Тёмный

The Ladies Who Lunch - Song Analysis 

Daniel Isengart
Подписаться 383
Просмотров 4,8 тыс.
50% 1

The Ladies Who Lunch is a very popular showstopper from Stephen Sondheim's Musical, Company, but I find that' it's all too often performed as a snarky putdown. Let's take a close look at both lyrics and music to see what they tell us in order to fully understand the character, Joanne, and use our analysis to craft a layered, detailed performance that lives up to this powerful song. My analysis may surprise you.

Опубликовано:

 

3 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 59   
@queerquill
@queerquill 3 года назад
This is simply wonderful. I'm an old queen slowly exposing a young queen to the history of musical theatre. We listened to three versions of this song today . After the third, he liked it, but asked what it meant. I looked up "analysis of ladies who lunch" and found your video. Perfect.
@isengart
@isengart 3 года назад
Thank you so much! I am glad you found it... I really ought to make more of these.
@TheBamst
@TheBamst 3 года назад
Oh my God this is so brilliant!!! Just brilliant!! I am completely magnetized, thank you so very, very much for this!!!
@isengart
@isengart 3 года назад
Thank you so much!
@BTURNER1961
@BTURNER1961 2 года назад
A very interesting and persuasive take on what may be the lyric with the most potent dose of irony in Broadway's history. It is on its face a 'snarky put-down' but the fear, jealousy, desperation underneath are what needs to resonate in a successful performance.
@brstfr7126
@brstfr7126 2 года назад
I've been listening to this song since the 70s and thought I knew all its ins and outs, but I somehow never noticed the double meaning of "a copy of Life." Thanks for showing me something new.
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you!
@pfar
@pfar Год назад
Thank you, Daniel, so much for this analysis. Last week, we saw COMPANY in Madrid and I immediately liked this song, listened to it over and over ever since, but your explanation makes so much more sense to me now. Sondheim is a genius. Now I wonder how all these meanings translate/interpret into a different language. It must be very difficult.
@isengart
@isengart Год назад
Thank you, Pavel. Yes, translating song lyrics well is an art from. I have done a lot of it in my years of performing and the challenges are huge.
@almondmilkbone
@almondmilkbone 2 года назад
This was captivating omg
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you! All I had to do was break down what's there on the page, and in the music.
@vincentpchevalier
@vincentpchevalier 3 месяца назад
This is one of the best pieces of musical criticism I've ever watched!
@liveegge1547
@liveegge1547 2 года назад
This is absolutley brilliant. Fantastic and such an insightful analysis - please please analyse more of Sondheims texts!
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
I'm very glad you've enjoyed this, thank you for your kind words. I mostly do opera aria analysis but maybe one day I'll tackle another Sondheim. Thank you for encouraging me to do so.
@queerquill
@queerquill 3 года назад
I disagree with you as well.... I also think she loves, respects, and admires these women she talks about. And I do not think she's alone. She too, is one of the women she is talking about. This is what happens when her kind of women (and maybe men) don't deeply connect with someone. They become plastic shells. And she is saying to Bobby: we are powerful.... But don't be like us.
@isengart
@isengart 3 года назад
Your conclusion makes a valid point. Yes, clearly she is singing about herself as well, but I personally don't see much respect or admiration in her for these women, I sense her fear of becoming or being like them. Any singer performing this - especially in a concert setting - can give this character her or his own choice of color - the key is to make it specific;,to know where you're coming from and where you're going.
@MsCeiBell
@MsCeiBell 2 года назад
@@isengart I think you completely misunderstand the song and the character. Joanne grew up with all of the constraints of being a wife of her class who meets other ladies who lunch. She cynically sees through it, and she's done with it. She has anger and may be about to depart. "Does anybody still wear a hat" refers to when ladies were required to wear a hat (along with white gloves) as part of the respectable ladies's uniform that was going out of style. That hat was an anachronism.
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
@@MsCeiBell Thank you for watching my video and for putting your thoughts to it. There is always room for more than one interpretation in all art - that's what makes it interesting.
@jkvictus8965
@jkvictus8965 4 месяца назад
Thank you. I've been listening to this song since my 20s with my understanding of it growing as l got older. But your analysis of the emotional thru-line of the song finally answered a question l had since discovering Company... and that was why did Joanne hit on Bobby. You just explained her beautifully and tragically. And her sudden "pick me up" after being rejected, "l think l just saved somebody's life", is much clearer and deeper. Thank you.
@isengart
@isengart 4 месяца назад
This is the sort of gracious and positive reaction that makes me want to do more of these kinds of videos, despite my low viewership. Thank you so very much!
@jacobzieper3846
@jacobzieper3846 2 года назад
This was absolutely fascinating!!! I just saw the new revival of Company on Broadway, and seeing Patti Lupone (may she live long and be well) perform Ladies Who Lunch was a whole other level! I so appreciated your deep dive into the subtext of the lyrics! Will leave me with a lot to think about every time I hear this song performed.
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you so much!
@paytonfit
@paytonfit 3 месяца назад
One word for you. Subscribed! You're fantastic! I loved every word that fell out of your mouth!
@isengart
@isengart 3 месяца назад
Thank you very much for your encouragement!
@suzanne6441
@suzanne6441 2 года назад
Helpfully, and stylishly comprehensive. Thank you - this and Send in the Clowns are the 2 songs I struggle with.
