад

Shh! Make sure to just pretend this is a joke

@mewmew8932 Год назад

Let it be known that we've shrunken down the dragons to make them seem less deadly

@jessical4866 2 года назад

This makes me excited to think about how people hundreds of years from now look back on OUR maps. What have they discovered since then? How has the format changed? Who will they remember from our time?

@Username-le4eq 2 года назад

Prob not much about the earth, but probably about the universe.

@jessical4866 2 года назад

@@Username-le4eq I was actually thinking about the ocean! There’s still a lot of unexplored seafloor, so it’s not like we can’t improve our maps of Earth.

@setcheck67 2 года назад

@@Username-le4eq You'd be surprised considering how current maps still get the scale wrong in terms of actual land area. Many places are misrepresented to be larger than they should be(like the British Isles, which get beaten by Florida+Georgia alone).

@kobewankenobi8926 2 года назад

@@setcheck67 that’s not a problem that can be improved on… 500 years from now maps will have the same problem as no flat map can accurately display areas.

@monicabrandhuber1228 2 года назад

One of the most interesting map mistakes recently noticed: After the launch of the Sputnik satellite in 1957, people realized that the supposed positions of certain islands were off by a few miles/kilometers. This was discovered because scientists had calculated when Sputnik was supposed to fly over different places on earth (so people could go out and see it). However, the timings of the sightings over these islands were off. Since the timings were correct in other places, clearly the math around the speed/trajectory/etc. of Sputnik was correct, and so therefore the recorded geographic positions of the islands were wrong. With the ubiquity of photographic satellites in the modern day, it's safe to say we have a pretty good idea of what the terrestrial landscape looks like, although any map (not globe) is always going to be distorted because it's simply impossible to accurately project a 3D surface on a 2D object.

@stuffes3495 2 года назад

Trippiest quote Ted Ed ever put out 0:02

@jimmymarrs1556 2 года назад

I don’t think it’s fair to criticize these mapmakers for not being 100% accurate all the time. They did the best they could with what they had and probably did a better job than any of us could do with their limited information.

@averageday 2 года назад

She sounds so condescending too

@gfhit7520 2 года назад

@@averageday very

@jens-kristiantofthansen9376 2 года назад

Yes, I found her tone frankly grating. The dismissiveness of the German mapmaper who marked the Americas as a thin sliver of land where the east coast would be. He was entirely right to do so - he mapped according to what was understood at the time and as such took a fairly scientific approach to that; We know it's there, but not how much of it there is. It's one of the poorer videos of this type, sadly, as it mostly displayed that whoever is behind it may know maps but has what appears to be a very thin sliver of understanding of historical context.

@DoomFinger511 2 года назад

The reason the myth of the Dragon is so prevalent in Asia is because of the high concentration of dinosaur bones there. When they found partial dinosaur skeletons or skulls they used their imagination to fill in the rest and thus created the legendary dragons.

@MysteryMonarch 2 года назад

This is wrong. Maybe just maybe the so-called science of carbon dating is highly flawed. The reason dragon tales exist in every culture worldwide is that simply humans lived with them. Dragons demanded sacrificial animals and humans or they would torch your village or spew water on it. Knights were known to slay dragons as well, they didn't just find bones and make this up. Dinosaur is just a modern renaming of the very real dragon.

@DoomFinger511 2 года назад

@@MysteryMonarch I appreciate your dedication to that troll reply.

@MysteryMonarch 2 года назад

Every culture on Earth from europe to the Mayans represent dragons. Many had no contact with each other. You believe that they all found bones and made them a huge part of their religions , art, and culture uniformly. Read the story of the Wawel dragon in Poland. They were real and even intelligent.

@Twas-RightHere 2 года назад

2:10 The original Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy

@DqwertyC 2 года назад

Regarding California, I once saw a map in a museum with a note next to the "Iland of California" that stated: "This California was in times past thought to beene a part of the Continent and so made in all maps, buy by further discoveries was found to be an Iland long i700 legues".

@nenenindonu 2 года назад

Turkish admiral Piri Reis, according to historians, was the first cartographer to give an accurate description of America along with a deep insight on circumnavigation of Africa as he presented his work to the Ottoman Sultan Selim I.

