Тёмный

The Bizarre Case of Dellen Millard and Mark Smich 

That Chapter
Подписаться 2 млн
Просмотров 2 млн
50% 1

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

26 сен 2019

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 4,6 тыс.   
@wolfsbaneandnightshade2166
@wolfsbaneandnightshade2166 4 года назад
I'm from Hamilton. When the guilty verdict was announced I was on the bus, someone yelled it out and everyone cheered.
@paulasimone8356
@paulasimone8356 4 года назад
Wonderful
@reallyhotheat
@reallyhotheat 4 года назад
Nice meme
@leea8706
@leea8706 4 года назад
I’m from the U.K., but I have a lot of family in Burlington and Hamilton, I visited when I was younger and absolutely loved it, Canadians are so friendly and kind, Canada will always hold a special place in my heart
@Val.Kyrie.
@Val.Kyrie. 4 года назад
Grew up in Ancaster and lived in Hamilton after college. Grandparents lived there my whole life off Aberdeen, had cousins that went to Mac.
@andrewhussey4538
@andrewhussey4538 4 года назад
Don't remember that level of excitement lol, I do remember the case for sure, but then I was in Brantford so a city or two over... people definitely knew what was up, it caused a lot of discussion around such advertising sellers
@northpappyflappy
@northpappyflappy 4 года назад
The wife begging for her husband back was heart breaking 💔
@danyamariegeddes8320
@danyamariegeddes8320 4 года назад
😭 I would be so broken
@Akearsing0603
@Akearsing0603 4 года назад
I teared up. Horrible
@williss11
@williss11 4 года назад
northpappyflappy Yeah, she shouldn’t had said to go with them Incase they steal it. It’s always risky when you do transactions with people online. It’s better to let them go at a test drive alone or take a gun Incase
@annettetalavera3739
@annettetalavera3739 4 года назад
I'm still balling😪😪😪😪
@dontbefatuousjeffrey2494
@dontbefatuousjeffrey2494 4 года назад
Her palpable anger when she said "It was just a truck!" The senselessness of it all had already struck her hard. I really felt her. It gave me chills.
@luluhussain7592
@luluhussain7592 3 года назад
I just cried when Tim wife cried and said "it is just a truck!!" That hurts so much, it was obvious she loved him a lot
@firetruckoff
@firetruckoff 3 года назад
she's the one that told him to go... to protect the truck, she feels to blame
@doranvee5944
@doranvee5944 3 года назад
It was like every word dripped with tears of her soul. God bless her and their child.
@levisguy53
@levisguy53 3 года назад
indeed, i felt for her too. i touched a nerve more than other horrific losses that have been covered by this channel.
@davidimrie6916
@davidimrie6916 3 года назад
She loved him so much she got remarried 2 years after Tim's death.
@doranvee5944
@doranvee5944 3 года назад
@@davidimrie6916 I think you are being unfair. She did love her husband, but i have told my wife that if I die, she is free to remarry. I want her happy. Im sure Tim did too.
@richardbwanika2166
@richardbwanika2166 3 года назад
To be loved like the way Tim's wife loved him is to be a truly blessed man. R.I.P Tim and may God bless and watch over your wonderful family.
@Jacob-df5hr
@Jacob-df5hr 4 года назад
The way his wife says "it was just. A truck." really underlines the banality of it all.
@lololandify
@lololandify 3 года назад
I know :(
@andreasjohansson3813
@andreasjohansson3813 3 года назад
It broke my heart, poor woman. :(
@TheCrypticSyx
@TheCrypticSyx 3 года назад
I know I'm super late but it was never about the truck, sadly. It was just opportunity for these pieces of shit
@andreasjohansson3813
@andreasjohansson3813 3 года назад
@@TheCrypticSyx I think everyone understood that. 🥳
@cUser691
@cUser691 3 года назад
@Jacob Agree w you about his wife Thx too for word “ banality” - forced me to look it up since hadn’t used SAT vocab in a while. Thx , man
@emmabbyreborns341
@emmabbyreborns341 3 года назад
"It was just a truck". That being the truest and saddest part of all. Poor young man. My deepest condolences to his wife and family.
@luluhussain7592
@luluhussain7592 3 года назад
Yes exactly, I cried so hard, that poor wife seemed to love him so much 💔
@heyysimone
@heyysimone 3 года назад
You can hear it in her voice when she says that
@TheRukisama
@TheRukisama 3 года назад
Yeah it's really too bad the scumbags who did it get to live out their lives.
@raspberryroses6362
@raspberryroses6362 3 года назад
@@GaslightingIsEvil she didn’t mean that they killed him over the truck, she’s upset because it was something that if he didn’t go to buy the truck he would of still been here, and probably the fact that trucks are listed for sale all the time. She’s upset that out of all the listed trucks, he ended up going to see the one who would end up being a trap to murder someone so senselessly. If they had clicked on any other listing, he would still be here.
@raspberryroses6362
@raspberryroses6362 3 года назад
It hit me so hard I actually got choked up and I’m not the type to be emotional watching these. Something so inconsequential that ended a life before he even got to experience.. Really tugs at the heart strings.
@mercielynmarmolejos7888
@mercielynmarmolejos7888 Год назад
Saddest part is the wife begging for her husband back. I don’t think anyone has any idea how that really feels. To see the one person you love and care for disappeared. Every time I hear her say “it’s just a truck” makes my heart break and I cry. Truly the saddest thing anyone can ever go through. God bless her heart and soul for his daughter too.
@CantTellYou
@CantTellYou Год назад
What’s (extra) insane to me, is all of that happened BEFORE the other 2 murder trials happened... already had a life sentence, then got a second, and he STILL tried to deny the third? I guess the idiot thought he had a chance of appeal 🙄
@mybraineatseverything7404
@mybraineatseverything7404 3 года назад
This story breaks my heart. They didn't even want the truck - they just wanted to murder a good man. I hope neither of them has a good night's sleep as long as they live - and I hope they both live a very, very long and miserable time.
@imomediaimomedia6648
@imomediaimomedia6648 4 года назад
Anyone else out there HOOKED on THAT CHAPTER videos ?
@kaylaelias5947
@kaylaelias5947 4 года назад
Yes!!!
@ofthedarknessthemoonlight5412
@ofthedarknessthemoonlight5412 4 года назад
Me too.
