Тёмный

The Massive Molniya Satellites - How The Soviet Union Solved Satellite Communications Their Own Way. 

Scott Manley
Подписаться 1,7 млн
Просмотров 443 тыс.
50% 1

Part 4 of a series on communications satellites. The Soviet Union had a big advantage in launch vehicle capability, but, while the US had adapted the Delta to launch small satellites into Geostationary orbits the R7 which had carried spacecraft to the Moon and Venus was not capable of doing the equivalent without significant redesign. Instead, the Soviet Union's scientists came up with their own solution which had some advantages for covering the massive territory of the USSR.
The Molniya satellites would be in a highly eccentric orbit that spent about 6 hours per day over the USSR, this orbit was easier to reach and this let them launch spacecraft 40 times the mass of the American satellites. but as communications platforms they were no more capable.
Most of this information comes from Boris Chertok's Memoir - Rockets and People, specifically volume 3 "Hot Days Of The Cold War" - NASA has translated this and I highly recommend it.
www.nasa.gov/history/history-...
Follow me on Twitter for more updates:
/ djsnm
I have a discord server where I regularly turn up:
/ discord
If you really like what I do you can support me directly through Patreon
/ scottmanley

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

22 окт 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 712   
@inhuman4
@inhuman4 7 месяцев назад
That poor technician with the tape. All the hard worked and money wasted because you did a quick fix with some tape. That must have been a rough week at the office.
@nathanaelvetters2684
@nathanaelvetters2684 7 месяцев назад
He probably fell out of a window shortly afterwards in a tragic accident.
@GuntherRommel
@GuntherRommel 7 месяцев назад
​@@nathanaelvetters2684and landed on 36 bullets
@CptJistuce
@CptJistuce 7 месяцев назад
​@@nathanaelvetters2684That's a modern thing. The old KGB just disappeared you.
@SMGJohn
@SMGJohn 7 месяцев назад
​@@nathanaelvetters2684 Putin was not in power then
@StringerNews1
@StringerNews1 7 месяцев назад
In America, you're fired. In Soviet Union you're fired from cannon.
@MarkDahmke
@MarkDahmke 7 месяцев назад
Hi Scott, thanks for the video about the Molniya satellites. I built a receiver & tracking system using an 8 ft dish (1987 to 1991). They also broadcast Radio Moscow on a subcarrier. One day in 1991 I tuned in and heard Rod Stewart and realized that things really were changing in Russia. My article about how to track Molniya satellites was in the August 1989 issue of Circuit Cellar Ink magazine.
@smeeself
@smeeself 7 месяцев назад
Very cool. 😎
@georgejenkins8063
@georgejenkins8063 7 месяцев назад
Cool.... way cool. !!
@Ben-eo5vd
@Ben-eo5vd 7 месяцев назад
Very cool mate!
@MorzakEV
@MorzakEV 7 месяцев назад
Awesome. Thanks for sharing.
@dfgdfg_
@dfgdfg_ 7 месяцев назад
Primary source evidence
@VideoFlyer10
@VideoFlyer10 12 дней назад
In the late '70s I went to a broadcast satellite (TVRO) convention in San Jose, CA, mainly for those wanting to get into home satellite systems. This was when everything on satellite was broadcast in the clear (no encryption). I had brought my Tektronix 465 to work on a project with a friend. We got into a conversation with a group that had a dish on site that they decided to try to pick up Molniya. They succeeded, and I was told that the audio was in the horizontal sync area, rather than a subcarrier, so I got my scope, and found the audio, and we slapped together a simple circuit to demodulate the audio, and listened to Molniya auido until the satellite went below the horrizon. Definitely a fun weekend.
@MontegaB
@MontegaB 7 месяцев назад
I love that they had to start the first satellite like a 59' chevy with a bad starter solenoid
@DavidOfWhitehills
@DavidOfWhitehills 7 месяцев назад
Yeah, it must of been the start of the "Have you tried switching it off and on again?" helpline protocol. Bill Gates was watching and learning from the Soviet Union, who'd a thunkit?
@DamirAsanov
@DamirAsanov 7 месяцев назад
@@DavidOfWhitehills ...it must HAVE been...
@putinslittlehacker4793
@putinslittlehacker4793 7 месяцев назад
Yea exsept they didn't have a hammer and a 2x4 to hit it with
@DavidOfWhitehills
@DavidOfWhitehills 7 месяцев назад
@@DamirAsanov And yet you have no problem with "thunkit"? Language changes: it is ours to do with as we wish. Like music. Slang. Rap. Patois. Punchuation.
@battleoid2411
@battleoid2411 7 месяцев назад
​@@DamirAsanovgo back to your basement
@SVanHutten
@SVanHutten 7 месяцев назад
-What is Scott´s today´s video about? -The Molniya -Is it a launch system, a spacecraft or an orbit? -Yes
@mc_cpu
@mc_cpu 7 месяцев назад
I thought it was Thor`s hammer!
@scottmanley
@scottmanley 7 месяцев назад
@@mc_cpu same etymology root
@Chuckiele
@Chuckiele 7 месяцев назад
yeah, both mean lightning.
@KnightRanger38
@KnightRanger38 7 месяцев назад
One thing that has interested me is that Soviet launch vehicles in the R-7 family often took on the name of one of the early payloads that used that variant.
@zapfanzapfan
@zapfanzapfan 7 месяцев назад
@@scottmanley Oh, didn't know that connection. "Blixt" is Swedish for lightning, "Mjölner", which is the hammer, is pretty close to "mjölnare" meaning miller. "Mjöl" is Swedish for flour.
@newq
@newq 7 месяцев назад
All those hundreds of Molniya launches are why one of the most common "satellites" you can see flying overhead anywhere on Earth are spent Russian rocket bodies in polar orbits. You will know these by the fact that they're always traveling directly north/South and they tend to slowly fluctuate in brightness as they tumble. You're pretty much guaranteed to see them on any summer evening after twilight.
@wally7856
@wally7856 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for the tip, just threw away my compass. Obsolete now.
