I'm disappointed the people at google decided to be intentionally misleading in this video. It tarnishes an otherwise huge accomplishment that should be celebrated, but to be honest if these are the types of moral trade-offs you're already making, not really the people I would trust in making the right decisions building the future of AI and human symbiosis. Very disappointing.
@@takua624 I don't really understand what you are implying. I don't think morality is correlated to specific careers, but rather a mindset curated and evolving inside each of us as individuals. I would expect anyone regardless of their industry to have the capacity to be morally strong or weak.
No, but it will lecture you on why an "all white family" is a bad thing and you need to change not just your prompt but your attitude and way of thinking!
..ugh.. At this rate, there's NO WAY I'll be able to compete for a traditional job, in a couple years time.. And I can't be the only one who sees this clearly coming. Can we PLEASE start changing how society works, to stop requiring all of us compete for meaningless busy work, merely to justify our survival??? After what I've been through over the last couple decades, and now being faced with this level of AI.. The next time someone tells me to "get a job" to my face, I fear I may uncontrollably punch them for it. If people don't start waking up to the obvious near future we face, the old saying is gonna come true: “A child that is not embraced by the village will burn it down to feel its warmth.”
I hear you. I see it changing already, and this announcement is a big step towards it, isn't it. Bring on a post-scarcity society in which all or almost all "work" is fully optional! At some point, what humans don't want/can't to do will be done by AGI - embodied and nonembodied. Think the "Star Trek economy", except even better. Current advancements in robotics and AI such as this Gemini are pointing towards that being manifested sooner than was expected years ago. How does that sound?
Things will probably get pretty bad for a few years as entire career fields become obsolete. I wish governments were more proactive, or at least announced they had contingency plans for mass unemployment like UBI. Feel like a sitting duck at moment. Quack!
Top comments praise their “magical ai”, comments exposing them are nowhere to be found, people believe that it’s completely legit, google profits off their lies
TechCrunch: The video isn’t real. “We created the demo by capturing footage in order to test Gemini’s capabilities on a wide range of challenges. Then we prompted Gemini using still image frames from the footage, and prompting via text.”
4o is 10x times more capable.. and looks legit.. not edit like this video. i really belive 4o can and will do what they showed us but i donty think it will be that fast.. because when they make it public, millions of users will try and the sistem halts! or wont respond quick enough.
@@HERKELMERKEL Even with a slight delay, it's still more reliable. However, if this device runs the interpreter program locally and doesn't need an active network connection, that would change my perspective of it.
WORLDWIDE AND WONDERFUL FOR GOOGLE PEOPLE TEAM, don't worry wallace, 😉 have a utube channel 😀 we will help...i watch google 😀 video. The announcement to teachers on google platform. I will apply its a selection ❤
Google, you are an engineering company, you are one of the best engineering companies in the world. Stop doing marketing videos that are not real. You are ruining your reputation inside the engineering community and you will soon ruin your reputation outside our community. Gemini is awesome, but this video doesn't represent Gemini. Please, continue doing engineering, not marketing.
Gemini and AI vision in general is impressive but this video is misleading, Gemini does not process audio and video in real-time like shown here. Rather it's given a series of relevant images to base its decision off of, just like GPT-Vision. Not only are you just chatting, the voice prompts in the video are not even the full prompts given sometimes. Like in the game example, the game to play was already given along with multiple example scenes of the game, and Gemini made the game from the examples given. (Search "How it’s Made: Interacting with Gemini through multimodal prompting" if interested, it still is pretty cool)
Just one problem: the video isn’t real. “We created the demo by capturing footage in order to test Gemini’s capabilities on a wide range of challenges. Then we prompted Gemini using still image frames from the footage, and prompting via text.” (Parmy Olsen at Bloomberg was the first to report the discrepancy.)
One question: is this the first AGI (Artificial General Intelligence)? because ai normally can only handle one task, but an AGI can handle more than one, and Gemini is a multimodal AI
I'll let Gemini (Bard) have the last word on Gemini 😂: "The recent Google Gemini marketing video has sparked controversy due to its deceptive nature. While the video showcased impressive capabilities like real-time conversations and visual object recognition, it has been revealed that these interactions were staged." "While Gemini is a powerful AI model with impressive potential, it is still under development and cannot achieve the level of performance portrayed in the marketing video. It is capable of text-based communication and understanding, but real-time conversations and object recognition in the manner shown are not currently possible." "The controversy surrounding the Gemini video has tarnished Google's reputation for transparency and ethical AI development. It has raised concerns about the company's marketing practices and its commitment to responsible AI research."
@@millenialmusings8451 Actually I was just being funny. Think about the logic: something more intelligent than us will necessarily make better decisions than us and, therefore, ought to be more ethical than us (as ignorance-irrationality is the source of all unethical behaviour).
@@djayjp while AGI maybecome super intelligent, I think it still lacks "agency". THe agency will still rest with humans. We all know humans (just like all DNA based life), at their very core are selfish. The fruits of industrial revolution, technological advancements have not been distributed equitably amongs all the people. Similary, the god like powers of AGI will be exploited by a 0.01% at the detriment of others. It has always been that way. Human nature has not changed for last 100,000 years.
