I read in Mary Agreda's 'The Mystical City of God' that Mary, when given the option to die or directly go to heaven, chose to die to follow Jesus, God elevates her to her leadership role but she continues to humble herself to Him, it's why He has full confidence and satisfaction with her, His masterpiece, because she never ceases to acknowledge and praise Him, she is the perfect human, His treasure. Jesus and Her are the perfect road maps to what is pleasing to Him.
@@suzannemcmaken4648James 5:20 let him know that he who turns a sinner from the error of his way will save a soul from death and will cover a multitude of sins. This is scripture. So who saves soul, the man who turn the error, or Christ?
@@suzannemcmaken4648 Do you really think that you honor Jesus by your blasphemy? If someone spit on your mother would you be ok with that? Perhaps you would be ok with that.
Mother Mary Change the hearts of the Political Leaders 😢 and let them know that their dirty politics innocents are suffering and dying . Let all world live peacefully Amen 🤲🙌🙏🕊⚘
Mary, Dear and Loving Mother who along with Your SON tried and tried to open the hearts of us unworthy sinners throughout the history of the human race and we ignored Both of YOU but YOU did not give up. Help to to pray and keep the Faith,
@gabrieltrabadillo6982 Rosary is miraculous and if you pray everyday it gives you that peace that defies understanding especially in these troubled times.
The Blessed Mother would have died at least three times: Simione prophecy. The finding of Jesus in the Temple after three days of searching; and at the foot of the cross, where she absorbed the full impact of the lance that pierced the heart of her Son, simultaneously piercing her heart. Kept alive by the decree of the Eternal Father. For me the Blessed Mother, when the time arrived to leave the world decreed by the Eternal Father, lapsed into seas and seas of ecstasy. Jesus, with the whole of paradise came to receive her body and soul, carried on the wings of angels to the bosom of the Eternal Father. The Blessed Mother lived and breathed the Divine Will and did nothing outside the Will of her Son.
@@patriciaw4270 Not everything that Jesus did is recorded in Scripture - this is stated by St. John. You are not obliged to believe this belief. But we Catholics do, and we also rejoice in this truth.
@@patriciaw4270 My faith. Paul, please research the story of Our Lady of Fatima and Our lady of Lourdes. You have nothing to lose; only to grow in knowledge and truth. God bless. Paul, I rarely share spiritual experiences. My mother for example: she had an enormous devotion to the Lord's holy mother; so much so, that she appeared to her on the very day that mum was to be operated, and asked her to cancel her scheduled operation, which mum did. Praise God that she did, because her specialist down the track said to her: Anna, I don't know what prompted you to change your mind concerning the operation, but thank God that you did, because when we investigated further with your cancer, because of your age, you would have endured immense suffering. My mother didn't share with him the reason she decided against it. Furthermore, Paul, when she died, the whole of my mother's house was filled with a fragrance of roses, so intense, which lasted for 8 solid hours in her home. My mother died in ecstasy. An impression that I will take to the grave and beyond. You are one of the few I have shared this with. Don't allow fear to stop you from being open to the Holy Spirit guidance. God bless.
The Church Fathers were split about the death and the location. It doesn't matter much. It could be theologically argued either for death or not. We know she's in heaven and we hope to join her and Jesus someday.
@@suzannemcmaken4648 Actually every Protestant Reformer viewed the Woman of Revelation 12: 1-6, which is the Lectionary Reading in the Roman Mass celebrated according to the 1970 Missal. John Calvin, the theological father of much of Presbyterian and Reformed doctrines did not do a commentary on Revelation (he questioned its canonicity just as Luther quested James) However Francois Lambert (A.D. 1528) a Calvinist and Heinrich Bullinger, the Swiss Reformer who was a pupil of Zwingli in their Commentaries on Revelation 12: 1-5 both say Mary as the Woman in Heaven. Leo Jud, also a Swiss Reformed theologian did as well. Other 16th century Protestants saw Mary as the Woman in Revelation 12 include David Chyträus, a German Lutheran from the mid to late 1500's and Jean Gagny (Famous German Lutheran Reformer from the Mid to late 1500s), Explicatio Apoc. XII, 1564, 234-235 Regarding Mary and the Assumption, Martin Luther himself preached a sermon on it in 1522 as did Zwingli. In fact, I as a Catholic can use all the original Protestants in the 16th century to refute 21st century protestants, without having to use the Early Church Fathers to come in and finish the job.
