The Darkest Roblox Game... 

The game was removed off of roblox (by the original creators's request), but it is still on Itch.io! Heres the link if you want to play for yourself: nouhidev.itch.io/my-eyes-deceive

I think one of the first red flags this game presented was that you drink water from the tap. If the world is ridden with disease, wouldn’t it be safe to assume that something in the water is contaminated?

If I’m not mistaken, this is based off of the Fritzl case, where a father kept his daughter hostage in a bunker he made for 24 years. He regularly forced himself on her. I recognize the hallways and walls, they used the same design as the bunker. The halls are skinny and they walls are cork to silence any noise.

For those wandering about the 2nd ending it will skip to day 147 and father wasnt caught and when father came back the player asked the father "why do i feel nauseous every morning? " Just to let you know nausea is a sign of pregnancy so yeah.

Its wild how some people pick Roblox as a creative outlet to make these terrifying pieces of media. The concept alone and the interactions between the girl and her "papa" make this absolutely frightening.

I remember reading a two sentence horror story on reddit that had the same exact line from the ending of the game, and seeing this visually is very depressing. Just imagine if this was based on a true story.

-The Darkest Roblox game -Can see things clearly

I’m surprised no one is talking about how the plants, horse chair, and tablet all represent childish objects implying that the character isn’t just the daughter, but is also extremely young. This could also mean that the man was expecting her to get pregnant and have a kid or that she has been in there since she was a kid which makes sense considering she hadn’t seen the sun nor an apple edit: plants can mean flowers which little girls like

Man, i usually dont get that disgusted at heavy topics such as this but when i found out what was actually happening to the girl in the basement it actually made me feel sick. This game honestly does an incredible job at what it tries to achieve.

Summary: "The father is actually a creep and the daughter is a victim." So your self intuition may guess this very correctly... [The Good Ending] is when the daughter escapes at Day 7 for not taking the so called "antidote" [The F***ed-up Ending] still continues with the day progression when said daughter continues her daily basis and as it stops at Day 147. From there, the daughter asks herself why "Is her belly round and big" This fricking made me gag, and i have no idea how'd this get to roblox, probably an 18+ restricted game, if not, what the hell Edit: Bad ending was censored with a different dialogue

Disturbing fact: This is actually based on a real crime and there were hints in the game that were removed but was referencing the things that happened to the crime. (Inspired by a basement dwelling reddit post and real police case).

I believe this game is about the true story of Elizabeth Fritzel. Especially how the rooms were laid out is exactly how Elizabeth’s room was. (The thin entrance way to her bedroom to kitchen to bathroom) She was taken to her own family basement at 18 by her dad and was kept there for 24 years. Her dad Josef r@ped Elizabeth and she gave birth to 7 kids (one died). Soon her oldest daughter is the one who got sick a lot and Elizabeth was able to convince her dad to take her to the hospital to treat her daughter aka Josef’s daughter aka his granddaughter. Elizabeth was able to go and spoke to a security there? Or a doctor? (I’m unsure) and she revealed about her situation. They all were saved. It was later discovered that Elizabeth’s own siblings and mom lived upstairs the entire time and had no clue. I believe this game’s good ending is what her life could’ve been. And the horrible ending when she stayed there longer till she finds out she’s pregnant is the true ending and the beginning of her nightmare. This story is all how Elizabeth’s story began when she had her first child. Except this time for the game, it seems your character is even younger than Elizabeth especially how she had no idea what the outside world was.