@cambridgemart2075
@cambridgemart2075 6 месяцев назад
I spotted one back in the spring which turned out to be a 1974 rocket body. When I saw it it was brighter than any star for a few seconds. It was travelling almost due south to due north.
@user-oo6si5jf8t
@user-oo6si5jf8t 13 дней назад
You haven't spotted the thousands of cube sats that have been launched recently? I'd say they're a much more common sighting for me.
@Rob2
@Rob2 7 месяцев назад
Another interesting property of those satellites was that they actually had a sealed capsule with an atmosphere inside them, where the electronics were located. So some of the problems of having electronics in a vacuum (like no convection cooling possible and problems with outgassing of some components) were avoided, of course at the expense of a huge mass increase.
@KarolOfGutovo
@KarolOfGutovo 7 месяцев назад
due to the lack of relative acceleration, the cooling against the internal atmosphere wouldn't really be convective since that relies on hot air rising (which it only does because cold air displaces it due to buyouancy which is a thing cuz gravity), it'd be only conductive.
@mshepard2264
@mshepard2264 7 месяцев назад
@@KarolOfGutovo yea but if there was a fan in there it would still be convection
@johnpublic6582
@johnpublic6582 7 месяцев назад
@@mshepard2264 The fan makes it not convection. The fan makes it circulation.
@johnwang9914
@johnwang9914 7 месяцев назад
Although simply binding the electronics to an aluminum plate could transport the heat to a radiative panel. Although it is true that our modern consumer electronics are designed to be air cooled, that isn't entirely true, there are plenty of electronics that are water cooled, oil cooled, alcohol cooled and or cooled by an aluminum plate. Simply bathing the electronics in something like mineral oil which would be a liquid would be more effective than a pressurized air environment as liquids are considered incompressible and hence less vulnerable to pressure changes and would carry a lot more heat than air could. Though it would be possible to have the electronics in a pressurized air container, that is hardly necessary nor would it be the most effective solution especially as we even have water and oil cooled electronics in our consumer market.
@stusue9733
@stusue9733 7 месяцев назад
@@johnwang9914 Wouldn't oil have the same convection issue as air? Also weight is a thing, I assume they did the maths.
@arctic_haze
@arctic_haze 7 месяцев назад
Sting, the singer, was shown a Molnia receiving station on an American university by a friend and watched some Russian cartoons (it was Saturday evening in the US and Sunday morning in Russia). This was the inspiration for his song "Russians with the refrain "Believe me when I say to you / I hope the Russians love their children too".
@Itoyokofan
@Itoyokofan 7 месяцев назад
It always amazes me how braindead brainwashed the westerners were about the SU to even consider that Russians DON'T love their children.
@mattbartley2843
@mattbartley2843 7 месяцев назад
Our amateur radio station in college (northern California) had a satellite dish antenna which tracked the succession of Molniya satellites and patched at least some channels into the campus cable TV system. I don't remember how the cable TV system dealt with SECAM vs NTSC video formats. We had multi-format TVs to watch it directly if we wanted. I only vaguely remember seeing morning exercise shows. We also had a dish antenna we could manually aim at geostationary satellites, and a smaller microwave antenna we could aim at mountain tops, both of which we of course used to watch bootleg movies from any unscrambled systems we found.
@joedellinger9437
@joedellinger9437 7 месяцев назад
@@mattbartley2843”Rhythmic gymnastics by the sea”, that woman they had doing the exercises on the show was insanely flexible. Taught me to count to 4 in Russian. :-)
@MostlyPennyCat
@MostlyPennyCat Месяц назад
Sorry Sting, it seems the Russians do not... 😢
@Qsderto
@Qsderto 2 дня назад
@@MostlyPennyCat You seem to read a lot of nonsense at night.
@jeromethiel4323
@jeromethiel4323 7 месяцев назад
The Soviets were never short on ideas, or even expertise to pull those ideas off. The Soviet government just didn't have the money to spend. Or would not spend it. For as much as NASA has it's hands tied by politicians, the US managed to get a lot of stuff done. And most (if not all) of it was stuff the Soviets could have pulled off, had they had the money. Much respect to the engineers and scientists behind the iron curtain who did what they could with what they had. Very capable people.
@Valsorayu
@Valsorayu 7 месяцев назад
The difference between a super power that had to rebuild after the war, and a super power that profited from the war.
@SMGJohn
@SMGJohn 7 месяцев назад
There were no money in USSR like in capitalism. Every state enterprise and bureau had something called a credit budget. This budget was not money because money has to circulate whereas this credit was an artificial limitation on what these enterprises could buy in terms of what they needed. Instead, the Soviet Union may have been vast but its resources were not infinite and the Soviet Union had an industry twice the size of the entire West, its not easy to distribute resources in such a large industry. The military and the space industry had priority on everything, the space industry however was secondary to the military. The USSR lost 27 million people during WW2, this fear had built into their psych and thats why they were on such a large military build up. Because they feared another war.
@kleinerprinz99
@kleinerprinz99 7 месяцев назад
Bureaucrats personal luxury and military budget was more important than anything else.
@extragoogleaccount6061
@extragoogleaccount6061 7 месяцев назад
Eh…they expanded their “empire” quite a bit by/at the end of the war. So they weren’t completely crushed economically or at a loss of resources. But also they were way more hamstrung by their economic woes in the 80s and towards the fall.
@iandonnelly6684
@iandonnelly6684 7 месяцев назад
​@@SMGJohnthey feared US/Western agression and bugeted heavily towards defence. Its wild to think were we could have been if the US hadent been such a huge dick lol
@spencerburke
@spencerburke 7 месяцев назад
Молния / Molniya = "Lightning" if anyone wanted to know.
@Keenath
@Keenath 7 месяцев назад
Hang on, is Molniya cognate with Mjolnir?
@spencerburke
@spencerburke 7 месяцев назад
@@Keenath I'm not sure, but it probably is. As far as I remember, it's distantly connected to the word for hammer, молоток / molotok i.e. mallet. So, hammer of Thor connection makes a lot of sense.