@@patriciaw4270 If you are Catholic, then you would listen to the Pope because Jesus left him as his representative on earth. If you are not, it's your loss. As to whether or not one should read the bible, that's a non sequitur. One has nothing to do with the other. The Bible is the only authority for those who believe in Sola Scriptura (which isn't biblical). Catholics have Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition. Sacred Scripture came from the Sacred Tradition. Read a little Church history.
As our priest reminded us on the Feast of the Assumption: Our Lords blood came from Our Lady, so did his bones in fact the growth of his whole body was because her body sustained His in her womb. In childhood she guided him towards the Father. Its only right that she, of all humans ever born, should not be subjected to an ordinary burial and the consequence of a decaying body; hence her Assumption into Heaven
@@Pablo-gl9dj Pablo .To honour is no way her making her higher than Our God Jesus.To tell me I am silly is a sin against charity.I hold the Blesses Virgin Mary ss the mother of God.
Yes! St. Luke painted the Our Lady of Czestochowa, Poland on the table top where Jesus, Mama Mary & St Joseph used to dine. It's a beautiful story worth sharing, it saved Poland from insurgencies throughout the centuries.
By the Holy Grace of God I have been privileged to visit Lady's House in Ephesus and I am totally convinced that she died and was Assumed into Heaven from Ephesus.
I am privileged to have Mary's beautiful name. And years ago when I was confirmed I took the name St Mary Magdalene. ❤️🙏💚🙏Bleased mother I love you with all my heart ♥ 🙏💚🙏💚🙏❤️
Salve Maria🙏🏼Fr Timothy Ring, Fr Br Vincent Fr Stephan. Thank you Herald of the Gospel for your Spiritual teaching I am learning so much and keep me closer to Jesus and Mother Mary, I feel close to God through the Consecration to Our Lady Mother of God and praying the Rosary every day of my life.Amen🙏🏼📿🌹💒🕊♥️🕊✝️📿📿📿⭐️⭐️⭐️
Well, the first follower of our Loving Saviour Christ is our Loving Mother Mary. She followed Christ until death towards the Cross of Christ. I read in a book, follow Christ and his cross daily. So that is the first thing our Mother Mary did during her earthly life. She was the first guidance, she was the first Mother that Divine, she was the first teacher, she was the first nun, she was the.first martyr, she was the first Lover of Christ, she was the first doctor and nurse of Jesus!!! She was the first of everything!!!!! She was the first that Christ resurrected.and assumed to heaven!!! She is the only Queen of eternal heaven!!!
@nathanmullins9203 You have no idea what you are talking about. The bible is a Catholic book. The Apostles are all Catholic. I suggest you repent, and perhaps the demon(s) will leave you.
There is a detailed story of Mary's passing in the Poem of the Man-God. She is with John the Apostle and knows Her time has come. He is reading scripture and praying with Her and She stops breathing. John tries to stay awake but on the third day he falls asleep and is only awakened in time to see Her being assumed into Heaven by angels through a hole they had made in the roof. The palm branches John had put around Her fell as the angels lifted Her up to Heaven where John saw Her embrace Jesus. The room smelled strongly of roses. Jesus explained that only Her spirit had left Her and that She didn't die like all the rest of die as Her soul did not leave Her Body. The Truth is Mary never had a tomb, She was not buried, but was assumed into heaven by the angels where She was crowned Queen of Heaven and earth and still prays for us Her children that Jesus gave to Her from His Cross. Thanks be to God. I love You, Mother Mary, please love Your Son with me and within my heart with Papa God for me especially at the Holy sacrifice of the Mass. Amen!!!