Reminds me of an actual situation that happened, a man kidnapped a little girl and kept her in a crawl space behind his closet with police coming to the door each day from how suspicious he was but they never found anything. It's crazy how this could happen with a child but have it where the child has only memories of doing things like that. I couldn't imagine how it would be like.

damn rogurt really went from goofy games to games that have serious topics edit: I HAVE MORE LIKE THEN YOGURT LET'S GO

There's a reason i watch people play horror games, i'm not gonna play this by myself

One thing i noticed when playing the game is that the "antidote" pills had no label or prescription whatsoever which made me think "This child is receiving pills without the label from her father... Pretty sketch". I also can't believe the bad ending where shes pregnant and how this is inspired by a real life case. Great game really putting you in the perspective of CSA victims and what their thoughts and minds must be at.

the real game is very dark. in the original for this route(bad ending for taking your "antidote") the girl asks "why is my belly so big and round". due to roblox rules its censored as "why do i feel so nauseous every morning" which is also a sign of pregnancy, but more child friendly to explain. the good ending is where you don't take your "antidote" you pretend to fall asleep, but "papa" comes down and attempts to rape you(again). this time, the police come early and you don't get raped. you find out your so called antidote is actually sedatives. in the original game, the post ending for either one or both(cant remember sorry) you can see condoms on the nightstand. hope this clears up everything.

I absolutely adore the atmosphere games like this pull off and the fact it’s in roblox adds a sense of nostalgia for me and immerses me so much more crazy how so many elements come together for stuff like this

This roblox game has a lot cut from the original game probably because of roblox policies. Basically what happens is: you play as a little girl, the antidote are actually sedatives and whenever you go to bed to sleep, papa comes inside and rapes you. In the bad ending, you end up pregnant and the little girl says “why is my belly so round and full papa?” to papa instead of “why do I feel so nauseous every morning papa?”. In the good ending where you don’t take your sedative, you hear him coming in and unzipping his pants but then someone knocks at his door (probably the police) and you make a run for it and you escape. There are also condoms on the nightstand in a post credit cutscene.

This game conveys its story so well. It leaves most everything ambiguous to the point that you'll only really understand it if you *know* the topics

Thanks for playing the Roblox port of my 'game'! Since the original download link has been removed, if anybody sees this comment and has questions, I'd be willing to answer them!

WARNING! This game is a roblox recreation of original game "My Eyes Deceive". It's more scarier because of the PS1 style and contains the story not all of you might wanna read in this comment down below. If you didn't understand what happened in this roblox game and original one, you can read it here. (MASSIVE SPOILERS FOR BOTH GAMES) Main character is a girl, she is locked in the basement and her father visits her almost every day, you will understed later on why I said ALMOST EVERY DAY. As we progress further into the game we see the pills, the "nightmares" and choices. Lets start low: "Choices" - first one with "the outside" is basically changing the look of the free roam part and doesn't really affect the game itself, the other choices will affect the endings... There are 2 endings (both of which I will type here later on) 1 is good, second is bad. Nightmares )here comes in the full description, here we go) - First one is basically some kind of intro that gives us a question: "What's outside?". Second one is a semi labirinth (First choice with spikes will change the nightmare to be non labitinth but still with a monster in the end and just some spikes; second will be teh labirinth and it's image leaks us the corridors, but not of our bunker, of one of the endings.) with a monster in the end as was listed in these shits:"(" ; ")" Third one is just free roam and basically almost none on YT know wth is this one since it literally describes the staircase like first one. AND HERE WE GO: Choices with pills will affect the endings. First one is: "Take the pills" - So what heppens? The nightmare will be repeated with our roomspace where we can see the illustration of us repeating the same day over and over again without the change. The chains will grow more in more because we literally limit ourselves by drinking those pills withourt the change. After that the ending will be a black screen with the words from main character such as: Why is my belly so round and big, papa? (WE WILL TALK ABOUT THAT LATER) - Ending number 1. What if we will not take the pills? Heres whats gonna change: The nightmare will be like rogurts one and the exact same ending. About the nightmare: We are breaking the chains that are limiting us, by that move freeing us from the shit we live in every day. We soon in semi-ending will PRETEND that we are asleep, papa will go into our "bunker" and will say words like in the video (exept that the word shoot was originally meant to be "Shit." \ You know... roblox policy.) Then we awake again and escape the basement. SO HERES THE MOST IMPORTANT PART. The pills were not against the fucking infection or smth, ther are just sedatives (You will know why our father want us to drink em) And here we go: "Why our father wasn't coming back so long?" Police took an eye on his purchases and then after some time in "monkey cage" he came back. Also here in that location after going outside we will see that our main hero NEVER SEEN A SUN BEFORE. And the most horrific part is: Why dad imprisoned us here? Whats the DARK BOX ON OUR DESK? Let me explain: Dad is not that good as you know now, every fucking night he comes into our "bedroom zone" and then... RAPES THE MAIN HERO "US". YES EVERY FUCKING NIGHT. THATS WHY IN ENDING 1 (The bad one) WE GOT THAT ONE BIG BELLY - WE ARE PREGNANT IN THAT ONE ENDING. BUT THERE WE ARE FREE FROM THIS SHIT AND ARE SAVED BY OURSELVES FROM THIS SHIT. So whats in the black box? Rogurt didn't show us (or the ending of the roblox game didn't show him and all of us) that one intro after credits. Black and white style, camera slowly approaches our bed and then shortly after focuses on the desk with the pills... The black box, was a pack of rubber condoms. So yeah, sounds in the black screen which Rogurt just watched, was our father taking his pants off, and then being interrupted by the police, saving us from being raped once more... Thats the full story, all the way from the original game, not any fiki, not any YT video from dev with "secret info", ALL IN GAME. A scary story, with a hidden pardons inside it. That's it...