@oxyrisin
@oxyrisin 4 года назад
I’m not really hooked but they’re pretty damn. good.
@SabbyTheNerd
@SabbyTheNerd 4 года назад
YES!!!!!!!!!
@darkegreen
@darkegreen 4 года назад
Nope just u, he doesn't have 180k subs.
@brianm4178
@brianm4178 4 года назад
Follow your gut feeling... People don't come to look at things when it's dark out, if you feel weird then stop immediately. Don't feel guilty, don't apologise, just survive
@docsnake
@docsnake 3 года назад
People have wanted to come and see my cars that I have sold in the past after dark. I always always say no, and have no problem telling them why.
@darude2893
@darude2893 3 года назад
I selll kitties and someone came at 9:30 to see them. I can gladly say I’m still alive
@Nobddy
@Nobddy 3 года назад
@@darude2893 daredevil
@Andrew-jn9yp
@Andrew-jn9yp 3 года назад
I was gonna hookup with this girl and smoke until I pulled up to her house in a familiar neighborhood I've lived in all my life and got a weird gut feeling. Never know if anything would've happened but I dont ignore my gut
@sarahalbers5555
@sarahalbers5555 3 года назад
If I get a wierd feeling that is really unsettling, I follow my gut. I think alot of us have that spidey intuition.
@kimberlyb4013
@kimberlyb4013 3 года назад
Dellens farm was 10 minutes away from my home. I remember all of Ontario being on alert for Tim. I would look obsessively for his truck in hopes to spot him. Everyone was so upset at the outcome. Such a senseless tragedy. RIP Tim Bosma 🙏💔
@murielfinster3758
@murielfinster3758 3 года назад
I lived in BC when that happened and I followed the story very closely. Something about it made me need to care about the Bosma family deeply.
@CJLOVE23
@CJLOVE23 2 года назад
Did your community ever get a sense of the motive for those 2 assholes killing Tim? Why’d they kill him??
@moseschrute
@moseschrute 2 года назад
I live in Cambridge and think of Tim and Laura every time I drive by Dellen’s former farm on Roseville Rd. Such sad and needless losses
@MrHootie249
@MrHootie249 Год назад
So what was the deal with Tim's murder? Any local reasons why they did it?
@sundayspecial2722
@sundayspecial2722 3 года назад
I wish Tim's wife and child get at least some money from Dellen's family so they can survive. My heart brakes for them. They are just a little family trying to survive with a good way.
@nathanielmccoy7610
@nathanielmccoy7610 3 года назад
She definitely got victims compensation, but that won’t last a lifetime
@niomisingh8871
@niomisingh8871 2 года назад
Ya hopefully she sued the estate
@kittyellen1122
@kittyellen1122 4 года назад
Mike I’m 70 and lots and lots of these stories I’ve heard of. But I love how u tell a story I never listen to books or anything like that. But I turn on one of your stories and I can crocet forever. Yout talent isn’t easy to come by. Story telling needs much talent to keep the public interested
@constantdarkfog49
@constantdarkfog49 3 года назад
I so agree, Mike really does a great job holding my interest. Also Mike's stories have much unknown details per case.
@kittyellen1122
@kittyellen1122 3 года назад
Moto 90 great come and meet the kids. Smith and Wesson
@andio3500
@andio3500 3 года назад
Kitty Ellen haha badass 😁
@charleslaughton8092
@charleslaughton8092 3 года назад
I agree with you.
@kittyellen1122
@kittyellen1122 3 года назад
Miss. Van Helsing oh my gosh you are great. Being 70 and having friends on line is great. I’m all by myself holed up in a 8 by 11 room. This virus has me scared a little. Well really a lot. But thank you hun and bless you and your days
@zzzzoot
@zzzzoot 4 года назад
The real mystery is how a person with three 1st degree murder convictions can get be eligible for parole in any year..
@PREPFORIT
@PREPFORIT 4 года назад
Because laws are a joke here.
@PREPFORIT
@PREPFORIT 4 года назад
@@dizzychizzy1 Let me know I'll be there to help.
@PabloGonzalez-hv3td
@PabloGonzalez-hv3td 4 года назад
He'll be 103 when he's eligible for parole
@valeriebertolo2449
@valeriebertolo2449 4 года назад
Fragarbai I was at the sentencing for the Laura Babcock murder. They had already been convicted and sentenced to life (25 years before parole) for Bosma and they were sentenced to a second consecutive life sentence (additional 25 years). Now Millard has been convicted and sentenced for the murder of his father too, (another 25 years). Because the sentences are first degree & consecutive, so is the parole - meaning he will not be eligible for parole for 75 years and he will be 102 years old. DONT WORRY GUYS he’s not getting out. (Edited cause I hit send by accident)
@yashanacol6403
@yashanacol6403 4 года назад
V Brt I was confused earlier in the case because they hadn’t gotten to whether these would be consecutive or concurrent... Damn glad it sounds like to going to be conservative 👍...
@TheMissuz82
@TheMissuz82 3 года назад
Man I heard about this case on another channel and they played a longer clip of the wife’s plea to the public ...she went on to say “you don’t need him, but I DO” and I lost it😢😢😢...they are what shit wants to be when it grows up.
@mrs.snyder2170
@mrs.snyder2170 2 года назад
I know the story is just horrible. So tragic! BUT at the very beginning when you introduced Dellen & showed the pic of his dad & grandfather at the SAME time as saying his mother’s name, the insert of typed “Not Madeline ↘️” had me laughing so hard, out loud, all alone at my desk. Well done, thanks for the pressure release. 😅
@dionnefaulkes
@dionnefaulkes 4 года назад
"it was just a truck" struck a cord with me. Dillard is plain evil.
@urmammy84
@urmammy84 4 года назад
Yes. I felt her pain. 😭
@janelle009
@janelle009 4 года назад
🙁
@laurasnear1625
@laurasnear1625 4 года назад
Me as well, you could hear her pain....
@dionnefaulkes
@dionnefaulkes 4 года назад
Chord
@luciasardo1176
@luciasardo1176 4 года назад
Dionne yes i agree with you 100 percent on that
@artiefufkin88
@artiefufkin88 3 года назад
This is what happens when you spoil your kids or name them "Dellen."
@Tina-ip9yp
@Tina-ip9yp 3 года назад
i know right? what kind of name is that 😂
@cathyallen6541
@cathyallen6541 3 года назад
The parents couldn't be bothered to check for the correct spelling of "Dylan".