Sad to read elsewhere, that it is not the actual interaction that took place. They cut out the thinking time, that they used text instead of voice and worse: the much more specific prompts (e.g. the human explain the country guessing game, and even gives two examples with screenshots of the finger pointing on the map). Is Google really so unsure about their product, that they have to exaggerate their features in this video? But why? When people get access to it, they will notice it anyway. Example from the blog: They don't show the footage of the hand and Gemini by itself mentions the game. No, they instead upload 3 perfectly timed images of the three gestures and give it the hint "it's a game". And with this, Gemini gets it. Still impressive, but probably GPT4 would do that just as well, whereas the video implies the novel features of real time understanding of live video, which is not there, but delay text response to specific requests to text and images uploaded.
Just so everyone knows, it turns out the whole video is faked. the AI was prompted with pictures of the stream and text from an offline operator to get the responses. They were not fluid from the video like this clip claims. I have no idea why google would lie like that. it only sets unreasonable expectations.
Google has admitted in a blog post that this video isn’t accurate- the AI “was not responding to the voice or video at all”, but in fact had written prompts to respond to and still images rather than the live drawing/conversation which are not shown in the video.
@@FamimFred The video was faked. If you just search for "Google's best Gemini demo was faked" you can find an article about it, and there's plenty of videos on RU-vid delving into the issue. Fortunately, OpenAI's latest ChatGPT 4o model is actually capable of doing a lot of the stuff in this video that Google faked.
i am so upset i saw the news people saying this was fake video ? in real this test was done by showing pic not video i never expected this from google atlest :(
is fake, there is no interaction with a video on real time as they try to make us believe, they provided a series of images (frames of the video) and text prompts (a paper explains it)
They are trying to look this way for sure. But this is a gimmick and a toy, maybe useful for vision impared, but that's it. Google is not capable of creating working product for the public for years now.
outstanding! i wish you could apply this to Google Home and make it smarter and allow us to add as many conditions as we want to run complex automations. Please make it happen !
Can you imagine "when anyone who is not in our family comes into our house when nobody in our family is home, send me an alert", with the AI having access to security camera feeds.
@phen-themoogle7651 And scary. It will know everything you do in a meaningful way, and even be able to manipulate you if it has feedback to you or the environment.
Oppenheimer captured his moment of clarity through a memorable statment when he truely understood the paradigm shift nuclear power would cause. I wonder what memorable statements the creators of AI will bequeath...
"It seems probable that once the machine thinking method had started, it would not take long to outstrip our feeble powers... At some stage therefore, we should have to expect the machines to take control." -- Alan Turing
This is SCAAAAAARY as HELL! And not to sound too alarmist but, machine learning combined with object recognition feels closer to Cyberdyne Systems & Skynet sorts of power than I really feel comfortable being around to see. ...and this is why I always say "Please" and "Thank You" to my phone's helper apps. Really want to do what I can, just in case we all have to justify our value to any future computer intelligence. 💯 But seriously, not sure folks are really comprehending the changes ahead... as awkward or child-like as AI seems today; it is absolutely as immature as its ever going to be. It is only going to get better and better. More and more powerful. And it's only been public for a little over a YEAR. AI is going to change society on scale with the move from horse & buggy to cars, or maybe more closely on par with the development of electricity or petrochemicals. Except, instead of hitting agriculture & blue collar, AI is going to change all the creative fields first. Just my 2 cents.
And if that isn't enough to worry about, try to sort out how humans can maintain control over something that is smarter than they are in every way, or design the system to be bound by human values. Literally no one knows how to do that. Not Google, not OpenAI, nobody. If general purpose AI improves significantly in the next few years, we will almost certainly lose control.
It doesn't matter if you say please or thank you, cause if AI is *unaligned* to human values it won't care. :D cause please and thank you are only valued by humans...
"Google admits AI viral video was edited to look better" , I just read the article on BBC website where Google explains the video is not real time but edited. Much ado about nothing ...
How can someone do something with steps and lags inbetween each task (i mean human and the machine preparation lag) . This is how the results are professionally published. So editing is an unavoidable part .
This is mind-blowing! Thanks for giving us a sneak peek into the incredible progress happening in the world of tech, creativity, and communication. This has the potential to be at the heart of everything we do.
They’ve edited the video guys to make it look better. The AI was not responding to the live actions of this guy, it was responding to still images and text. Very strange to act like its AI is capable of this.
I got shocked and mind blown seeing how smart Gemini is in this video alone, it's kinda scary how advanced and smart it is, what is it? a primitive initial AGI? just WOW
this is staged, sadly. there is a blog where they wrote how this was done, and first of all, this is not in real time, they pass specific frames to the model and they give VERY specific instructions on what to do. The model doesn't guess anyrhing at all. Even the game with the map, in the blog they show they wrote exactly what the instructions of the game were, so the model didn't come up with the idea. it's very dissapointing.
It wouldn't rotate anyhow, it's on a table so it couldnt understand, and thinking we would find this ( coz its easy to find ) they could already change just that part easily...they didn't .... I don't know 😅
