Тёмный

The Great Framerate Non-Debate 

TotalBiscuit
Подписаться 1,9 млн
Просмотров 568 тыс.
50% 1

TotalBiscuit takes on the issue of frame-rate and the recent claims by a certain developer and their fans that 30fps is "filmic" and 60fps can ruin a game's aesthetic.
• Monitor & TV Refresh R...
30vs60.com
Ratchet and Clank footage courtesy of: / zybaktv
FFXIV footage courtesy of: / rurikain
Watch Dogs comparison video courtesy of: / cartelstrims369
Follow TotalBiscuit on Twitter: / totalbiscuit
Follow CynicalBrit on Twitter for video updates: / cynicalbrit
Follow our Facebook page for announcements: / cynicalbrit

Игры

Опубликовано:

 

1 июн 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 96   
@theshazman
@theshazman 10 лет назад
Music to my ears.
@meatsafemurderer7743
@meatsafemurderer7743 5 лет назад
5 years later and the "Is there a sky, yes or no?" debate is still raging... We have failed him.
@WhoisTheOtherVindAzz
@WhoisTheOtherVindAzz 3 года назад
The war continues!
@mjc0961
@mjc0961 3 года назад
I find myself here again because Insomniac just dropped a 60fps patch for 2016's Ratchet and Clank -butchering- remake, and Digital Foundry doing a video that talks about the same Insomniac 30fps stuff that starts off this video. It is indeed sad that this debate still goes on. Because we're one again at the launch of new consoles that have no new games to play, we're at the part of the debate where developers and publishers, desperate to convince people that their launch console purchases were worth it, are releasing 60fps versions of their previous games and singing the praises of 60fps at us. But don't worry, once new games finally get here, and developers put pretty graphics over performance, they'll be back to defending 30fps once more and the debate will begin once more. Can't wait. 🙄
@lilian1812
@lilian1812 3 года назад
@@mjc0961 what seems different this time is that many AAA games have 2 modes. We have the choice now and many games actually hit 60 fps in performance mode on console. It is starting to be the norm and people will hate games that don't let the choice.
@theanimerapper6351
@theanimerapper6351 5 месяцев назад
Still going on in 2024 lol
@BigDogBarnhart
@BigDogBarnhart 5 лет назад
God I miss him...
@BK-gz3gh
@BK-gz3gh 5 лет назад
i was laughing when i saw him in the killfeed, heheheeh
@point-bl4nk
@point-bl4nk 5 лет назад
John Bain's definitive eyeopeners and masterpieces: - "The Great Framerate Non-Debate" - "What a PC Options menu is supposed to look like" - "Have single-player FPS gone backwards?" - "Modern Military Shooters in a nutshell" - every FarCry video featuring alligators
@Hamon_Beat
@Hamon_Beat 5 лет назад
You forgot the God Hand video
@ISetYourFaceOnFire
@ISetYourFaceOnFire 4 года назад
If i could another. His research stream of guise of the wolf.
@Lucas02000
@Lucas02000 3 года назад
@@ISetYourFaceOnFire That video was hilarious.
@slkjvlkfsvnlsdfhgdght5447
@slkjvlkfsvnlsdfhgdght5447 3 года назад
@@ISetYourFaceOnFire that's not an eye opener, that's just taking a massive shit on a game that totally deserves it
@DrAnimePhD
@DrAnimePhD Год назад
Don’t forget “The Bore-Z”
@BigDogBarnhart
@BigDogBarnhart 4 года назад
I just miss him so much...
@DrAnimePhD
@DrAnimePhD 4 года назад
6 years later and we finally got the choice of 30 FPS or 60 on console. Took another generation but the Xbox Series X and PS5 now have the option to downgrade the graphical quality of games to get a higher framerate. Why we wouldn't get this during this generation is a mystery, but hey better late than never.
@DrAnimePhD
@DrAnimePhD 4 года назад
MEME GOD Yep. Spiderman Miles Morales and the Demon Souls Remake are the first to have this feature.
