The Most ACCURATE Violin Movie Acting!??? 

She trained 2 months just to get approved by TwoSetViolin

Sounds like Ling Ling was trying to possess her but the Wi Fi signal was spotty.

"You don't change bow hold half way through a concert." You seem to underestimate younger me trying to fix her bow hold

Me: Wow, the way she's holding that bow looks good and realistic. Twoset: That's a weird bow hold. Me: The way she's holding that bow is WEIRD.

She actually spent 6 months practicing 3 times a week with a french violinist. But sometimes the left hand we see on screen is not her !

For those of you who don't know, the movie's called The Concert

When she stares at the conductor, it is a cinematic choice. It creates a team between the conductor and the violonist. Small details like this changes the viewer's perception of the story and shows them the personality of the character. It makes the story feel bigger than life.

Please allow me a comment that doesn't directly have something to do with this particular video: As a retired musician (first trumpet player, then bass trombone player, mostly in orchestras) I REALLY appreciated your professional comments about violin playing, and music making. It shows you have a great love and appreciation of the art as well as an understanding about how it's done. And of course your quick demonstrations show, you have the expertise to back up your talk. Plus your humor is golden. Keep up the great work!

Every actors and actress should watch twoset before they act their musical movies or drama 🙏thankful for all these likes and replies MOM I’M FAMOUS

TwoSet needs to be hired as producers and supervisors for any violin movie that’s made

Woman: trains 6 months to be accurate TwoSetViolin: *I S E E Y O U H A V E C H O S E N D E A T H*

“You also dont really keep looking at the conductor while you play” 😂😂😂

A violin playing actress that gets Twoset’s applause 👏👏👏👏

At least they still got a musician who knows the importance of PRACTICING, kudos to her for that 2 months worth of practicing!

She probably had to go through that scene twenty-five times, and every time it was different. She may have gotten tired, and just wanted it to be over. And the amazing thing is that she was close enough for the CGI to correct it. Imagine playing guitar, or even piano, and not knowing how, but having to make it look real...

The actress was trained by my good friend, the violinist Sarah nemtanu 🎻

Take 96! Dang it why can't we get this intro right?!

She is half a Ling Ling. The right hand belongs to her, left hand belongs to Ling Ling. You can call it left hand or... Ling hand

When I first watched this movie (a few years ago) I was very impressed with her violin acting actually, so I went and did research, and I remember that she was coached by a violinist really well. But she doesn't play violin! So, really impressive amount of work. She said she really tried to mimic what her violin coach did when playing the actual concerto. I find it pretty fascinating how well she captured it. I agree, pretty amazing amount of work to get this, (even with the small parts that were off, hats off to the actress and the coach :) ) Its a good movie also :)

I like how the more realistic the movie is about orchestra, they get serious is nitpicking xD

I was the coach for the two cellists in “Le Concert”. The big bearded cellist from the orchestra was very funny when I tried to teach him the moves and shifts on cello but he couldn’t remember so well. The other guy (the rich bald one) he managed to learn to play all the parts like a first grader. He wasn’t supposed to make “sounds” on cello because the soundtrack was to be added afterwards. But he told me he wanted to learn to play the parts in the hope that the film director choose his playing instead of the audio recording. Sadly, the film director added the prerecorded sound to his playing. I was present the day they filmed the scene you presented. 70% of the orchestra was a real symphony orchestra from Romania. The “ concert maestro” was a virtuoso gypsy violinist. The scene is filmed on the stage of the Romanian Opera from Bucharest between 18:00 and 4:00 the next morning. I had to coach the two actors for almost a month prior to the filmed scenes. It was a nice experience. 2 SET, thank you for the memories!

that movie used actual orchestra slightly diluted with actors. My friend, cellist, played in it (not an actor)

they might have told her to stay still to make the vfx easier

Mélanie Laurent is one of those french actresses completly underrated. There's a few movies out there (gems really) in which people make sure the tiniest detail is legit. You go Mélanie !

“It’s 1,2, and 4” *shows 5 fingers* 😂 relatable

So Brett, when are you dropping your recording of the Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto?

