THE HOBBIT: AN UNEXPECTED JOURNEY | FIRST TIME WATCHING | MOVIE REACTION 

Two other important words to quote. “Baggins…Shire…” If Bilbo had killed Gollum, Mordor wouldn’t have been able to torture him, and the ring may have stayed hidden forever.

​@BDogg2023 not forever. The ring would have found its way back eventually and maybe in far worse hands.

@@thomasriddle7005 That's absolutely right. At the Council of Elrond one of the Elves suggests that they throw the Ring in the Sea. Gandalf argues against this saying that it would eventually be found and that they needed to eliminate the Ring forever, not just for one or one hundred generations.

They also might not have known about the secret path and attempted to enter through the gate and who knows what happens.

@@BROPify Gandalf's plan was to go around and come into Mordor from the north but it was a lot longer route and would have provided the enemy more time to pinpoint Frodo's position.

Balin, Lord of Moria.

I didn't know that about Ori, thank you! Also, in the extended edition of The Fellowship of the Ring, we see a white-haired Gloin at the Last Homely House in Rivendell, accompanying his son Gimli.

Don’t forget Gloin, the father of Gimli.

The songs sung in Bilbo’s house were written by Tolkien himself.

And the trolls are the same Trolls that Bilbo tells the small Hobbit children at his birthday party about

It is definitely a read-aloud book that should be shared!

My mom did that for me as a kid and The Hobbit was the one book I retained the most knowledge from I really hope parents reading books to their kids before bed doesn’t die out as time goes on

@@brianalex5083 Unfortunately, I think it is already gone - except maybe in the many death cults that require indoctrination from a young age.

That is great and as it should be. 😊 I read The Hobbit to my daughter as well.

Because she is smart and not infantile. :)

@@taylemgames2652 Lol. No need to be infantile about it. She just has good taste.

She is sooooo accurate!! I agree with EVERYTHING she said! Love Harry Potter too but LOTR is just number 1 for me.

Imagine the insight she’d get from the books. Amber is the best

Her smile and enthusiasm are infectious. Gets me in a good mood right from the start.

Tolkien stated both Gal and Gandalf could wield it to full capacity and the weakened Sauron who’s already been “dead” more than once before already could easily keep him at bey. There were other reasons they rejected the ring entirely. Amazing stuff. Truly. ❤

​@@Makkaru112Tolkien outright admitted that Gandalf with the ring would have been worse than Sauron. Because Gandalf was righteous and with his power would "correct" the world towards "good" - which would be awful. I imagine it would be the same with Galadriel who basically confronts her will to power within herself when she faces the temptation of the ring. But ultimately Tolkien was very wise in seeing the evil in good people thinking they can coerce the world towards good. Were living through that now. No shortage of those who think they know whats best and want to force others to comply. Their "social justice", "equity", "reparations" and "being on the right side of history". Delusional, self assured moral tyrants. THAT is what the ring would turn Gandalf into: a meddler with ultimate power and a desire to "correct" everything towards "good".

Sam and Galadriel, Aragorn, Elrong? could all resist it, especially Sam despite being so near the source of its power, which the closer you get to it, should overwhelm anyone but im just saying

Ya the films were already set back with the changes in director and the studio wasn't giving Jackson the time and money to do practical effects so he had to go quick and dirty with CGI.

It's so sad because Jackson had to sort out Del Toro's shit show in such a short amount of time with an awful budget. It's amazing he managed to pull it off at all let alone make highly watchable and entertaining films. It really does annoy me when people slag off The Hobbit trilogy because I think Jackson pulled off a miracle given what he had to work with.

@@bethcushway458 True. I wish more people knew that before trashing them. I like them!

@@pamelahofman1785 same here.

Jackson did pretty well except for no tom bombadil he was too powerful But everyone wanted to see him He was noted as 1 of the original and strongest wizards Of Middle of earth

@@terryconnelly484 Yes, it was disappointing Tom was left out. He was no wizard though, he was, as if middle earth itself. To him the ring was a trinket, of no concern.

