Тёмный

The Macabre Origins of the Grim Reaper (feat.  

Storied
Подписаться 887 тыс.
Просмотров 436 тыс.
50% 1

Thanks to Ancestry for supporting PBS. Check out your family's history at www.ancestry.com
Don’t miss future episodes of Monstrum, subscribe! bit.ly/pbsstori...
There are fewer images of Death personified than the scythe-wielding skeletal form of the Grim Reaper. But where did it come from? You may have heard that this haunting figure emerged as a result of the Black Plague, but that’s only a fraction of the story. Featuring ‪@AskAMortician‬, this episode looks at the long history of skeletal Death in religion, literature, art, and pop culture. From violent reaper to dark lover and virtually everything in between, there’s a lot more to Death than, well, Death. #grimreaper #mythology #MonstrumPBS
Written and Hosted by: Dr. Emily Zarka
Director: David Schulte
Executive Producer: Amanda Fox
Producer: Stephanie Noone
Illustrator: Samuel Allen
Editor: Ray Lux
Produced by Spotzen for PBS Digital Studios.
The world is full of monsters, myths, and legends and Monstrum isn’t afraid to take a closer look. The show, hosted by Emily Zarka, Ph.D., takes us on a journey to discover a new monster in each new episode. Monstrum looks at humans' unique drive to create and shape monster mythology through oral storytelling, literature, and film and digs deep into the history of those mythologies.
Follow us on Instagram:
/ monstrumpbs
----------------------------
Bibliography
Burke, Joseph P. The Black Death. Greenwood Press, 2004.
"Chronos." Britannica Academic, Encyclopædia Britannica, 26 Sep. 2018.
"Cronus." Britannica Academic, Encyclopædia Britannica, 26 Sep. 2018.
Gertsman, Elina. The Dance of Death in the Middle Ages: Image, Text, Performance. Brepolis, 2010.
Goetz, Hans-Werner. Life In the Middle Ages: From the Seventh to the Thirteenth Century. E-book, Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1993.
Guthke, Karl S. The Gender of Death: A Cultural History in Art and Literature. Cambridge University Press, 1999.
Kinch, Ashby. “Image, Ideology, and Form: The Middle English ‘Three Dead Kings’ in Its Iconographic Context.” The Chaucer Review, vol. 43, no. 1, The Pennsylvania State University Press, 2008, pp. 48-81.
Kurtz, Leonard P. The Dance of Death and the Macabre Spirit in European Literature. Gordon Press, 1975.
OED Online, Oxford University Press, March 2021.
Roberts, Michael. “Sickles and Scythes: Women’s work and Men’s Work at Harvest Time.” History Workshop, no. 7, Spring 1979, pp. 3-28.
Stone, David. Decision-Making in Medieval Agriculture, Oxford University Press, Incorporated, 2005.
Tholuck, August. The Circle of Human Life. New York: Robert Carter & Brothers, 1860.

Опубликовано:

 

30 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,3 тыс.   
@Schlachti10
@Schlachti10 3 года назад
"The Grimm Reaper should be the Grimm Mower" - Caitlin "Scytheman" - Germany
@Das_Kaenguru
@Das_Kaenguru 3 года назад
Scytheman got unemploymed years ago in Germany. We have „Lawn Mower Man“ now….cause we are into efficiency and stuff
@scytheslash
@scytheslash 3 года назад
@@Das_Kaenguru So what do i do?
@Richard_Nickerson
@Richard_Nickerson 3 года назад
Grim* Grim means dark, depressing, uninviting. Grimm is the surname from the fairytales. Grim comes from the same place Grimm does, but one's a name and the other's an adjective. A Grimm Reaper is one who reaps people named Grimm.
@Carewolf
@Carewolf 3 года назад
@@Richard_Nickerson No, he is just the Reaper named Grimm.
@Richard_Nickerson
@Richard_Nickerson 3 года назад
@@Carewolf Nah. Grammatically, it's what I said.
@cramerfloro5936
@cramerfloro5936 3 года назад
The fact that they pointed out the difference between Chronos and Kronos gave me physical pleasure!
@doomedmessenger
@doomedmessenger 3 года назад
I never knew about the pronunciation difference between them! That's the first time I've heard them be different.
@VergilsApprentice
@VergilsApprentice 3 года назад
@@doomedmessenger I think she mispronounced it, since if you plug in the greek pronunciation of Chronos into google translate it sounds much more like Chronos than whatever she said.
@VergilsApprentice
@VergilsApprentice 3 года назад
At least it sounded like she mispronounced it the first time she said it; subsequent pronunciations sound much closer.
@cramerfloro5936
@cramerfloro5936 3 года назад
@@VergilsApprentice it doesn't bother me that much: there isn't any word with an aspirative followed by a consonant in English, so her adding a short E after the aspirative is a close enough approximation.
@gabrielasolis2657
@gabrielasolis2657 3 года назад
I'm still at the beginning but this gives me serotonin
@Corporis
@Corporis 3 года назад
This episode has something for everyone: Greek mythology, vivid depictions of death incarnate, and Caitlin's bangs
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Yes Death Momma Catlin Doughty & Dr Z together in the same video! 😁😄👍 What an *AWESOME* gift for the 4th of July! 💀
@emv8869
@emv8869 3 года назад
I totally read this is Stefan’s voice
@Corporis
@Corporis 3 года назад
@@emv8869 as intended 😊
@thetedentertainmentstudio
@thetedentertainmentstudio 3 года назад
What about the Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy?