@alexginger1948 2 года назад

Not Turkish rather Ottoman. No Turkish nationality existed at this point and his ethnic background is not necessarily turkic

@nenenindonu 2 года назад

@@alexginger1948 Nonsense the concept of Turkish and Turkey existed since the middle ages whereas Ottoman is the dynastic name... Turkish power had become a reality , to the extent that a chronicler of the Third Crusade already gave the name " Turchia ' to Seljuk Asia Minor . The Cambridge Illustrated History of the Middle Ages Volume 2. 950-1250 pp.465

@papazataklaattiranimam 2 года назад

@@alexginger1948 his nationality was Ottoman and ethnicity was Turkic

@alexginger1948 2 года назад

@@nenenindonu The name of the realm is the Ottoman empire both by governments and commoners , one chronicle isn’t enough to change historical facts and his ethnicity is not even known. You are just assuming he is turkic based on wrong ideas or maybe wishful thinking

@nenenindonu 2 года назад

@@alexginger1948 Another illogical sentence, China was mostly named after its ruling dynasties like the Ming, Tang, Han yet China was still 'China' and its people Chinese, you seem to have a poor knowledge about this topic I suggest you to do some basic research before getting into an argument

@noix666dezephir 2 года назад

Those violins in the background make this wonderful video feel both epic and nostalgic

@MegaDurvin 2 года назад

My favorite one is “a Mapp of Virginia Discouered To Ye Hills”, a detailed 1651 map of the Chesapeake Bay area depicting the Pacific as being right on the other side of the Appalachians

@agamer5953 2 года назад

Ah yes utopia, filled with creature that want to drop the beat of your heart to zero

@l.o.b.2433 2 года назад

"There weren't really dragons anywhere on earth" You really gotta do us like this, huh? This is the saddest thing someone ever told me without realising the tragedy.

@adorablegodzilla5628 2 года назад

That blob isn't a correctly shaped Sub-Sahara Africa. I assume the makers of this video believe dangling bit next to it is also a super accurate version of India too.

@sergioperez1543 2 года назад

Why are people disliking this?

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

Because it reeks of wokeness to them?

@xmichael8238 2 года назад

A rock sorrounded by a whirlpool... That sounds a like Antartica... A continent surrounded by the raging vortex that is the antarctic circumpolar current

@frostincubus4045 2 года назад

They just depict the wrong pole😂

@darksecret965 2 года назад

@@frostincubus4045 and a wrong hole

@poggers213 Год назад

@@darksecret965 Thats what she said

@martijn3151 2 года назад

Just imagine making a world map without being able to make use of satellites or even airplanes. Even with all the mistakes they made, it was an extraordinary feat.

@micahbush5397 2 года назад

2:35 Judging by the scale, the Chinese apparently thought Japan was much larger than Africa.

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

And no one mentioned that as a mistake. While European maps were seemingly depicted as the most primitive of the bunch.

@russiasgreatestspinmachine4096 2 года назад

"It replicates the curvature of the Earth by compression of areas farthest away from China (most obviously the extreme horizontal squeeze of Europe), their reduced size making both a geographical and a political statement." The scaling was intentional dude, the focus is on East Asia, so they inflate it on purpose.

@micahbush5397 2 года назад

@@russiasgreatestspinmachine4096 If that's the case, then why is Japan (or is it supposed to be Korea?) so massively inflated relative to China? If the point is to centralize China, then one would expect it to be smaller or equal to its actual size, not exaggerated.

@russiasgreatestspinmachine4096 2 года назад

@@micahbush5397 "by compression of areas farthest away from China " it is also based on distance. Since Korea and Japan are closer they are obviously bigger. Perhaps it is to help detail those two places, as the bigger a map is, the more accurate a point on that map would be. The sizing wouldn't matter as we have established that it was intentional.

@hamelconsultancyllc 2 года назад

I thought this video was going to be about actual mistakes not just poor maps due to insufficient knowledge… poor click bait title

@brimstoner982 2 года назад

They did tho

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

It was never about actual knowledge. It was about supporting a "woke" narrative.