Dear god, the poor girl didn’t even know what the hell the sun even was. She’s been kept down there for who knows how long and it’s so disgusting to think about. This game has perfectly captured the scariest concept of horror, which is reality. It’s absolutely horrifying to think that things so disturbing happen in the real world, and this game gives a glimpse into what it’s like being taken advantage of as a poor, innocent child that doesn’t even know they’re being manipulated. 11/10 horror game, I’m glad an actual high quality horror game such as this was published because the trash, cheap jumpscare games were starting to define roblox horror. Good to see there’s still hope. For all victims of horrible crimes like these, I hope they only receive nothing short of kindness and support

I played this game (and got the same ending as you) right before watching this video and the beginning of the game is much more chilling after getting ending 2. Some things I picked up while watching this that I didn't realize on the first playthrough: -The "monster" he was talking about running into might have been a cop or someone else questioning his activities. -Papa telling the kid to not trust anyone without the password is probably an attempt to have the kid not be found if the cops investigate -The days during which Papa was not there were probably when the spontaneous investigation happened and Papa was taken to be questioned

The twist was very chilling indeed, no one should ever experience this.

You can say the game was full of dark moments.

This case is so disgusting. I thought this would be a game similar to omori, but really, it was about a father raping her 11 year old daughter and gaslighting her everyday or so. Im so glad she got saved from it. From google, this game is based off of the Elizabeth Fritzl case; "Fritzl kept his daughter Elisabeth locked in a cellar from when she was 18 until she reached the age of 42. Trapped underground and enslaved, she was raped thousands of times by her own father and gave birth to seven of his children. He had sexually abused her from when she was 11." As a two-sentence summary, "My papa always made me take my antitode, it alway made me sleepy but it was keeping me safe." "But, sometimes i wonder, why has my belly grown big and round from it?" This is the bad ending, by the way!

I knew something related to sexual assault (like rape) would take place in this, as soon as I saw the “antidote” I knew it was some form of sedative or drug like ketamine (which is used in most cases of rape due to its paralytic effects, the dissociative effects that cause people to have no idea about what is going on around them and the way it makes your body not feel any pain) I do like how it shows and gives you a uneasy feeling about “father” as soon as he is introduced, making you feel unsafe, it makes it feel so much realer than a game and more horrifying due to how real this is

never saw rogurt being that serious in an intro Edit:still shocked on how much like this is gaining

"A raspberry, hooray!" exclaimed as a giant shadow demon appears.

This is easily one of those games that didn't scare me, but straight up just felt creepy and disgusting.. Honestly, the dev did a pretty good job

I'm glad you didn't get the other ending. It ends with the main character you play as getting pregnant. It's disgusting honestly.

You can’t escape me and you know it.

The way the character said "is that an apple?" even tho it was a rasp berry, it actually shows that the character is very innocent, which means he/she was born or grew inside the bunker....