Actress: Actually legit violin player TwoSet: Ummmm, well...she came in on the e flat 0.002 seconds early. I deem it SACRELIGIOUS

the way eddy sang the meme musik at 4:45 kinda cracks me up bcus first i noticed he sang literally in tune then i recalled he has perfect pitch and that shows even in meme bgm what even

Btw, the actress can seriously play the piano ( she even released some pieces she composed)..... not a ling ling music genius, but her music is nice

When it’s « accurate » TwoSet : sOmEthIng iS gOinG oN

I LOVE Le Concert. I really think that is one in a few movies that treat music seriously. The storyline is all focused in a situation that occurred during a Tchaikovsky violin concerto presentation in the past, and those events lead to the final scene (that one two set are showing in the video). It's kinda weird in some scene, like the chaotic begining when everyone is out of time and not together. In the begining all orchestra is out and a chaos because EVERYONE is a retired musician, and they went to play this last concerto after so much (you'll need to watch to know!). The went to another country and everyone was more concerned to do a tour than playing. This lead out to a concern to the maestro who is trying to make this happen because of the soloist. Her is very upset because there isn't a rehearsal and a lot of unprofessionalism. The chaos in the scene stops when she started to play the solo and everyone remembered her mom that one day played with them in the past, and the real scene begins. There is a lot of little details that make this scene incredible, on music technique and plotpoints. Her acting is really good for someone that doesn't play the violin and is good to know that there is some actors who cares about doing the right stuff. I really recommend the movie, it's funny and have a cool story around this amazing concerto that I love so much ♥ Thanks for this funny review Twoset. Love you!

She trained 5 months with Sarah Nemtanu of thr Orchestre National de France. Also for the Tarantino fans, Shoshanna anyone?

Funny how Eddyy is showing his perfect pitch even when he just doing the Illuminati sound... Lol

Dude, Melanie Laurent is a reaaally good actress. She also acts on Inglorious Bastards and the acting and filming on that movie is sick.

You guys are the reason that movies are becoming accurate

2:19 honestly it sounded like my school orchestra

There's a 2002 Chinese movie called "Together" and all the violin playing is pretty much spot-on imo-- way more legit than anything I've ever seen with violin playing in movies

I'm sorry but when you say "bow hold" really fast over and over it starts to sound like "butt hole"... you're welcome.

When I was little my dad showed me this part from the Concert and after that I just fall in love with the violin. So all the summer I begged my parents to go to the violin lessons. And here I am after 6 years.

notice how eddy is singing the illunati song at perfect pitch 04:45

Eddy’s perfect pitch while doing the illuminati sound tho 😆

The guy at 3:57 is Anghel Gheorghe an incredible musician from Taraf de Haidouks a roma taraf band from Romania. Check videos from Taraf de Haidiouks I guarante you will be mesmerized.

That's Shoshanna from Inglorious Basterds :)

React to the rehearsal scene of the same film. There, the gypsy violinist, Caliu, played Paganini, after only hearing it on a tape before. (I doubt he can read notes)

Hi guys, Actually "her" left hand was Mathilde Borsarello (musical director and concertmeister of l'Orchestre de Chambre de France).

I'm early! I admire the actress' dedication to learn the movements/where her hands should be even if she can't really play. That's real acting.

A lot of this is just the unavoidable problem of making a film, particularly when the actors are playing music. You MUST have an audio track that provides more continuity than you can get from the multiple takes that are required for film, and generally NONE of that actual audio is going to come from the filmed performances. So the different bow-hold from one take to the next is not at all surprising. Also, the editor of the film has to piece all of these camera angles together, and it's safe to assume the editor is not a violinist (nor are they really making the film for violinists), so it's not surprising that some angles show the soloist playing a different phrase than the audio being played at that time.

Brett: also like, you don't really keep looking at the conductor while you play I DIED SODJDK

For those of you who don't know, it is Tchaikovsky - Violin Concerto in D major

audio and recording is usually separate and cut into small bits so you can do editing maybe they messed up the syncing for part of it

One of my favourite movies! Great acting! This final scene is incredible ! The actress is not only trying to copy the violinist moves so well, knowing that she didn't know how to play, she expresses so many emotions and feelings! Impossible not to cry at the end!

I recommend this film whole heartedly, it’s really good. Comedic yet very moving.

I like when twoset go serious about this review, so much detail and explanation. Now I know how hard it is to fake good violin play.