@rdrgz6217
@rdrgz6217 3 года назад
Don’t forget that cool t-shirt Dr Z was using
@freiht7508
@freiht7508 3 года назад
Dr. Z and Caitlin talking about The Grim Reaper, this is pure perfection.
@misssomayea
@misssomayea 3 года назад
This is the crossover we needed.
@Spectrulus
@Spectrulus 3 года назад
I don't have the words for how delighted I am to see this. Legendary feels close though.
@josediego9219
@josediego9219 3 года назад
I agree
@sriprakhyapochiraju9498
@sriprakhyapochiraju9498 3 года назад
Definitely!
@JimmyNails27
@JimmyNails27 3 года назад
I came here to say exactly this
@marinara3306
@marinara3306 3 года назад
I got so excited.
@titangirl161
@titangirl161 3 года назад
Fun fact: Scythe's are not practical as weapons. Sometimes farmers would use them in an uprising because it was what they had. This would make the grim reaper using one less of a warrior and more of a farmer. But there are also battle scythes, which were specifically made to be weilded in a fight.
@monsternside1509
@monsternside1509 3 года назад
Great, now I'm imagining Death running around chasing folks with a push mower.
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
ROTFLMAO!🤣🚜💀
@fruitygarlic3601
@fruitygarlic3601 3 года назад
In Terry Pratchett's Discworld, the Grim Reapers of other planets sometimes use combine harvesters.
@giladpellaeon1691
@giladpellaeon1691 3 года назад
And the Death of the Discworld defeats a combine harvester in a John Henry style contest (with the help of some sabotage)
@kaylathehedgehog2005
@kaylathehedgehog2005 3 года назад
Funnily enough, the manga/anime "Black Butler" actually has a Grim Reaper character that modified his scythe to look like a push mower. The character's name is Ronald Knox, if you want to look him up.
@thoughtengine
@thoughtengine 3 года назад
I'm imagining him trying to start it whilst streaming expletives in small capitals...
@memmermiller
@memmermiller 3 года назад
They did all this without mentioning Sandman or Discworld? Here’s hoping “It’s Lit” do a literary-focused follow-up 🖤
@theasinclaire52
@theasinclaire52 3 года назад
I want that! I bet Lindsay Ellis has talked about Death.
@catherinefilcher236
@catherinefilcher236 3 года назад
I think they have already done a "it's lit" on death. It's great and they talk about the discworld Death.
@FlorenceFox
@FlorenceFox 3 года назад
Right? They even brought up humanizing portrayals of Death in particular.
@erkindanger
@erkindanger 3 года назад
Lindsay's Loose Canon episode on Death: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9aNax1Rhs-w.html
@giladpellaeon1691
@giladpellaeon1691 3 года назад
@@theasinclaire52 Yes she has and mentions Death of the Discworld
@TheNightmareRider
@TheNightmareRider 3 года назад
"DONT THINK OF IT AS DYING," said Death. "JUST THINK OF IT AS LEAVING EARLY TO AVOID THE RUSH."
@RodLandaeta
@RodLandaeta 3 года назад
I love that quote from Good Omens. I REMEMBER WHEN ALL THIS WILL BE AGAIN.
@ladykoiwolfe
@ladykoiwolfe 3 года назад
Terry Pratchett always wrote my favorite Death.
@RodLandaeta
@RodLandaeta 3 года назад
@@ladykoiwolfe it was his favourite character. A true genius.
@fist-of-doom487
@fist-of-doom487 3 года назад
Here’s a Death Quote for you from The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy: Billy: why do the good die young? Grim Reaper: Well usually it’s because I get confused
@ladykoiwolfe
@ladykoiwolfe 3 года назад
@@RodLandaeta one can tell when the Author truly cares about a character. I would guess Granny Weatherwax to be his second favorite. I know she's one of mine. Her death tore me up just about as much as his did.
@HarryBuddhaPalm
@HarryBuddhaPalm 3 года назад
You might be a king or a little street sweeper but sooner or later you'll dance with the Reaper.
@adnaanu
@adnaanu 3 года назад
Thumbs up 👍for the Bill and Ted reference
@andrewbond4353
@andrewbond4353 3 года назад
This was actually said by a prisoner just before his execution in the USA
@HarryBuddhaPalm
@HarryBuddhaPalm 3 года назад
@@andrewbond4353 It was also said by the Grim Reaper in "Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey". ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N9YpnklYhxY.html
@emiliaortiz2458
@emiliaortiz2458 Год назад
Oh, I like that. is that a quote or entirely you?
@HarryBuddhaPalm
@HarryBuddhaPalm Год назад
@@emiliaortiz2458 It's from "Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey". ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-N9YpnklYhxY.html
@fireflyer97
@fireflyer97 3 года назад
So, the grim reaper is basically a medieval meme.
@DavidTokugi44
@DavidTokugi44 3 года назад
A timeless meme
@nunyabiznes33
@nunyabiznes33 3 года назад
Undying meme
@notimetolive12
@notimetolive12 3 года назад
Medieval version of Coffin dance meme.
@vee-bee-a
@vee-bee-a 3 года назад
An eternal meme.