The Poem of the man God was written by Maria Valtorta. This book, The Poem of the Man God, was added to the Index of Forbidden Books in Dec 1959 by Pope John XXIII and does not have an imprimatur and broke with Canon Law. Pope John XXIII condemned this book, truly once this book was condemned by him, no further consideration should be given to this book. Avoid it and avoid this author Maria Valtorta.
@@AliciaMenchaca-n5v Padre Pio recommended this book and if You had read the 5 volumes multiple times as I have; you'd love these books as well. The Catholic Church also forbid Padre Pio from public mass for around 20 years, the church does make mistakes, now He is recognized as perhaps the greatest saint of the last century. Our lady of Medjugorje also recommended the Poem of the man-God, now you're going to tell me she hasn't been approved by the Church either? I tell you I became catholic because of my pilgrimmage to Medjugorje, whether or not the church approves it or not. don't get too hung up on the church's approval we now have an usurper for pope.
It sounds like you are a bit sensitive about the fact that you have decided to ignore the decision of a Pope and read a condemned book anyway. You need to wake up and realize that you can not do whatever you want in the Catholic Church. There are dogmas that must be believed and followed. Our Lord left us the office of the Pope as our guide and in cases of the magisterium he is infallible. This book was condemned before Vatican II and at a time when the hierarchy of the Church was much more solid than perhaps it is today. The exorcists also told us that the most important virtue that we can posses over any other, even over faith, is that of obedience. It really doesn't matter what you want. You must believe the dogmas of the Church and never abandon them. You can do as you please in Catholic Church. Keep on reading books on the Index of Forbidden Books and following Unapproved Apparitions. But do realize that this book is condemned by Pope John XXIII and printed anyway. Those who decide to do whatever they want and not follow the clear direction of the Church will need to account for this before the Holy Trinity at the Final Judgment. Take Good Care and may God always help you to discern what is best for your soul, for the only goal we have in life is our reunification with God in heaven.
@@AliciaMenchaca-n5v I obey the dogmas, you are mistaken if you think these books are still forbidden. I am 100% faithful to Popes like John Paul II and their directives; if you did some more checking you will find the ban on these books was lifted by a later pope.
Listen you can do as you please and follow whatever you want. I will follow the initial judgement of Pope John XXIII as these books should not have even been printed or distributed. May God Guide & Bless you and your family, as we all strive to be reunified with the Holy Trinity in heaven during these chaotic and confusing times.
Holy father's please will you keep our only brother Vincent in your Holy devotions please as he goes for his 2nd lot of treatments and the a 3rd lot for cancer
i believe she didnt die because she was immaculate. because death is only for all sinners as the scripture says death is the wage of sin. Salve Maria. 🙏🌷😇
@@coolcatbaron no she didn't die I believe, cuz that was impossible. I believe that maybe in another private revelation, mama Mary revealed to us how or what really happened during her assumption like a private revelation to a saint (forgot her name) where mama Mary revealed how she gave birth to Jesus which really shocked me. wow, beautiful holy birth that was. I'm sure if anyone learns how she gave birth to Jesus, that person would really be so amazed. so, I believe that the way she assumed body and soul into heaven was something similar to the way she gave birth to Jesus. Salve Maria. 🙏😇🌷
We adore her as the mother of christ she has never put herself before christ she leads us to him in prayers. She represents us the church as she is all human like us Our Lady was chosen by God to be the Immaculate conception Jesus is the fruit of her womb..
Hello. Yes, we honour and love Our Lady as the mother of Our Lord. We adore and worship Our Lord, for adoration and worship are reserved for God alone. God bless you.
Blessed Mother was pure no sin didn’t die why would she have a choice. I have so much respect for her she is perfect. The only woman in the human race to be the mother of our Savior.
So good to see you Fr. Steven! Received so many graces from the retreats you have given in Canada. Highly recommend the one upcoming in Calgary this fall for those who can attend.