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you! Send in the Clowns is a song that I don't think benefits from over-analyzing. It's pretty much one poetic statement that is stretched out, a realization of failure and a failed attempt at laughing about it. The best version in my mind is the recording of Rosemary Clooney who sang it with wistful tenderness.
@jerryshimon8541
@jerryshimon8541 2 года назад
Plaid on plaid with supporers, Wonderful! Thanks, love.
@Locadelly
@Locadelly 11 месяцев назад
Incredible! I have loved Company for years, but often felt as though I'm just skimming the surface of the meanings of the songs. This was a huge help for this particular puzzle :)
@BrentS007
@BrentS007 Год назад
Wow Daniel, your explanation presented through performance was absolutely fabulous and electrifying. How did you time your words? Was it just ad lib? You timed your words so well, you said certain words perfect to the music. The Ladies Who Lunch has been one of my favorite songs of all time, the music, the lyrics. After many years of listening to this Sondheim song, I wanted an analysis and was blown away by your presentation! Thank you!
@isengart
@isengart Год назад
Thank you so much. I simply created an extended track, synced to my commentary.
@deadsatiro
@deadsatiro 3 года назад
simply perfect explanation. Thank u.
@isengart
@isengart 3 года назад
Thank you so much! I have made quite a few videos with analysis of this kind but most are about operatic arias. I am glad you like this one.
@christinatsigka8645
@christinatsigka8645 2 года назад
Thank you for this wonderful analysis! You've helped me understand many details... By the time I've listened to that marvelous song, I have been trying to figure out if the lyrics reveal either misogynism or a kind of defeated feminism. Of course I release that it's above all that -but still leaves a bitter taste in my mouth! It is kind of an addictive heartbreak! Well...this is life! Thank you once again!
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you for your kind words. I might add that the kind of distilled drama we see in this song is why theater is so important for us to understand ourselves. I personally prefer it onstage, artistically shaped and fascinating, whereas facing it in real life would indeed leave behind a more than bitter taste
@notverynotoriousg5674
@notverynotoriousg5674 2 года назад
I never really thought about how foreign this must be to younger people, when the 70s kicked in women all wanted a career and an era came to a screeching halt. The clubs and restaurants were really swank to me at least when I was a little kid, we used to dress up to go out, shocking, I know. i would tag along if it was a shopping excursion, like if I needed school clothes, etc. Optical art was a trend at the time, it fits with the Pinter, it was very important to be au courant, my mom took art classes, lol. School was much more than just picking up the kids, it was important to be interested in your child's education, moms would volunteer, PTAs were social events. I read a hysterical op-ed on dressing for school, as the teacher might just be anti-capitalist and find any display of wealth abhorrent. I think of Joanne as socially awkward, she doesn't fit in with polite society, so she mocks it even though she wishes she did fit in.
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Very interesting, thank you!
@alexjemphrey
@alexjemphrey 2 года назад
This is just so great, Daniel!
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you, Alex. Most of my videos are about arias, not songs from musicals, but you may find them interesting as well.
@alexjemphrey
@alexjemphrey 2 года назад
@@isengart That’s cool. I sing classical repertoire as well as musical theatre, so I’ll be sure to check them out! Would be awesome if we could work together someday!!
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
@@alexjemphrey Thank you! Yes, that would be great. Let me know if you want to book a zoom coaching session...
@d.prescott4895
@d.prescott4895 2 года назад
This is fun. I'm glad I found it.
@VanessaCarrMusic
@VanessaCarrMusic Год назад
You're fabulous. 👏 👏 👏
@isengart
@isengart Год назад
Thank you! I am glad you're enjoying my presentation.
@VanessaCarrMusic
@VanessaCarrMusic Год назад
@@isengart Thank YOU for your help!
@denroleonard5345
@denroleonard5345 2 года назад
you are amazing
@NicoLuengos
@NicoLuengos 2 года назад
BRILLIANT!
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you!
@JonesJr876
@JonesJr876 2 года назад
Buenísimo. Gracias
@zzzut
@zzzut 2 года назад
That young man is brilliant.
@stephaniedegange2737
@stephaniedegange2737 2 года назад
wonderful analysis
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you!
@saigewinters
@saigewinters 2 года назад
Love!
@katrinas2752
@katrinas2752 2 года назад
Wow. Fabulous
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
Thank you!
@dinachan898
@dinachan898 3 года назад
Between Elaine Stritch and Patti Lupone who in your opinion sang this song the best?
@isengart
@isengart 3 года назад
I thought Patti Lupone did a fantastic rendition in the Carnegie Hall concert in honor of Sondheim. I also like Cleo Laine's recording quite a bit, and Streisand's mash-up of the song with "Pretty Women" on her guest Broadway album is worth listening to.
@stephaniedegange2737
@stephaniedegange2737 2 года назад
@@isengart i like elaine stritch's version. she was an alcoholic her entire life...this piece reminds me of how she must have felt sometimes. i loveeeee your anaysis. spot on, i say
@isengart
@isengart 2 года назад
@@stephaniedegange2737 Thank you!
Далее
Ladies Who Lunch - Saturday Night Live
4:11
Просмотров 3,4 млн
Analyzing Patti LuPone's "LADIES WHO LUNCH!"
27:28
Просмотров 6 тыс.
ОВР Шоу:  Семейные понты  @ovrshow_tnt
07:21
Elaine Stritch - Ladies Who Lunch
7:46
Просмотров 223 тыс.
Patti LuPone - Ladies Who Lunch (Sondheim's 80th)
4:39
Conversion Testimony - Vlasta
14:48
Просмотров 22
Sondheim teaches 'Not Getting Married' from Company
7:05
Medley: Pretty Women / The Ladies Who Lunch
5:10
Просмотров 131 тыс.
How Sondheim Writes A Musical
8:10
Просмотров 27 тыс.