Тёмный

The Mahabharat Mystery: What Archaeologists Discovered 

TRS Clips
Подписаться 1,8 млн
Просмотров 198 тыс.
50% 1

Watch The Full Episode Here: • Indian Archaeologist S...
Listen To The Full Episode On Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/2lyZ...
🎧 Listen To #TheRanveerShow On Spotify:
open.spotify.com/show/6ZcvVBP...
Follow Disha Ahluwalia's Social Media Handles:-
Instagram: / dishaahluwalia
Twitter: / ahluwaliadisha
✅ Subscribe To Our Other RU-vid Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
BigBrainco. :
/ @raaazofficial
BigBrainco. Shorts :
/ @raaazclips
Bringing you a "History" special episode with Archaeologist Disha Ahluwalia. She is the founder of a page called Confessions of an archaeologist - Link here: / confessions. .
History is a subject that most kids tend to dislike in school, they say it's no point knowing about the past, and they find it to be boring. But, what if I tell you that history has so much to do with the future and even more lessons to be learned for the present. This is one of the most interesting episodes we've created on the show, talking about my favorite subject which is "Historical Facts, Vedic Truths & The Aryan Theory".
In this episode, we speak about archeological truths about the world that are kept hidden from the general public. Only deep researchers, Archaeologists, and historians with enormous research and digging can find out hidden facts and have evidence for the same. This Episode on TRS brings you a mind-blowing conversation of all the findings of India's True History uncovering India's real past.
#archaeology #1795
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.

Опубликовано:

 

30 янв 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 590   
@TheRanveerShowClips
@TheRanveerShowClips Год назад
Link to our blog - beerbiceps.com/indian-archaeologist-shares-vedic-truths-breaks-aryan-theory/
@SJ-zo3lz
@SJ-zo3lz Год назад
Kindly bring in Shri Nilesh Oak, Jeevan Rao and Rupa Bhaty.Their's is the most scientific approach. Nilesh Oak 's work is too accurate to be opposed by any scientifically inclined person. Any independent person could understand that the Mahabharata for sure happened in 5561 BCE.
@shalakajoshi4043
@shalakajoshi4043 11 месяцев назад
Pls read books from P.V. Vartak. Books like Swayambhu, Vaidic kaal ani vedkalnirnay. Its in Marathi. But you would find it interesting. Some of the writer's claim are outrageous but most do warrant further study
@shalakajoshi4043
@shalakajoshi4043 11 месяцев назад
Pls read books from P.V. Vartak. Books like Swayambhu, Vaidic kaal ani vedkalnirnay. Its in Marathi. But you would find it interesting. Some of the writer's claim are outrageous but most do warrant further study
@advaitkamat1940
@advaitkamat1940 Год назад
She mixed up two stories, the 1 year in Virat where they disguised themselves came after the Vanvas, after the Draupadi Vastraharan. They married Draupadi after they escaped Varnavrat.
@pranavanath
@pranavanath Год назад
rightly said
@grapeshott
@grapeshott Год назад
There are several versions of one Mahabharat also. Exact details may not match even from same Vyasa Mahabharat. And I think she has better understanding of epics than you
@advaitkamat1940
@advaitkamat1940 Год назад
@@grapeshott I don't think she does, I think she has a better understanding of archeology than me. I have studied the Mahabharat quite a bit, there is not one instance or one manuscript where the Agyatvas year came immediately after their escape from Varnavat. It was moronic for her to say that, maybe she said it by mistake. For a credible source check out Ami Ganatra, probably the most credible and rational source to get information on both the epics. You gotta do some research before blindly calling someone out.
@shankares388
@shankares388 Год назад
@@advaitkamat1940 people also need to understand that the epic is a complete version which is an mix of archelogy, sociology, anthropology, epigraphy, hoplology etc plus modern addition of history, epigenetics, sculptures etc.. there is so much to explore, learn, understand & appreciate it spiritually rather to weaponize the findings.
@simhadri56
@simhadri56 Год назад
She didn't mention Dwarka under water which is a clear archeological evidence of Mahabharatha and she didn't mention that...
@asifanwar9636
@asifanwar9636 Год назад
🙉🙉🤣🤣🤣🙊🙊🙊👹👺
@ravirajbl1
@ravirajbl1 Год назад
How was karn born?
@rtchhangte5045
@rtchhangte5045 Год назад
i thought they haven't discovered the city yet. Can you give a link to this discovery?
@shubham8264
@shubham8264 Год назад
They have found a submerged city in the gulf of khambhat. But we are not sure that, that city is in fact Dwaraka. And even if it is Dwaraka, it only proves that the city existed and nothing more.