​​@@terryconnelly484Tom Bombadill is no wizard. Tom Bombadill IS Middle Earth, or at least he was the first being to enter Middle Earth. When Frodo asked him who he is, he responds " Eldest". Tom Bombadill taught the Ents speach before there were Elves

​@Jp421JP no one wanted to see a fat dude signing and dancing . Would've legitimately ruined the entire vibe of the trilogy

@kellytrimble7019 - I read the book around the same age and had never read anything like it before - fantasy fan from that time.

Oh really? You didn’t read LOTR first? That’s an interesting perspective 🤔 I know when I read LOTR I hadn’t realized it had a prequel (I was born in 81 & a teacher recommended LOTR) but I couldn’t get enough Tolkien & tried to get my hands on everything he wrote. 😅

@@Taewills Early 70s and I was into mythology. Found The Hobbit because of a sweet old librarian that saw my curiosity.

You should try reading the Xanth novels by Piers Anthony. They are so entertaining and David Eddings is another amazing fantasy writer with lots of awesome novels too.

Same for me. This book was on a reading list in my grade school and you got points for reading books. I've loved reading and fantasy ever since.

@@sueparras6028 I've read over 20 of the Xanth novels. Loved them. Plus a lot of other stuff by Piers.

Tolkien wrote this book after world war II so it could not put him on the map in the 30s... your information is false. I'm not trying to be mean I'm just pointing that out. The story of Lord of the Rings was reflection of the horrors that he saw during the war.

@@thomasheath9824 The Hobbit was published in 1937. Tolkien was a soldier during WWI. After The Hobbit, he spent years developing the languages of Middle Earth, and then he wrote The Lord of the Rings which was published in 1954. He intended it to be one book, but it's so long that the publishers broke it up into three books. Yes, they depict the horrors of war, as well as the close bonds that form between brothers in arms.

@@thomasheath9824 Tolkien was in WW1 but during WW2 it was his two grown sons who served. The Hobbit (There and back again) was first published Sept. 21, 1937. The Lord of the Rings: Tolkien wrote LOtR in stages between 1937 and 1949. It was originally published in three parts in the years 1954 and 1955. Although often called a trilogy, the work was intended by Tolkien to be one volume in a two-volume set along with The Silmarillion. For economic reasons, The Lord of the Rings was first published over the course of a year from 29 July 1954 to 20 October 1955 in three volumes rather than one under the titles The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and The Return of the King; The Silmarillion appeared only after the author's death. The work is divided internally into six books, two per volume, with several appendices of background material. These three volumes were later published as a boxed set, and even finally as a single volume, following the author's original intent.

@@thomasheath9824 No. And yes, but wrong war

​​@@thomasheath9824Your information is false. All of the devastation of war represented in Tolkien's works are from his experience in World War One. BTW brutal wars in the Lord the Rings are walks in the park compared to those in The Silmarillion, his master work...his first work...his lifework

and all the singing is in the book

@@emilmlodnicki3835although the song in the book was longer lol

Do they even know what the two trees are?

@@BubbaCoop yeah, didn't really think about that, they probably have no idea of the history of Middle Earth or of the Second Age

@@michaellockhart554guess they don’t read the comments we’ve given them on their trilogy reaction lmao. Too bad they don’t interact with the subscribers. All the biggest most successful channels do this. Heck. Even do videos addressing comments and letting them be discussion videos type of thing. Letting everyone’s voice be heard as CutterOne is doing. Building a community by and FOR fans of both Tolkien and many other cool things such as DragonLance and so many other things. ❤

And with the respect Gandalf gives her... he's five and a half thousand.. but a youth to her 😊

Nice read on both of them. They definitely are my favorite reactors on both of their channels

I think "The desolation of Smaug" is the best of the three. Love Beorn, Smaug, and even like the added character of Tauriel.

Peter Jackson said he was just trying to hurry up and finish this trilogy. he grew tired of it at this point and just wanted it to be over.

The extended Galadriel scene in this first film connects to battle of five armies but they didn’t watch the extended so….

@wendell6468 it's not that he was tired of it, it was his job to take over and hit the deadline for the wrap or finish. Peter Jackson was not the original director of the hobbit. Someone else was hired, and after they parted ways, Pete Jackson was then hired to direct and save the project.