I did the other ending to see where it would go, and god, I feel terrible. I can’t believe how well the game manages to kinda put you in the steps of a child yourself, because before I saw the ending 2 on this video, I thought of all the ways the father could be good and innocent and how dangerous the outside world could be, then realized how hard I was lied to. Vivid imagination, trust in those close to you, it’s disturbingly able to pull your ankle in. In the bad ending, the same room loops over and over with chains and a red hue, it’s quite literally like a repeat every day and a prison. It even skipped to 147 days- I didn’t expect it to go on so long- and the end implying something *that bad-* I’m really disturbed. It’s a good game and gives you a step in a victims shoes, it’s just.. so disturbing.

i thought this game was actually about a daughter and a father surviving in this so called apocalypse but now that i see the ending and check the comments, i realize how messed up this game is and how people in real life also experience the same thing. It made me feel sick to my stomach.

hearing rogurt talking so softly in the intro got me feeling chills to my spine, definitely need to start a horror storytime channel bro

I never thought the first thing I'd hear when I clicked on a Rogurt video would be "A raspberry, Hooray!", in the most dead voice possible

The other ending (the most disturbing one): The character still takes the 'antidote' that we found out is called sedatives, sedatives are used to decrease the sensation of pain and touch, so basically when the character sleeps her, papa (you know what is) her. And we get a dialog saying "Why do I feel so nauseous every morning now, papa?" This is called "morning sickness" which occurs in pregnancies. The sad part is that she is a kid.

I find it really interesting how some roblox games can range from fun and goofy to really eerie depressing stuff like this

Rogurt being that serious is terrifying.

the fact nothing could actually hurt you is a nice thing as it just adds to suspense bc you expect to die or get chased

I remember playing this when it was at 0-2 players daily, im glad more people are starting to play the game (Yes I know it’s a remake of another original game but they had permission to make this)

I love when rogurt plays these types of games, hes just so chill and its fun to watch. especially when im eepy and the way he reads the dialogue it like hes reading a bedtime story to all his rogurt children. all of your work is amazing, thank you for being on youtube.

rogurts voice acting is a 10/10. very calm sounding and i honestly find it really nice. (especially whenever he voice acts the dad in this video)

This is definitely one of the best games (not just in roblox) I have ever seen, I mean tbh i had never felt so uncomfotable and thrilled at the same time. Thanks Rogurt for bringing this amazing (although very dark) game to us!

The only thing that disturbs me is the game story itself. The endings explained everything and it is so disgustingly disturbing. Bad Ending (disturbing asf): The daughter decides to continue it's daily cycle with the pills. She ends up pregnant because her "papa" actually rapes her on her sleep. The pills are actually sedacives. Good Ending: She decides to not taje her pills and she escapes to the police. This game captures what child abuse feels like. This gane is very disturbing but a creative way to represent the evilness of people nowadays. I feel bad for the girl. Poor girl. :.

12:05 My theory is that apple doesnt look like an actual apple because it the main character (you) has never seen an apple before and the character's mind is making what they think it looks like and I believe that the "monster" towering above you is actually a giraffe. It has a long neck, it is large, it is yellow and it has those sticks things that come out a giraffe's head and the giraffe is only trying to eat the "apple". What makes it so scary is that the giraffe doesnt totally resemble a giraffe. It was a nightmare because you have never seen a giraffe before. (I posted this late because I only thought of this recently)

its scary when rogurt doesnt laugh in the intro

I fucking knew i shouldnt trust papa, i called it from the start. When he made sure we took our meds everyday, and the fact that we got sleepy. Ah hell nah brother no way EDP was allowed to keep a child bro

Dang this really was dark. I wasnt expecting it to be that sad. This might be the first serious video I have seen by u. And no outro text. Feel better rogurt :(

If you whanna know, Ending 1, is the ending where you get a weird P.T type thing, you keep walking up the stairs, leading back to your room, and chains connecting from everywhere, every time you go up through the stairs and back in your room, they are placed somewhere else, until eventually the "Antidote" is there,and it says: "I trust papa." And then it skips to day 141 and you say you feel nauseous, and then it turns to black.