@untitled6391
@untitled6391 Год назад
They haven't found anything lol There is no underwater city
@sadhanadolly
@sadhanadolly Год назад
There should be some experienced person on subjects like this.Sudhanshu Trivedi is very good on our cultural knowledge
@sahilmishra6529
@sahilmishra6529 Год назад
Kuch hote he Apne baap ko baap nahi unka hi Halala hota kitne baap Jan hi nahi pate
@notofyourneed5728
@notofyourneed5728 Год назад
O aunty here conversation is about archaeology and the fact she discovered sudhanshu trivedi is not a archeologist, and she is putting facts
@aksworldinfo
@aksworldinfo Год назад
@@notofyourneed5728 at first learn how to respect your seniors. Be it the person is wrong or may be right.
@grapeshott
@grapeshott Год назад
She has enough field experience. What more experience you want? If you believe in exact historicity of epics, don't come to these channels. If u believe in scientific explanations, then only come.
@pavitraranjanswain4010
@pavitraranjanswain4010 Год назад
So we will have various version of our History. Sudhanshu Trivedi' speech is not for academics or research scholars. Sudhanshu is good for WhatsApp group.
@Ishan.d21
@Ishan.d21 Год назад
You don't dig people... you dig history 😊
@sahilmishra6529
@sahilmishra6529 Год назад
Kuch Suvar hote he Jo Baap ki nahi mante .Angrejo ka Chatte pite he .guru ki na man Atanki ban fatte he .kal..peda huve sanatan ko gyan lutero ko mahan
@sahilmishra6529
@sahilmishra6529 Год назад
Tere jese hi Osama .Ko .man fat jate he Dhrm ki na man
@mihirdighe2488
@mihirdighe2488 Год назад
Absolutely
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
But history today is a battle of narratives between left and right 😅 everyone wants a history they like to hear
@pepewr
@pepewr 4 месяца назад
@@kalebj7001unfortunately history is written by victors
@brandedbihari2202
@brandedbihari2202 Год назад
I think you should also add a screen ..so when they explain about a place or river system ..you should show the map of India ...people would love that
@greywolf9341
@greywolf9341 Год назад
Time and again I've noticed Ranveer interrupting the speaker before they can answer the main question. She was just about to explain Prof Lal's theory on the mahabharata when he interrupts with childish questions.
@SanjuSanju-me2tn
@SanjuSanju-me2tn Год назад
Every show it happens, but he loves it 😂
@youtubestudio2817
@youtubestudio2817 Год назад
I like to think that episodes like this will inspire the young generation to look into such matters and become archealogists that will discover the truth!
@galaxyuniverse7313
@galaxyuniverse7313 Год назад
In Nepal, there are also places linked to mahabharat period. Like keechak badh. It is protected by the govt. and there are some archaeological findings as well.
@shivprasadjoshi5280
@shivprasadjoshi5280 Год назад
Kindly speak with Nilesh Oak and discuss "archaeo-astronomy" readings from Maharabharat and Ramayan. It would be interesting to get more clarity.
@debayanpal6538
@debayanpal6538 Год назад
The crap nilesh oak proposes is truly mind boggling.
@kaamdev810
@kaamdev810 Год назад
@@debayanpal6538 Absolutely...
@SJ-zo3lz
@SJ-zo3lz Год назад
Nilesh Oak 's work is too accurate to be opposed by any scientifically inclined person. Mahabharata for sure happened in 5561 BCE.
@sohamshinde7978
@sohamshinde7978 Год назад
@@SJ-zo3lz no its after 1500
@grapeshott
@grapeshott Год назад
@@sohamshinde7978 Even if it happened in 5000BCE, of course there were no chariots, iron swords, boats, etc at that time. These were all added over thousands of years till Gupta age in 4th century CE
@gyulajakabffy1451
@gyulajakabffy1451 Год назад
Thank you for gifting us a such a wonderful channel
@balamenon4033
@balamenon4033 Год назад
I would like to suggest interviewing K K Muhammed - former Regional Director North of ASI. He is an authority on excavations - especially Ayodhya and he is also proficient in Sanskrit. His wisdom and eloquence are needed on these subjects.
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
His name is enough to trigger right wing fanatics
@vinz8081-2
@vinz8081-2 8 месяцев назад
​@@kalebj7001Atleast he is educated Unlike the rest of Madrasa community
@dr.e-zone642
@dr.e-zone642 Год назад
taking references from mahabharata for initiating the research and then saying we archaeologists are not sitting here to validate beliefs. Then why the hell you are making a belief a basis of your research?? Ranveer you should have interviewed much more experienced archaeologists to avoid this mayhem she created about mahabharata. archaelogists are excavating dwarka out of the ocean and she is saying we are not here to validate belief???
@untitled6391
@untitled6391 Год назад
Nobody is excavating Dwarka lol There is no underwater city
@dr.e-zone642
@dr.e-zone642 Год назад
@@untitled6391 take the opportunity and bless yourself with lil knowledge and Google
@Bharatglory
@Bharatglory Год назад
@@untitled6391 if u want more specific knowledge about Dwarka Excavation then please read the book of Mr. S.R Roa who did the first Marine Archeology excavations.