@toxics.
@toxics. 3 года назад
😂😂🤣
@zaptor1514
@zaptor1514 3 года назад
@@cathyallen6541 He’s named after his paternal grandmother Della hence the name Dellen. It was in the paper if you read it.
@dawnitalutz1953
@dawnitalutz1953 3 года назад
@@zaptor1514 Still a stupid name and a spoiled brat.
@doranvee5944
@doranvee5944 3 года назад
When Charlene made that plea for her husband, it tore me up inside. A young beautiful family destroyed by two people with no respect for life. How horrible! God bless the victims.
@cookie_dough_hangover
@cookie_dough_hangover 2 года назад
"It was just a truck", man, this sums it all. So heartbreaking. 💔I hope his wife and little baby girl are healing.
@PistachioPistachio
@PistachioPistachio 3 года назад
My dad always taught me if you’re going to sell a car privately you MUST require they hand over their drivers license to you to make a copy before you let them test drive the car. Just a way to protect yourself from theft, or worse
@susanivy3619
@susanivy3619 2 года назад
Just make sure to leave the copy w/ a loved one and not have it on you for the test drive....in other words, don't make the copy w/ the guy and then go immediately for a test drive w/ the copy in hand because the person can just remove it off you before they take off (or if you're not found again, neither will the copy be...). It's a good tip tho. Thanks dad 👍
@seangildersleeve1270
@seangildersleeve1270 2 года назад
100%, but I'm sure these guys were seen by the wife and the friend. They didn't care.
@Akula114
@Akula114 2 года назад
Keeping the license or getting a copy in the hands of someone else is imperative. Do NOT trust anyone. the only way I'm getting in the car with anyone I don't know is if I've got the barrel of my loaded and cocked sidearm pressed to the back of their neck with one hand and my bag of cannolis in the other,
@wcolautti
@wcolautti 2 года назад
That’s a good idea; I wouldn’t of that of that. This poor young wife and mother - what absolute monsters.
@FC-hj9ub
@FC-hj9ub Год назад
Many people get fake licenses
@susancrawford5927
@susancrawford5927 4 года назад
I'm from Toronto and remember this case so well and discussing it with my coworkers on the trip home on the bus from work the day after Tim went missing. One story you kind of missed out on here was in our local paper The Star later on during the arrest/trial, and it was goosebump inducing. The man who identified the tattoos on Dellen Millard was an intended victim prior to Tim. The story is he also took his truck out for a test drive with these two. The man was Russian and during a short conversation they touched on his past and how he was fully trained to defend himself. When Mark Smich, who was in the back seat asked him where he trained, the Russian man (the seller of the vehicle they were test driving)....replied "the Israeli army". The two of them, Mark and Dellen exchanged a long look and the test drive ended without incident. That man dodged a bullet.
@susancrawford5927
@susancrawford5927 4 года назад
@@johnfreel5059 They are in prison for life. I doubt they will ever get parole.
@genellecampbell5378
@genellecampbell5378 4 года назад
@@johnfreel5059 I've very often asked the same question.
@zammmerjammer
@zammmerjammer 4 года назад
@@johnfreel5059 In the US, people are in prison for life for petty theft and drug possession. I'll take Canada's system over the USA's anyday.
@haveabanana2930
@haveabanana2930 3 года назад
@@zammmerjammer yes, the US takes advantage of being able to lock people up on small crimes for years and years; this way they are able to have the cheapest labor imaginable. The prisoners will work for eight dollars a month or less. Its very close to slave labor.
@anti-ethniccleansing465
@anti-ethniccleansing465 3 года назад
@@haveabanana2930 Lol people aren’t locked up for “small crimes” for years on end. And what else do you want them to do in prison? They aren’t forced to work - but it’s not like I’m gonna feel bad if they choose to pay some of their debt to society by pumping out some license plates and whatnot for shit pay! They shouldn’t be having a vacation in there, ffs! , the taxpayer pays for their food, shelter, healthcare, etc. And you’re whining that some of them choose to work for cheap to pass the time and make it look good for parole? Bleeding heart Ieftist, aren’t you?
@kimlathephotography5921
@kimlathephotography5921 3 года назад
Loved the "Not Madeline" graphic that popped up - the little moments of levity in these video are fantastic.
@MultiSirens
@MultiSirens 3 года назад
A sensitive commentary thank you! As a Canadian we don’t have the number of horrific crimes, but when we do they are freaking disgusting! I along with many, many Canadians, followed this horrible case! It’s no good to say, well he was a rich kid this happens all too often and in every walk of life! Thank you for doing such a sensitive report on it! Take care and God bless! X
@ms.bkaraokeb4307
@ms.bkaraokeb4307 4 года назад
Tim looked like he was a great guy. So sad. SMH
@cdd4248
@cdd4248 4 года назад
I was thinking the same - he did look like he was just a good man trying to live a good life.
@christina7215
@christina7215 4 года назад
😂😂😂😂😂
@twelveera4289
@twelveera4289 4 года назад
Christina x why tf u laughing bitch
@HzPjtvHYom4991
@HzPjtvHYom4991 4 года назад
Ya I remember feeling so bad for this guy. Talk about wrong place, wrong time, wrong truck. Terrible
@dorisjoy9666
@dorisjoy9666 4 года назад
Twelve Era I wonder why she is laughing too. Awkward
@ElaAusDemTal
@ElaAusDemTal 4 года назад
If Toronto police had listened to Laura's ex-boyfriend when he tried to file a missing person's report, Tim would never have met Dellen and Mark. Like so many times before, law enforcement officials were unwilling to investigate the disappearance of a woman who worked as an escort and who had mental health problems throughout her life.
@H_A_L_7
@H_A_L_7 4 года назад
My thoughts exactly, and they did not investigate the father’s ‘suicide’ properly either……just throw in the mental health issue : Depression They took the easy way out, until something obvious happens, in which the community got involved did they finally investigate with gusto. Tim was a happy healthy young man, married with a child.
@sogno_di_carta6430
@sogno_di_carta6430 4 года назад
wupperelfe this is the second time I find that Canadian police is lacking. I watched another video on another channel about a man who was clearly an abuser, had sent one woman to the hospital; served two sentences for domestic violence and yet the parol officer and the cops wanted to give him a chance and allowed him to be near the women he abused. 🙄 They ignored complaints about him and brushed them off because he hadn’t had priors and only served like 10 months in jail when he actually served time for the domestic violence . At the end he killed 3 women in one day including two of his ex that had testified against him before.
