[THE IDOL BAND ] Why did the Korea-Japan joint idol band audition fail? 

For some people Idol Band might be boring but for me its the best survival show ever. No evil editing, no popularity or handsome contest, the senior is really kind to participant, they respect each other and become very close after the show end.

Please do not use their image as a cover to criticize them as they prepare for their upcoming debut. I certainly agree with some of your opinions. However, please do not criticize them in a way that hurts the younger generation, especially if you are involved in the music industry. Many people look at the cover and title before they look at the content of the video, and you are hurting the viewers who were supporting the 54 participants and, most importantly, themselves, and you are not making a good impression on those who are newly interested in them. It is a survival show, but it is also a part of their lives. Their musical path will continue. Please change the cover if you are willing to listen to this opinion in any way.

I enjoyed this show much more than the boring dance idol group auditions. The issues I have with this show are the ever-changing rules and the horrible broadcasting timing. It is a wasted effort if they broadcast the show at ungodly hours when most viewers would be sleeping already. Since this is the 1st time they are doing this, hopefully they can improve on the format and rectify the above issues I stated. Mainstream Band music should get a chance to develop a wider audience in Korea, so that the music scene is much more diverse and interesting. Some of the contestants are diamonds in the rough, and with the producers guidance, they eventually improved a lot, so it would be good if you reviewed the later episodes and see if your opinion will change.

4:00 에 일반아이돌에서 최상위권이라고 설명하시는데 뒤에나오는 영상자료 이홍기는 그냥 가수들중에서도 잘하는..

I love this audition show. But regret there is no English sub for the international fan to watch. Band need to grow like idol and should given chance to develop too in Korea. There is so much talent but no place to grow it though so they need to go to Japan. Maybe because you are such specialist critics you have high expectation but for usual people like me, i already love all the boys and are excited to see their growth and the result in future too ☺

you are certainly right in all your opinions, I admire that you speak like that knowing that there was a lot of discussion over who should have been the winner of the battle of the bands, good criticism was constructive

Without a doubt, what will stay with me the most about the idol band is the quality of the covers and above all, the final that PARTYAFTERSIX, Hi five unicorn and CLRock gave us

다른거 보려고 티비 체널 돌리다가 밴드 오디션 하기에 멈췄는데 그날이 마지막 방송 이더라구요 밴드음악 좋아하다 보니 이분들 우승하는거 보게됬네요 ㅋㅋ ft아일렌드 .씨엔불루 말고 최근엔 아이돌 벤드는 없었는데 활성화 됬음 좋겠구 아이돌 벤드 아니더라도 한국도 벤드가 활성화 되길 바라는 맘 입니다.

그런데 참가자들 보니까, 유튜버님께서 리뷰에서 비판하신 한국 참가자들 대학교가 서동호 실음과에서 3대 대학에 한 명은 버클리 음대라네요….

Fnc bands have more than 30 concert every year in japan and asia maybe they are not really popular in korea but they have solid fans outside korea

정말 가장 정확 하신듯 ㆍ

厳しい意見ですね、、 私はこの番組で好きなボーカルが多かったです。 しかし、最終ステージのしゅうとは...正直他に相応しい人がいると思いました。 デビューチームにはがっかり...

本当に言いたいことを全部言ってくださりありがとうございます。 間違いなく日本人メンバーを入れるなら楽器隊で入れた方が絶対的に良かったと思います。

한국 아이돌 밴드는 아이돌중에서도 노래잘하고 잘생기고 악기도 다뤄야하는,, 춤은 못춰도 ㅇㅋ

I've been commenting in some of the idol band videos how shuto and taemin's voice tones don't match and i agree with your points. It was better for taemin to just be a soloist than have shuto with him. Shuto has a lot to work on if they both need to shine equally as vocalists or one will overshadows the other. They're still new so I think time will tell if their chemistry will improve after debut. With taemin at the front playing guitar and singing, u can't help but have your eyes focus on him as the main vocal and shuto's presence would look unnecessary there. I think if shuto can learn to play an instrument like the keyboard or a second guitar, that would be much better for the band whole look.

I have been a long time seeing FNC's artist. I am a Boice since their debut and yes I agreed with some of the review. Shuto and Taemin are apposite vocal style. I think it's better to have a sub-vocal like Yejun or Jiseok. Their vocal can bland well with others vocal. They are good in pop song. For Guitar, Kim Hyunyul is the most handsome among the contestants. And he already has an idol image. I think they would go like N.Flying, having 2 vocal with opposite style. Low tone Seunghyub + Power vocal Hweseung. Don't know what they would go. I just remember they ever had Honeyst but disband. I really like Chulmin vocal and their image really fit for teenager band. I was crying a river after their disband announcement. I think it would really nice to have Oya Takayuki as 2nd guitar.

괜히 일본 시장 의식해서 어설픈 일본애들 버스 태워주는 이런 시간낭비 좀 안 했으면.이제껏 한일합작이라는 이름으로 퀄리티 있게 뭐가 나온 적이 없음. 될성부른 한국의 떡잎들 잘 키우고 만드는데에 정성 쏟아도 모자를 시간과 돈일텐데 엔터업계도 정신 차려야 할 듯..

이 프로그램의 유일한 의의라고 할 것은, 이전까지 있던 한국의 모든 라디오나 케이블 방송을 통틀어서 가장 많이, 그리고 자주 일본 가수와 그 곡을 소개한 것 뿐이다. 이외에는 단 하나도 없음. 김영서같이 실링 낮고 평범한 랩 원툴인데 싱잉랩을 락이랑 묻어서 계속 올려치기하는게 이해가 안되어서 중도하차했음

나코 보는 재미만 있던 오디션