@untitled6391
@untitled6391 Год назад
@@Bharatglory they had nothing to show for it. A bunch of stones that were not carved or anything and a piece of wood that also wasn't carved. There's literally no evidence.
@spirallydv8
@spirallydv8 Год назад
Agreed. She's not up to date
@kanthu1931
@kanthu1931 Год назад
Mahabharata has connections with entire world. Madri, mother of Nakula and Sahadeva is from Spain or Madra Desha, the capital of Spain is "Madrid" Gandhari, mother of Kauravas is from Afghanistan, capital of Afghanistan is Kandhahar (ka and ga are used as alternate pronunciation) Greeks were called Yavana. Genghis Khan is descendant of Karna, it's Kahn, later turned as Khan, he never invaded India, is probably the 5th generation of Karna.
@gauravpatil9536
@gauravpatil9536 Год назад
Fantasy
@madjack9283
@madjack9283 Год назад
Hm interesting
@gouravdey497
@gouravdey497 Год назад
Please don't say such garbage.
@kanthu1931
@kanthu1931 Год назад
@@gouravdey497 little research and you would agree with me. no need for personal attacks as such. Thanks for understanding.
@gouravdey497
@gouravdey497 Год назад
@@kanthu1931 Don't take it as personal attack.... sorry if it seems little harsh..... Actually I want to say sometimes for this kind of things people laugh on us.
@alakh-niranjan
@alakh-niranjan Год назад
There is nothing like "Mahabharata" It's MAHABHARAT Similarly they were Pandav and Kaurav ..not Pandavas and Kauravas.
@snehajagadeesh1650
@snehajagadeesh1650 Год назад
As you travel to the south of India, in the languages a/am sounds are predominant. Ram is Rama, even Raman, Mahabharat is Mahabharata, Kaurav is Kaurava and Pandav is Pandava. So there is a thing with names ending with 'a'
@AKSHAY6346
@AKSHAY6346 Год назад
It’s sad that we expect them to teach us history who pronounce our words like GANGES , Pandavas etc
@Diavol0Krimson
@Diavol0Krimson Год назад
Its pronounced like that in sanskrit.
@GJALBARR1
@GJALBARR1 3 месяца назад
Great interview based on facts and fiction! No effort to be right or wrong only pointing out the facts of what has been found in the layers of cities in time.
@marinasharma782
@marinasharma782 Год назад
HAR HAR MAHADEV Thankyou Be Blessed
@harshpathak7981
@harshpathak7981 Год назад
Please do the archeological survey on Taj Mahal
@yourdad4670
@yourdad4670 11 месяцев назад
You have to watch Nilesh oak's research...he did fantastic job on ramayan and mahabharat...according to him, mahabharat happened in 5561 BCE.
@debashishpaul8342
@debashishpaul8342 Год назад
Dear Ranveer, May I suggest that you invite only those who are experienced and knowledgeable in their field, and more importantly are excellent speakers (like Mr Rajarshi Nandy). Keep up the good work.
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
Invite an archeologist to discuss Archeology... U won't go to a barber if u want to have a surgery, u go to a surgeon!
@gvijaychandu8720
@gvijaychandu8720 Год назад
We should know that Archeologists don't know every thing.. they are still in the basics... GOD BLESS THEM.
@ajaykumarsharma1573
@ajaykumarsharma1573 7 месяцев назад
She had only worked on painted grey ware and came to conclusion that epics have some sorts of reality . Nice knowledge👍🏻
@Indigo280
@Indigo280 Год назад
Great discussion.
@Koushik6103
@Koushik6103 4 месяца назад
Really good question on Bramhastra, you see it is an astra not a shastra so it means it can only be invoked rather than carrying it around in the quiver.
@gauravpatil9536
@gauravpatil9536 Год назад
Following drushyam movie story, you match time and space, archeologist like fancy name. And you can prove there was vijay salgaonkar was real person.
@shikhersrivastav
@shikhersrivastav Год назад
It needs a lot better mind & an experienced person for this topic! Tonnes of love & support Ranveer ❤🤘🏻
@kalaichelvan
@kalaichelvan Год назад
yeah she's just blabbering not even making a point
@sahilmishra6529
@sahilmishra6529 Год назад
Jehadi .Bhi nahi mante the Pak me fat Rahe he Hindu hi Sains Vale Robot
@grapeshott
@grapeshott Год назад
She has field experience. And these knowledge come after years of study with facts. She is not just an armchair politician/religious leader who speaks whatever comes to their minds or whatever is written in scriptures.
@aazadi_baaki_hai
@aazadi_baaki_hai 3 месяца назад
​@@grapeshott yes😂
@krekar8775
@krekar8775 Год назад
I feel like if it was any other religion with epics like this, more serious research and talks would be there, for context the great Alexander is found nowhere other than in books with no actual evidence in real life, compared to having places with same name, asteroid impact with same location details, etc
@karan.kunwar543
@karan.kunwar543 Год назад
She even doesn't know how to speak and sounds dumb nice of marketing her fake book
@dr.e-zone642
@dr.e-zone642 Год назад
noobri archaeologist.. she will turn the whole archaeologist profession upside down
@Morpheusdarkson
@Morpheusdarkson Год назад
She should start onlyfans. She acts like a feminist but has no knowledge of our history.