Not as dark as rogurt's basement (please let me out)

You know its actually scary when rogurt is serious and doesn't joke around with the boys, legitimately scary and dreadful and I feel kinda bad for rogurt, I would most likely never play this. But props to rogurt for actually pulling through.

Bro the moment when dad said "if you hear anyone besides me, do not make a sound" was so dark, because it signals that the cops could've found her. Dang they werent lying about the game being dark

Everything about this really reminds me of Presentable Liberty, especially the minigame tablet and the 'DAY X' text. The journal and dream parts are great additions to the formula!

This game is crazy, I was not expecting it to be how it was, but I had ideas of what the 'father' was like. It changed my whole point of view, such a dark game. I admit, I never get scared at games, but I was feeling anxiety watching this, immersed. Dark, really dark.

the roblox game is a recreation so it had to be watered down a bit; in the original ending where you take the antidote, she’d state that she’s “feeling nauseous” while in the original it says “why is my belly so big and round” which the original is easier to understand, she’s pregnant i think you can figure out how this happened.

one of my favorite parts of this game is the music. i like the vibe of it, the clair de lune and the chopin nocturnes edited to have a slightly fuzzy background noise to it. this game also makes me cry too, thank you for playing it.

The crazy thing about it is that the most scary things in life are real, monsters and ghosts and demons might frighten you, but a human is the most terrifying creature of them all. 🙌🏽

The fact that the dad was a hero for the child-

I feel kind of proud that i guessed the entire ending the first time i saw "papa" talk about the outside world. I like how it gives hints, for example, how does he bring the food if he cant come in? There was also the fact the kid had warm water and electricty even though there would be nobody filtering the water in the apocalypse. Even in his dialogue you can see the cracks when he only mentions that he saw a "Monster" but never actually explains what the "Monster" did after he witnessed it or if he had to hide from it. Overall this is probally one of the best horror games i've ever played! Theres no cheap jumpscares and you're actually afraid aswell as curious for what happens next, the ending actually feels like a real scenario (most likley already happened at some point in the world) and i really hope more horror games (not just in roblox) actually make stuff like this instead of shitty jumpscare fests with no plot or gimmicks.

Rogurt i love your horror game videos its sooo entertaining, i hope you have a good day and stuff .✌

bro the first ending is even darker than the second cause at least she escapes the first ending she asks why she feels “nauseous” which is a sign of pregnancy i think

This reminds me of a 2 sentence horror story that goes like this "My dad told me never to open the basement door, one day I did. whats that glowing ball in the sky and why does it hurt my eyes?"

actually saw different gameplay, i know whats gonna happen but its fun to watch you play (: in the other ending, if you do take the antidote, on day 8 you will mention that you are "starting to feel sleepy".

I always come to your channel to find genuine scary games on roblox! Played this game before watching the video, I got the good ending and was a little confused, did some researching, watched videos of the original game and then realised how f-ed up the other ending was... THIS GAME IS GENUINELY A PSYCHOLOGICAL HORROR!

I should not have watched this video and understanding the story before going to work, I felt sick throughout my shift. I just want to know what compels someone to do that with their child, and some people want to normalize it, it’s really sickening.

I just finished a video from you, and then a new one is posted. the never ending entertainment train

Nothing is more better than a long horror video with rogurt and us getting heart attack 24/7

this looks like a computer science class project and it genuinely made my stomach churn. keep up the good work man

I love this video, but also thank you so much for including the ORIGINAL game in the description, i haven't really seen any other RU-vidrs do this and its super helpful for the original creator ^_^

damn, this is quite dark. Thanks Rogurt!

rogurt is back again with long creepy roblox videos and WERE ALL FOR IT

Hey rogurt, my cosuin had died yesterday, everything was bad. I still watch ur vids ur personality is amazing I love the games u play always giving out horror games to play making roblox not boring, thanks so much for being a RU-vidr, I love ur vids man ❤️

