I think to fully understand Brian's version of this song you have to be well versed in Gaslight Anthem's music. When I hear this song the imperfections and the nervousness only add to it. In much of Gaslight's music Brian sings and writes as a character who is a bit of a loser, a nervous kid who struggles with romance and self confidence. Listening to this song with an understanding of that context puts the listener (or at least me) in a place where I picture Brian as an afraid teenager pouring his heart out to this girl he has a crush on. He is trying to impress her with a song that he feels captures his love for her and shows her his sensitivity and emotional depth. This version is not about hitting the biggest notes or being spot on with pitch--Brian, Gaslight and even Rock and Roll has never been about that-- it is about being emotionally vulnerable and putting yourself out there anyways. It is about conveying feelings and emotions, not about being technically perfect, and in this case I think the imperfections add to the character of the song. My two cents.
Evan Blackwell makes sense. I could totally understand him being nervous, covering a song that's as difficult to cover as Hallelujah can be an absolutely nerve-racking thing
So sometimes he starts a little off, or to some people's ears, fuck it, he's Brian Fallon. His voice is beautiful, and I don't know about you guys, but he definitely knows a lot more about music than I do. And even if you don't like the first couple of notes, it's so worth it for what comes next. I love The Gaslight Anthem, and this song is a classic
He sounds kind of nervous until the second verse. I'd love to hear him do a much more polished version of this. It's not awful, but there are times it feels like he's not sure what he's doing until he's doing it. Not bad, not great either.
i really love brian...but...there are many many artist who did a better version of this...maybe i prejudice this version because of the difference to the sample in my head i'm familiar with : )
i love fallon, but the more you listen to his live stuff the more you realise he's a studio artist. I still like it, but sometimes its not emotion, its just a man looking for the right note.