@spencerburke
@spencerburke 7 месяцев назад
Incidentally, the Soviet Minister of Foreign Affairs, Molotov (he of cocktail fame) chose this nom de guerre as it has a nice industrial communist association. Hammers again.
@Lowkeh
@Lowkeh 7 месяцев назад
Now, I haven't looked it up myself, but Scott Manley replied in another comment*, saying: "same etymology root". Thanks for the extra insight/interesting tidbit about molotok and Molotov, btw! __ * If I'm to be overly specific (for no reason): said reply can be found within the comment thread that reads: "What is Scott's today's video about? -The Molniya -Is it a launch system, a spacecraft or an orbit? -Yes" ... kinda wish we could link comments on this platform
@alexhajnal107
@alexhajnal107 7 месяцев назад
@@Lowkeh You can. Just right-click on the comments "posted" time and copy the link address. There's a pretty good chance though that if you try including the link in a comment then the comment will immediately be deleted as being "spam". (It's not just including links, just today I had a comment get deleted just for parenthetically recommending someone's channel.)
@kl0wnkiller912
@kl0wnkiller912 7 месяцев назад
I was in SATCOM in the US Army in the mid-1980s. We used the TWT amplifiers to transmit. They were cooled by pure water and laboratory pure (99.6%) Ethylene Glycol (antifreeze). Even with a continuous flow of liquid around the pass tube it still glowed cherry red on the outside so I can imagine what all that heat was doing to that equipment...
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt 7 месяцев назад
So mount these outside! Surely tubes have no problem with vacuum.
@nickfirst7249
@nickfirst7249 7 месяцев назад
​@@ArneChristianRosenfeldtvacuum is not thermally conductive, therefore only mode of thermal transfer in vacuum is radiation.
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt
@ArneChristianRosenfeldt 7 месяцев назад
@@nickfirst7249 they glow cherry read. Nothing stops you from cooling the base (socket) using water.
@cambridgemart2075
@cambridgemart2075 6 месяцев назад
I've worked with many satellite communication HPAs up to around 7.5kW and they have all been air cooled. It would have to be a huge power output to require liquid cooling.
@kl0wnkiller912
@kl0wnkiller912 6 месяцев назад
Well this was 1983-85 The amplifier that we used was the standard HPA used by all branches of the service then on their large, fixed station antennas. I cannot remember the exact numbers but it was capable of 15KW transmit power singular or 25KW combined if memory serves. We had two units for redundancy but could run them in combined mode if the enemy was trying to jam us. Remember, back then this system was intended to be used in a combat environment so it was quite powerful. One thing I never could figure out though... if they were jamming us and we were running full power, what would happen if the enemy were to just drop their jamming? I would think it would blow the LNAs in the satellite pretty quickly. No one could ever give me a good answer. One time I remember we held an 8 ft florescent lamp up in front of the antenna and it actually glowed... We were only running about 15 watts then too... Have to be pretty nasty running full power. @@cambridgemart2075
@jimdawdy6254
@jimdawdy6254 7 месяцев назад
A lot of amateur radio satellites used the Molniya orbit. It worked very well, since amateurs could have a satellite that would stay up in the sky over a certain position for hours at a time and then go back to another position over a different part of the sky for hours at a time allowing amateurs all over the world to share the satellites to make contact.
@isbestlizard
@isbestlizard 7 месяцев назад
Amateur radio enthusiasts financed and launched a constellation of Molniya-orbit satellits? Tell me more
@x-ray-oh3134
@x-ray-oh3134 7 месяцев назад
I wouldn't describe any satellite as "amateur"
@dougtaylor7724
@dougtaylor7724 7 месяцев назад
I had a QSO with a ham in Florida. He was a satellite guy from way back. He said in the 60,a you could talk a long time on the sats. Now it’s minutes. With the help of your post and this video I understand what he was talking about. Many thanks!
@snorttroll4379
@snorttroll4379 3 месяца назад
its only like 50 bucks to send one up to geostationary and like 20 to low earth orbit. what are you talking about?@@x-ray-oh3134
@joakimlindblom8256
@joakimlindblom8256 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for a great video series on communication satellites, and particularly appreciate your explanation of the unique Molniya orbit! I did internships for Ford Aerospace (later renamed SSL) while in college in the 1979 and 1980 and worked on the first 3 Intelsat V satellites, so com sats are near and dear to me (lots of memorable stories from that time, not the least of which was when I had inadvertently changed the software constants for the flight-ready F-2 spacecraft while it was undergoing final testing in their large vacuum chamber, causing the senior managers to get woken up at 3 am due to telemetry readings being way off... all was well once they figured out what had caused the problem, but it's a miracle that as a lowly intern I wasn't fired on the spot 😲)
@Ben-eo5vd
@Ben-eo5vd 7 месяцев назад
Great story, thanks for sharing!
@mshepard2264
@mshepard2264 7 месяцев назад
the soviet space hardware always looked cool and characteristically soviet. I think it must be the symmetrical pressure vessels.
@i-love-space390
@i-love-space390 7 месяцев назад
GREAT explanation of the Molniya orbits. Wikipedia is not nearly so cogent and easy to understand. Plus you always make talk about the Russian achievements so interesting. I am constantly amazed at how brilliantly people used mathematics to achieve exact solutions to problems before computer power got so strong as to make simply modeling the behavior and observing the solution a possibility. That period after Newton and Leibnitz where they exploited Calculus to solve so many problems is such an amazing period. Clearly, the Soviets had very smart mathematicians to make up for their primitive computers. I guess we also had a lot of advantages with our better miniaturization and those hydroLOX upper stages.
@vikkimcdonough6153
@vikkimcdonough6153 7 месяцев назад
1:50 - "Strategic Rocket Forces" is the most awesome name for a military branch ever. (It also makes much more sense than lumping in satellites and ballistic missiles with the Air Force like the U.S. did for the longest time.)
@fallinginthed33p
@fallinginthed33p 7 месяцев назад
Space Force sounds rather pedestrian.
@juhasznagyjozsef
@juhasznagyjozsef Месяц назад
Their motto also slaps. "After us, silence."