@DocHolliday1851
@DocHolliday1851 2 года назад
Seasons don't fear the reaper Nor do the wind, the sun, or the rain
@tskmaster3837
@tskmaster3837 3 года назад
THERE IS NO JUSTICE, THERE IS JUST ME. With regards and thanks to Mr Terry Practhett. Oh and never quote Death, only Ravens.
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
GNU Sir Terry Pratchett 😔
@giladpellaeon1691
@giladpellaeon1691 3 года назад
GNU Sir Terry
@amarketing8749
@amarketing8749 3 года назад
@@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 Excuse my ignorance, but what does GNU stand for?
@BeatrixOnyx
@BeatrixOnyx 3 года назад
@@amarketing8749 it comes from Going Postal. In the book the Discworld have gained internet-like technology called Clacks. GNU is a code that means: "“G” means that the message must be passed on, “N” means “not logged”, and “U” means the message should be turned around at the end of a line."
@eskarinakatz7723
@eskarinakatz7723 2 года назад
@@BeatrixOnyx @a marketing It can also be construed as “Good Night Universe”.
@mortified776
@mortified776 3 года назад
I was so keen for this I didn't even notice that it said this is a collab with Ask a Mortician. I screamed like a little girl when Caitlin appeared! Animated skeletons are easily my favourite horror trope. If they're yours too I strongly recommend Percival Landon's short story _Thurnley Abbey._
@jessicaclakley3691
@jessicaclakley3691 3 года назад
Thank you for the recommendation
@Spectrulus
@Spectrulus 3 года назад
I also screamed...
@mortified776
@mortified776 3 года назад
@@jessicaclakley3691 My pleasure! Hope you enjoy it!
@dianaadhdchannel
@dianaadhdchannel 3 года назад
I’ve now just learned about her because of this channel. I love her already 🤩
@mortified776
@mortified776 3 года назад
@@dianaadhdchannel Welcome young Deathling!
@dlollard
@dlollard 3 года назад
Until now, the character Death, from Neil Gaiman's Sandman, was the only female Death I was aware of. Thank you for a fascinating trip through the history of Death.
@andrewmalinowski6673
@andrewmalinowski6673 3 года назад
Another version is Azrael from Lucifer, she was mentioned as Lucifer and Amenadiel's sister but doesn't show up until episode 326 (S3E26). It was interesting seeing a version who was a kind and pleasant dork rather than a terrifying image; "I only ever hang out with dead people they're so...morose."
@originaluddite
@originaluddite 3 года назад
I was quite pleased to hear that, because in my D&D game the death deity appears as masculine, feminine or skeletal-neuter depending on circumstances, and also is neither evil nor good.
@scipio109
@scipio109 3 года назад
In Spain we always see death as a woman, there is even an old military song where soldiers refer to themselves as Death‘s groom, you know like they are her boyfriend?
@staceyt557
@staceyt557 3 года назад
Not necessarily Death, but In the Supernatural series, the first Reaper was male until Crowley killed him off, then the new Reaper was female. I thought that was a very different take on the it,, to see that the gender of the Reaper could be either gender as long as they were good for the role.
@Moonfire289
@Moonfire289 3 года назад
The Kindred in LoL are two entities that never leave each other's side, and Lamb is (I'm assuming anyways by her voice) a female
@nemilyk
@nemilyk 3 года назад
OMG MY TWO FAVORITE RU-vidRS TOGETHER!!
@dseray9494
@dseray9494 3 года назад
Same!
@lancebiggerstaff2660
@lancebiggerstaff2660 3 года назад
Right?!
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Yes Death Momma Catlin Doughty & Dr Z together in the same video! 😁😄👍 What an *AWESOME* gift for the 4th of July! 💀
@IshbelJekyllhyde
@IshbelJekyllhyde 3 года назад
Yessss
@AslamGreyFox
@AslamGreyFox 3 года назад
Yeah...this was the 1st vid I saw.. Omgosh my heart fluttered, 2 most beautiful people in in the same video.. And the day after watching one being preserved with formaldehyde... Ahahahaa my own fairy-tale 😁
@nightthought2497
@nightthought2497 3 года назад
My personal favourite depiction of the Reaper is the Terry Pratchett Death.
@andrewmalinowski6673
@andrewmalinowski6673 3 года назад
I'd say it's between Death from Hogfather and Azrael from Lucifer. One is calm but authoritative and compassionate "Then we have an agreement," the other is kind and somewhat dorky and had a great reveal as the Angel of Death; "what too cool to call me Rae-Rae anymore?"
@MWhaleK
@MWhaleK 3 года назад
The Discworld Novels have the best depiction of Death.
@foreverpinkf.7603
@foreverpinkf.7603 3 года назад
Yeah, the most funny death ever.
@andrewbond4353
@andrewbond4353 3 года назад
I like to think death from disc world is the real grim reaper he just knows how to put the fun back in to your death.
@devilbydeed11
@devilbydeed11 3 года назад
@@andrewbond4353 You can't spell Funeral without FUN!
@Gandalf-The-Green
@Gandalf-The-Green 3 года назад
I always loved Terry Pratchett's stories on his Discworld version of the Grim Reaper, especially the one in which his mortal apprentice had to take over because Death had a midlife crisis. I hope that when the reaper came for him he came as an old friend which is the most you can expect from death. By the way what a great idea to get Caitlin on board, can't imagine a better collab.... unless LED Zeppelin and Rush were doing a gig together.
@kanrup5199
@kanrup5199 2 года назад
I think the story of book 'soul music' has some to do with death of Death's daughter and mort, and Death's granddaughter Susan.