@rupallodha8967
@rupallodha8967 Год назад
TRS clips never bores
@Chatterbong-travel
@Chatterbong-travel Год назад
So basically they didn’t find anything yet. Good luck and thanks for shedding light on this topic
@sakshamsharma7929
@sakshamsharma7929 Год назад
please call J Sai deepak next ranveer bhaiya
@BangadBilla..
@BangadBilla.. Год назад
I listen to your amazing shows while going to bed. While listening, my eyes start shutting. But when the video ends, the irritating loud music disturbs the sleep.. pls look after 😊
@tvesarathavrtraghna3688
@tvesarathavrtraghna3688 7 месяцев назад
If you know Sanskrit, you know that the language in which mahabharata is written is panini's Sanskrit. Sage panini contemporary to budhha STANDARDISED this language in which the text mahabharata is written. You guys understand this? Mahabharata cannot predate the language in which its written The text of mahabharata therefore is no longer any older than 500 bce
@simhadri56
@simhadri56 Год назад
K .K .Mohammud the archeologist should be invited on such topics
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
U think the right wing fanatics will keep quiet in the comment section on hearing the name?
@simhadri56
@simhadri56 Год назад
@Kaleb J K.K. Muhammad is a genuine archeologist.. I dnt think right wing will have any trouble.. I think u r not aware.. He is an acclaimed expert and right wingers will acknowledge him irrespective of his religion. He is respected already.. He was on archeological researcher n expert on Ram mandir too.. He was hugely offered bribe to facilitate with left wing but stood his ground in his research findings and even threatened.. I salute this man for his sincerity and integrity..
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
@@simhadri56 bruh his name is Muhammad.. just his name is enough for right wing groups... U know what will happen right?
@simhadri56
@simhadri56 Год назад
@Kaleb J that's the fake narrative politically is sold.. so have you bought..
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
@@simhadri56 well whether it's fake or not will be decided by the voice of the leaders of the right.. be honest you seriously think the right wing mass will react in a positive manner when they hear the name Muhammad coming to explain about Ayodhya.. just be honest!
@aravindsanthosh334
@aravindsanthosh334 Год назад
Ranvir... Kindly see if you can bring in Krishna Udayasankar to this show. She is the author of Aryavarta Chronicles and has authored other works based on mythology.
@vaibhavawasthii
@vaibhavawasthii Год назад
Too qestion the existence of Mahabharata or ramayana is like question your own ancestory.
@manojkumar-xo6ib
@manojkumar-xo6ib Год назад
🤣🤣
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
To question the Greeks about Zeus and Hercules is to question their own ancestry, to question the Norwegian about Thor and Odin is to question their own ancestry.. right?
@vaibhavawasthii
@vaibhavawasthii Год назад
@@kalebj7001 Yea same goes with adam & eve
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
@@vaibhavawasthii yep.. everyone that's in every religious books and cave drawings.. human history is very vast.. tens and thousands of years.. just imagine the number of Gods and goddesses we came up through these time and space..
@vaibhavawasthii
@vaibhavawasthii Год назад
@@kalebj7001 yeah most of human history is lost and fragment
@ttdx6851
@ttdx6851 Год назад
Well noice podcast, I love this type of podcast.
@vikrantdagadkar7352
@vikrantdagadkar7352 Год назад
With due respect please don't bring such young Archeologist on discussion of such topics. Lack of experience is clearly visible. There are some archeological evidences that are discovered and she mentioned nothing of that.
@manojkumar-xo6ib
@manojkumar-xo6ib Год назад
and what is that
@princeaugustine1929
@princeaugustine1929 Год назад
I think she is giving her best answer to the best of her knowledge and ability..
@ReligioCritic
@ReligioCritic Год назад
She did. She mentioned BB Lal who has found evidences.
@yashsonune4391
@yashsonune4391 Год назад
Kuch nahi logo k ego hurt ho jate h
@sheetalsingh9594
@sheetalsingh9594 Год назад
True
@madjack9283
@madjack9283 Год назад
But they should not disregard it completely saying them as just myths.
@rajatchopra1411
@rajatchopra1411 Год назад
4:16 that's so synced!
@anjalishejwalkar3400
@anjalishejwalkar3400 Год назад
And what if we find the tunnel in future? Or what if the tunnel was created in the laksha gruha itself?
@ritantareprises7967
@ritantareprises7967 Год назад
Pandavas were not in Viratnagar after laksha gruha episode, they went to Ekasila
@newmemesfile
@newmemesfile Год назад
Praveenmohan and archeologist should meet
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
Is Praveen mohan an archeologist? If not then what's the point of the discussion?