Its immaterial whether she died or not , what is important is, Isaiah : A virgin shall conceive" its not about just a virgin but about an " Eternal Virgin" from this discern her truth, nevertheless revelation about her comes only comes according to the Will of God, Even as it is recited in the Holy Mass " As it was in the beginning it shall always be " How was it in the beginning ? Thesis & Phd's would not reveal , but unto babes,
I've heard it before, but it stands out this time - "if it serves for devotion and does nothing against faith and morals..." does this mean if I find something DOES cause my faith to lose focus and is not a gospel matter, do I have to adhere entirely to practices of Marian devotion? I agree with the church about Mary in every way discussed here - I'm not anti-Marian devotion in any way. But I lose focus on Christ.
@@AndrewKendall71 oh please, do not lose focus. Mother Mary would be so sad if you do. She ever only wants to magnify the trinitarian God and not obscure them. "My soul magnifies the Lord..."
It's true that devotion to any Saint, including the Blessed Virgin, is not a requirement. That said, you might want to study the Church teachings on Mary and the Communion of Saints, especially the biblical basis for these beliefs. You can Google that on Catholic Answers. Dr. Brant Pitre and Dr. Scott Hahn have both written books on Mary that are very enlightening. 🙏🌹
Immaculate Heart of Mary Triumph and Reign ❤️ Immaculate Queen Triumph and Reign ❤️ Immaculate Heart of Mary Triumph and Reign ❤️ Immaculate Queen Triumph and Reign ❤️ Immaculate Heart of Mary Triumph and Reign Immaculate Queen Triumph and Reign ❤️
@@patriciaw4270 The focus of the New Testament is on Jesus Christ, but you can believe that the early Church and especially St. John took great care of the Virgin Mary because JESUS asked him to.
There is a theological thesis that states that the Blessed Virgin didn't physically die, at the end of her earthly life, because she mystically died at the foot of the Cross on Calvary, by uniting her moral sufferings with her Son's death. She was therefore assumed into Heaven without physically dying. Interestingly, Pope Pius XII, when defining the dogma of Our Lady's Assomption into Heaven, makes no mention whatsoever of her alleged death. This was because a young beneficiary of apparitions of Our Lady (Gilles Bouhours from France) was told by Her that She had not physically died, and this young boy was commissioned by Her to pass it on to Pius XII, who struck out any allusion to Her death in his Apostolic Constitution concerning the dogma.
Hello. We are the Heralds of the Gospel, a Catholic International Association of Pontifical Right, first approved by Pope St. John Paul II. You can learn more about us here: reconquest.heralds.org/about-us/
Our Lady died in a small house in the garden of Gethsemane that had been given to Her and St John by Lazarus . There was no tomb and after 3 days John, being tired , woke up just in time to witness her Assumption. Just read the last few chapters of " The Poem of the Man-God" by Maria Valtorta.
As the papal encyclical; MUNIFICENTISSIMUS DEUS - Pope Pius XII explains She didn't suffered the corruption of death, meaning the virgin Mary's body didn't deteriorated unlike the rest of us human beings, similarly as her son our Lord Jesus Christ body didn't deteriorated, our Lady's body similarly, on the third day similar as her son she was assumption into heaven, Why? She had to experience the resurrection as her son did, this is what what the Pope mentioned thst the Virgin Mary had a temporal death, the byzantines call this 3 day dormition of the Teothokos (in greek this word means the Mother of God) Our Lord Jesus Christ raised her. In Byzantine iconography our Lord takes her soul into heaven. In Roman tradition angels take her body to heaven. She is alive body and soul into heaven, God Ressurected her on the third day. That is Byzantine and Roman tradition. Both we Catholics and Eastern orthodox agree in this subject.
I'm perplexed because my Catholic school has taught she went up body and soul to heaven because she was uncorrupt. I haven't been to school coming up on 20 years now but that's what they were teaching just 20 years ago. Her death is news to me.
@ericks.peters3695 well that would make her Jesus. An uncorrupt person dieing when they do not deserve death as they are void of sin which is the very cause of death. Then resurrecting and rising up into heaven...yeah that's Jesus.