@Booksds
@Booksds 2 года назад
@@DrAnimePhD And now the new Ratchet and Clank game has a 60 FPS ray-tracing mode and even a 40 fps mode on 120hz displays. Hopefully the consoles keep maintaining their momentum of actually good options menus
@TheGoreforce
@TheGoreforce Год назад
we are quickly aproaching 30 fps across AAA board, because they will want to push every bit of juice again :(
@StormsparkPegasus
@StormsparkPegasus Год назад
@@TheGoreforce Yep. That's why the only console I own anymore is a Switch. I'll just wait for games to come to PC, and if they don't come to PC I won't bother. I waited for the PC versions of the Spider-man games.
@igodreamer7096
@igodreamer7096 4 года назад
Man, they still defend this shiet argument about 30fps games, what joke! We all miss you honest takes so much, mister Biscuit.
@mjc0961
@mjc0961 3 года назад
People still arguing that there isn't a sky.
@KapitanPazur1
@KapitanPazur1 2 года назад
@@mjc0961 and that a human eye cannot see above 30 fps
@IncrediBurch
@IncrediBurch 3 года назад
We gotta keep fighting the good fight for him. We are winning. I hope TB is smiling down on us.
@Cxs1a3
@Cxs1a3 3 года назад
10 years later and most AAA games still don't look as good as that watch dogs trailer
@mjc0961
@mjc0961 4 года назад
What he described about 7th gen machines running sub 720p and still can't deliver 30fps just happened again with 8th gen machines, at least the base models. Better stump up another $400 or $500 to avoid it. And right about now, everybody's getting hyped up for 9th gen consoles, and how this time surely there will be enough power for native 4k at 60 fps or higher. Nah. They're consoles. Developers will crank graphics up to make it look pretty for marketing materials and we'll still get stuck with 30 fps with drops. It'll be the same crap as PS3/360 and PS4/XB1.
@Diablodave363isawsum
@Diablodave363isawsum 4 года назад
60 fps should be industry standard by now. There were no games that were less than 60 fps before 5th Gen consoles.
@grunklebran7535
@grunklebran7535 3 года назад
York doom snes, 32x?
@MaximusOwen1
@MaximusOwen1 Год назад
I always remember this video every time a developer or publisher tries to defend their 30FPS game. Usually including the word ‘cinematic’ in there somewhere.
@XDWX
@XDWX 7 месяцев назад
Because 30fps DOES look more cinematic...meaning looks more similar to movies that commonly use 24fps.
@ianhenry6874
@ianhenry6874 5 лет назад
And this shit is still relevant to this day💯💯
@SarahWeisters
@SarahWeisters 5 лет назад
I've never had hardware good enough to run anything above 30fps, so I really don't know what I'm missing.
@mungojerrie86
@mungojerrie86 3 года назад
You're missing quite a lot. It's very hard to go back though, so don't pursue high framerates if you're comfortable with 30.
@SarahWeisters
@SarahWeisters 3 года назад
@@mungojerrie86 I'm comfortable with 30 :) Thanks for the tip.
@mjc0961
@mjc0961 3 года назад
@@SarahWeisters That tip was honestly terrible. You should absolutely pursue 60fps. It's very easy to reach if you have decent hardware. I would only apply that tip to going above 60fps. Once you get into 120fps, 144fps, 240fps, and so on, you can have problems unrelated to your hardware. Maybe you get a game that has an engine limit or some kind of bug, so you have to go back to 60 from 120 and then woof, it doesn't feel great. And of course, having to go from 120fps to 30fps because a game is just hard capped is really awful. But going from 30 to 60? Do it, 100%.
@AntonChigurh-
@AntonChigurh- 2 года назад
@@mjc0961 "Once you get into 120fps, 144fps, 240fps, and so on, you can have problems unrelated to your hardware." What does that mean? Do you mean things like the physics of a game freaking out if you run it at a higher framerate than 60 (e.g Skyrim)? If that's what you meant, then I would say that that doesn't apply anymore to most games released in the latter half of the previous decade. Almost every single new game comes with unlocked framerate. I'm going to actually say that 60 fps nowadays is outdated as well, especially after having used a 165 hz monitor for a couple of months now. 60 fps, to me, has become so choppy that I can't even use my laptop anymore.