@brianarbenz1329
@brianarbenz1329 7 месяцев назад
Great video, Scott. Well presented, with suspense about whether they’d ever get a successful deployment. You not only have vast technical knowledge, you also tell a story well.
@joedellinger9437
@joedellinger9437 7 месяцев назад
At Stanford in the 1980’s a student figured out how to receive signals from the satellite over Siberia and it was piped into the campus wide cable TV system. At our research group it became the habit to all go buy a snack at “The Store” in the student union then race back to the office to watch “good night kids” on Russian TV at midnight local time. As the politics changed we had a front row seat. We watched “spotlight on Perestroika”. The funniest thing was when they had the first ever live call-in program. There was some government person they could ask live questions of. But every caller’s question was “this can’t really be live, I don’t believe it”. The host eventually got angry and held his watch up to the camera. It is LIVE, this is the ACTUAL TIME, does anyone have a REAL QUESTION?!
@richb313
@richb313 7 месяцев назад
Thanks Scott for explaining the developement and deployment of early Soviet communications satelites.
@paleo_astro
@paleo_astro 7 месяцев назад
Love learning about all these older satellites! Great video!
@_herince
@_herince 7 месяцев назад
We started with a masters program in aerospace engineering one week ago and one of the first things that were mentioned in orbital dynamics was Molniya. So it was really exciting to see you post a video about it just a few days after the lecture. I saw the youtube notification a few hours ago and watched it with great interest as soon as I got home. Thanks! 💙
@tarmaque
@tarmaque 7 месяцев назад
As a suggestion, I think a video explaining the Van Allen radiation belts themselves would be helpful. Not everyone knows.
@scottmanley
@scottmanley 7 месяцев назад
I have one already
@TracyNorrell
@TracyNorrell 7 месяцев назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-h9YN50xXFJY.html
@zebo-the-fat
@zebo-the-fat 7 месяцев назад
This one I think ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-h9YN50xXFJY.html
@wolpumba4099
@wolpumba4099 7 месяцев назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-h9YN50xXFJY.html
@jblob5764
@jblob5764 7 месяцев назад
His video on the belts -> ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-h9YN50xXFJY.htmlsi=oyTAGGXH-8Ey_9Jp
@kangirigungi
@kangirigungi 7 месяцев назад
It's amazing how quickly the space program moved back then.
@MikeOxlong-
@MikeOxlong- 7 месяцев назад
Big ole fat bureaucracy had to go get itself in the way during the latter nasa years… 😂 Obviously in the past decade it’s picked back up quite a bit - especially in the US and Chyna.
@Xaito
@Xaito 7 месяцев назад
They were replacing those satellites at the pace of smartphone life cycles.
@Cosmic_Fyre
@Cosmic_Fyre 7 месяцев назад
They launched 164 of those monsters, Van Allen belts really do wreck havoc huh
@Rob2
@Rob2 7 месяцев назад
They never really were concerned about wasting resources, it seems. More than 1900 Soyuz rockets were launched with different, mostly military, payloads.
@padders1068
@padders1068 7 месяцев назад
Scott, great video as ever! Thanks for sharing, educating and entertaining!
@cpm1003
@cpm1003 7 месяцев назад
Another awesome history lesson. Thanks Scott!
@ryann6919
@ryann6919 7 месяцев назад
Another great video scott! Love this series!
@Davefromcanada411
@Davefromcanada411 7 месяцев назад
I am loving this series giving me a view of a history I had not really heard of before!
@hagerty1952
@hagerty1952 7 месяцев назад
This whole story is a perfect example of the Soviet space program development methodology. Ground testing actually seems to have hurt them on this project! I have no doubt that, if allowed to continue, the N1 program would have succeeded, probably with the next launch (which was on the pad undergoing fueling tests when Glusko cancelled it). The USAF launched a similar system to Molniya in the late '70s. It was called "Bent Pipe" and was used for communications between their tracking station in Thule, Greenland, code named "POGO", and the Satellite Test Center (which was, despite the name, actually the command center) in California. It had two vehicles in 24 hour orbits so that at least one of them was visible to both stations at all times.
@olasek7972
@olasek7972 7 месяцев назад
I very much doubt N1 would have been successful at any point and definitely not on the next launch, it never lasted even through the complete first stage burn
@hagerty1952
@hagerty1952 7 месяцев назад
@@olasek7972 - That underscores my point. The fourth flight, N1-L7, got within 15 seconds of successful staging. The first stage was the only really experimental piece of the stack. The stages above were much more "normal" in terms of engine count and arrangement. The 4th stage, the "Block D", not only worked, but has been used for nearly 60 years as a "space tug" at the top of the Proton booster and other vehicles. The main problem with the first stage was the engines. In the first four flights these were the development NK-15 engines, with lots of teething problems. In the N1-8L (the one sitting on the pad I mentioned above) these had been replaced with the production version NK-33, a design that is still being used today as the Aerojet AJ-26 used on the Atlas V.
@filanfyretracker
@filanfyretracker 7 месяцев назад
@@hagerty1952 one understanding I have is that they had no way to ship completed stages, the USA could ship completed Saturn V stages and had stands to test them. The important factor is basically the US was capable of testing things like a full stage with all its engines and then send it to KSC as a completed unit(first stages for Saturn of course went by barge).
@hagerty1952
@hagerty1952 7 месяцев назад
@@filanfyretracker- You are basically correct. They had both highways and railroads from central Russia, where the pieces were made, to the launch site in Kazakhstan. These were limited, though, in how large the components could be for transport. The largest building at Launch Complex 110 was the assembly building where the entire N1 stacks were built horizontally. This, as you mentioned, meant that full-up ground testing could not be performed, so they did their best and tested full vehicles from the start. This has always been their way, and the R7 (the ICBM that is still used today as the Soyuz launch vehicle) took nearly 20 development flights before they got a fully successful flight. The N1 had 12 test vehicles scheduled in its development program, but it was cancelled after 4.