⬆️ THIS!!! This right here. Bilbo could have shanked Gollum right then. But his pity won the war. This was the moment Sauron was defeated.

hold on, it was Gollum searching for Bilbo that led to the dark lord learning the ring had been found and who/where it now could be found. if Bilbo had exterminated Gollum in the Goblin caves Sauron would of remained ignorant of it's existence for perhaps another 500 years or more. it was Gollums obsession for the ring that led to all that happened in the war of the ring. Sauron was confident his Wraiths would secure the possession of the one ring that allowed him to rush his plans for conquest, he was gambling on becoming all powerful before the allies could even react. Gollum plunged all into war through his personal jealousy.

​@stevechurch4728 yes, but if Gollum wasn't there to attack Frodo and fall into the fire with the ring, Frodo would have left with it. He was about to keep it for himself before he got attacked by Gollum. Gollum not being there would have ensured it not being destroyed.

@@flu1dz they may never of had to do it at all if the lord Sauron had continued to believe the ring was never found. he would not of felt strong enough to start his war. becoming aware of the ring prompted his gamble to plunge the world into war.

@stevechurch4728 he was always looking for it, and he would have found it eventually. 500 years, 1000 years, 2 years.. he would have. But now it's destroyed forever and all the "what if's" and "maybe's" disappear. Who knows what would have happened if it wasn't destroyed? Perhaps nothing, perhaps the end of man altogether. All we know is what did happen. I do appreciate your logic, though! I fully get and understand it AND it's not wrong or misguided. It's just another "maybe" is all, and an interesting one :)

Not entirely. I think the Fellowship at least is better in the theatrical cut. Two Towers is indeed better extended. I'm torn on Return of the King.

@@Brejanrotk is worse in extended, you watch it every now and then for like the extra scenes but the theatrical is a much better movie.

@@Mini_Hayley I think theatrical but with the death of Saruman included at the beginning would be the best of both worlds.

We’re just so excited for you to get this apartment!!

Same!! 😃

@@jasonpratt3970 what?

Many great artworks of this character. Don’t know why they had to keep him constantly covered in bird poop and stuff though. Lol. This is supposed to be Aiwendil who was sent by Yavannah.

Doctor Who, Yeah. The Hobbit read by Nicol Williamson, great, I love both too.

The term goblin refers to Orcs almost interchangeably. Although they often seem to be smaller than soldier Orcs.

Between 1910, and 1973, Tolkien created fifteen languages. Christopher Lee (Saruman The White), one of the most interesting people ever to grace our planet, was the only cast member, who, actually, once met J.R.R. Tolkien.

Also, Geoff Castellucci. He's a base singer like Tim Foust and has his own channel as well as singing A-Cappella with Voiceplay.

Agreed!!!

Yes, I still find it amazing that Tolkien and Lewis were friends in a literary group known as the Inklings. They would read and offer constructive criticism about each other's work

Those are significantly different, but yes. Also, the 2nd Narnia movie feels - without being dirty - noticeably less like a kids movie. But they’re all good! Oh. And don’t let anyone tell you the green mist isn’t from the books. It’s in the 4th book, and shows up early in the 3rd movie to help things move at a movie’s pace.

I never believed any of this . The story would've played out so much differently, that there's no way to say he was needed . If golum was dead he never would've ratted out the Baggins' . Bilbo still would've left after his bday and frodo would still have the ring. The journey to destroy it would have been vastly different and frodo may have not been corrupted bc the journey would be alot faster. So yes golum destroyed it in the end but also 80% of the fellowships problems wouldn't have happened if golum was dead

that is such a fantastic explaination, i LOVE it. I'm not sure it could be any more well put

@@GRIZY28 It's true that Gollum knew where the ring was, and directed the Nazgul to Shire. But if that hadn't happened, the ring would've still been in Frodo's hands, and it still would've corrupted him, eventually. Either that or Bilbo would have come back for it, since he was still attached to it even when he was close to death. Gollum selling out the Shire actually set the plot to destroy the ring in motion. The journey also would not be faster, since Frodo and Sam would still split up from the rest of the party due to the fear that the ring would corrupt all of them, but this time they would not have a guide. And during that time wandering around, the ring was already weighing on Frodo. The more time wasted, the more the ring could work on Frodo. Sam was ready to go straight into the Black Gates, which would've spelled doom for both of them. Gollum was the one who pulled them away Either Frodo would've died on his way to Mordor or he would've been captured and taken to Sauron if Gollum was dead. Hell, Saruman might have gotten the ring early on. Gollum also acts as an anchor for Frodo, because Frodo says he has to believe Gollum can come back, otherwise he won't.