@@seansean7643Yes. The immaculate conception they teach would liken her to the same divine conception as Jesus Christ and make her divine, when she was a miracle conception like Elizabeth and Sarah in the OT in their old age. It was a miracle and not divine as they teach. So that elevates her to a goddess by their doctrine. I don't see a prophecy written of her divine conception, but I did of her miracle conception in her parents old age. They teach this because they need her to be already clean to carry Jesus Christ, even though He purified her the moment she conceived. The dogma of immaculate conception is like an extra hedge of protection like the Talmud that was written to make sure she was worthy. She was chosen by bloodline. She was made worthy because Jesus Christ made her worthy. It isn't because she was divine already before she conceived Jesus Christ being immaculately conceived by Anna getting pregnant when her husband kissed her cheek after the angel gave both of them the good news they will conceive her in their old age.
And yes, to what you say by their description of her resurrection like Jesus Christ. They do not believe she was conceived in sin by natural means like everyone else, so they teach of her never dying too. Enoch didn't die nor Elijah, so maybe... Or maybe she died and she was taken up after, maybe. But their dogma of Mary's "immaculate" conception is just another way she was conceived in the same way as Jesus Christ and that would make her a goddess. A kiss on the cheek by a man doesn't make a woman pregnant who is already married and has received a message from an angel that they would get pregnant in their old age. The husband and wife naturally would make it happen after the announcement of the angel like Elizabeth and Sarah did in their old ages. The case for Mary getting pregnant who was not yet married to Joseph when she conceived was before Joseph took her in. The Holy Spirit entered her and she became pregnant like a miracle divine conception. This is different from Mary's parents.
Meditatio by John Joseph... She is there... she is Always there From the Absolute Abandonment of the Cave.. To the Absolute Abandonment of the Cross...î She is Here... she is Always Here 🙏
Our Lady of Częstochowa-- there is impressive evidence re this painting whose provenance is known at least from the 1300s -- and goes back to luke having painted this portrait of Mary in the house of St john -- (ref shrine of the divine mercy and Chris Alar)
What does the Church teaches about the dogma of the Assumption? Whether that she die is just a speculation. At least the is another person whom the scripture didn’t say he died but was taken up too and that was Elijah. So I don’t know why people are afraid to say together with the Church that, “At the end of her early life She was taken up to heaven ..”
I think she died, just like her Joseph did, confident in eternal life and welcomed into heaven by the angels reciting the Hail Mary prayer to her amazement and joy.
Meditatio by John Joseph... Our Almighty Father chose His Ideal student.... Mary.... And she Alone kept Perfect Attendance... Even to the Father's final class... The Crucifixion
@@luvpamelanewton The fantasies and mythologies created around the Mother of Christ are disgusting and are neither the teachings of Christ, nor any of the Apostles. Your false goddess in no way follows the gospel and your assertions, written by people living perhaps a Millenia or more after the events of the New Testament, are false doctrines.
Mary diedvand was buried, THEN she was physically resurrected, i think. Her bidy wasnt buried anymore. Im Greek and accordingvtovtradition there was a prayer that miraculously appeared on her tomb. It is known as Kyrie Isous Imon. Miracles have been attached to this....still so much in Greek that wasnt translated ...
Rosa Mystica Mary! My Mother! Mystical Rose!🌹 Flower God chose! His Son's repose! You held Him First in your precious Womb You cared and watched over the Bloom And finally beneath the Cross's bloom O Mother most fair! You are always there! In you Now we place our Care! Into Your tender heart Our pledge is to become part To you we pray Impart The Master's Loving Art!!! Amen 🙏
In Medjugorje, Our Lady was questioned and replied on Monday, October 12, 1981, "Did you go to Heaven before or after death? 'I WENT TO HEAVEN BEFORE DEATH.' " Our Lady told us in Medjugorje she did not die, I will believe Our Lady over some priests who are purely speculating or members of the Church who say there is credible information that she died, but have no proof or do not reveal any convincing evidence contrary to Our Lady, Our Lady, who knows above any of these people in the Church; saints, popes, or otherwise.
