‚120 Fourth Age: In this year on March 1st came at last the Passing of King Elessar. It is said that the beds of Meriadoc and Peregrin were set beside the bed of the great king. Then Legolas built a grey ship in Ithilien, and sailed down Anduin and so over Sea; and with him, it is said, went Gimli the Dwarf. And when that ship passed an end was come in Middle-earth of the Fellowship of the Ring.‘ I remember reading the ending in the appendix. I almost cried.
I love the story of there friendship because if you think about it they both had to get over so much to be just friends like the most obvious one, legolas is a elf and gimli is a dwarf. But they also had to get over more like. Legolas's father inprisons gimli's father and the hatred over that. And the fact that they became great friends to the point they are like brothers is truly amazing. I have seen much friendships in life that rise and fall but I have never seen a friendship more inspiring then legolas and gimli.
The fact that Gimli's video lasted a minute more than Legolas's one could be a hidden easter egg to their first bet that Gimli won by 1 score. Don't know if Nerd had that one in mind, but nonetheless, cool stuff :D
Same here. I think it comes from the fact that he may not be the wiser but the most passionate. He's not the hero that acts because it's the right thing to do but the one whose acts reflect what he believes in. Loyalty, friendship and honor.
I think it's touching to see a gruff, salty dwarf become fast friends with those who were once his enemies. Gimli is that friend that can be a little much to take with you when you go out, but he's the first one you call when you're in trouble.
7:50 I still feel that the gift Gimli requested and received from Galadriel is one of the best pieces of character and lore building in any medium. Perfectly executed in the extended edition of the film, we clearly see the admiration Gimli has for her when he's asked by Legolas. The fact that the true meaning behind this gesture is unbeknownst by him (and I'd imagine most viewers) makes this such a powerful scene when you do finally research and realize the significance behind it.
It was news to me aswell as it is not mentioned in the Silmarillion to my knowledge. Where is it written that Feanor asked Galadriel? I hvae not yet finished the unfinished tales.
Valar:no dwarves Gimli and Legolas: *have a beautiful friendship that truly benefits all of middle earth* Valar: *crying at the sheer greatness and wholesomeness of the friendship* maybe this can be an exception
I thought the reason was actually because he possessed the hair of galadriel which is not of the moral realm. Kind of like why Frodo and Bilbo were allowed
Which is so stupid to think about, like, why would the Valar only allow elves there? Aren't men and even dwarves children of Iluvatar as well? Would it be because only elves are immortal? I don't remember seeing any reason for that on the books.
learning that most of Gimli's anger when first meeting men, which is shown in the films as him just being proud and quick to anger, is actually most of the time in defense of Galadrial is so much better and makes much more sense
I find in the movie Gimli isn't really angry at the riders, he just thinks eomer is being rude and replies with a little passive aggressive attitude. But Legolas does not take threats on his bffs life lightly and is genuinely ready to kill every one of those men to protect him.
I'm of the opinion that Tolkien wrote the Dwarves to freely, and ignorantly always get themselves in trouble. In the same way that Aule freely, and ignorantly created the dwarves. Their punishment in life, was to suffer for his creation. Many dwarves started great relationships. But, were always impertinent in how they felt betrayals from elves and men in the same way Aule suffered when his creation was found out.
Thank you for this. The Dwarves are the most difficult of Tolkien’s creatures to understand, yet you have brought them to life with this recital. Thank you also for finding such beautiful illustrations.
I’m a Midlands engineer from generations of smiths, miners and masons. They aren’t difficult to understand at all. Most of my family are just like them!🪓⚒⛏. Baruk Khazad! Khazad Ai Menui!
Interesting perspective, I find them very close to my heart, and Elves to be most alien. I can't imagine the worldview one has on the world after living for 1000 years.
@@TheTeodorsoldierabvb In retrospect, the Dwarves felt more kinship to Men than Elves. After all both races shared mortality and the free will of their desire - either greed and stubborn personality. The reason why Elves felt 'alien' to the rest of Middle Earth is because they are a race that is more related to the Valars, angelic beings that served the One, Eru Illuvatar, creator God of their world and universe.
As Dwarves live to 250 he is what a human would be in his 20s at the time. Dain killed Azog at 35 years, which for Dwarves is like a middle schooler killing the Orc leader.