@vegetablepimps
@vegetablepimps 4 года назад
Well said.
@breez706
@breez706 4 года назад
@@sogno_di_carta6430 not just Canadian police
@LSPD1909
@LSPD1909 4 года назад
@Rebecca Buschhorn The Fifth Estate is a TV program on government owned CBC TV and it is one of the only enjoyable (and non-biased) programs they make. Not going to disagree that our refugee and immigration processes are extremely lenient too say the least and I will full heartedly agree our judicial system has blatant flaws, but you ignore the incomprehensibly vast area that our Royal Canadian Mounted Police are responsible for ( being most rural areas in the second largest country by landmass), and how many cases they have successfully investigated. It's also important to note that some of these RCMP stations, especially as you go further north) are incredibly underfunded and understaffed, Have heard personal anecdotes from Mounties of months long shifts in northern towns where they are only working with 4 colleges in a station. That being said you want LEO's with a bad track record OPP is your department.
@knc1
@knc1 3 года назад
This happened in my city and I remember how sad and tragic the story was as it was unfolding. All anyone could say after was, " it was just a truck..". Great job retelling this story Mike. Well done.
@pocketlinttreasures33
@pocketlinttreasures33 3 года назад
I will never forget Tim bosma. This case was so awful and his wife's pleas in the news conference have always stayed with me. I live near Hamilton and this case was huge here.
@drnogueiras8783
@drnogueiras8783 4 года назад
Crazy when you consider that he would’ve gotten away with his dad’s murder and maybe even Laura’s, had he not killed Tim
@rekietabeatslc9980
@rekietabeatslc9980 3 года назад
He was rich & flew planes-what if he decided to go to developing countries to get his thrills??? A few little bribes in the right places...
@johannak1983
@johannak1983 3 года назад
Or Laura and Tim would be still alive if the police had done their job right arresting him for his dad's murder.
@johnnywriight
@johnnywriight 3 года назад
Spoiler alert?!
@MA__
@MA__ 3 года назад
@@rekietabeatslc9980 "developing" lol. You mean corrupt?
@sp1cyn0va35
@sp1cyn0va35 3 года назад
@@johannak1983 that’s what I was thinking /:
@TK-yh4hn
@TK-yh4hn 4 года назад
When you get a bad feeling, listen.
@smokejc
@smokejc 4 года назад
Then people with anxiety would never get anything done.
@klantifashakur9894
@klantifashakur9894 4 года назад
@@smokejc but they will live
@femalearmyvet7636
@femalearmyvet7636 4 года назад
@@smokejc lol soooooo true!!!!!
@MsTinkerbelle87
@MsTinkerbelle87 4 года назад
Thelema This is a different feeling...
@missjem79
@missjem79 4 года назад
@@smokejc That's what happens. Anxiety is paralyzing.
@sherylzeyen367
@sherylzeyen367 3 года назад
Tim seemed like a nice man who loved his family. This is so sad. I’m glad his family has beautiful memories of life with him. God bless. 😢💛
@hotrod8558
@hotrod8558 3 года назад
He incinerated that poor man in Roseville Ontario on property that had previously been owned by my great grandfather. I was shocked when I seen the police searching the barn for further evidence on the news. I was first made aware of Tim Bosma when I met his father in law putting up a missing person poster in a variety store in Princeton Ontario (about 30 min from Ancaster) was very sad.
@cellisttare
@cellisttare 4 года назад
I was with my ex-boyfriend during this time and Tim was one of his co-workers. The disappearance hit us hard and you just got that sinking feeling something wasn't right...it's so sad and senseless
@LazyDaisyDay88
@LazyDaisyDay88 4 года назад
What a complete waste of oxygen these people are. RIP the victims and I hope the relatives have found a measure of peace since these events. Thanks for another great vid.
@ThatChapter
@ThatChapter 4 года назад
Thanks for watching!
@janelle009
@janelle009 4 года назад
As well as the relatives of the murderers. Many disagree with this but I feel for both sides.
@marquisdelafayette1929
@marquisdelafayette1929 4 года назад
Yeah I said before I am a harsh critic of the American criminal justice system but in this case he probably wouldn’t have been around after the “suicide “. Also, they all deserve to never live in society again. I would say that they deserve the death penalty but I think making sure they live an extremely long life but in solitary confinement for the rest of their lives never having contact with anyone else.
@janelle009
@janelle009 4 года назад
@@marquisdelafayette1929 It was in Canada but I absolutely agree they dont need to be in society again! I always felt the same about it's better they get life but they all fight for life in prison over getting death.. on death row they dont even get contact with other prisoners & the cell is much smaller.
@gaylorde4607
@gaylorde4607 2 года назад
I live in Hamilton and absolutely forgot about the death of Tim. Didn’t know him personally but heard from everyone how much of great person he was. Still can’t believe it
@RPDthe3rd
@RPDthe3rd 3 года назад
I was almost brought to tears from Tim’s wife pleading for the return of her husband. I couldn’t fathom something like this happening to my family. RIP TIM
@Infantryvet156th
@Infantryvet156th 4 года назад
I can feel the pain of the wife who lost her husband. I hate this world.
@stephaniebach__12-24
@stephaniebach__12-24 3 года назад
I hate it too, it’s far too evil 😥
@jancyvidya8243
@jancyvidya8243 3 года назад
😞
@K131399
@K131399 3 года назад
Is it like the pain of a stubbed toe or the pain of losing a good friend? Bill Clinton would never tell lol
@samphimm8253
@samphimm8253 3 года назад
It is evil but i dont hate it. Cautious but still alot more love to experience so no hate on the world.
@johnnywriight
@johnnywriight 3 года назад
This world is breathtakingly beautiful it’s just the negatives stand out more than the positives
@valeriebertolo2449
@valeriebertolo2449 4 года назад
I was at the sentencing trial for the Laura Babcock murder. Literally feet from the back of their heads. And ya, Mark smirked on his way out of the courtroom. It was crazy.
@therearenoshortcuts9868
@therearenoshortcuts9868 3 года назад
sounds like there was more to it any theories?
@ninjacat508
@ninjacat508 2 года назад
Psychopathic grin.