@daltonmichelsen6046 2 года назад

Beautiful animation ❤️

@Jake-isCool 2 года назад

Love you ted ed, keep making fantastic videos

@Dream_soul26 2 года назад

The last line 04:31 'There were people and culture all over the world, many of whom eradicated by those who put their lands on world maps' summarises transition of humans from hunter gatherers to so called developed modern humans.

@cassieperalta7859 2 года назад

TED ED: "Here Be Dragons" SCP fans: starts sobbing uncontrollably

@ruhup1xel 2 года назад

Mesmerizing Ted solves mysteries💙

@musicsnow1963 2 года назад

Oh yeah😅

@dragonguy556 2 года назад

This was a very well done and enlightening video! Keep it up Ted Ed! And may you do more history vs?

@illyasvielemiya9059 2 года назад

the drawing in this video are so beautiful

@thituannhanguyen2056 21 день назад

Did you mean you are so beautiful

@ippolit23 2 года назад

The first Australians probably met the giant lizard Megalania - look it up! - a real-life dragon if ever there was one.

@jorgesoberon6866 2 года назад

All the xvi century Spanish maps depict baja California as a peninsula. The first time Baja California was shown as an Island is in Herrera's Historia (1601), an error corrected by Kino (1705).

@joaobello7179 2 года назад

Unknown waters exist: Mapmakers: DRAGONS!!!

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

Preachy as ever, Ted.

@renafielding945 2 года назад

I have always been fascinated by maps and mapping my environment. Translating the tactile world onto paper.

@Weissenschenkel 2 года назад

I love the narrator pronunciation when she says "Waldseemüller" (forest-sea-miller.) Second, it's impossible to depict a spherical shape in a plain surface. The Mercator although heavily misrepresenting land size was somewhat accurate regarding distances. Vikings also had a good map from the Americas since they crossed the Pacific and the Atlantic way before anybody else on big vessels.

@christopherx7428 20 дней назад

I think you mean the North Sea and the Atlantic, I have a hard time imagining vikings in the Pacific... 😉

@jyusatsu 2 года назад

The last part of the video hit hard. Many small civilization had been eradicated by the colonizers for the sake of expanding their territories and power.

@goldenvulture6818 2 года назад

Never forget colonization and colonialism was committed by non-White people & non-Christians as well as by White People & Christians

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

The last part hit very hard, in a preachy way.

@joelmonteiro1419 2 года назад

Not really. The vast, vast majority of the eradication (almost 100%) was done by diseases, completely out of control by the explorers. European conquerors were ruthless, no question about that, but European diseases did the blunt of the work.

@joelmonteiro1419 2 года назад

@@DogseatDogs it felt like a last minute addition to the video.

@gs4ndy175 2 года назад

"we" have to accept it whether ones like it or not...

@RyanCoomer 2 года назад

I regularly visit buffets in different cities around the states. Before I go to a buffet, I will place 6 corndogs in my jacket pockets. After entering the buffet, I sneak the corndogs into some of the fried food section trays. It is such a joy for me to see other customers of the buffet eat my corndogs thinking they were part of the buffet.

@luisandrade2254 2 года назад

The history of cartography is absolutely amazing

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

Man, if this video doesn't have some narrative to support. Very objective facts, Ted.

@valentinaciccarelli7228 2 года назад

So you believe in flat Earth, dragons or that Europeans didn't steal land from natives. I'm curious about which one it is

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

@@valentinaciccarelli7228 So you *actually* think I believe any of those three "facts" you listed. I'm flattered. You just demonstrate my point through and through. Thank you, "kind" stranger.

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

@@valentinaciccarelli7228 Thank you for debasing yourself before me.

@flanderstruck3751 2 года назад

Muh genocide

@gfhit7520 2 года назад

I don't see many mistakes in any of the maps shown... they actually were pretty accurate with the information available to them, plus it must be remarked that the purpose of maps was not necessarily the same of today (if rulers needed a decent visualisation of their surroundings, nobody travelled through the whole world like today), it made perfect sense to introduce Here be dragons (incidentally, a nice way to admit ignorance) or features like the Eden garden. I think the title of the video is incorrect and misleading.

@vivanakashbeere2854 2 года назад

All progress comes through mistakes and primitive experiments, what leads to truth is actually the will to change vision to reality, though vision doesn't match reality, surely enough will lead to progress, or help in progress.