@theanimerapper6351
@theanimerapper6351 Год назад
@@AntonChigurh- if you play alot of pixel art or hand drawn indie games you are stuck at 60fps alot of the time
@lesath7883
@lesath7883 Год назад
8 years later, and nobody talks about framerate yet. May you be in light, Total Biscuit.
@Alex_Martin_
@Alex_Martin_ 4 месяца назад
And here comes ninja theory making the same tired lies.
@StormsparkPegasus
@StormsparkPegasus 4 года назад
Heck games become even more responsive when you go higher than 60 (though 60 is adequate the vast majority of the time). Take a look at One Finger Death Punch 2. The PC version has the option of unlocked framerate. There is a massive difference in input lag between the 240fps my PC can push in that game vs the Switch version running at 60.
@ilDuderoni
@ilDuderoni 4 месяца назад
Dragon's Dogma II now joins the ranks of shame
@thenomad4123
@thenomad4123 2 года назад
I remember getting used to play say Witcher 3 at 30-40 fps with no problem. Then I bought a new pc and 60 fps felt so fast I was having trouble reacting to what is going. Now I am used to 60 fps sometimes the game drops to 50 fps etc. and I immediately notice it and get annoyed. Funny how our minds work.
@AntonChigurh-
@AntonChigurh- 2 года назад
60 fps feels choppy now that I'm used to 165 fps. Once you make the switch, you won't ever go back.
@ZoruaHunter
@ZoruaHunter Год назад
I played Monster Hunter Rise on my Switch at 30fps and it was buttery smooth, then I played the demo on PC at 30fps and it looked terrible. Apparently it was because the Switch's screen is more optimized for 30fps than my monitor was.
@BlueKunai
@BlueKunai Год назад
Came back here after seeing people today coping about the new A Plagues Tale game running at sub 30 on consoles billing themselves on being able to run at 120fps+, not even two years into their life cycle.
@lilian1812
@lilian1812 3 года назад
You know I would like to add that I'm playing on the og Xbox one for 6 years. All the games now looks downgraded as hell can't even hold 30 fps sometimes and while I understand that if you're used to 60 fps it's unplayable when you're not it's completly fine and you forget about it when playing the game. I tottaly understand that 60 fps really add something to the experience I don't think we should blame devs for not allowing 60 fps on their games (if it's not justified by lies). I'm pretty sure it adds a lot of work considering there's a tons of different console now and sometimes it's just up to the devs. If they think prioritizing graphics over framerate is better for games then we should let them choose. Some games on consoles tottaly reduces the graphics to have a better framerate and it's ok because it fits the game.
@petrus4
@petrus4 4 года назад
Honestly it depends on the game. If I'm playing XCOM or something else turn based, where there is going to be a forced delay in interactivity anyway, then I will be less likely to care. If, on the other hand, I'm playing a first person shooter, or any other genre where I need to be able to instantly respond to whatever is happening, then yes I am going to want 60 FPS.
@Armadyz
@Armadyz Год назад
Starfield 2023
@stealthgyro
@stealthgyro Год назад
Seriously, I've shared this video so many times with all the Starfield announcements.
@Katechon1349
@Katechon1349 Год назад
Instantly thought of Totalbiscuit when I saw that. Absolutely ridiculous. What reason is there at this point to buy a 500$ console instead of waiting a bit to get a gaming PC.
@SharpEdgeSoda
@SharpEdgeSoda Год назад
I had someone tell me "The human eye can't see past 60 fps" today. They moved the goal posts now that consoles have "60fps" in their marketing. Still fighting the good fight out there. Frame Rate Deniers are functionally science deniers.
@TMORAF
@TMORAF 6 лет назад
The higher the framerate the better. Thank me later or never. Tacka mig senare eller aldrig.
@davecrupel2817
@davecrupel2817 3 года назад
I rarely played a game in 60fps, untill i got my first PC a year and a half ago. As in, i can think of maybe 3 or 4 games in my entire life i have indeed played in 60+fps. Killing Floor 2, Doom 2016, Doom: Eternal, and Battlefield 4. Battlefield 4 was the first for me. And, after spending some 2000 hours on Battlefield 3 at 30fps, Battlefield 4 was, frankly, a disorienting experience. Everything felt so much faster, i felt like i was playing after a shot of adrenaline. It almost felt like everything was on a skating rink. I have since played many games in 60fps thanks to my pc. And have gotten more used to it now. I can still play fine at 30. But, having played heavily under both rates, i can confirm thag 60+fps DOES make a big difference. If only because 60 is pretty much right at the threshold of the human eye-brain processing rate imo.