@manijohal
@manijohal 3 года назад
It’s nice to see Tim’s wife/widow have the strength that she has & remember her husband in a positive way
@ThoughtfulPotato
@ThoughtfulPotato 3 года назад
I've read about this case a lot and this isn't the first time I'm seeing this video either... But every time I hear the wife begging for her husband's life, I choke up ... That poor poor woman.... I cannot imagine what state I'd be in if I were in her place ... What a demonic thing to do to (seemingly nice) random strangers!
@BeardFaceSuper
@BeardFaceSuper 4 года назад
Of course a little rich kid has a tattoo "ambition" as if he actually did any work.
@MarksTournaments
@MarksTournaments 4 года назад
Lmao hate Rich fuckboys
@tylercochrane1762
@tylercochrane1762 4 года назад
It's hard to know what ambition is when every goal you ever want to set is easily reachable with minimal effort :(
@jarmilaadam6707
@jarmilaadam6707 4 года назад
Well, I'd call three consecutive life sentences hella ambitious.
@mrc6176
@mrc6176 4 года назад
Daddy’s money would’ve been better 👍
@ZeranZeran
@ZeranZeran 4 года назад
Tattoos are supposed to be reminders. He had awful ambitions. The tattoo had no true meaning to him.
@kristenpatterson8407
@kristenpatterson8407 4 года назад
I'm from around the area when Tim when missing. It was heartbreaking, everyone wanted to bring him home so badly. It really rattled a lot of people when we learned what had really happened to him. R.I.P Tim, you deserved better
@jamesstewart7736
@jamesstewart7736 3 года назад
One of the most chilling sentences ever, "he shot his Father in his sleep."
@lisaproustresearch
@lisaproustresearch 2 года назад
Great recap! I used to live in Toronto when this happened. A lady from the gym I used to go to, actually went on a date with Dellen (he was actually living very close to the gym). Then I went to his trial (the one re: his Dad). I sat down about 40 feet away from him. I wanted to determine if you can see evil when you look at it. The disturbing fact, was that I couldn't. He looked "normal" to me... That was interesting AND scary at the same time.
@mannymidwest9886
@mannymidwest9886 4 года назад
Imagine being known for wearing a satchel bag and having an “ambition” tattoo on your wrist 😂
@22ergie
@22ergie 4 года назад
A 'fag bag', or 'man purse', or also called a 'man bag'...not my words...
@ZeranZeran
@ZeranZeran 4 года назад
Man, I love my backpack. I dont care how many people call it a man purse lmao. It's nice to have a phone charger and not have bulging pockets. Some mens bags look pretty cool too. But.. yeah.. not something I'd want on my obituary. Lmao.
@Gabbo-lv3zo
@Gabbo-lv3zo 4 года назад
😂😂😂
@pottymouthedplanter
@pottymouthedplanter 4 года назад
Hahahahaha
@floridasoldat
@floridasoldat 4 года назад
Wearing a satchel bag= antifa members, wooks, trust fund hippies, & suicide bombers. Being ambitious= not antifa members, not trust fund hippies, not suicide bombers, not wooks. That tattoo wouldn’t hold water even if it were a tattoo of a bucket
@Kat-tr2ig
@Kat-tr2ig 4 года назад
1:27 "not Madeleine" I choked on my slice of pizza when that popped up. Lmao!
@JimmyFoxhound
@JimmyFoxhound 3 года назад
9:00, as a confirmed monk who gave up on relationships ages ago it breaks my heart to hear Sharlene talk about her husband like that. If I could have ever had a wife I would have loved to have been with someone who thought of me & spoke of me in that way. They must have had something special. Just heartbreaking.
@savitaram3975
@savitaram3975 3 года назад
When going for test drives with strangers, meet at a police station, have all parties sign in, leave the keys of the prospective buyer inside (if they drove to the station), and have all parties sign out.
@michelle3445
@michelle3445 3 года назад
This!! I hope your comment gets more attention. I’ve also seen it said to have both parties (and anyone else with them) need to leave a copy of their ID with the police station.
@lesliefroelich4144
@lesliefroelich4144 3 года назад
I'm sure the police will be happy to have this additional burden on their work day.
@savitaram3975
@savitaram3975 3 года назад
@@lesliefroelich4144 Police officers are public servants, so mitigating potential threats within their jurisdiction is a part of their job.
@evelynwaugh4053
@evelynwaugh4053 3 года назад
@@savitaram3975 While I think this is an excellent suggestion, it's not necessarily a service that your local law enforcement agency would provide. You should Google Warren vs. District of Columbia, if you have any questions about the duty of care owed.
@PabloGonzalez-hv3td
@PabloGonzalez-hv3td 3 года назад
Or just let people test drive on their own. If they steal it you call the police.
@conneroneill8506
@conneroneill8506 4 года назад
“With dreams of becoming an actress her personality was optimistic.” Subtle dig.
@ThatChapter
@ThatChapter 4 года назад
I was wondering if anyone would notice that
@conneroneill8506
@conneroneill8506 4 года назад
That Chapter Very good. Your videos have really increased in quality. Keep up the good work man, in a couple of years you’ll be the top RU-vid true crime channel.
@chowder8802
@chowder8802 4 года назад
@cosmosspring I agree... Surprising
@davedogge2280
@davedogge2280 4 года назад
it never stopped Pamela Anderson
@TheSquareOnes
@TheSquareOnes 4 года назад
@cosmosspring He didn't do anything to them, they're gone. And even if their ghost was haunting this comment section, being called an optimist isn't a particularly harsh burn is it? Grow a sense of humor and get a bigger perspective on things, it'll help a lot. Just keep doing you, Mike. You inject the perfect amount of levity into these grim and disturbing cases, please never change that.
@aimeeblack76
@aimeeblack76 4 года назад
In Gavin de Becker's book, "The Gift of Fear", he mentions that's dark humor is often your gut telling you that something is not right. That joke someone made when he got in the truck with those men gave me the chills.
@lizbrown7232
@lizbrown7232 3 года назад
A great book. He also commented that when your dog does not like someone it is because you are picking up bad vibes from the person and the dog senses your feelings.
@maramarxx2431
@maramarxx2431 3 года назад
The lesson on the story is that,: if contacting smbdy on the net, you feel strange vibes, just quit, leave!!!!
@hrdcoremetalchik
@hrdcoremetalchik 3 года назад
Interesting! Going to check that book out!