@DogseatDogs 2 года назад

They highlight all the Europeans' mistakes while not mentioning other mistakes of the other nations and cultures. How unbiased of them.

@DrastikTrap Год назад

This video does exactly the opposite of what it was meant to do - educate. Instead used as a smear campaign against the West.

@johnnicholas1657 2 года назад

In fairness there are Komodo dragons there. So the mapmakers were spot on

@SerGio-xs9ss 15 дней назад

Dinosaur bones have been found in ancient times. The legend of dragons must come from there...

@medusagorgon8432 2 года назад

I adore and collect historical maps and this just made my day! Much appreciated!🗺️

@themightybunghole1088 2 года назад

This is why I subscribe! Incredible, interesting, evolving, and educational! Thanks for your work!

@plumeater1 2 года назад

"There aren't any dragons in South East Asia" Komodo Dragons: *Adios*

@10hawell 2 года назад

Worst are netflix shows maps, especially history documents

@goldenvulture6818 2 года назад

Such as?

@BigattckFirecat 2 года назад

"Every map is wrong" Even google maps

@v.miguel.almeida 2 года назад

Talking about ancient cartography without referencing the Portuguese and their advanced and top-secret maps is unbelievable and a symptom of general world ignorance of portugueses history, the discoveries and birth of globalisation.

@larsmunch4536 День назад

I am completely sure, that Mercator's map of the north pole can't be created in what we now know as Mercator projection.

@teawrecks1243 2 года назад

to be fair australia is filled with things that may as well be mythic beasts to the people of yore. a bird that laughs like a human? a beast that leaps on two legs as tall as a man that carries its young in a pocket? a creature with the beak of a duck, the tail of a beaver and the fur of an otter that laid eggs and was venomous?

@basantprasadsgarden8365 2 года назад

Everybody was a gangster Until a *Sea* was declared a *River* and a *River* was declared a *Sea* In the Map....

@scythal 2 года назад

Caspian -Lake- Sea: *sweats*

@pollutingpenguin2146 2 года назад

And of course the video had to end with an anti-white/anti-european conclusion.

@Hfled2 23 дня назад

Those Spanish cartographers in the 1500’s were just waaaay ahead of their time depicting California as an island cut off from the rest of the country! 😂

@Oneiroi0 2 года назад

"....There are no dragon on earth." Komodo Dragons be like : *Excuse me.*

@nurboldospambetov1010 2 года назад

Does anyone know the name of the violin bit at the end?

@koriw1701 2 года назад

2:00 ~ ibn Hawqal is not the name of a man, it is the name of a man's *son.* In Arabic, 'Ibn' stands for "son of," so essentially Ibn Hawqal means "son of Hawqal."

@rayanbakhtiar8440 2 года назад

ye bro no -offence i understand how pronounication of different langauges can be hard , but they really did mispronounce that name

@koriw1701 2 года назад

@@rayanbakhtiar8440no offense taken. 🤜🤛❗️

@justsaadunoyeah1234 9 дней назад

Bro ibn Hawqal is the son of a man who is a man himself so ibn hawqal is a man@@koriw1701

@XxskidudekidxX 2 года назад

3:10 Martin-who now?!

@jorgeraminhos4133 2 года назад

I'm really disappointed with TedEd, this video promotes ignorance. Ancient world maps give us a way of glimpsing into the perspective and worldview of our ancestors. This "mistakes" are what makes them so interesting and important to preserve and learn from. The best way of appreciating this old maps is to understand the mastery behind them, but also to view them from their perspective of the age when they here made. To compare these old maps to modern ones in an attempt to ridiculise them is just sad.

@DionysusFTW 2 года назад

I'm not sure the despiction of Australia with all those tragons and absurd animals is wrong. The only thing they missed is that it's located somewhere like 10 km from the sun

@halepauhana153 2 года назад

If you were transported back in time by 500 years or more, no GPS, no satellite imagery, no accurate time-pieces, only the most rudimentary equipment for measuring latitude by sun and star sightings, and working with the anecdotal reports of boastful captains and superstitious sailors, let's see you do any better. As a qualified Cartographer myself, I am in awe of what mapmakers of the era were able to do, and the steady progress over the years.