@KapitanPazur1
@KapitanPazur1 2 года назад
The word you are searching is not "faster", mate. Its "smoother" because thats a difference from 30fps to 60 fps - a smoother experience.
@pawlogates
@pawlogates 2 года назад
@@KapitanPazur1 also that last part of the guys message like holy shit how are we not past this even now is amazing
@skrie
@skrie 5 лет назад
I think despite humans not being able to see above a certain number of frames... a higher framerate is better because the way eyes track movement. (eyes track movement in a jerky motion which benefits from having more moments a image is available).
@memnarch129
@memnarch129 5 лет назад
I think there is more to it than just that. There likely is a difference betweening "Seeing" somthing and "Perceiving" somthing. Seeing somthing is when you are looking at it and actively observing it. Perceiving is the ability for your brain to notice things that are there that you conciously cant. While we may only be able to See up to 30 or how many ever FPS its likely our brains Perceive up to and above 120 FPS. Easiest examples are when you think you see somthing move but werent paying attention. You didnt see it occuring but your eyes and brain where able to perceive it occuring.
@Warm_Summer_Rain
@Warm_Summer_Rain 5 лет назад
We can manage around 150 idk why 30 is a thing....
@vinx.9099
@vinx.9099 6 лет назад
i must disagree with that everyone can feel it. i can, at least i can nowadays. i used to play on a terrible pc. 30 fps was a rare occurrence. i could not feel the difference between 30 and 60. nowdays i can and it feels so much better. but when you are used to that unresponsiveness it's hard to feel something is more responsive. of course 60 is still objectively better then 30. it's closer to real life (and to idiots, no, the eye doesn't see in frames. the eye sees changes, the smoother the change, the more frames a change uses, the better it looks). but not everyone can easily feel the difference.
@vinx.9099
@vinx.9099 6 лет назад
nothing to back your statement up with? no evidence? just declaring i'm retarded? why should i change my mind? because a random twat on the internet said not even it was dumb, but that i was dumb? it's a very unconvincing argument.
@SpartanPrimeDSTY117
@SpartanPrimeDSTY117 6 лет назад
Everyone *can* easily feel the difference. Give them a higher fps than they've experience, and they will intantly notice. All that needs to be done is make them play any first person shooter at 60 frames per second, then make them go and play the same game capped at 30fps. it is VERY noticeable. You WILL feel the difference.
@vinx.9099
@vinx.9099 6 лет назад
so, in my experience that isn't the thing. at least not the jump up. like i explained i used to play skyrim at maybe 30 fps, generally lower. when it suddenly jumped to 60 i didn't notice it being smoother. of course the lack of stutters i could feel, but not the much higher framerate. maybe the games i played wheren't the best for it, but i didn't notice that jump up. but when you get used to it (or stop being used to 30) you will feel the jump down. i'm not saying it isn't better. but if you are used to bad the sudden jump to ok isn't that noticeable.
@SpartanPrimeDSTY117
@SpartanPrimeDSTY117 6 лет назад
I might need to correct you on the fact that stutters have nothing to do with the framerate being higher. Stuttering is just the game playing herpa-derp. Regardless of whether you percieve the fps increase or not, you will naturally *feel* the difference. With 30 each frame needs to be displayed twice, so any buttons you press? The game has to wait for the next frame. With 60, pressing a button instantly displays the next frame. A higher framerate increases your reaction speeds, and is crucial for any instance where quick reactions are needed. That's why Uncharted 4's MP still ran at 60fps and the SP only ran at 30. The big devs have a reason to say a jump to 60+ is transformative. 30 is not as jarring if you use a controller on a console, but on a pc 60 is accepted as the standard for a reason: It just makes the games *feel* better and more responsive.