@kimvalenzia3265
@kimvalenzia3265 3 года назад
Great book! Helped me in recovery after assault. Helped me with trust of my instinct.
@squarepeg4227
@squarepeg4227 3 года назад
Going to look that book up - thank you!
@andreahermann2902
@andreahermann2902 2 года назад
What some people don't understand is we are designed to be able to hear when someone is lying, or fake crying. People that commit crimes tell on themselves. Love you channel Mike. I've heard a bunch of case files, but you are the best!
@PeriLyons123
@PeriLyons123 Год назад
Her speech was heartrending. As others have noted, “It’s just a truck” was such an anguished cry from the heart- made me weep. That poor lost girl; the poor Dad; and Tim, who just seems so lovely.. One of the things that makes “That Chapter”, so extraordinary.. Mike’s respect for and honor of, the innocent victims. Fantastic work. And may Poor Lil Rich Boy, burn in hell.
@BoRjanap
@BoRjanap 4 года назад
I remember this like it was yesterday, it was tragic. I remember the funeral and bawling like a baby. RIP Tim you are never forgotten 💔💔💔
@BangTanPrettiNikki
@BangTanPrettiNikki 4 года назад
That Chapter has officially taken over my life. I’m so deep into these videos I’m probably gonna need rehabilitation😩😒❤️
@kerryn6714
@kerryn6714 4 года назад
It’s lucky he uploads twice a week or I’d be going through withdrawals ✌️😂👍
@communicationbreakdown256
@communicationbreakdown256 3 года назад
there's another cool one where the narrator explains the psychology of the person being interrogated. very interesting as well.
@Luckysquirrel1256
@Luckysquirrel1256 3 года назад
@@communicationbreakdown256 that is actually how I found this channel from a JCS - Criminal Psychology video. Those also make for great deep dives, if you have the time.
@gordonaliasme1104
@gordonaliasme1104 3 года назад
🎯
@therearenoshortcuts9868
@therearenoshortcuts9868 3 года назад
That Chapter is the true criminal stealing our time LOL
@jewlz1.1.1
@jewlz1.1.1 3 года назад
I remember this in the news, being in Ontario, Canada. His wife saying, "It was just... a... truck..." That in itself was SUCH an impact statement. 😪
@whade62000
@whade62000 2 года назад
This should also be a lesson to those who think it's cool to be friends with a bad kid or a criminal. Someone who's willing to harm others will also be willing to frame you for it.
@Jusdippin78
@Jusdippin78 4 года назад
My daughter walks by while im watching and asks ,daddy what is nineteen ninety tree,😂😂😂😂😂.As an american i love the accent. Im sure we say things u guys smile about😁. Good video.
@CrushableANNIE
@CrushableANNIE 4 года назад
Barely started watching That Chapter vids a few days ago and I can't stop watching them. Really interesting.
@jaray7710
@jaray7710 4 года назад
Yeah I know what you mean.
@Queen_Kellz_1120
@Queen_Kellz_1120 3 года назад
Yes! Same..
@RhomanysRealm
@RhomanysRealm 3 года назад
My theory is that if you can immediately tell the police where you were and what you were doing when they say a time or date, you’re probably lying - unless it was in some way a memorable event. Honestly if someone asked me what I did yesterday I’d have to think about it.
@knoda2603
@knoda2603 3 года назад
😂 dude was rapping “if u go swimming u can find a phone” 😂
@nocturnalmayhem0
@nocturnalmayhem0 3 года назад
lmao find a phone
@tyga6348
@tyga6348 3 года назад
These guys are cowards bruh fucking with innocents. Smh
@arianajessica
@arianajessica 3 года назад
i can't even haha
@CodeeXD
@CodeeXD 3 года назад
Find a phone
@remedy9648
@remedy9648 3 года назад
It was painful to say the least.
@jessiimamii5113
@jessiimamii5113 4 года назад
There's no other pain like losing a loved one to murder, especially over something so petty. It absolutely is a life sentence, you're never the same. This poor woman. 😔
@standoughope
@standoughope 4 года назад
Thank you so much *That Chapter!* After Cayleigh Elise retired I was so depressed, seriously. Having you come along with awesome content is the drug that I needed. Your production is spot on too, advanced. Stay who you are! =)
@ThatChapter
@ThatChapter 4 года назад
Thanks Ryan!!
@andiemay8410
@andiemay8410 4 года назад
I miss her so much!!
@hazevthewolf178
@hazevthewolf178 4 года назад
@@andiemay8410 I, too, miss her. She is a compassionate, empathetic human being.
@Doctor_Rouge
@Doctor_Rouge 4 года назад
Ryan Swanson Yep. Me too.
@bah-be8159
@bah-be8159 4 года назад
Deadbug has some good content along with criminally listed..
@Gaetano.94
@Gaetano.94 3 года назад
I remember when this happened :/ his family went all over the place to hand out missing flyers. Such nice people :(
@emilywalker3678
@emilywalker3678 3 года назад
Tons of other news outlets could cover this (or any of your stories) and I still would learn/find more info about these people and these cases through you/your videos. Keep doing you Mike!
@keyanatinae
@keyanatinae 4 года назад
Also, I know y’all all got secondhand embarrassment when he was trying to rap...
@codex_logos
@codex_logos 4 года назад
Firsthand for me🎲.. lemme see u show how it's done missy, I know u got the sauce 🤔
@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim
@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim 4 года назад
It was PAINFUL...swim for bones? What the actual f*** 😂😂😂 he shoulda gotten the death penalty just for that
@JacaboBlanco
@JacaboBlanco 4 года назад
Phone under water. Phone underwater 🔥 🔥 🔥 Best rappers Dylon Dylon Dylon Dylon And this guy
@nicolerene2777
@nicolerene2777 4 года назад
Elena B. 🤣🤣 yes the death penalty bc he def murder those lines 🤣🤣🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️ straight lyrical killer 😂😳
@wolfwoodx15
@wolfwoodx15 4 года назад
I personally found it amusing. I figured that was his goal.
@amberdean374
@amberdean374 4 года назад
It’s a sad world when someone dies just going on a test drive. So sad
@greent6823
@greent6823 4 года назад
My husband fixes and sells cars as a side business and when he goes on test drives he packs so much damn heat I dunno who to be more afraid for. He goes in expecting the worst every time.