@kbrv89
@kbrv89 Год назад
@@kalebj7001 why do you care?? Why do you have to reply to everyone's comments here??
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
@@kbrv89 everyone?? I comment for 7 comments... And there are like 430 comments here.. U been reading every comment to spot mine?? 👀 Why do u care to read so many comments to find me
@godbutcher72
@godbutcher72 Год назад
@@kalebj7001 lol true😂
@NaveenSiddareddy
@NaveenSiddareddy 5 месяцев назад
history is only valuable when a story is told well with right amount of masala to make kids intrigued. take Basha movie by Rajinikanth .. thats how we Indians entertain! what exactly happened 1000s of years is not of use but what morales can you get from it by using right storytelling tactics.. tribes in deep Indian jungles are not academics but they know the story of Ramayana and Mahabharatha
@_kunal_ch_
@_kunal_ch_ Год назад
Another episode in Praveen Mohan's presence , people should know both sides of the coin , through an archaeologist's point of view and through point of view of a person who spent his life around temples and decoding carvings and our history . Just my opinion...
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
Academic background is very important my friend... We will not say i wanna hear the opinion of someone who's not a surgeon when we are talking about surgery.. Archeology requires archeologists... Mythology requires mythologists.. two different academic backgrounds
@krishnanath08
@krishnanath08 2 месяца назад
Dr. Sanjay has also explained the same thing and many more archaeologists aslo
@floor4714
@floor4714 Год назад
Its not epic but history
@manojkumar-xo6ib
@manojkumar-xo6ib Год назад
🤣🤣
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
It's history as much Zeus was history to Greeks, Horus was history to Egyptians, Adam is history to Jews, Thor was history to vikings, etc
@kbrv89
@kbrv89 Год назад
@@kalebj7001 and just as much Jesus walking on water!
@illusion8340
@illusion8340 Год назад
Putting forward ancient indian history ( civilization) in foreign language This really 🤕😔
@grapeshott
@grapeshott Год назад
Good scientific explanation to be understood by common people.
@pratikgaikwad8452
@pratikgaikwad8452 6 месяцев назад
Need podcast of Nilesh Oak Sir.....he has done reaserch the dating of the Mahabharata and the Ramayana...
@sushilamalanathans5523
@sushilamalanathans5523 Год назад
Excellent, this discussion was objective without promoting left or right wing views.
@suryaprakashvyas3627
@suryaprakashvyas3627 Год назад
One thing should be noted if settlement at one place is continuous how can you excavate that place. structures and architecture of that place can be modified continuously with time span. The problem of Indian archeologist is, they follow western frame work which is being applied to dead civilization. Western Dristi/frame work is not universal. Archeology is branch to determine existence and age of any settlement at any particular place. But how can it only the way to decide time line of historical events. Archeology is just one tool out of many. Particular civilization demands combinations of different tools. Don't apply western Frame work blindly.
@mr.greengold8236
@mr.greengold8236 Год назад
What's the name of the book?
@staymotivated6591
@staymotivated6591 Год назад
I think you should invite Shudhanshu Trivedi sir on ancient history. She mixed up all those things,she doesn't know anything about Mahabharat.
@abhishekchakraborty6352
@abhishekchakraborty6352 Год назад
Who wants SUDHANSHU TRIVEDI JI on the TRS? I guess we'd get a lot better answers from someone experienced like him.
@ayushthakur173
@ayushthakur173 Год назад
Bro his lvl is just🔥. I don't think he would come in podcasts like these.
@xyz-le5wh
@xyz-le5wh 5 месяцев назад
He isn't archeologist
@penoge
@penoge 18 дней назад
What about the Ramayana, fiction? • What about the similarities of the contemporary circumstances of the time before the great flood, which ended the Tretayuga and simultaniously the Chakshusha Manvantara (!), in the Ramayana and in the 6th chapter of the book of Genesis in the Bible? • What about the similarity between the claim that Rama was an incarnation of Vishnu, who's constellation in the Rigveda is the Orion, and the 6th king of the Old Babylonian Kinglist who's name was "Daonos the shepherd" (he is the only of the ten kings before the flood whom was given an attribute!) which refers to the constellation Orion which is called the shepherd of the Zodiac? • And what about the similarity that the 10th of the kings before the flood who's name was Xiusuthros who was the surviver of the flood according to the Gilgamesh Epic and the Manu Vaivasvata who also survived the flood and according to the Srimad Bhagavatam was king of the Dravidians before he became Manu after the flood? Should all this really should be coincidence? Or Invention? (But there could not be accordance in Inventions).
@deeprajdas9555
@deeprajdas9555 3 месяца назад
Spiderman story was set in Newyork, as Newyork exists so does Spiderman. That's the logic 😂 Archeologists don't deal with approving beliefs but we people always try to connect all in our mind to validate our beliefs.