@trollkienofficial1225
@trollkienofficial1225 3 года назад
If I die and the death coming for me is not Death from Neil Gaiman's Sandman comics, I'm not dying.
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
I haven't read Sandman, but if it's the same Death there as in the. Terry Pratchett Discworld novels then I can whole heartedly agree with you. 💀
@giladpellaeon1691
@giladpellaeon1691 3 года назад
@@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 Sandman's Death is female and less "skeleton in robes".
@Lucius1958
@Lucius1958 3 года назад
@@giladpellaeon1691 Who else thinks Caitlin could do a great cosplay of Death from Sandman?
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
@@giladpellaeon1691 Cool, but I think I'd prefer Terry Pratchett's Death to come for me. Then I could at least have a curry before I went to the Great Beyond. 🍛💀 🤣
@giladpellaeon1691
@giladpellaeon1691 3 года назад
@@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 And probably get to pet a kitty too. Because CATS ARE NICE
@LeeDeeThe1
@LeeDeeThe1 3 года назад
5:36 "Just butting in here for some scythe facts" is exactly what I imagine Caitlin beeing like at partys.
@gwendolyn2001
@gwendolyn2001 3 года назад
Re: Female Grim Reapers--in Greece, Hekate is closely associated with death and a goddess triad, ruled the underworld before Hades came along. In Norse myth, the underworld has a goddess, not a god, of death. In Celtic myth, the Morrigan, also a triple goddess, is the goddess of death and war. There are precedents for female "reapers." And well done!
@asmith8692
@asmith8692 3 года назад
Macaria, daughter of Hades and Persephone.
@gwendolyn2001
@gwendolyn2001 3 года назад
@@asmith8692 I have studied Greek myth rather extensively and never heard of Macaria! Thanks for introducing her to me. However, the sources which I found say her mother is unknown. She is mentioned in the Suda, apparently, but that work is from the 10th. century. I can't find any other info about her.
@pedroarjona6996
@pedroarjona6996 3 года назад
The White Lady or maybe the Lady in White, "La Alba Doncella" o "La Dama Blanca", a very thin and pale or skelitical well dressed female in a white dress, that will kiss you, sometimes in the forehead or the cheek, other deeply in the mouth, and with that kiss take your soul to your judgment.
@gwendolyn2001
@gwendolyn2001 3 года назад
@@pedroarjona6996 Thanks for the info! Interesting.
@Nightwalker-zk6ce
@Nightwalker-zk6ce 3 года назад
Isn’t the underworld god in ancient Japanese mythology also female?
@themerryreaper4667
@themerryreaper4667 3 года назад
There is a book called the Book Thief and it is written from the perspective of one of the best depictions of death as someone neutral and fair. For people that are as interested in the concept of death as me.
@macdege6754
@macdege6754 3 года назад
Ah i have to read that book again, I remember liking it.
@thefragrantwookiee
@thefragrantwookiee 3 года назад
Pratchett's Death is iconic: Albert - "Never say die, that's our motto!" Death - "I CAN'T SAY IT'S EVER BEEN MINE." Teatime - "Don't try any last-minute stuff!" Death - "I *AM* LAST MINUTE STUFF."
@gracemanock2471
@gracemanock2471 2 года назад
I didn't give you a start, I gave you a stop!
@williamwhitney5266
@williamwhitney5266 Год назад
No I'm the Final Note ...Silence... -Bill Door💀
@princekrazie
@princekrazie 3 года назад
I am reminded with the words of John the Baptist: "The ax is already at the root of the trees, and every tree that does not produce good fruit will be cut down and thrown into the fire.... His winnowing fork is in his hand, and he will clear his threshing floor, gathering his wheat into the barn and burning up the chaff with unquenchable fire"
@EveloGrave
@EveloGrave 3 года назад
Aww, was hoping to see mention of Malthael in Diablo using two sickles or how death can be portrayed to children as in the Cartoon Network show "The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy"
@loretaarroyo
@loretaarroyo 3 года назад
OMYGOD DR. EMILY AND CAITLYN OMG OMG 😭😭😭😭 THE CROSSOVER WE LIVE FOR 😭😭😭😭
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Yes Death Momma Catlin Doughty & Dr Z together in the same video! 😁😄👍 What an *AWESOME* gift for the 4th of July! 💀
@kellydalstok8900
@kellydalstok8900 3 года назад
"It’s funny. The day you lose someone isn’t the worst - at least you’ve got something to do. It’s all the days they stay dead." - The Doctor
@TheBearAspirin
@TheBearAspirin 3 года назад
The Grim Reaper: the OG skinny legend.
@mg4361
@mg4361 3 года назад
4:28 correction: in Slavic languages (at least the two that i know) the word for death, smrt, is female and is depicted as a pale, skinny old woman in stories.
@Miraihi
@Miraihi 3 года назад
Can confirm, death is female in Russian, my mother tongue.
@riograndedosulball248
@riograndedosulball248 3 года назад
Actually shocked to learn that there are cultures in which Death is NOT female
@pkups.79
@pkups.79 3 года назад
As a Pole, I caught this mistake too (śmierć is a female noun)
@rotciv557
@rotciv557 3 года назад
Death is often seen as female in Spanish speaking countries too (the pronoun used to refer to Death, "La", is exclusively used for female nouns which the spanish word for Death, "Muerte", counts as. We refer to Death as a concept or person as "La Muerte")
@Ellestra
@Ellestra 2 года назад
@@riograndedosulball248 You're not the only one - one of the most common questions (besides the Sto Lat one) Terry Pratchett got when he came to Poland was why is DEATH male.