@PabloGonzalez-hv3td
@PabloGonzalez-hv3td 4 года назад
@@greent6823 Bosma was likely shot from the rear seat
@MarksTournaments
@MarksTournaments 4 года назад
@Y. Not lol head was needed in this, light them up
@funghoul9124
@funghoul9124 3 года назад
i feel like you try to find stories with the number "turdy" as much as possible......im kiddin...channels awesome!
@tallgirl55
@tallgirl55 2 года назад
I remember those missing posters around my community. Very, very sad. What an enormous amount of evil dwells in some people! Tragic!
@concretenmyveins8403
@concretenmyveins8403 4 года назад
This is one of the best channels on RU-vid
@tracyd693
@tracyd693 4 года назад
Heartbreaking for Tim's wife. Over a truck! So senseless 😢
@kickz2828
@kickz2828 4 года назад
T DRIT I wouldn’t say it was over a truck, they probably were planning on murdering that day
@chocomanger6873
@chocomanger6873 4 года назад
Yeah, it wasn't over a truck. The guy had a ton of money and didn't need anyone's used truck so much as to kill them.
@lauriedavidson4953
@lauriedavidson4953 2 года назад
I always wanna give Mike a big ol' bear hug each time I see that cute little wink! He's such a sweet guy!
@asiadenney7030
@asiadenney7030 2 года назад
It breaks my heart to see these family members plead for safe return... 😢
@emperorspock3506
@emperorspock3506 4 года назад
1:56 That record sounds exactly like something that a rich parent would hire the Guinness book people for, to pamper the vanity of their spoiled kid.
@yeah.cheers
@yeah.cheers 4 года назад
exactly
@emperorspock3506
@emperorspock3506 3 года назад
@Van Helsing They won't hesitate to take your money to accept whatever bizarre record you've decided to invent for yourself. They're darlings with all sorts of dictators.
@tylerskiss
@tylerskiss 3 года назад
So you're saying it's not likely that someone ran into the Guinness' offices shouting " you won't believe what I found! A young man who can fly a helicopter and an airplane..." "So what?" "Wait! Did I mention he can fly them.... On the SAME DAY!?!?" "What!? No way!!!"
@SNP-1999
@SNP-1999 3 года назад
If our daddies had been rich enough to pay for the lessons, I do not doubt that most of us could have got our pilot's licenses by that age. "Daddy paid it all - lucky me !". Spoilt scumbag !
@cierracherwaty1685
@cierracherwaty1685 3 года назад
this case happened in my hometown, and I remember being terrified until they found the killers of tim, when the trial finally finished and they were found guilty, I cried so hard. this case is what got me into true crime, because it will always hit way harder than anything else
@redstateforever
@redstateforever 2 года назад
When I was 20, a close friend was raped and bludgeoned to death after being left alone at her inner city rec center job. It’s strange how much it affects you, in so many ways, and I wasn’t even related to her. It’s affected my behavior, how I raise my kids, my faith in humanity in general. When violence like that gets close to you, you’re changed forever, even if you’re just on the edge of it. Luckily, my state has the death penalty, and we killed the monster not very many years later. Slept a little better that night.
@nannysfolly
@nannysfolly 2 года назад
I remember this case well. And , I remember how pleased everyone was that justice was served. I'm from Niagara Region, so our big crime that hit everyone was Bernardo and Homolka. Justice sure screwed the pooch on that one.
@jessicamilestone4026
@jessicamilestone4026 Год назад
Thank you Mike for another excellent video. Sensitively dealt with.
@stykes1185
@stykes1185 3 года назад
I'm from another province in Canada and I remember Tim's disappearance had a big impact here, his best friend at the time lived here and got news of it, facebook groups and posters came up even here. It's terrible someone could do something like this not just for a truck, but for thrills. The overwhelming positive support that emerged from it is the only way I can reflect back without losing complete hope in humanity.
@mercedesheredia
@mercedesheredia 4 года назад
“He just enjoyed the Trill of it!”Love the sound to it but only when he says it🤗
@tarajh
@tarajh 4 года назад
I'm just here for the trill of it!
@kingayy9267
@kingayy9267 4 года назад
Me t'urteen
@meepding3259
@meepding3259 3 года назад
Me tirteent and a turd
@thaisb229
@thaisb229 4 года назад
So heartwrenching listening to Tim's wife He looked like he was a really good guy WHERE ARE SOME HUMANS HEARTS?
@mackhomie6
@mackhomie6 4 года назад
HUMAN BEANS
@chriscash7779
@chriscash7779 4 года назад
I. Know. Right. FUCKING SAD.🤔👵
@scumbagm2995
@scumbagm2995 4 года назад
I ate them
@mariacupo4955
@mariacupo4955 4 года назад
@@scumbagm2995 😆
@xmiunax4385
@xmiunax4385 2 года назад
Some humans are just born without
@lesleymoir3265
@lesleymoir3265 2 года назад
Mike, I LOVE the fact that you don't beg for likes and views! You are genuinely one of the best channels on here and I am enjoying every minute of binging ALL your content 💙💙💙
@jaymichael3079
@jaymichael3079 3 года назад
Mike, I love your videos so much. Thank you for all the quality content. It's helped me get through alot of shitty days lately. Again, thank you Mike.
@Swimwhiz
@Swimwhiz 4 года назад
I love this channel, just found it and been binge watching it over the holidays. Just want to point something out about this case. I live not to far from where this happened and Laura babcocks friend begged the police to look at millard after she disappeared. He sent them texts and other things that he had got from her in her final days that definitely pointed at millard, but they ignored him. This was long before the Tim bosma murder. Had they done their job bosma would be alive today
@heatherhent4445
@heatherhent4445 4 года назад
I'm American but a fan of the fifth estate and learned about this case from them. If you haven't already done so it's a good watch.
@Queen_Kellz_1120
@Queen_Kellz_1120 3 года назад
I'm an American as well and love both channels. True Crime Daily is another great one!
@aircastles1013
@aircastles1013 3 года назад
I’m not an American but am fascinated at this hating and criticising the police that Americans seem to love doing. Being a police officer in the USA would be terrifying, never know if someone has a gun or not. I would be interested to see their society , or sudden lack of, if it had no police.