@TriplePistol
@TriplePistol 7 месяцев назад
Molniya was my favorite Sattelite when i was 5 because of it's fan shapped outlook and I forgot its name till now and now i have a reason to like it.
@StuartWoodwardJP
@StuartWoodwardJP 7 месяцев назад
I remembered it from the cool shape too. I must have been about the same age.
@johnwang9914
@johnwang9914 7 месяцев назад
Speaking of communication satellites, one of the professors at my engineering school told us a story of when he was a junior on the Telstar satellite though this might also just have been an urban legend instead of a personal account. The project was compartmentalized so few knew the whole design and each team was to build a module to certain specifications that would survive the acceleration of launch and the harsh environment of outer space. There was one module that they were having a lot of problems with that was to design a filter with a linear phase response and no one could design one that would survive the acceleration of launch. They finally contracted a reknown engineer who only agreed if they would not open the module to see how it worked. He came back with a module that met all the specifications and survived both launch and the expected harsh environments of space. As juniors, they were very interested in how it all worked so they secretly opened the module and it was aluminum foil crumpled till it had the right magnitude and phase response of the desired filter.
@bradnail99
@bradnail99 7 месяцев назад
That’s a great story! Clever with the crumpled foil.
@cambridgemart2075
@cambridgemart2075 6 месяцев назад
Sounds like an urban myth to me, RF filters are precision devices requiring a lot of fine tuning.
@johnwang9914
@johnwang9914 6 месяцев назад
@@cambridgemart2075 Except I did a paper in engineering on physical signal processors that even used physical acoustic properties to achieve a linear phase response in a filter. Crumpling aluminum foil is a valid way to achieve magnitude and phase responses that can't easily be achieved with electronics alone. As to precision, it's bestoke, you crumple till you get the right response so it's really more precise and accurate than you are assuming, it's just not readily mass reproduced without again more custom crumpling. The difficulty in mass production is also why we design filters with capacitors whenever possible and not inductors as inductors have high variability, we use inductors in the lab because we can measure hundreds till we find the right one but we can't measure hundreds for each production unit. To a certain extent, crumpling aluminum foil is adjusting it's inductive values manually. The analog world is a lot more varied than you imagined. Just because it looks cheesy to you doesn't mean it isn't precise, it's still just what it is and if that happens to be precisely what's needed then it's precise. You could say that crumpling aluminum foil is fine tuning.
@cambridgemart2075
@cambridgemart2075 6 месяцев назад
@@johnwang9914 You are conflating acoustic filters with RF filters, they are completely unrelated devices.
@johnwang9914
@johnwang9914 6 месяцев назад
@@cambridgemart2075 Sigh, and you don't even realize that crumpling aluminum is fine tuning. The acoustic piezo electric signal processor was a paper I wrote in engineering and shows that some magnitude phase responses are difficult to achieve through electronics alone and yet can be obtained by material properties and morphology. What do you think makes crumpled aluminum do anything at all as a filter but material properties and morphology. You are specifically tuning the crumpled aluminum morphology by tuning it. Crumpled aluminum is the epitomy of a manually tuned filter so your whole argument that it's just urban legend just because filters need to be precisely tuned us false. Also as I say we engineers intentionally try to design filters with capacitors as capacitors can be precisely manufactured while inductors have high variability in mass production shows we try to design filters that do not need manual tuning. Everything about your premise is simply false and shows you have no education in analog signal filters.
@davidboyle1902
@davidboyle1902 6 месяцев назад
It’s amazing what need and country-to-country competition can do to foster creativity. Let the military find use for a new innovation and sky’s the limit. A wonderfully detailed presentation, Scott. Learned a lot here. Keep doin’ what you’re doin’…
@alexanderzelenkov6944
@alexanderzelenkov6944 День назад
Hi Scott, Hello from Russia and thank you for the video! I read Chertock memories about 20 years ago too. A great insight to Russian space program heydays. Such a open and sincerely book without mouth-playing. Recommend to everyone tech gigs.
@NateMansfield
@NateMansfield 7 месяцев назад
You’re doing a great job with this series.
@jarlesagheim9710
@jarlesagheim9710 7 месяцев назад
This series where you talk about old communication satellites, was really interesting and cool.
@Ben-eo5vd
@Ben-eo5vd 7 месяцев назад
This is a great series, thank you!
@ted356
@ted356 7 месяцев назад
Good video, Scott! Well researched and presented.
@fullsenderman8291
@fullsenderman8291 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for all your hard work scott
@RicheBright
@RicheBright 7 месяцев назад
Great stuff! I didn't know about the use of highly eccentric orbits. Thank you.
@georgejenkins8063
@georgejenkins8063 7 месяцев назад
Scott, while visiting the Smithsonian, I looked into the window of one of the Soviet manned spacecraft... it's control panels had like about 40 simple toggle switches where as the American manned spacecraft had like 4000 switches of very high quality. The thing that really got me was that the Soviet space craft were the same switches I bought from Radio Shack for like $2.00 apiece... very high tech...!! Thanks as always Scott,...Sir !!
@georgejenkins8063
@georgejenkins8063 7 месяцев назад
What I'm saying... yet not very well is that the Soviet sourced their switches From Radio Shack during the 1970-1980s... fyi... lol
@rwboa22
@rwboa22 7 месяцев назад
Soviet and Russian manned spacecraft until 2000 (when the Soyuz TMA was first launched) used the GLOBUS navigation system, which was in essence a mechanical computer not much different than the Norden bombsight used by USAAF bomber crews during WW2. Only the Mercury capsule used a mechanical sequencer operated by a clock (thus the astronaut's calling out, "The clock is operating," as that was the main clock; a backup clock was also added for redundancy along with a watch strapped on the astronaut's wrist); all subsequent spacecraft starting with Gemini used an onboard computer with the Apollo Guidance System being the most well-known of these electronic computers.
@georgejenkins8063
@georgejenkins8063 7 месяцев назад
Yes, and as I understand it the Soyuz got a huge up to its controls in 2015. With this 'huge' up grade to it flight control system... when they Finally got a Digital computer... in 2015... What I saw of the Soyuz when I visited the Smithsonian in 1983... I wouldn't let them roll me 10 feet across the floor... how did Cosmonauts achieve orbit with 1940s tech ?? Not Mr Sir...!! Thanks Scott and all !!