@ghsdkj
@ghsdkj Год назад
Gotta dig deeper
@eraiyanbu4200
@eraiyanbu4200 Год назад
We know what ASI did in keezhadi while they unearthed a settlement dating back 600 BCE. They buried it literally, which caused a massive uproar and the 600 BCE was within 6 m deep what will we can find when we go deep. I think she is a part of clan that despise aryan invasion theory.
@ziamthamel
@ziamthamel Год назад
Give respect to young archeologist... One day she became master in her field like Dr Meenakshi great historian
@longerodds5077
@longerodds5077 Год назад
Problem with today's youth - They think they know everything. They are in a hurry to show off their 'knowledge''. The host sarcastically asking about nuclear weapons was disgusting
@karthi7016
@karthi7016 Год назад
Indians just assume that the people back then from the mahabaratha looked like present day Indians.... Humans are always moving, mixing, conquering, etc... An eg. Is USA in 500 yrs one rarely sees the indigenous people any more.... What would happened Over 5000 yrs
@MandarJoshi
@MandarJoshi Год назад
Archeaology is clearly one branch of estimating the time. Another way is looking at astronomy as described in ancient texts. Stalwarts like Lokmanya Tilak have used this approach.
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
Ur confusing science with pseudoscience here... It's Astrology not astronomy.
@tanukumanohar2621
@tanukumanohar2621 3 месяца назад
Guys.. i have seen in comments in that people already debating/arguing about her knowledge etc ... First if our epics like Ramayan/Mahabharat etc who were written by great sages to that microlevel of details of exact location which she accepted that we still call them with same names.. then cant she accept that there might be great powerful weapons/mantras flying chariots, people flying and forming into gigantic shapes at will was not true? Because probably they would have not have found it yet.... Usually science and religion doesnt go hand in hand.. today they couldnt found it and she doesnt believe it.. 300 yrs down the line probably someone would come up with proofs of these weapons etc and then at that time whether people buy that or not is something we cant predict now.. coz things change... so people who believe in these epics continue to do so and who believe in science they will anyway ignore epics..
@gagandeeparora7715
@gagandeeparora7715 Год назад
Its vaarnavart not vrnavrat
@viraj5053
@viraj5053 Год назад
I would want a person who can actually explain what happened in Mahabharat very precisely... Like one special podcast dedicated to Mahabharata please !
@Spyron_
@Spyron_ 11 месяцев назад
Then need to do tapasya and Summon Vyasa himself. He can tell you. Our belief system is on one side and our in human experience is on other side in the respective field. She mentioned her deduction as per her work. Thats just add one more perspective to look at the world. Sometime we seek validation against our belief a bit in depth.
@hashtag9990
@hashtag9990 8 месяцев назад
@@Spyron_ will you take on the task? I can fund your tapasya if needed.
@Spyron_
@Spyron_ 8 месяцев назад
No thank you, i dont intend to proof something someone myself, its just perspective from different angles@@hashtag9990
@ravichandel8690
@ravichandel8690 3 месяца назад
if harappan urban starts and mahabharat war is starting then why there is not tangable proof of war not even a single weapon found till date.
@vaibhavawasthii
@vaibhavawasthii Год назад
Hmm
@adityamarathe1801
@adityamarathe1801 Год назад
This is by far the dumbest discussion I have heard on this channel. Please invite Nilesh Oak if you need factual discussions on archaeology. This conversation feels like two primary school students discussing their history textbook. There's a whole city drowned under the Arabian sea, and yet people call the Mahabharat as "Epic". So did the fiction book writter also construct an underwater city?
@ayushthakur173
@ayushthakur173 Год назад
Idk why after study something for some years, people start to believing themselves as the supreme intellectual of that field. If u doesn't know it doesn't mean that it was not happened. Everthing is not funny by calling it as fiction or Epic!!
@sunilm6463
@sunilm6463 Год назад
Totally, dumbest discussion so far on this channel
@____________TB1827o0o
@____________TB1827o0o Год назад
It's ok. For people who have just entered into these topics it will be easy to understand. Then eventually they will elevate.
@Jagannath38103
@Jagannath38103 Год назад
Same bro Nilesh oak 🔥🔥
@Vor567tez
@Vor567tez Год назад
For god sake give some respect to her. She is archeologist, has done and seen more than any of us. She didn't got the knowledge just by sitting on mobile. Beside Archeology doesn't work like that. With Astronomy you hv to match up other evidences too. If it was that easy archeologist would hv happily declared every epic and event real.
@manohars6997
@manohars6997 Год назад
That war is the reason why we are in this state, there is no fiction
@deeprajdas9555
@deeprajdas9555 3 месяца назад
How did she know Hastinapur said in Epics used to called Hastinapur back those days? Harappan language we are not able to decode yet. Sanskrit was not language that time.