Ah wow. The story of gold not having power over Gimli, and him treasuring Galadriels hair above all is so sweet. Same with Legolas helping his, by that time, old friend to sail to Valinar. Very touching.
For some reason this video made me cry. I love Gimli's story. Him departing with Legolas to the west is the cutest and most heartwarming thing ever. Thank you
What I love about Gimli, is that he has the fierceness that Dwarves are known for, yet he had the uncanny ability to befriend those that he once was at odds with. That singular fact made Gimli possibly the most important Dwarf in Tolkien's writings, helping to both mend and establish important relations.
@@willchen4138 Aulë seeing one of his people in Valinor would be such a great moment for him. Let us not forget that two of his Maiar, Sauron and Saruman, betrayed Eru and turned to evil. Seeing one of HIS creations, who were set by Eru to be at odds with the Elves, gain entry to Valinor through his friendship with an Elf must've made the Valar Smith very happy
Gimli is really the only dwarf that were permitted to enter the Undying Land. In fact, I would be happy if Aule finally talk to one of his children after a very long time that haven't contacted them at all.
Overall Dwarves came out ahead over Elves and Men. AFAIK, there's no massive kin slaying among Dwarves and overall they resisted evil fairly effectively. That god has a lot to be proud of.
Aulë seeing one of his people in Valinor would be such a great moment for him. Let us not forget that two of his Maiar, Sauron and Saruman, betrayed Eru and turned to evil. Seeing one of HIS creations, who were set by Eru to be at odds with the Elves, gain entry to Valinor through his friendship with an Elf must've made the Valar Smith very happy
I’m so happy I found this channel. You do an excellent job of telling Tolkien’s stories in a simple way and yet with all the emotion of a huge fan of the books, I welled up at the end of this video even though I knew perfectly well what was coming. Tolkien’s work stays with you through a lifetime, unabated.
That Durin's Bane art is gorgeous. THAT is what a Balrog should look like. The humanoid form is somehow so much more intimidating than what we got in the film. I suppose because you can see it as the dangerous intelligence it is rather than just a big scary monster.
I don't know why, but this video just hit different than the others. Maybe I'm a dwarf at heart, but I felt so much emotion when Gimli went to Valinor with Legolas, so he could be with his friend until the end of his days.
Something about Gimli's tale really hits me right in the feels. He treasures his friends above all and his unlikely best friend loves him so dearly that he can't bear to leave him behind making him the only dwarf to ever join the elves in the gray havens.
Your content is beyond helpful for those of us who have a hard time with comprehensive reading like I do. Reading a book while listening to its audio book and then going back and reviewing content like this to cement what was read and extra information to fill in blanks. So thankful and grateful.
I like how this video was posted on the anniversary of Legolas hearing seagulls for the first time. Gimli's reaction to losing his friend proved his profound emotional depth.
That was actually a really moving end for Gimli. I tried to read the books as a kid but found them to be quite a laboring read so never went back. I like these vids showing me what happened after
I somehow read the books when I was a kid. I have no idea how I did it, but I did. Returning to the books now, I was a bit scared of their "density" in advance, but to my pleasant surprise it's going great so far. I'm getting very excited as the action builds up, and I'm expecting to revisit all the awesome characters and events which are sort of embedded in my subconscious, as well as illustrated by the amazing movies I watched countless times :) Rambling aside, I would encourage you to pick up the books again - chances are you will find it easier this time. The beginning (about the history of the hobbit race) can be a bit daunting, as well as the constant descriptions of nature - but you can get used to those very quickly and they do help paint the picture. Nature is an important theme in the books, and being constantly aware of how it looks and feels, in specific Tolkien-brand detail, really does wonders for immersion.
@@alexeyagapov4205 you’re probably right. I managed to get through the ASOIAF series and there’s few book series as daunting as those. Ok I’m sold I’ll give it another go
I love that illustration of Galadriel giving Gimli the hairs. It's so wholesome. That smile on her face shows she knows there's no darkness in his heart.
As others wrote before me... i can only add that it moves me to tears to hear from Gimli's story .... it's wonderfull, adventures and full of loyalty and friendship ... he's a true Dwarf for sure .. but what moved me most is the friendship with Legolas and the fact that he went with him when he left Middleearth.
