Coming back to this in 2022 and it makes me reminisce about the good ole of playing this on repeat because I was such a fangirl, I wanna thank the janoskians for making my middle school and some of high school amazing🤍
At first I thought the lyrics were fucked up but when I really listened to it it's actually really sweet and gentle besides the swearing. I personally like Jai's part the most, so cute.
OMG I saw a comment of yours on Zoella's video and thought I'd watch some of your videos and you're so funny! I subscribed to you like 10 minutes ago and now I see you comment somewhere else! What is this? Hahaha, I love you x
I love how inspired and happy i get when i hear this song and then you see the comment section on youtube with all the girls getting offended. Just because they're saying "real girls eat cake " does not mean that they anorexic girls are fake and ugly. They are trying to say that girls should not be so insecure and that you are beautiful no matter how you look or if you cringe every time you look in the mirror/step on the scale. Also if you're saying that the song is offensive it's not going to affect the other 99% of the girls who love this song because we're "over-weight" or "guy-like" because we don't fit the standards of the shitty society we live in.
I woke up this morning with this song stuck in my head, it took me a while to remember a part of the lyrics to finally find that song reminding me of fun memories
people saying this song brings down people who are skinny, what about "all that bass" by Megan, she calls skinny girls "skinny bitches".....megans song brought me down. i love this song as its for all shapes and sizes.....they never said "big girls" in this song, they're singing this song for all types of woman, just enjoy the music!!! even if you dont you dont need to find an excuse to write a horrible comment.....this song makes me feel really happy because it tells me i can really be my self when im round a boy i like xD
I agree, they just mean they like a girl who doesn't care about her size, meghans song is just awfull, i'm just skinny from myself even thoo i eat a lot and she's just saying it as a bad thing!!
no one should really take this offensively. i think the message or meaning about this song is that you shouldn't have to worry about what you eat in front of guys. it's not here to make fun of people and their obesity. they just want you to be yourself and do whatever the hell you wanna do and not care about what people have to say about you. you don't have to be a quality starred model or be skinny enough. be you and thats the only way you can be real and unique ☺️✌️❤️
I first found these guys while listening to iTunes and this song came up. I thought it was stupid and always skipped it when it came up, but then I decided to look them up on google and started listening to their music and liked it. Then I saw they made RU-vid videos so I watched that too. I thought they were hilariously funny and now I've been a janoskians fan for like a year now. I may have not been here from the beginning but these guys are my idols💓
Omg same. this song came up on I heart radio. I always thought was weird until I really listened to the lyrics. I love them so much lol. I'm glad that I heart radio played this song or I wouldn't be so happy hhaa.
This video is perfect! And Jai sings like an angel and Skip at the end and James silly faces and Beaus thrusting and Lukes..everything! I just love this song/video so much♡
I like how people call them "a boyband" just from one video. shows how our generation is fucked up. also, i find it funny that people are taking this seriously. their born to entertain, not to make a fucking hit
they arent a boyband for one... theyre family and yes people do take them seriously even if theyre youtubers... for ex... ricky dillon is a youtuber and then became a singer (but is still a youtuber) they, the janoskians, can sing if they want to... its their lives and if you havent noticed.. you dont need a hit to be famous... so fuck off
I call them a boyband all the time but it's as a joke because in one of their old videos beau said that they aren't singers and won't release songs and stuff... And then they come out with 3 songs... Those people might be doing as a joke like me and then others might do it because to them having a group of guys that make music classify them as a boyband
Akaylah Cockett but thats the thing... they arent a so called boyband... theyre just a group of friends that make funny youtube videos.. yet later in the future they will be considered a "boyband" bc the signed with a record company... am i right?
Had an eating disorder back when this came out and I loved this to hear a group especially a group of guys come out with a song like this made me feel better I blasted this daily they were my favorite made me feel little bit better when listening to it me being someone that never had a thigh gap what I know now is just regular thighs and terrified to eat even a mouse size bite of cake now hell thick thighs saves lives didn't know that was true but thicker thighs actually help prevent heart attacks so don't feel bad if you have average to bigger thighs try to think at least it'll lessen your chance of answer attack
OMG get a grip all of you. This song is meant to raise spirits and tell young girls that worrying too much about your appearance, makes for a sad life. They say it jokingly to make the message easier to swallow. If you're too offended or hurt by this, then maybe you're the one who needed the message the most. The real girls/cake part all a big metaphor... meaning be happy with yourself regardless of how you look, then maybe other people will start doing the same.