@mukundranjan11
@mukundranjan11 Год назад
Call two people on your podcast. Nilesh Nilkanth Oak and Birendra K Jha
@culturemania178
@culturemania178 Год назад
I hope she wouldn't be ban for saying these things about mahabharat
@amgstarlord
@amgstarlord Год назад
We humans will never see beyond the 3rd dimension.
@sreeharsh6466
@sreeharsh6466 Месяц назад
This channel is the best example of the Dunning-Kruger effect
@abhineetjn
@abhineetjn Год назад
Over 1000's years geography change dramatically...
@RishiRajMusa
@RishiRajMusa 3 месяца назад
well it's expecting that you won't find a thousands of years old mud cave, it might have been destroyed by rain or earthquakes.
@Sameer-wy7cy
@Sameer-wy7cy Год назад
Bro.dwarka have been found.30 years ago my grandma visited dwarka nd said thr is dwarka under sea.i made a joke of her thinking its all story..u cnt mahabharath era sites on mailnlad bec thy are buried deep beneath cities nd large villages now.archeologists speak only whe thy have proof .bt this lady even left out dwarka
@bhumika1839
@bhumika1839 Год назад
Want a podcast of ajanta elora caves
@sudeepchajed5762
@sudeepchajed5762 Год назад
Please Bring Sudhanshu Trivedi
@yugpanchal7809
@yugpanchal7809 Год назад
yes im also a panchal and i believe that my great great great grandfathers were pandavas which is truth my grand parents also tells about our great great great grandfathers
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
My grandfather told us we all came out from Africa tens and thousands of years ago.. maybe he was wrong then 🤔
@yugpanchal7809
@yugpanchal7809 Год назад
@@kalebj7001 no it's not true u didn't came from Africa u came from india
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
@@yugpanchal7809 not me... I'm saying our ancestors who's DNA we all carry... Where did our ancestors come from say 60,000 years ago?
@yugpanchal7809
@yugpanchal7809 Год назад
@@kalebj7001then your grandfather was being propagated
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
@@yugpanchal7809 propagated on what?
@mihirsanghvi9876
@mihirsanghvi9876 Год назад
10:10 it's wrong info bro They didn't go to Virat after all the lakshagrah shit and stuff but they insted stayed in the forest and eventually won dhrupadi and stuff. They went to Virat for the 1 year of agyatvas(hidding in plain sight)
@ThevijuAtDaeDge
@ThevijuAtDaeDge Год назад
She mixed two events into a one. Think how many things this archeologist do mix up to prove their findings.
@ashutoshmahapatra4071
@ashutoshmahapatra4071 Год назад
Interested why kurukshetra which should have skeletons of those warriors of those era, any thoughts?
@nirupamateghbahadur1705
@nirupamateghbahadur1705 Год назад
There is.
@RahulKumar-ul3ne
@RahulKumar-ul3ne Год назад
After the war, warriors/horses/their carts were burned as per our culture. So, very little chance you'd find any skeleton in that area.
@Vor567tez
@Vor567tez Год назад
That's great question.
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
Ever wondered why there were no skeletons for the Trojan war ? Stories make it intersting, now imagine a story over thousand years...
@kbrv89
@kbrv89 Год назад
@@kalebj7001You are so hellbent on proving the epic a mythology is hilarious! You don't even have the balls make these comments from your original ID! 😂
@manbirdadwal9864
@manbirdadwal9864 5 месяцев назад
I thought that Saraswati Vedic culture preceeded Harappan culture by many millennia
@geraldj9963
@geraldj9963 Год назад
I give it 28,000bc. Her writings has to be in line with the "theory of modern man" or it will be labeled as mythology, or fiction.
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
U give it? Who are u? Mr. Indiana Jones the super archeologist?
@kbrv89
@kbrv89 Год назад
@@kalebj7001 why do you care?? Why does he have to explain it you?? Are you a super archeologist yourself?
@sujithsuresh5822
@sujithsuresh5822 Год назад
This is what happens when you taught your students, that harappa and mohenjo daro are just water drainage systems
@experimentnation3612
@experimentnation3612 Год назад
Call someone like Nilesh Oak he is an expert on Mahabharata and it’s time frame
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
This topic was on Archeology.. if it was on mythology surely he'll call him
@experimentnation3612
@experimentnation3612 Год назад
@@kalebj7001 this podcast seems to be talking about the dating of Mahabharata. Nilesh Oak is one of the experts on that subject
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
@@experimentnation3612 does he use Archeology to date Mahabharat?
@kanthu1931
@kanthu1931 Год назад
Hastinapur is near meerut...thanks for the user with name gamerzone, corrected my comment
@Ridhima_Soman
@Ridhima_Soman Год назад
Ull said umm at the same time 😎 Anyways loved the podcast 🥰🥰
@77RahulTiwari
@77RahulTiwari Год назад
Please get KK Mohammad Sir for such topics 🙏🙏
@rajhanssarjepatil5666
@rajhanssarjepatil5666 Год назад
Ranveer if you really want to know the actual date of Ramayan and Mahabharat happened then you must take an interview of Mr. Nilesh Oak. Because according to Niesh Sir Ramayan happened before 15000 years and Mahabharat before 7500 years.