Gimli and Galadriel’s first encounter is one of the most beautiful passages in the entire trilogy. 😭❤️ And I love it’s immediate effect on Legolas. Galadriel’s words open his heart to Gimli and, suddenly, one of the most beautiful and truest friendships is begun-a ripple effect of Galadriel’s own love and compassion.
Gimli has always been my favorite character in all of Tolkien's work. There's been lots of different great and timeless characters but it always comes back to Gimli for me. Love his story through Lord of the Rings and his friendship with Legolas is incredible.
I like to imagine that Aule visited Gimli after he arrived in Tol Eressea and they spent many long days together talking about his adventures and the good of the Dwarves. Sauron and Saruman's betrayals probably hurt Aule horribly, but seeing one of his own children, this eloquent, humble dwarf who helped save the world, probably gave him so much pride and happiness.
This is exceedingly well done and very heart touching, maybe its the nature of the subject but I always thought the dealings with Galanderal and Gimli was among the more profound parts of Tolkien's work.
I liked gimli’s character in the trilogy but it’s sad that he really only served as a comedic element. Book Gimli is so much better. Gimli and Legolas friendship is just legendary, and the fact that he, of all the dwarves, came to Aman. I mean just imagine his wonder when he meets his maker, Aulë, or as the dwarves call him, Mahal. Also, idk if those in the Halls of Mandos can have visitors, but imagine Gimli visiting Feänor’s cell and taunting him because Galadriel gave him her hair but not to Feänor. Lol, jk, that’s not Gimli but it would be pretty funny
I wouldn't said "Sad", it's actually a testament to Gimli's character and personality, that yes as a typical rowdy Dwarven member of the fellowship, he was used for timed comedy moments, but however Gimli is still seen as a powerful member of the group, and repeatedly shown to keep up with all members and have no fear when going toe to toe with anyone who threatened his friends or the missions he was tasked with. So even in the light hearted moments, not once do Gimli's character look stupid or unaware of the horrors that lay wait. He was proud, strong, and with his few words spoken, always held weight to the greater audience. Anyways that's just my opinion.
@@xianxiii3029 I agree, Gimli was not just some witless moron in the films. His behaviour lines up with the typical dwarf characteristics and he was portrayed great in the films. I just like book Gimli better. One such example from the books is Gimli’s convo with Legolas about the Glittering Caves. That passage is one of my favourites, and it would’ve been so awesome if it was in the movies, but obviously, movies are movies and it’s not always simple and practical to do those types of translations from text. By no means do I think movie Gimli was bad, and that’s honestly my fault if that’s the picture you had. I shouldn’t have said “sad”, it is a bad way to describe it, so that’s on me, sorry.
There’s just something really touching about how Galadriel had the wisdom and knowledge needed to help set Gimli straight and get the ball rolling to unite elves and dwarfs as friends and allies once again. Both come from mighty and unimaginable heights. Both had fallen from grace and carry countless marks of shame. Both by the end could finally start shedding those burdens as they fade into history, united once again.
Wow! You brought me to tears again! I thought this would just be a rehash of your Legolas video. How wrong I was! Fascinating to get the different perspectives! Their different stories and character journeys. More please! There are a lot of great middle earth RU-vid channels, and yours is my favorite.
What a great video to come home from work to! Gimli is definitely one of my favorites his loyalty and peerless fighting skills with his axe. I adore his close friendship with Legolas and how he endeared himself to Galadriel.
I know I'm repeating myself but you have a fabulous voice. I'm ashamed to admit it but at the end of your videos a few tears from emotion always fall. You should read ebooks as a profession (if you don't already). p.s. congratulate Chief40123 for the amazing job on the shots!
I always end up getting teary eyed everytime I hear about Legolas and Gimli sailing into the west together to Aman. It's such a touching story that really shows true friendship. May their friendship never be forgotten until the end of days.
Gimli has always been one of my favorites. Learning that he goes to the Undying Lands with Legolas to spend the rest of his days warmed my heart so much it brought me to tears. Such a beautiful friendship. I have been binge watching all of your videos lately and I really enjoy them. This one, so far, is my favorite ❤ thank you for what you do!