@vinx.9099
@vinx.9099 6 лет назад
stutters aren't frame rate related? depends how low they get (: don't think many games these days calculate of frames anymore ether as it's a pretty stupid way to do things. it might work for a simple 2d platformer, but for real 3d games you want the game to calculate things over time. not frames, that messes up to easily. and i know 60 fps is better, i'll never claim against that. what i'm saying is that when you are used to gaming at 30 fps you won't feel the jump to 60. that's what i'm warning against. you and I both feel the difference between 60 and 30 fps. but if your brain is used to 30 fps you won't feel the difference. that's why console peasants say that 60 fps isn't needed: the few times they tried it their expectations of 30 fps meant that they couldn't feel it. saying that everyone always feels the difference is incorrect. and that type of talk makes them thing we are talking out of our ass.
@bryceebert6999
@bryceebert6999 5 лет назад
I don’t agree with the stance that, “if it doesn’t run at 60 FPS, then it’s garbage.” I always felt that John was way too dismissive about it. Well, it’s nice that you can afford a computer that costs more than some cars Totalbiscuit, but what about those of us who can’t? I miss him though, I would have loved to have met him one day.
@Grandmastergav86
@Grandmastergav86 5 лет назад
You don't need a PC that costs this much to achieve 60FPS though.
@Masilya111
@Masilya111 5 лет назад
I'd say it's not they're garbage as videogames, but defective/flawed as products.
@darkmanx8497
@darkmanx8497 5 лет назад
Defective or flawed? lmao is too harsh and too simplistic as it applies to most games.
@bryceebert6999
@bryceebert6999 5 лет назад
Masilya111 but that was how console games were for a long time. And frame pacing is more crucial than frame rate.
@akse
@akse 5 лет назад
I would say that maybe with a 4K monitor where achieving constant 60FPS is difficult it is fine to run lower at some points, but then you need an adaptive sync monitor (which is very common nowadays) to make it look decent.Everything below 4K resolution I always aim for high framerates 60 minimum 120Hz+ preferred.
@madtricksterrc1506
@madtricksterrc1506 6 лет назад
if you have a console your a child
@Canadian_duck31
@Canadian_duck31 6 лет назад
Your comment says more about you than the people who buy game consoles it’s plastic and electronics get over yourself who cares what you play on.
@madtricksterrc1506
@madtricksterrc1506 6 лет назад
Spaceduck31 it doesn't really matter it's my opinion why do you got fly a kite
@Canadian_duck31
@Canadian_duck31 6 лет назад
Madtrickster rc why do you go fly a kite? Why don’t you learn to use some punctuation douche canoe.
@madtricksterrc1506
@madtricksterrc1506 6 лет назад
Spaceduck31 geez take it easy spacefuck enjoy your console gaming at shit fps if that's what you enjoy. the video is about how consoles and low fps are shit.
@Canadian_duck31
@Canadian_duck31 6 лет назад
I watched the video whole video do you not think I’m not aware of that?
@cityassassin
@cityassassin 5 лет назад
Don't know about that, really. I've always been unable to tell the difference between 16 FPS, and 60+. So doesn't matter to me, as long as it's not 5 FPS, or so. I'm going to wager that he was just overly hyper sensitive to it. That, or he just lusted for something to complain about.
@TheGuardianDevil4
@TheGuardianDevil4 5 лет назад
You need to get your eyes checked.
@spaghebbio
@spaghebbio 5 лет назад
There's actually something wrong with your body then. It's not that everyone is hyper sensitive to it you may just actually be blind.
Далее
OceanGate Is Worse Than You Thought
28:41
Просмотров 3,8 млн
What Happened to the 9th Generation?
22:18
Просмотров 1,4 млн
How To Get Better At Fighting Games (Game Theory)
14:37
Why Consoles Are Going Extinct
23:30
Просмотров 584 тыс.
When "Classic" WoW Really Died
14:06
Просмотров 103 тыс.
Simplifying Fighting Games - A BBTAG Retrospective
10:37
Cleaning Up Steam
15:11
Просмотров 581 тыс.
The Big Bad Embargo: Just what is it anyway?
23:48
Просмотров 356 тыс.
...Why Skyrim?
28:58
Просмотров 251 тыс.