@havock76 2 года назад

"Without Geography, you're nowhere" -Unknown

@alparslankorkmaz2964 2 года назад

Nice video.

@jaimel88 2 года назад

Wow, that was a packed >5 minutes! 👏🏼

@spencercochran3908 2 года назад

I like how the globe spins on a flat plane, and not on the axis of the stand, in a video about bad maps hah

@abdillahfamilychannel8418 Месяц назад

If you see those Al Idrisi map, north become south and west become east. That map very accurate for that time...

@cesar.leyvag 2 года назад

I kind of would like we keep drawing dragons and other cool creatures on maps

@dakumasuta1303 2 года назад

thanks to scp whenever i hear "here be dragons" i start crying

@atriagotler 2 года назад

"A Guide to Plesant Journeys into Faraway Lands" sounds like a medival version of hitchhikers guide to the galaxy xD

@tonidiwan5142 24 дня назад

The early T-shaped mappa mundi don't show north on top but east on top. Thus making the large bit on top Asia, the left bit Europe and the right bit Africa. Look at them the proper way and they don't seem that silly any more.

@trempire7514 2 года назад

Our Ancestors worked so hard for future generations! Can't even imagine it!

@Aninkovsky 2 года назад

Actually, it's true, since Komodo Dragons are indeed in Southeast Asia, in Indonesia...

@adityakhabiya5348 2 года назад

Wow your voice is so soothing

@Ritikkumar-fr4hy 2 года назад

i am from india i like your video

@hayafatimah7823 2 года назад

I’m just amazed how Muslims work hard to know the maps very well before anyone else and they draw it better than anyone which means they are ahead of their time

@MIRAAJMUHAMMAD_666 2 года назад

Indeed 😊😁

@xNazgrel Год назад

Those are upside down Ptolemy world map

@gomez7166 2 года назад

“Here be dragons.” *Me remembering those paper dragons coming out of a box...*

@Jon.A.Scholt 2 года назад

"A correctly portrayed portrayal of sub-Saharan Africa" Um... If you say so...

@ancientpear6780 2 года назад

The song that plays towards the end is really nice, anyone know where I could find it?

@dynamosaurusimperious2718 2 года назад

Well this video was just so interesting and I love it

@BeedrillYanyan 2 года назад

Well those last statements came out of nowhere and felt unnecessary.

@windyplaysgacha1511 2 года назад

"Here be dragons" **sobs in scp 1762**

@owenmersk4626 2 года назад

Thank you for this

@teoengchin 2 года назад

There used to be dragons in South East Asia. We used to hunt them for food when I was very young. Unfortunately they were too delicious and were hunted to extinction before the Europeans arrived

@MrTeknotronic 2 года назад

I've never personally feared death by lobster but i will now reconsider my position on the matter.

@GurpreetSingh-ml8ct 2 года назад

Narrator's voice is so soothing!

@CookedMeat 2 года назад

Born too late to explore the continent, born too early to explore the seas, but born just in time to create fan fiction of the planet we live in and publish as official work because no one bothers or have the ability to debunk!

@DoomFinger511 2 года назад

How were you born to early to explore the seas?

@CookedMeat 2 года назад

@@DoomFinger511 Take a look at these abominations created by the people who thought they are born to explore the seas.

@zandrewmorano4747 2 года назад

@@DoomFinger511 He's probably talking millions of years ago

@aniketshukla3824 2 года назад

Here be dragons. Had me laughing wildly. 😄😄

@BS-vx8dg 2 года назад

At 1:44 there's an error. The T-O map shown is fine, but the narrator describes it as "the world's landmass divided roughly in the shape of a "T" and surrounded by a ring of ocean". Well, the last part is correct, but the "T-O" map is named for the shape of its prominent bodies of water. The vertical staff of the T is the Mediterranean Sea, the right "wing" of the T is the Nile River, and the left "wing" of the T is usually regarded as the Don River (though I have seen others suggested). So the land is not in the shape of a T, the land is divided into three parts, with Asia at the top, above the full bar of the T, Africa at the right of the vertical Mediterranean staff, and Europe on the left. Here's a crude, but very famous, simplification: upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/70/T_and_O_map_Guntherus_Ziner_1472.jpg/330px-T_and_O_map_Guntherus_Ziner_1472.jpg