So it's the 2nd day of 2021 and Beau just uploaded a video with his mum and I started scrolling down their page. Eventually, I saw a music video and remembered that they also made some (in the opinion of my 15 year old self pretty banging) music, so I searched that up and landed here. Now, listening to this song about 3 to 4 years after I fucking jammed to it every day, suddenly the memories are coming back. I just remembered how I thought they were all so cool and funny, I probably had a crush on everyone at a certain point, I remember skipping school and walking home listening to their songs and the most impressing thing to me is that, even for just a few seconds, this song made me feel the exact same way I felt when I was in that whole different stage of life a few years ago. Life, nostalgia, feelings and that are just magical. Feel it, cherish it, live it. Thank you for reading kind stranger.
It's okay, I can't listen to "live forever" because it reminds me of the video. Goddamn i love that video, i cry every time I watch it, especially when the camera zooms in on Beau crying 😭😍😍
Ugh. Please everyone, stop taking this song so seriously... The Janoskians aren't trying to say that you're only a real girl if you eat cake, they're trying to say that real girls aren't afraid to be themselves around guys. And that is completely true! They're not promoting obesity, or any of that so.... Lay off, bcuz this is a catchy song with good lyrics. Thanks
I love how this song is for girls of all shapes and sizes and reassures girls that u shouldnt give a crap what people think coz u r who u r and no 1's gonna judge u for being ur self and they really spread a message across to girls so thank you boys for releas this song it's great
I think this is a great song. And I think it's hilarious, half of these comments. Skinny shaming? Are you guys kidding me! Half of the song these days Fat shame half I is girls even if we're not obese. So don't give me this crap about artists all of a sudden starting to 'skinny' shame you bc we've been having to deal with fat shaming for a hell of a lot longer. How many bigger sized woman have you seen in music videos these days? Hardly any! There all skinny models. So at least you all can look at them and relate to them a little when half of is cannot. So please do us all a favour and stfu.
I don't need a girl that worries about a thigh gap I like the fact that u don't give a shit about that! Yessssss u have boosted my confidence so much.💕👏🏻👏🏻
I'm a girl and honestly hate thigh gaps 😂 why would you want to look unhealthy? Honestly... To those who naturally have thigh gaps, I'm not hating on you, you can tell the difference between natural and forced. I have a small natural thigh gap and I don't really like it. Fit is the new skinny people 👏🏼 maybe just toned, not full on muscle 😂 I also don't like that. Geez I never realised how picky I am...
Briii Griffin they're making a video called "real girls eat cake"...seriously? It's saying that ONLY REAL WOMEN WIL EAT CAKE IN FRONT OF PEOPLE!!! but that's not even a giant issue? It's also implying that body weight issues is always due to high eating. We can't also forget the time one of them fucking slut shamed Ariana Grande just because some shit went down between her and Jai. And the comment section is for both praise and criticism.
To all the people saying they're degrading women that's bull you are making it into sleeting that it's not they're just having fun and you need to not take as seriously as you are
dude chill out, yeah he's dating Ariana Grande. No one said he was automatically gonna start dating someone else. He can date who ever the hell he wants.
why is everybody talking about their singing? maybe think about the message of the song!! its true, real girls eat cake and dont have to have a tigh gap
Some girls naturally have a 'thigh gap' and some girls dont like cake? and how the fuck does eating cake make you a 'real girl'. This is supposed to empower women I am guessing, but it isn't at all. There isn't really a good message to this song
This song doesn't send a positive message at all, it's saying girls that choose to have this sort of lifestyle can be judged as not being "real" girls.
leave, "real girls" are GIRLS every girl is a real girl whether they eat cake or have a thigh gap. also i eat cake and still have a thigh gap am i only half a real girl? smh
Today a boy in my class came up to me and said 'i see you made an effort with your lipstick, with you got some on your teeth you fucking dipshit' and i almost DIED. I shall treasure this boy forever.
to everyone hating on them remember theyre not actual singers, theyre doing this for us the fans!! plus this song is soooo amazing and fun and they great vocals than yall will ever have bye. keep it up boys ilysm
I love how there saying we don't need to worry about a thigh gap, we don't need to eat a salad at every date, not to worry about our appearances. Which is really nice to say cause I have low self esteem like other girls'.
This is the first video I’ve clicked on from you guys, and even after the first verse, I couldn’t stop laughing 😂😂😂 thank u so much for making my day 😂😂😂