@emmaanderson2766
@emmaanderson2766 3 года назад
@@aircastles1013 i’m an american and we criticize them bc the criminal justice system in this country is so outdated and corrupt so we really can’t ever trust that the police are always trying to protect and serve like they’re supposed to yanno? like there’s just alotttt of corruption and funds that are allocated to misconduct settlements & it’s super frustrating
@FORGEgentek
@FORGEgentek 5 месяцев назад
​@@aircastles1013they CHOOSE that job, they give too many trigger happy idiots guns.
@samf3080
@samf3080 3 года назад
RIP Tim. Chris who is in the first video standing with tims wife they are my step-cousins. When this happened, the videos of Charlene crying on camera is so sad. I hadn't seen these for a long time.
@jadexjade
@jadexjade 3 года назад
Mike I love your dry humor and comedic timing you my friend, are awesome
@MartaWomack
@MartaWomack 3 года назад
What a horrific thing to do to his own father and a young girl! Whatever goes on in people like this's head is beyond my understanding! The only thing that makes these scary stories bearable, is our friend Mike, here.
@taraw4633
@taraw4633 4 года назад
This happened not far from where I live. Privileged narcissist at its finest. 🤢
@beehiveear8883
@beehiveear8883 4 года назад
Agreed. I'll add that he's a clinically psychopathic narcissist.
@luciasardo1176
@luciasardo1176 4 года назад
Yes
@eddiehockley4144
@eddiehockley4144 4 года назад
To quote The Matrix, " You believe you are special Mr Anderson, you are different, the rules of life do not apply to you.
@marquisdelafayette1929
@marquisdelafayette1929 4 года назад
If this was in America he wouldn’t have been out to begin with after the “suicide “. All three would have the death penalty or life with no parole ever. Honestly, death is too easy. I think they should have extremely long lives in solitary confinement with no contact with anyone other than guards passing. No phone, no tv, no anything.. for the rest of their (hopefully long) lives.
@Plague_Angel
@Plague_Angel 4 года назад
@@shitwindsshitcity6689 id have to disagree with that. I think some of these sick fucks deserve alot worse than what they inflicted on others. A very slow , long, torturous existence till they die of old age is what they deserve.
@tmcrocker1115
@tmcrocker1115 4 года назад
Don't mind my late comment, just found That Chapter and have been binge watching. These people are just wastes of oxygen.
@chubbiMommi
@chubbiMommi 3 года назад
It's ok I'm new here too
@1979Spica
@1979Spica 3 года назад
I will never forget this. It happened close to where I live. I went to help search for Tim twice and it was a sickening feeling.
@Lt.Scotty
@Lt.Scotty 3 года назад
BIG THANKS for keeping up with our collective history professional as f despite the haters, love watching your videos. Thanks from NZ
@bramabull111
@bramabull111 4 года назад
One of my best friends dated him, she was being stalked after they broke up.
@bramabull111
@bramabull111 4 года назад
Laura also went to my school 😔
@WellStudied
@WellStudied 4 года назад
Not even in his turdies and trows his life and fortune away.
@jenniferl6017
@jenniferl6017 4 года назад
Lol I love his little accent. My RU-vid crush.... In the most non-weirdo way : )
@derekweinerttv4163
@derekweinerttv4163 4 года назад
I cant tink of anyting worse
@MsFifi11c
@MsFifi11c 4 года назад
Jennifer L I have a crush on him too
@bradlemmond
@bradlemmond 4 года назад
💩ies
@janetrodgers8473
@janetrodgers8473 4 года назад
Brett Allen. He is Southern Irish and in certain areas that is the way they speak. Have y'all listened to various US accents!
@slapeters2004
@slapeters2004 3 года назад
Crazy thing is, I remember the news footage of when this dude set the world record with bilateral pilot qualifications, but don’t remember hearing anything about him turning into basically a thug and serial killer. Wow.
@meganc4519
@meganc4519 3 года назад
I live for ur true crime videos. BEST format I’ve ever seen. So informative but also a great and entertaining host ! I LOVE IT
@jackselle4607
@jackselle4607 4 года назад
Dellen’s ex girlfriend Christina Noudga needs to be sent back to Canada and charged for at least an accessory to murder for Laura Babcock’s murder, living her life in Poland, it’s so wrong
@dontbefatuousjeffrey2494
@dontbefatuousjeffrey2494 4 года назад
You're very right... I guess the evidence was not substantial enough. I'm not surprised she fled to another country. She'll never get that lucky again.
@davidlynch9049
@davidlynch9049 3 года назад
Plea deal, which means the lesser psychos are let go to convict the top psycho.
@jackselle4607
@jackselle4607 3 года назад
@@davidlynch9049 such a good point sadly!
@paulasimone8356
@paulasimone8356 4 года назад
I have recently swapped Dateline for That Chapter as my go-to-sleep video. ❤️
@brittanyhunt6816
@brittanyhunt6816 3 года назад
Yes! I'm not the only one! 😂
@kylienms
@kylienms 11 месяцев назад
Thank you Mike for covering this story. I grew up in Hamilton and this story was absolutely shocking and terrifying. Reports of an incinerator were used in the crime, which was even more sinister. Especially with the added fact of 2 other crimes committed by Millard. The respect you show the victims and families is insurmountable. You are amazing. Thank you again.
@blissfulpanda1
@blissfulpanda1 3 года назад
I've already watched all your videos, but here I am again for round 2 lol. Hands down one of the best RU-vid channels. 👌
@Solidsnake8608
@Solidsnake8608 4 года назад
I've said it before Mike, seriously underrated channel. Keep up the awesome work!
@ThatChapter
@ThatChapter 4 года назад
Thank you!
@billyconforto9108
@billyconforto9108 4 года назад
“It was just a truck’ ah fkn killed me! :(
@urmammy84
@urmammy84 4 года назад
😭
@luciasardo1176
@luciasardo1176 4 года назад
Me too, man they really didn't need to to kill him fricken psychopaths
@kjeezy2990
@kjeezy2990 4 года назад
Yooooo Embankment Gang. RIP Billy Conforto.
@billyconforto9108
@billyconforto9108 4 года назад
K Jeezy my man 🤘🏽
@annika_panicka
@annika_panicka 3 года назад
R.I.P. Tim Bosma and condolences to his family and friends.💐 He looked like a lovely man-the kind of Canadian I (an American) thought represented the majority of that nation's population. Unfortunately, "That Chapter" has disabused me of this illusion.
@samantha4238
@samantha4238 3 года назад
I love how in the beginning you put the arrow and write “not Madeline” bc I was a little confused lol