Played this game and the second i got into it and talked with the dad i knew exactly what was going on, the dread in this game is immense

i saw this video, paused it, played the game for myself, then watched your play through, and OH WOW. i recognized the story from somewhere when i played, and then i remembered! the fritzl case! i did research on it for a school project last year, and it’s kinda cool to see people create their own idea of an incident like that. the two different endings also brings somewhat of a creative twist to the original story, but maybe that’s just me. thank you for randomly popping up on my recommendations and showing me this game, lmao.

fact: The real game “my eyes deceive” is where a game that has to endings: Bad And Good The good ending: the little girl of the “father” was pretending to sleep, well her father tried to.. you know later. The father heard a doorbell ring, but the father didnt shut the basement door. So the his “daughter” came outside the house finding a sunlight after years locked up in there. Bad ending: so.. the father always lied about monters roaming in the city, when the day the father wasnt there 2 days the police went to investigate because of the fathers suspicious purchases when the little girl checked the pharmacy receipt, yeah you know. The father was giving the girls those pills so the father can r@p3 her, the original game bad ending titles the little girl saying : why is my belly round and big That the girl had been pregnant with the father, disgusting dark truth..😨 So thats why the father has been r@p1ng her for months/years

It's really crazy where in real life this could really happen to anyone, even children, just like this game shows. Couldn't believe you could do that to a very young child.

"Right is always right, until it isnt." That quote describes the game a bit.

"You know here at the Rogurt channel, we're not big fan of the right idea. We're kinda stupid around here." -Rogurt

this is just sad. what a roblox story game wasnt that scary it was just... depressing.

Thinking about it, everything in the game is lines up. All the nightmares correlate to some tough thing in the child’s life, the maze being like what he feels his bunker is like. The fall, like being helpless and isolated from the outside word. And the chains and how we broke them, like being finally free from the bunker after he stopped taking the antidotes. I also noticed how the receipt spelt “shopping” wrong, as the receipt spelt it “shoping”. Overall, this game is very well made! It really takes the horror genera to a whole new level.

just to be silly you should totally read bedtime stories to us 😊tbh your voice is just so nice I've fallen asleep to like half of your videos

I had a feeling that was going to be the twist for the game. Also thank god you got the second ending becomes the first one’s implications make me want to vomit because yes, the situation is actually that bad.

The black bars on the side make the atmosphere so much scarier and I can’t think why

reminds me a lot of cry of fear and afraid of monsters - especially considering the major themes of just how it's all in le head and how medication for rampant, vicious afflictions within the faculties of the human mind often only exascerbates the suffering the victim goes through.

wow... just wow. and to believe this game is actually something that can happen in real life is just sad. amazing game. really makes you feel all that tension.

I feel so bad for the girl in this story. Its so sad what happens to her in both games, made me almost cry.

when rogurt said "right is always right" the legendary phrase, i could feel it coming inside of me

When I hear dark games, I think of like gore, but this game really opened up my eyes to the extreme level of a dark indie game

This was dark, but it proves that Roblox can be much more than just some kids fun. I honestly did not expect that ending and holy fuck, was it well made.

My anxiety has never went up that fast until i saw the words "Where's Papa?" And I have immediately thought of many situations where I am alone in an enclosed place. With no one helping me.

SPOILERS: The og game was has some stuff cut out because it broke Roblox TOS and for a good reason, it's inspired from a real case. Just look up Elizabeth Fritzl and the fucked up shit starts there.

After looking a little bit deeper into this game, I feel genuinely disgusted by how real and horrible the story is, and just knowing that there’s people out there that are this sick in the head makes me want to throw up

This game is just dreadful, the music is perfectly eerie, and the maze thing is.. wow.. the music is loudened, and it feels like you are not alone, and the true originsmof it

This reminds me of a two sentence horror story that goes along like this: Mom and dad told me to never open the basement door, but one day I got curious. What is that giant glowing ball in the sky, and why does it hurt? I really hope this isn't based on a true story.

the storyline was so sad. The ending was just saddening:(

i absolutely loved seeing you play this!! this was absolutely haunting

Haven’t watched ur videos in a while but OMG I LOVE THIS