@@janeyount8412 She doesn't have a tomb. Any tomb that claims to hold the remains of Our Lady, is a false claim. Whether you believe in private revelations or not is not the issue. I do not care if you believe in private revelation. That is between you and God; not me.
@@janeyount8412 Did you read my message. Any tomb that claims to have the remains (or not) is a false claim. There never was a tomb because there never was a body. Whether people make tombs or not for her, there never was a tomb that contained her remains. How can there be a tomb if she never died?
@@janeyount8412 As far as private revelations and our non-obligation to believe in them, the catechism states: "Throughout the ages, there have been so-called “private” revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith. It is not their role to improve or complete Christ’s definitive Revelation, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history. Guided by the Magisterium of the Church, the sensus fidelium knows how to discern and welcome in these revelations whatever constitutes an authentic call of Christ or his saints to the Church." -Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 67 Reply
she did have to die, she chose to die? Get real. She was human and died like the rest of us. Fabricated stories to ask the innocent to send you money. 2 Timothy 3:16 “16- All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:”
If you want to know everything and I mean everything about the holy mother Mary please read the book The Mystical City of God. written by the venerable Maria of Agreda. Everything from just before her immaculate conception till her assumption is there. All your questions will be answered.
Read first the scriptures of God. Don't fall for men's knowledge. The root of history to evidence of Jesus ways is in the scriptures. The scriptures are against the man made dogmas. 1 Thessalonians 4 1 Corinthians 15. Shalom.
@@Sentinal6405 did you read the Scriptures I quoted ? Compare that scriptures with the catechism on its doctrine of the assumption and intercession and purgatory. Then Yll see the scriptures do not agree.
The Bible doesn't speak about Mary's death and ressurection, nor the assumption. We have it from tradition and the magisterium guided by the same Holy Spirit that guided the Church to compile the Bible.
.. What did Our Lady die from and where is see buried ?? Name the place. What foolish men. Then he says Our Lady, had to die that her heart cannot contain any more love, so She died..
We in the Roman Catholic Church Honour Our Lady's Feast Day 15th August " The Assumption ": Our Lady was taken alìve to Heaven: She was Assumed! The Purest of ALL creatures NEVER experienced DEATH AND no CORRUPTION OR DECAY OF HER BODY, OR DEATH: GOD DID NOT ALLOW DEATH TO THE MOTHER OF GOD. SH E WHO WAS CREATED BY HER SON TO BE HIS MOTHER.
Just as Jesus , need not die but chose to die, accoring to the will of the Father , Remember the prayer of Jesus " Not my will but yours be done " Gnosticism/Protestantism/ Judaism rather Talmudism Refuted Thiis is how one was placed before God Allmighty A Visionary in spirit was instructed by the Holy Spirit to kneel, with both hands straight down at the sides, palms open, and facing forward, head lifted up when he sees a Dark & Frightening Cloud above, and from his mouth utters The Lords Prayer, as Jesus taught, No any other words Thats all Note, before the presence of the Allmighty God even the hands are not raised Refer to the Posture of the humble Our Lady of Grace
Born sinless, mother of God, queen of heaven, perpetual virgin, appears to tell of of the future, her states cry, we pray to her. We devote ourselves to her, all graces come through her, we light candles and kiss her statues' feet. She isn't God though.
She is not God, but she is the pre-eminent disciple of Jesus who pointed to him her whole life. She is different from all other creatures because she cooperated with God's plan for salvation. Did you nurse baby Jesus? Did you contribute your flesh and blood and DNA to Jesus? Did you teach him how to pray? Did you nurse him through illness? The Blessed Virgin Mary deserves reverence. Reverence is respect. Worship means to offer sacrifice to a deity. Protestants cannot understand this because they don't have the sacrifice of the Mass.