Becoming addicted to your videos. The voice over, the maps, the knowledge, the pace, it's amazing work. It's been pushing me to reconnect with Tolkien's work. Now treated myself to all his books in hardcover/illustrated editions, re-reading everything after 20 years before the Amazon show starts. :D
With what material? Tolkien purposely wrote it as a record instead of a narrativr so people would use their imagination. God, these "gap fillers" are annoying.
If you haven't read the books here's a sample of why you should; Gimli lamenting leaving Lothorien and Galadriel: "The travellers now turned their faces to the journey; the sun was before them, and their eyes were dazzled, for all were filled with tears. Gimli wept openly. 'I have looked the last upon that which was fairest,' he said to Legolas his companion. 'Henceforward I will call nothing fair, unless it be her gift.'.... 'Tell me, Legolas, why did I come on this Quest? Little did I know where the chief peril lay! Truly Elrond spoke, saying that we could not foresee what we might meet upon our road. Torment in the dark was the danger that I feared, and it did not hold me back. But I would not have come, had I known the danger of light and joy. Now I have taken my worst wound in this parting, even if I were to go this night straight to the Dark Lord. Alas for Gimli son of Glóin!'"
Wow I have to say this video is deep on an emotional level. The friendship between Gimli and Legolas is profound. The response from Galadriel was also impactful. Someone started cutting onions at the end though... that music.
As I discover more and more stories from Middle Earth Gimli is slowly but surely becoming my favourite besides Gandalf. He always stood his ground and was willing to put it on the line when someone talked ill of someone. Mostly Lady Galadriel. I don't know why but the story about gifting 3 of her hair to Gimli always brings tears to my eyes. Gimli managed to form friendships so great that they influenced 2 entire races.
Finally!!! Just found your channel the other week and have gone thru a bunch. and was looking for this one, glad I now don't have to go searching for something that wasn't there
I've been watching hours and hours of these and i've never read the books and only watched the movie series maybe 5 times but these videos makes me wanna read the all the books too there's so much more story and it's much more in-depth and interesting
The idea of Gimli reuniting with Galadriel again across the sea fills me with great joy. It’s like seeing a long lost friend in Heaven, and it’s a beautiful thing to think about
Not gonna lie; I almost cried a little when seeing the part about Gimli being allowed to the Blessed Realm. I want a feature-length animated cartoon about Gimli made called Elf-Friend. Quick question, though: what happens if/when you die in the Land of the White Shores? I thought that was Middle Earth's immortality.
Mortal beings still die in Aman. It's called the Undying Lands because of the immortals who live there. The land itself doesn't have the power to make anyone immortal. Instead, in the Undying Lands are located great Halls/caves of Mandos, where the spirits of the dead Elves, Men and Dwarves go. The dead Elved are ultimately given new bodies and come alive again. The dead Dwarves stay in the Halls until the end or the world, when there will be a new world made - the Dwarves will help to shape it. And the dead Men (and Hobbits) depart from the Halls, are given a ship in a haven and sail out of the universe, to some unknown destination outside of it (probably they go to Eru).
I absolutely love the story of Gimli. Like most, the way he allows himself to see and been taken by the adoration of Lady Galadriel is so heartwarming given the rough and bristling persona when we first meet Gimli. Seeing that lead to the best friendship in Tolkien’s lore with his love of Legolas is one of the richest stories in all of Arda.
I love the films, they shaped my childhood perhaps more than anything else. But since reading the books, I think THE worst 'adaptation' is what PJ did to Gimli. In the books he's such a stoic character, and full of pride for his people in a restrained way. I get the films needed some kind of 'comic relief' to appeal to all audiences, but really not a good change.
Even if they wanted comic relief, they went way overboard. Gimli absolutely did not need to be what they turned him into. I like John Rhys-Davies portrayal of him but the way he was written is a huge disappointment.
I agree! Two major things he got wrong were Gimli Son Of Gloin and Faramirs response to finding the ring was borne by Frodo. Ruins the story arc of the healing of the rifts between the Free Peoples caused by Morgoth and Sauron and that those that desired the ring perished and those that refused it survived!
No, as much as I love the films I think the greatest travesty in them his his portrayal of Denethor. Denethor is just completely mischaracterized in the films as some sort of cartoonish villain and coward.
I always think of poor John Rhys Davies who played Gimli, allergic to the latex makeup and with terrible puffy eyes, unable to see in so many scenes of the movies.