@olcraigsen
@olcraigsen 7 месяцев назад
​@@georgejenkins8063 oh if we only had radio shack now
@uploadJ
@uploadJ 7 месяцев назад
The Mercury capsule "switches" looked rather basic too, back in their day. The Pate Museum of Transportation used to have on on display here in Texas.
@MCsCreations
@MCsCreations 7 месяцев назад
The human creativity is indeed fascinating! Thanks, Scott! 😊 Stay safe there with your family! 🖖😊
@DadofScience
@DadofScience 7 месяцев назад
That was very interesting, Scott. Cheers.
@mytube001
@mytube001 7 месяцев назад
13:57 Crazy that Brezhnev was a pallbearer!
@bksnider157
@bksnider157 7 месяцев назад
As always Thanks Scott
@scottwheeler2494
@scottwheeler2494 7 месяцев назад
As an aside, the first three satellites launched for the space based Sirius radio network used this orbit. It was thought this would give better reception versus the typical geostationary orbits. XM solved the issue by building hundreds of ground repeaters fed by the satellite. This made building their recievers with a built in method to deal with the delay necessary. It's way too complicated to explain here but it's pretty brilliant in its own right. The signal for both joined service is sent thru the XM satellites today.
@chaz720
@chaz720 7 месяцев назад
Sirius/XM used a related orbit called a Tundra orbit, not a Molniya orbit.
@steveschu
@steveschu 7 месяцев назад
Today it still sounds thin and low bandwidth.
@scottwheeler2494
@scottwheeler2494 7 месяцев назад
@@steveschu if you knew how beaten and abused those bits were you would be amazed it sounds as good as it does.
@ccudmore
@ccudmore 7 месяцев назад
So this is how 3-CP-1 took over SCTV! The guest from the Minsk Bus and Truck Works was informative.
@Allan_aka_RocKITEman
@Allan_aka_RocKITEman 7 месяцев назад
Great video, Scott...👍
@gregknipe8772
@gregknipe8772 7 месяцев назад
as the non scientist in this room, I thank you for your work and learning opportunities. thank you Scott.
@markrix
@markrix 7 месяцев назад
This is an awesome topic!!! Thx!
@baksatibi
@baksatibi 7 месяцев назад
12:35 The anniversary of the Great October Socialist Revolution was on November 7 according to the Gregorian calendar.
@carldori6172
@carldori6172 7 месяцев назад
That was an interesting insight into the Soviet era usage of space . Thanks and Best Regards
@GeneralZap
@GeneralZap 4 дня назад
If your taking an intermission while playing this, 'spin' up ''At Dawn', By Alliance, a Soviet era Synth and you will not be disappointed at such an esoteric music piece.
@JVAlexis
@JVAlexis 7 месяцев назад
Fascinating video! Little question, what KSP like game was used for the launch recreation?
@gregorycoogle7621
@gregorycoogle7621 7 месяцев назад
Scott, Thank you and keep looking up! 😉👍
@seabound1350
@seabound1350 7 месяцев назад
Thank you, very interesting 🙏👍🏻
@grummbe
@grummbe 7 месяцев назад
In the 1950 film DESTINATION MOON a flight to the Moon almost fails because a guy puts grease on an antenna not realizing it will freeze in space.
@TheHorzabora
@TheHorzabora 7 месяцев назад
I truly would love some sort of sci-fi setting that explored a future where the Soviet Technocratic utopia was successful. Sure, it wouldn’t sell in the US, but it would be really interesting as a cool and dynamic future :-)
@tenhendee5479
@tenhendee5479 7 месяцев назад
Just try to read some books from Stanislaw Lem. Not his philosophical books, but storys about Pilot Pirx, Ion Tichy etc. There can you find among eatch other, generations of inteligent robots - from steam driven to "modern" with vacuum tube build brains ... , atom reactor driven starships, etc. Read it just as they are, without political background. Hi is Polish , one of the most known scifi writers worldwide. "Solaris" is the commercialy most known book. I think here will you find some kind of what you are looking for, a kind of raw industrial sci fi. VERY fascinating. Cheers.
@1DE101
@1DE101 6 месяцев назад
Have a look at “Atomic Heart” by Mundfish. It’s not about future itself, but it is retrofuturistic game in soviet style. Strongly recommend to check it out. My parents, born in early 60s in USSR, confirmed, that it has truly “that” vibe. Especially in the beginning. P.S.: Also, looks like the canonical ending is a shorter one. You’ll get it after passing the game.
@marcwolf60
@marcwolf60 Месяц назад
For All Mankind series. Russia got to the moon first and the space race continued through the ages.
@river_salmon
@river_salmon 8 дней назад
​@@marcwolf60biased crap with space KGB eager to execute each and every one. Nothing to share with the Soviet union. Check out Ivan Efremov or Stanislaw Lem, maybe even Alexei Tolstoy if you're into retro 30s' aesthetics
@cerulean999
@cerulean999 7 месяцев назад
Scott- I was in the USAF Security Service in the late Sixties stationed on the north coast of Turkey at Samsun. Interesting memories you've evoked. Congrats on that PPL you got. I just gave up on renewing my medical certificate any more times, though I still fly by taking a PIC along. I'm 76. -Harv
@scottmanley
@scottmanley 7 месяцев назад
Have you tried Basic Med? You just get a regular doctor do do a physical and you can fly small planes with that plus a driver’s license
@mikeissweet
@mikeissweet 7 месяцев назад
Yes! Keep it going!
@brussels13207
@brussels13207 7 месяцев назад
I worked for GE during the period when we supplied bits for the space program, semiconductors and relays. If I remember correctly, GE was at least partially responsible for developing the methods for “testing “ components in such a way that they achieved VERY high reliability. What these methods were are too complicated to describe in a comment, but would make for an interesting video. Every time you test something, you “wear it out” a little bit, so how do you test without wearing it out? Not a simple question.