I have question ? According to Catholic church , Mary is born without Sin ? I believe that anyone born without Sin , it is impossible to die ? How she can die , when She couldn't die , because of her perfectness and She is born to be full of grace ? Her dead must be mystical?
In Genesis it was about Jesus, the seed of the woman. The woman would know no man and conceive Him divinely. The conception of Him purified her when she got pregnant, not before.
1 Timothy 2:15 in the Bible states, "Yet she [the woman] will be saved through childbearing - if they continue in faith and love and holiness, with self-control".
@@luvpamelanewton By stating that, you assume that Jesus Christ failed to establish His Church. The corruption took place in the 1500's when Luther told his sect that confession wasn't necessary in contradiction to James 5:16, and later the reformists abandoned Christ's last act and command in John 6:53. I don't know what sect of it you're a part of but I'd get out quick.
We know from Revelation 11:19 - 12:1 that the Virgin Mary is not a disembodied soul in heaven, as are all other souls in heaven who are awaiting the resurrection of the body on the Last Day. Mary was "assumed" body and soul together upon death, not "resurrected" as our Lord was. There is disagreement as to whether she physically died, but since there is a tomb, it's reasonable to believe she expired. Conversely, Elijah was taken up to heaven alive, and so there is no tomb.🙏🌹
@@janeyount8412 ok, thanks for that. Yeah I just assumed for some reason that the belief was the exact same thing as for Elijah. I'm not Catholic so wasn't entirely certain what was being said here, now I get it. Thanks
If the Blessed Mother didn't die, there wouldn't be a tomb. It only logical. Conversely, we can point to the Prophet Elijah. He was taken up alive to Heaven, and there is no tomb.
Not so. Orthodox and some Protestants also believe it. Martin Luther believed it. Calvin believed it. Every Christian believed it until the dawn of the age of un reason.
Than why did Jesus give her to St. John if there were ever any other children to look after her? There was a jewish tradition of husbands and wives dedicating their marriages to God and remaining chaste, especially when one is the spouse of the Holy Spirit. Joseph was more a protector for the Christ child and the woman who bore Him.
@@emmap1159 Regarding your question, I don't assume things. This only Lord Jesus can answer. Others, if they answer, will only be assuming things and jumping to conclusions, which the RCs do.
@@vijayramaniah4670 Actually you are the one assuming that Mary fornicated based on one word "till." From the many interactions with Protestants, it's apparent that chastity is not a virtue they understand despite the fact that Jesus and Paul endorsed it. Do you fast? If so ,why? Self denial and self sacrifice are elemental to devotion and spiritual communion is the answer. God's spirit dwelt within her even after the birth of the savior just as the dna of a woman's baby remains within her even after a birth. It is called Microchimerism. Her body was quite literally the temple of the Lord. She knew this and so did Joseph.
She did NOT die. She was assumed into Heaven alive. In 1950 this was proclaimed an article of the faith using his papal infallibility. If the 3 priests above don't know this, that is very sad.
You know what is really sad? You not reading your Bible Carol. That is truly sad. Our Lord gave us His Holy Word to read and learn. "She was assumed into Heaven alive." There is no single verse about this event in the Bible. Not a word.
The Blessed Mother physically died. That's why there's a tomb! "Assumption" means her soul didn't separate from her body at the moment of death; therefore, she was taken up (assumed) body and soul. 🙏🌹
@@patriciaw4270 The Apostle John saw Mary in heaven with body and soul intact. (Rev 11:19 - 12:1) All others who have died (except Elijah and Enoch) are disembodied souls still waiting for the resurrection of their bodies on the Last Day. 🙏🌹
for give me father,s but at around 8 ; 35 / 41;59 , it was stated all the apostles had in xxcxxrse with our MOTHER MARY , PLESE IF YOU CAN EXPLAIN THIS i dont understand what is ment by this ??? hail mary full of GRACE AMEN
He said "recourse" not "intercourse." The automated captions have it wrong. Look up the various meanings of intercourse. It's not what you think! Fun Fact: There's an Amish town in Pennsylvania called Intercourse.