If I remember correctly d&d was based on the lotr

It’s not meant to be LOTR. it’s a different era.

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-_G-SMBKcvMg.htmlsi=JfCjM_RReuvvWFp4

in addition, this is the story Bilbo was telling the children at his birthday party in Fellowship of the Ring.

Sam told Frodo “ look Mr. Frodo it’s Bilbo’s Trolls!”

Matilda is great!

The cartoon version is amazing.

Absolutely 👍

🖖😌

​@@martinbraun1211🖖

Lord of The Rings is 3 books, not 6. It was one movie per book. The Hobbit should have been just one movie. It's literally the shortest book of the quadrilogy. Not even Fellowship of The Ring, the longest book in the series, could make for an entire movie trilogy.

Yes, Willow is a great fantasy movie.

They’re not even the full songs. Many full versions on RU-vid via fully self composed works. Would you like some channel names to check out?

I'm not sure "youthen" is a word but if it's not it should be. It's so descriptive. 👍

@@DarqJestor I’ve heard it from movie special effects people, so if it wasn’t a word before, they needed it and alakazam! 🙂

@@aleatharhea Well I'm going to use it now too. Thanks!

She read all his books too and her fave character is Galadriel believe it or not! She also said in the documentary of the hobbit that she’d come and do anything that has Galadriel in it so you’ll see her in his future films coming out.

Not to mention playing Dr.Watson in the BBC Sherlock Holmes with Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock Holmes. And, Mr. Cumberbatch stars as the voice of Smaug in the next two movies of this Hobbit Trilogy.

I would second this suggestion.

I will third this one!

Absolutely!

Fifthed!

Weirdly, it seems to me there's much more packed into The Hobbit than into each LOTR book. I probably just need to read them again.

@urthboundmisfit you're right. Peter Jackson explained that's exactly why The Hobbit is three movies. Being aimed at kids, The Hobbit was packed with action, stuff that translated well to film and which you just didn't want to leave out. Being aimed at adults, The Lord of The Rings was packed with page after page of dialogue and histories and poetry and songs, which just wouldn't have made for particularly compelling movie making. I'm rereading the LotR now, and I see exactly what he means. I think people who poo poo the decision are just reacting to the number of books either without giving it much thought or without actually having read The Hobbit or the LotR.

@@aleatharhea Very true. I read LotR recently and its a slog, and I struggled to get through it. Its amazing for sure, but not "action packed" for movie reasons.

Here here

Becomes purified later on and becomes Eryn Lasgalen

The grudge is because of a certain singular clan of dwarves that fricken murdered the greatest elvish king who was born upon middle earth before the sun and moon named Elu Thingol! AKA Elwë (Finwë was his fave brother out of his 5 other bothers.) it’s very complex and so Galadriels gift to Gimli had multiple pronged significance which closes the gap between elves and dwarves. Ontop of that the ultimate dwarf friend was her eldest brother Finrod. Named Felagund by the dwarves of Nargothrond and gave him that dwarvish kingdom as a gift as they created and fortified it together. And Galadriel too was friends with them. Only named Galadriel but later on by Celeborn and she fell in love with it so much that she used it as what’s called the universal name instead of Nerwen or Artanis etc. ❤❤❤❤

I love Clamavi de Profundis! I always follow them on spotify.

@@GAdmThrawn Several of their arrangements and covers of LOTR songs and poems are my favorites!

Great movies too for riddick

Yup. And Deltoro ran away in the middle and everyone got swamped and the show was gonna get canceled to the point where they begged Peter to come back. They hollered for him to come back and he brought the entire team from the original trilogy and that’s why it worked out so well