@deus_ex_machina_
@deus_ex_machina_ 7 месяцев назад
Through the magic of buying two of them?
@stevejohnson6593
@stevejohnson6593 7 месяцев назад
​@@deus_ex_machina_then whichever one you test was used, is the point. Don't know the answer though.
@robertomartin8731
@robertomartin8731 7 месяцев назад
MTBF
@creounity
@creounity 6 месяцев назад
Hello from Russia, Scott, and thank you for this video!
@frankgulla2335
@frankgulla2335 7 месяцев назад
What a great piece of reporting on the Soviet TV satellite network.
@thek3743
@thek3743 7 месяцев назад
Very interesting, thanx!
@JoshuaC923
@JoshuaC923 7 месяцев назад
Thanks Scott!
@Laserblade
@Laserblade 7 месяцев назад
I understood the idea of communications satellites was first presented by Arthur C. Clark. Thanks for the video!
@AdrianMidgley
@AdrianMidgley 7 месяцев назад
As presented it required 3 equatorial geostationary satellite relays. So the Soviets came up with an idea that was better for their situation.
@Lion_McLionhead
@Lion_McLionhead 7 месяцев назад
A much more strategically important orbit than the orbits overview video implied.
@pirazel7858
@pirazel7858 7 месяцев назад
An episode about the European Projects Astra vs TV-SAT would be interesting. How the TV standard D2-MAC failed but gave birth to the SCART connector
@Fred-yq3fs
@Fred-yq3fs 7 месяцев назад
Doing the calculations of Molniya orbit stability is pretty satisfying when you study orbital mechanics. Taking into account he oblateness of earth and doing first order series calculations of the orbital elements, you get to prove that wdot (evolution of the argument of perigee) is proportional to 4-5sin^2(i) where i is the orbital incline. i =63.4 degrees is a solution. So the argument of perigee is constant. The orbit semi axis and eccentricity is made so the time spent at apogee is long enough for convenience and to have the orbital period = a sideral day. That way, the ascending node position -omega- stays a the same place relative to the ground. But given the Earth's oblateness again, omega dot (evolution of omega) is not 0 with this inclination and eccentricity, so the period of the orbit has to be changed from time to time to maintain omega (i.e. the apogee position relative to the ground). So Molniya have to regularly expand fuel for that purpose.
@ariochiv
@ariochiv 7 месяцев назад
"Horizon"... cool name for a communications satellite.
@deusexaethera
@deusexaethera 7 месяцев назад
Imagine being that engineer who wrapped up the scuffed wires with PVC tape, thinking you were being helpful, only to find out you completely screwed the satellite once it got into orbit. I'm sure he had a long and productive career breaking rocks for the glory of the Motherland after that.
@neves5083
@neves5083 7 месяцев назад
Our man is using Simplerockets 2, thank you for playing the game :)
@ghostblackout1
@ghostblackout1 7 месяцев назад
Great video
@gabbyn978
@gabbyn978 7 месяцев назад
Now I understand why Ken Schaffer, an inventor at the University of Columbia, could pick up the soviet TV program with his self built satellite receiver. One day someone came to visit him, saw what the Russians had as their children's program, and was deeply impressed by the care that was put in the creation of these animations. So he wrote a song about it, and called it 'Russians'. The author was Sting.
@dustysidepanel3075
@dustysidepanel3075 7 месяцев назад
i just went through an entire dmt trip during this video. your commentary kept me grounded. im typing this as the dmt finally fades off. thank you sir
@davidachorn931
@davidachorn931 7 месяцев назад
Man, I love that Saturn V and launch tower. Great backdrop.
@daredaemon8878
@daredaemon8878 7 месяцев назад
Small correction, Re: PAL. It's a European Standard developed in West Germany, while yes the UK saying it the way you did is a bit like implying Canada invented NTSC.
@celtspeaksgoth7251
@celtspeaksgoth7251 7 месяцев назад
But more nations around the world would adopt PAL as the Brits had it
@therealjamespickering
@therealjamespickering 7 месяцев назад
He said Britain had PAL, he didn't say they invented it.
@CptJistuce
@CptJistuce 7 месяцев назад
The USSR actually adopted SECAM to prevent people in their border states from watching european TV. France was far enough from the border that they didn't care. Just as a side note.
@royschering1140
@royschering1140 7 месяцев назад
I believe the first three Sirius Radiosat satellites used a similar scheme to extend their time over the US. They had 24 hour orbits that had an apogee that was about twice their perigee. They were launched from Russia in 2000. Later, after Sirius merged with XM, I believe they shifted to geosynchronous satellite locations.
@user-cd4bx6uq1y
@user-cd4bx6uq1y 7 месяцев назад
Very cool
@LiamDennehy
@LiamDennehy 12 дней назад
@13:50 That's actually quite beautiful. Wow.
@spushkin1
@spushkin1 7 месяцев назад
This is SO uncanny. I was reading about orbits and satellites literally a few weeks ago and stumbled upon the article on Wikipedia about Molniya orbits. I thought it was really cool. It seemed like a really niche topic, It’s somewhat crazy to me that I stumble upon this video in my recommendations a week or two later. Molniya in Russian means lightning.
@Sniperboy5551
@Sniperboy5551 7 месяцев назад
I remember learning about Molniya orbits back in high school in my aerospace engineering class. I always thought it was a really cool concept, some real out of the box thinking. I think the Cold War (and Space Race) was a boon for technological innovation. Think about just how many discoveries we would have missed out on if not for Cold War paranoia!
@bbbenj
@bbbenj 7 месяцев назад
Thank you 👍
@akretschmann6384
@akretschmann6384 7 месяцев назад
Yeah thank you for your vid
@harfenspieler
@harfenspieler 7 месяцев назад
The Soviet Union only had 11 time zones because they split them in 30 minute chunks, which apparently worked better with the railway system. In "western" time zones, it would be fewer. Russia is large (for the moment), but the Mercator projection maps can be very deceiving. Thank you for using better projection models here.