@saipraba8775
@saipraba8775 Год назад
That's very interesting. Thank you for sharing this information. Bhagavan Sri Sathya Sai Baba once said that Ramayana was about 20 thousand years ago and Mahabharata was 10 thousand years ago. I don't know if this time period is based on Vedic calendar or English calendar. I guess it must be based on the Vedic calendar time frame.
@rajhanssarjepatil5666
@rajhanssarjepatil5666 Год назад
@@saipraba8775 Mr.Nilesh Sir's research is based on position of stars described in Ramayan and Mahabharat at the time of any particular incident .For e.g. according to Mr. Nilesh Oak the Mahabharat war happened in year 5525 B.C.E.
@saipraba8775
@saipraba8775 Год назад
@Rajhans Sarjepatil I see. Thanks for sharing this information.
@kaamdev810
@kaamdev810 Год назад
@@saipraba8775 even Sai Baba could be wrong.. if indeed he provided such dates.. the battles on which the whole story of the Mahabharata is based did not happen 3500 years ago ...
@saipraba8775
@saipraba8775 Год назад
@@kaamdev810 How did you got 3500 years ago? I guess the date which Sathya Sai Baba provided are base on Vedic Calendar time frame. So we need to calculate 10 years of Vedic calendar and compare that with Gregorian Calendar. Maybe we might get some answers.
@goldysharma8151
@goldysharma8151 Год назад
I think Purana Quila in Delhi is again being excavated to check PGW.
@s.2697
@s.2697 Год назад
She is pretty and have good voice nothing else😅
@user-cv3ew
@user-cv3ew Год назад
You can say time & place not space.
@penoge
@penoge 18 дней назад
As far as I know the scriptures they were even looking at the wrong place for Kurukshetra.
@amitchhabra999
@amitchhabra999 Год назад
The current facts according to Archeology are 1.Aria is a province of Iran and previously included parts of India. 2. The greatest and noblest Arian king was Cyrus ('Kuru' in local language) 3. The Indus Valley script has no similarities with Sanskrit but can be related to Brahmi/old Tamil 4. Old Iranian language Avestan is extremely similar to Sanskrit Questions remain: 1. What happened to the Indus Valley civilization? 2. What was the language spoken in Indus Valley and why did it disappear? 3. When/Where did the Vedic Sanskrit civilization begin?
@sushilamalanathans5523
@sushilamalanathans5523 Год назад
There are good mix of German propaganda added to the Aryan story as well, Any propaganda will have lot of exaggeration. Most times, archaeologist and histories work with one find or one text, it is tough to draw any substantial conclusion based on such findings.
@SanjuSanju-me2tn
@SanjuSanju-me2tn Год назад
I think you mixed up script and language s
@niteshchandwani1809
@niteshchandwani1809 Год назад
yes many old scripture we find are in brahmi script but about indus valley i want to give you some info that the construction of indus valley city is mentioned in one of our scripture called i think brahmn samhita in that scripture it is written to how to made a perfect city and that is exactly how indus look like and i have many proof too that people live in indus valley definetly follow our culture and about which language they speak see language can vary like me i am a sindhi i speak sindhi but i am a hindu too thats how it varries and indus was not the only civilzation in india at that time
@utkarshraut7536
@utkarshraut7536 Год назад
Since Yadava period there are two scripts to write Marathi, Modi and Devanagari Modi was chosen by Maratha Military because it's faster way to write Same possibility with Bramhmi also. So just by script one cannot make conclusion that there are different races one using Modi and other using Devnagari. Similarly I am from Nag clan but Kshatriy at same time
@porismitaborah2703
@porismitaborah2703 Год назад
Pandavs didn't went to virat nagar after the lakshagriha incident , they went to virat nagar during the last year of there 13 years of banbaas after they lost in the dice game. Plz don't give false information if you don't know it .
@rushikeshkalwade9375
@rushikeshkalwade9375 Год назад
Please upload this video In hindi
@mitalimithun3
@mitalimithun3 Год назад
I am not convinced this lady has enough knowledge about the topic of Mahabharata.
@kalebj7001
@kalebj7001 Год назад
She's an archeologist not a mythologist
@kdjoshi726
@kdjoshi726 Год назад
Mhmm... another crazy theory: What if Mahabharat was actually some kinda pre/old world war? We just know that there was a massive war between let's just say technically advanced humans or either god-like beings. We can sorta connect this to world war too right?
Далее
Smart Sigma Kid #funny #sigma #comedy
00:19
Просмотров 7 млн
13 Карт - Клоны в супе | 3 серия
11:12
King Ravana's SECRETS Revealed
10:46
Просмотров 126 тыс.
Smart Sigma Kid #funny #sigma #comedy
00:19
Просмотров 7 млн