@kathleenjackson3258
@kathleenjackson3258 3 года назад
Lindsay Ellis put up a video quite a while ago about fictional representations about the personification of death. If you like this you could watch those too. All the great RU-vidrs talking about death!
@robertheller4583
@robertheller4583 3 года назад
The only grim reaper I know throughout my childhood was a skeleton guy with a jamaican accent and is mostly accompanied by an idiot and an edgy kid
@Raccon_Detective.
@Raccon_Detective. 3 года назад
My childhood show.
@slipstreamxr3763
@slipstreamxr3763 3 года назад
Loved that show, I have his figurine on my desktop.
@theintern2960
@theintern2960 3 года назад
Caitlin? My RU-vid subscriptions are turning into some kind of cinematic universe!
@tomasvrabec1845
@tomasvrabec1845 3 года назад
Hmmm Being a Western Slav we tend to speak of death as female because "Smrtka" End with an a which is female. A male would be "Smrtiak" Or "Smrto nos" (... My phone doesn't have the my. Vols for pronunciation as i lice abroad) Also in many Czech comedies it seems to tame the form of very old skinny woman more often than not although it does switch in between based on what you need for the story.
@Mikeztarp
@Mikeztarp 3 года назад
4:35 In French, Spanish and Portuguese and Latin, the word for "death" is feminine. I don't know about the others, but I think this explains why the personification of Death was female. PS: My favorite version of a personification of Death is Terry Pratchett's in the Discworld series. :)
@thomasboyd1402
@thomasboyd1402 3 года назад
In Slavic languages (at least the three I speak) the word is grammatically feminine, but the grim reaper is still a masculine figure..
@Mikeztarp
@Mikeztarp 3 года назад
@@thomasboyd1402 Interesting. So much for my theory!
@toropazzoide
@toropazzoide 3 года назад
Same for italian. "Morte" is feminine. Also, kinda unrelated, but I love her pronunciation of Trionfo della Morte lol
@AntediluvianRomance
@AntediluvianRomance 3 года назад
Bretons also have a male Ankou.
@tomasvrabec1845
@tomasvrabec1845 3 года назад
@@thomasboyd1402 in Slovak and Czech it is grammatically female but it is depicted either way, especially in modern media such as Czech comedies. :d I remember one with an old skinny lady that only played death to scare someone. 😂😂😂 "I suggest you for the death! No n ed for a costume, natural beauty will do" 😂😂 thanks
@alexandriacollins7119
@alexandriacollins7119 3 года назад
Surprised you never referenced Death from Terry Prachett's 'Discworld' franchise.
@philipalmeida4490
@philipalmeida4490 3 года назад
"Death is before me today: like the recovery of a sick man, like going forth into a garden after sickness. Death is before me today: like the odor of myrrh, like sitting under a sail in a good wind. Death is before me today: like the course of a stream; like the return of a man from the war-galley to his house. Death is before me today: like the home that a man longs to see, after years spent as a captive." -The Sandman: Preludes & Nocturne - The Sound of Her Wings
@rachelk4805
@rachelk4805 3 года назад
Oh man 😭🤗
@lycadia
@lycadia 2 года назад
He was quoting Miriam Lichtheim's translation in Ancient Egyptian Literature, Volume 1: The Old and Middle Kingdoms. I believe it is from a fragment of The Book of The Dead original.
@biorph8597
@biorph8597 3 года назад
I love the segment, but I admit I was a little sad that neither Terry Pratchett nor Neil Gaiman's interpretations got mentioned
@S08R01
@S08R01 3 года назад
This personification reminds me of the Indian belief of death talking the form of Yama and his assistants - The Yamadutas (Sanskrit: यमदूत), who wield a whip (made from all the materialistic attachments) instead of the scythe, to pull out the soul of the dead. Yama, quite like the Grim Reaper, is pictured in various advertisements that help spread awareness, such as road safety or in recent times, to protect oneself from the pandemic.
@lunacouer
@lunacouer 3 года назад
Now THIS is something I want to hear more about. Death has been personified all over the world. I'd like to hear more than just the European version.
@helenl3193
@helenl3193 3 года назад
So the whip frees you from your material attachments so your spirit can go in to the afterlife /reincarnation, or something?
@S08R01
@S08R01 3 года назад
@@helenl3193 Yes, the whip is meant to free one's soul from all worldly attachments.
@helenl3193
@helenl3193 3 года назад
@@S08R01 that's a great concept, makes so much sense to me! 😁 Thanks
@rriotghoul
@rriotghoul 3 года назад
Yes!!!!!! The Deathling Queen has joined :D
@masterrafferty4065
@masterrafferty4065 3 года назад
sees scythe: "Is it about the hedge?"
@thexalon
@thexalon 3 года назад
The salmon mousse!
@myragroenewegen5426
@myragroenewegen5426 3 года назад
I'd love a little commentary on how the entire costume of the grim reaper became as fixed as it is. The raggy , full-length hooded robe or cloak garment is pretty fixed now. Does it originate with monks? Older mythological references? regular farm fashion plus deterioration and black for death? Also, with everything else so fixed, it's interesting that death's face goes from skeleton, to white ghost face, to wizened old man(in the tarrot) , and is often hiding beneath the hood entirely, which implies a fair bit about the unknown. It'd be fun to explore the history and meaning creation of that.