@artemplatov1982
@artemplatov1982 4 месяца назад
Russia will only get larger, keep coping
@MykePagan
@MykePagan 7 месяцев назад
…that one burned down, fell over, then sank into the swamp. But the seventh castle… errr, satellite stood and it’s the strongest satellite in the land
@Chuckiele
@Chuckiele 7 месяцев назад
How did they calculate this ideal orbit? Was there enough information about the oblateness of the earth available at the time?
@scottmanley
@scottmanley 7 месяцев назад
It turns out that the ideal inclination is independent of oblateness.
@joellamoureux7914
@joellamoureux7914 7 месяцев назад
Fascinating stuff. I just wish there were more pictures. I guess that stuff is really hard to find. I'm almost at the end and maybe I missed what eventually has happened to all of these.
@markooklop
@markooklop 7 месяцев назад
For the third one engineers were like - "Have you tried turning it on and on again?"
@fagocitotico
@fagocitotico 7 месяцев назад
Great as always
@Major.Tom.1973
@Major.Tom.1973 7 месяцев назад
Wow if I were just finishing school today I'd go for a career in Orbital Mechanics ! Very interesting 👍
@oasntet
@oasntet 7 месяцев назад
As a side topic: how did later satellites survive the Van Allen belts longer?
@GeomancerHT
@GeomancerHT 7 месяцев назад
Better component shielding.
@oasntet
@oasntet 7 месяцев назад
@@GeomancerHT Given that it was the solar panels that failed first, it's clearly a more complicated topic. You can't line a solar panel with lead.
@stainlesssteelfox1
@stainlesssteelfox1 7 месяцев назад
Radiation hardened components as well. Of course now, it's tending more towards fault tolerant components instead.
@jk-video2716
@jk-video2716 7 месяцев назад
Mostly satellites avoid the VA belts.
@stevenversace2720
@stevenversace2720 7 месяцев назад
thanks scott
@sawyer4763
@sawyer4763 7 месяцев назад
I've been watching your channel for a long time, thank you for all of the stuff you do. I have to ask though... what's with the magnet on your shirt?
@scottmanley
@scottmanley 7 месяцев назад
Holds the microphone in place
@nagjrcjasonbower
@nagjrcjasonbower 7 месяцев назад
Long time sub and YTer here…. Love your channel! Keep up the awesomesauce! Just a suggestion… Lower your studio camera angle a bit… You are looking shorter with each new video! 🤣🤓🖖👍
@jamesgauselman265
@jamesgauselman265 7 месяцев назад
Scott, I don't believe you addressed why the USSR needed to launch satellites so much larger than the US's. And the relationship of both nation's satellites to their boosters.
@arctic_haze
@arctic_haze 7 месяцев назад
Also why were the Russian ones so ugly.
@dlueck1296
@dlueck1296 7 месяцев назад
The Soviet Union was generally behind in electronics and computer technology. If I remember correctly they also didn't develop computers that worked in a vacuum but rather put them in a pressurised container which adds mass
@mattmichael2441
@mattmichael2441 7 месяцев назад
@@dlueck1296would have made sense to note that in the video. Seems like important context.
@MollyGermek
@MollyGermek 7 месяцев назад
He did address it. They didn't need to get to geostationary orbit as it wasn't particularly useful at covering the Soviet Union, nor did they have the vehicle for it. Their easier, more useful orbit for their conditions simply allowed more mass so they used it.
@jpdemer5
@jpdemer5 7 месяцев назад
To function at apogee, these satellites had to have big antennae and hefty power systems.
@StuartWoodwardJP
@StuartWoodwardJP 7 месяцев назад
I remember seeing pictures of these in “Race Into Space” PG-Tips collectable cards in the 1970s.
@jankarolczak9668
@jankarolczak9668 7 месяцев назад
Thanx for video, others just do: finnaly happening faa relise date to SpaceX seccond lounch " ant then nothing happening. You find many different topics, thanx again, you rock.
@MichaelBrodie68
@MichaelBrodie68 7 месяцев назад
It's a rarely known fact that the first Russian satellite was a metalic object that looked like an umbrella. Ludmilla Sarevenova stood on the roof of the multiple storey People's 23rd Administration Congress Building, stretching the extended device out as Nikolai Bulganin and Khrushchev yelled directions at her to point it in slightly different directions for better reception.
@Vulkanlandsternwarte
@Vulkanlandsternwarte 5 месяцев назад
I got a creepy encounter with the Molniya satellites. I was photographing the Pinwheel galaxy with 1 minutes exposures. On a couple of the pictures where a short strick. What was it? Normally satellites tracks on an image goes through the whole picture as a line. Because they are traveling so fast. Geostationary satellits are a point. So was it a minor planet in near earth? No, it turns out to be a Molniya satellite. Thanks for this video!
@jsallen1946
@jsallen1946 7 месяцев назад
I am a graduate of Middlebury College, in Vermont, which is well-known for its language programs. There was a Molniya satellite dish behind the Sunderland Language Center at Middlebury College in the 1970s. I don't know details of who made it or paid for it. Other academic institutions probably had Molniya dishes; the US Government surely had them.
Далее
The Dumbest Mistakes In Space Exploration
16:16
Просмотров 1,6 млн
Rose Burrito #shorts
00:35
Просмотров 6 млн
Whyyy? 😭 #shorts by Leisi_family
00:15
Просмотров 2,9 млн
Why Nuclear Rockets Are Going To Change Spaceflight
22:03
The Insane Engineering of the F-117 Nighthawk
27:37
Просмотров 1,5 млн
What Is A Black Start Of The Power Grid?
17:06
Просмотров 2,1 млн
German Field Marshal Beaten With His Own Baton!
19:48
Просмотров 301 тыс.
APPLE совершила РЕВОЛЮЦИЮ!
0:39
Просмотров 989 тыс.
Купил этот ваш VR.
37:21
Просмотров 231 тыс.
✅ЛУЧШИЕ фишки iOS 18🔥
0:51
Просмотров 110 тыс.
Ноутбук без экрана
0:22
Просмотров 16 тыс.