@cuppiesaur
@cuppiesaur 3 года назад
As a number one fan of PBS shows and of Cait - this video makes me SO HAPPY ♥
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Yes Death Momma Catlin Doughty & Dr Z together in the same video! 😁😄👍 What an *AWESOME* gift for the 4th of July! 💀
@TheHallow31
@TheHallow31 3 года назад
I'm kinda surprised Grim from the Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy wasn't mentioned. His character is one of the funniest and most entertaining takes on the entity, in my opinion.
@PrestonC3po
@PrestonC3po 3 года назад
The image of despair and dread, the one thing that we cant run from, hide from, the one thing we cant beat, we can maybe push back its arrival, but like the old ones of H.P Lovecrafts mythos, there is no stopping death.
@drrocketman7794
@drrocketman7794 3 года назад
Well said.
@lorysafernandez8666
@lorysafernandez8666 3 года назад
OMG! my 2 favorite channels teamed up for a crossover on Death it self. This fangirl is in Shangri-La, keep doing your mythical and morbid thing you eloquent Queens of Darkness
@aisadal2521
@aisadal2521 3 года назад
Aaahhhh! First I screamed when I saw you were covering the Grim Reaper, and then I screamed again when I saw you had Caitlin Doughty as a guest speaker here! 😍😍😍😍😍😍
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Yes Death Momma Catlin Doughty & Dr Z together in the same video! 😁😄👍 What an *AWESOME* gift for the 4th of July! 💀
@pandapounce
@pandapounce 3 года назад
I know!
@thomasdevine867
@thomasdevine867 3 года назад
Grim also means "masked." As in Isengrim, Iron Mask, the beast fable name for a wolf.
@HellsCowBoy666
@HellsCowBoy666 3 года назад
No mention of Death from Sandman [sad face]
@ladykoiwolfe
@ladykoiwolfe 3 года назад
I love the way Terry Pratchett wrote Death. It was always so personal and relatable. Though I think Susan was my favorite part-time Death.
@ghoultiful
@ghoultiful 3 года назад
Dream team up tbh! Love this
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Yes Death Momma Catlin Doughty & Dr Z together in the same video! 😁😄👍 What an *AWESOME* gift for the 4th of July! 💀
@gregcampwriter
@gregcampwriter 3 года назад
One of the best portrayals is when the Warner Brothers and their Sister Dot meet Death. And Terry Pratchett's Death is the definitive version.
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Sir Terry Pratchett made Death more relatable than any other writer I know of. GNU Sir Terry 😔
@giladpellaeon1691
@giladpellaeon1691 3 года назад
I've read that many terminally ill fans found comfort in Pratchett's portrayal of Death.
@GryphonBrokewing
@GryphonBrokewing 3 года назад
I haven't lost a game of checkers since the beginning of time...I think it was a Tuesday. Not a lot of people know that.
@kouvang522
@kouvang522 3 года назад
Don’t know why, but I want Emily to watch “The Ancient Magus Bride” and give her best theory on what Elias is.
@Eontologist
@Eontologist 3 года назад
YES PLEASE
@BriAngel476
@BriAngel476 3 года назад
a good husband is what he is :)
@MichaelSHartman
@MichaelSHartman 3 года назад
Life? One can not exist without the other. I am not familiar with the story.
@darhaha3391
@darhaha3391 3 года назад
The Chronos vs Kronos thing was amazing to me... 😲 thanks a lot for that.
@Umbra-r4k
@Umbra-r4k 3 года назад
I remember fighting him in dragon's dogma but damn he one hit kills you a lot.
@houselightkell
@houselightkell 3 года назад
Might I ask how many people scream "TATAKAE" around you?
@BawonoSA173
@BawonoSA173 3 года назад
Really? It's instead a fresh memory for me of Dante's Inferno
@kenichiotaku3693
@kenichiotaku3693 3 года назад
If I have my Japanese mythology straight, the Shinto religion also portrays death as a bunch of human-like figures that watch the mortal realm and harvest the lives of people who are about to die and they are called "shinigami" which in Japanese means death god, god/s of death or spirits of death.
@anq4274
@anq4274 3 года назад
My two girls in one vídeo...HOW AWESOME¡
@kingoflife100200
@kingoflife100200 2 года назад
you guys ever herd of the grim adventures of Billy and Mandy?
@mr.midnight23
@mr.midnight23 3 года назад
A crossover...between two of my favorite grim-themed YT channels...sponsored by a site I use almost daily? Awesome
@emv8869
@emv8869 3 года назад
Oh hey it’s my favorite Mortician!!
@lordodysseus
@lordodysseus 3 года назад
I love your shirt.
@ShadowFungus
@ShadowFungus 3 года назад
Without the grimm reaper, our way to the afterlife would be lonely. I’m glad he’s there so we can talk to someone on the otherside.
@llamacado_animates6314
@llamacado_animates6314 3 года назад
I-I’ve waited so long for this… this collaboration… this… changes… everything….
@alexandraburton232
@alexandraburton232 3 года назад
One of my favourite portrayals of Death/Grim Reaper is from the comics by Jenny-Jinya. She raises awareness for a lot of animal issues and Death in her stories is so sweet and you sympathise with him. He just has to do his job but tries to comfort the animals he takes at the same time.
@Ninjaananas
@Ninjaananas 3 года назад
The grim repear is absolutly a cool thing. One of my favorites.
@Son0v4l1ch
@Son0v4l1ch 3 года назад
If you like bayonetta and borderlands then you'll be pleased to play darksiders 2
@Ninjaananas
@Ninjaananas 3 года назад
@@Son0v4l1ch I have played Darksider 2 but have never finished it.
@mythicalcreaturesdoctorsor3589
Grim reaper : 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 England medieval forest death spirit men dark hooded skeleton reaper scythe die people
@MrMman30
@MrMman30 3 года назад
The DMV persona was best presented by the late Terry Pratchett, in his Discworld novels, Death was a bored bureaucrat trying to leave his dull monotonous life and live a more vibrant one, going so far as to adopt a child (a female in a nod to the Grim Mowress alluded to in this video), make friends and have hobbies. This version of death was probably the most endearing to Gen X and Y English language readers, of whom I'm one, since it tried to disarm a malevolent character and show it a more benevolent if not humane light... This obviously ended with Pratchett's career/life and now we are back to the scary hardcore death of past years.🤦‍♂️
@johndemeritt3460
@johndemeritt3460 3 года назад
Death as a DMV persona . . . I don't remember this being brought up in the video, but your mention just reminded me of Paul Simon's song "The Afterlife". Just fill in the form and stand in the line . . . .
@BaldingClamydia
@BaldingClamydia 3 года назад
Seriously! I recently started watching Caitlin and now she's on here! I have to get out of my internet bubble. 😆 all my RU-vidrs crossover in each others' videos
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980
@itwasagoodideaatthetime7980 3 года назад
Yes Death Momma Catlin Doughty & Dr Z together in the same video! 😁😄👍 What an *AWESOME* gift for the 4th of July! 💀
@ScaerieTale
@ScaerieTale 3 года назад
NGL Neil Gaiman's Death is my favorite, but Sir Terry Pratchett's is a close (nearly equal) second 😍 Excellent video as always, Dr Z! I've always wondered when the Grim Reaper started to become synonymous with death (and hwy the scythe). Thank you both
@rossf8616
@rossf8616 3 года назад
The Avengers is the most ambitious crossover event in h....... I stand corrected.
@BrianWalters-ei7sd
@BrianWalters-ei7sd 8 месяцев назад
"Everyone thinks they'll be the one to defeat me, but no one's escaped me yet." Death. Puss in Boots: The Last Wish (2022).
@jeswicas
@jeswicas 3 года назад
Oh my, the collaboration I didn't know I needed! Love it 😊
@hankvine2149
@hankvine2149 3 года назад
I was surprised that there was no mention of the Mexican folk saint Santa Muerte, and the meteoric rise the faith has had both in Mexico and the US...
@izabellahortega2971
@izabellahortega2971 3 года назад
Two Monstrum episodes in two weeks!!! Who-Hoo!!!!!😁😁😁
@Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache
@Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache 3 года назад
*goes through comments* Any deadbeats lurking now?
@driftertravels928
@driftertravels928 3 года назад
The two coolest ladies on RU-vid :)
@markredacted8547
@markredacted8547 3 года назад
This could and should have been so much longer I absolutely loved it, not in a macabre way. I am absolutely fascinated with our (humanities) fear of "The Grim Mower" 😜 I would love to see this cross-over again maybe explaining in detail its earliest depictions and how it evolved and changed through history.
@Bacopa68
@Bacopa68 3 года назад
That "Bowling Death" AIDS PSA is pretty wild. It was used quite effectively in Vincent Ward's The Navigator. And that's a pretty trippy movie too.
@AslamGreyFox
@AslamGreyFox 3 года назад
Ohhh myyy... Be still my beating heart... It skipped a beat when I saw this video... Great combination death and beauty... Caitlin, formaldehyde yesterday and Grim today 😁 ❤️
@plasmaowl5281
@plasmaowl5281 3 года назад
I've been getting increasingly interested in this cryptid series. Don't know if the creators would be interested to look into this, but here's a native Alaskan story I heard of years ago. A girl went outside of her village along with some dogs overnight, and was going to travel at night. One of the dogs suddenly pawed off its skin at the head, and told her she's in danger. To live, she'd have to settle in for the night, to which she agreed to do so. The dog put the skin it tore off back on, and the girl went to sleep. The next morning, she woke up to the group of dogs massacred all about the area, undoubtedly in exchange for her life, though I can't remember if the messenger dog lived or not. I'm sure this version is very inaccurate as it's a story I heard years ago, and I'm sure the story was about a specific area, and not for any theme of safety because I've known many people in those rural areas to travel at night
@Phoenixash-delfuego
@Phoenixash-delfuego 3 года назад
That sounds like a paw story but thinking about how painful it must have been for the skinless dog makes me think it is more likely a poor paw story.
@themadowl9224
@themadowl9224 3 года назад
YES AMAZING COLLAB, Hello there Caitlin!!
@jso6790
@jso6790 3 года назад
As always a wonderful episode, showing us the origins of our ideas and how they connect to the real world. I never knew that the 3 Princes story was so significant artistically. I had heard of it, but the idea of it being the first European personification of animated corpses. Whoever that person was who first drew it.. literally sent ripples throughout the culture of the world. (probably a monk)
@jonasholzer4422
@jonasholzer4422 3 года назад
Omg this crossover with "ask a mortician" is all I ever wanted 😍✨💀🦴
@shockingheaven
@shockingheaven 3 года назад
Someone could make a video about eating cardboard and if Caitlin was in it, I would watch it immediately
@kelsey.targaryen
@kelsey.targaryen 3 года назад
AHHHHH I WAS LITERALLY THINKING THEY SHOULD ASK “ASK A MORTICIAN” I love it!!!
@ericharkleroad7716
@ericharkleroad7716 3 года назад
I subscribe to both RU-vidrs already and never imagined this crossover/colab, but it was great
@fs_000
@fs_000 3 года назад
I like to imagine that Death is actually Caitlin, I'd say that would be a very comforting way to go
@bravomike4734
@bravomike4734 3 года назад
In India as well, people used the personification of Death to depict the dangers of CoViD-19 and to wear a mask. However our death is a bit different. He rides a Water Buffalo and bears a mace instead of a scythe, a warrior's weapon. From wiki:- "Yama, also known as Yamaraj, Kal, and Dharmaraj is the Hindu god of death and justice, responsible for the dispensation of law and punishment of sinners in his abode, Yamaloka. He is often identified with Dharma, the personification of Dharma, though they have different origins and mythologies." Hence, our death is also known as Time (Kal) and upholder of Dharma (cosmic law). Hence he is seen as well as depicted as warrior that fights injustice and sinners. Instead of an indiscriminate farmer or mower of souls. But...that's just religion. The world doesn't feel righteous or just at times. And sometimes, all innocents die. And there is no answer. European personification of an indiscriminate Death might be more accurate given that our Death's personification may have instead been owed to a time full of good Kings and warrior castes ready to protect the victims and the innocent.
@michaelhegwood9977
@michaelhegwood9977 Год назад
"And I don't mean it metaphorically or rhetorically or poetically or theoretically or any other fancy way. I'm Death. Straight. Up"
@marinabarcellos9859
@marinabarcellos9859 3 года назад
Caitlin talking about myths and monsters???? Yes??? One hundred times yes! These 2 have to partner up more often!
@SPQR748
@SPQR748 3 года назад
The association with harvest may come from the scriptures where the chosen are “wheat” and the dammed are “tares” to be separated and burned 🔥
@glambertmonika9220
@glambertmonika9220 3 года назад
I can already tell this'll be a great collab
@DiamandaHagan
@DiamandaHagan 3 года назад
Lightly mindblowing that the term Grim Reaper (in English) is 5 years younger than the fax machine.
@jocelyn5423
@jocelyn5423 3 года назад
This is an amazing collab, I absolutely love this
@patrickperalta59
@patrickperalta59 Год назад
You might be a King or a little Street Sweeper but sooner or later you dance with the Reaper.
@ninjaahjumma
@ninjaahjumma 3 года назад
Quick aside: the pronunciation of Doughty is “dough-dee”, not dow-ty.
@dakunssd
@dakunssd 3 года назад
"Can I ask you a question?" "WHAT?" "How can we all have died at the same time?" ... ... "THE SALMON MOUSSE"
@Manuel-gu9ls
@Manuel-gu9ls 3 года назад
Death is but a passageway to the afterlife don’t look at as an enemy but a friend who’s here to guide you back to its creator for embrace or judgement
@tigressjolie
@tigressjolie 3 года назад
Two of my favorite people in one video?! This is amazing.
@anarchyantz1564
@anarchyantz1564 3 года назад
And now in the 21st century, with Manga and Anime, we have hot, goth "well shaped" ladies in robes, welcoming us Chunnis, hikkomori's, neets and weebs into the warm bosom of death......
@mikakestudios5891
@mikakestudios5891 3 года назад
Cause, why not?
@anarchyantz1564
@anarchyantz1564 3 года назад
@@mikakestudios5891 Exactly! I for one welcome our hot new Death!
@FBIandre123
@FBIandre123 3 года назад
You frogot to mention that the Grim Reaper has a son with a passion for symmetry.
@princekrazie
@princekrazie 3 года назад
Notice how death is a Farmer. Not a Wall Street executive, not a millionaire, not a celebrity, not a stock trader, not a lawyer, not a scheming businessman. A Farmer, the most basic and most necessary of jobs. If you are one of the poor, I would imagine that the Grim Reaper has a lot of sympathy for you, since he himself is a farmer, a peasant even. But if you are one who oppresses the poor, how do you think the Grim Reaper will treat you?
@BaldingClamydia
@BaldingClamydia 3 года назад
Oh I don't know, in most iterations, he seems to be pretty indifferent to most lives taken, only occasionally pitying souls. I do see what you're saying though, and it is probably pretty notable he's a farmer.
@AntediluvianRomance
@AntediluvianRomance 3 года назад
Whatever the crops are, they need to be reaped and collected.
Далее
Jinn: The Ancient Arabian Shapeshifters | Monstrum
10:36
How Gargoyles Became Monsters | Monstrum
11:17
Просмотров 412 тыс.
Трудности СГОРЕВШЕЙ BMW M4!
49:41
Просмотров 1,7 млн
The Origins of Lilith | Adam's First Wife?
18:40
Просмотров 2 млн
Why George Romero Changed Zombies Forever | Monstrum
19:52
The Killer Origins of the Werewolf | Monstrum
25:48
Просмотров 939 тыс.