Ah yes, the fine tuners, it's always 1☝🏼 2✌🏼 Or 4🖐🏼

“She’s way too-“ *dramatically turns head and places chin on chin rest* “tense” Why did I almost start laughing at that point

the gipsy guy in the movir is caliu. search: caliu paganini and see his part in the movie. he basically listened the concerto and sung it by ear as he has no music academic lessons. He is part of clejani taraf(search it out too).

Me reading the title: Accurate violin acting? That’s illegal! Also me: oh...

Imagine if twoset were as critical as previous movies/dramas compared to this video (checking fingering, bow changes, stiffness, etc) their vids on those chinese knockoffs will reach 8 hours lol

Literally having such a bad day and y’all are making me laugh so hard. Bless you boys

4:46 perfect pitch im *screaming*

Watching Brett and Eddy has inspired me to pick the cello back up after a year or so without playing. Thank you guys for making practice/playing a classical instrument a lot more fun ❤️

I don’t even play any musical instruments and watch their videos cause they’re so entertaining. Don’t ever stop uploading videos.

Please watch and review the 1999 movie: Music Of The Heart which stars Meryl Streep as a violinist and a teacher! At the end they have a scene where they play at Carnegie Hall in NYC and have some famous cameos from Itzhak Perlman, Joshua Bell, and others to perform the Bach Double. Would love to hear your guys thoughts and insight of it all. 😊🎻

"it doesn't get easier! Violin is one of those things that the more you practice the harder it gets" facts that break my self-esteem... gotta go practice now, enough TwoSet.

*"that sounds much worse than a youth orchestra"* MY CHWEST

"You don't really keep looking at the conductor.. It's a bit... Creepy" Well as a choir conductor is totally the other way round, especially if the members are new or junior. They just look around and never focus on signals; begins 1 beat later or never hold enough beats LOL I was like "I don't care if you sing out of tune of whatever now, please look at me or at least my hand!!" HAHAHAHA Anyway, I want to thank Bret and Eddy for their enthusiasm in music. Which inspire me to continue to learn music (although I ended up in Med school) *real sad case* . Watching ROASTING video is so fun and both of you are so truthful, which is why I decided to subscribe to, for the first time in my life, and ONLY to TwoSet violin, after being active on internet for about 11 years. I'm really grateful, from the bottom of my heart. Someone please tell them about this!!!! :D

I just started watching your videos like two months ago... I didn't know anything about classical music before so I was just happy to recognize Tchaikovsky violin concerto here!

"The Concert" is an extraordinary movie in every possible way. Ling Ling Hi from Mexico

When they said “bow hold” I thought they were saying butthole and I was getting so confused

It was nice at first. *But we all know how it ends.* *NOT ENOUGH PRACTICE! Y’ALL SHOULD PRACTICE!*

I love that movie! They started off rocky because they havent had a rehearsal after many years. Her mother was a violinist who played with the whole orchestra that many years back. Subsequently, when she started playing, they got back the feeling from many years back 🥰

You guys should review scenes from the movie amadeus

As a person who has made multiple productions, I can tell you. Making this was incredibly difficult. This scene was shot multiple times, meaning different bow holds. There is usually only one camera for a standard production, so all of those shots were filmed in different takes when filming the scene.

“Violin’s one of those things the more you practice the harder it gets” Good thing I’m a viola lol

Editing in the left hand on a moving person would be impossible. No doubt she was told to stay as still as possible. She did that really well... BRAVA! 👏👏👏

As a film major, I believe the differing bow holds could be from using two different shots from perhaps two different filming days or two separate takes of that angle. It would make sense if she adjusted her hold between takes, but idk for sure.

I just love y'all so much Brett and Eddy, you inspire me to play to the violin everyday for 40 hours.

Okay but everyone should watch this movie, "Le Concert", it's just sooooo good.

You guys are posting videos sooo funny, you're analyses are soooo hilarious, it's actually helping w/ my depression 🤣😭

Editor-San really had fun editing the intro to this video 😂😂😂😂

The last time i was this early Liszt was breaking his first piano

This movie is actually called "Le Concert". It's a very good comedy film about classical music, you guys should definitely watch it! And btw the soloist that was playing Tchaikovsky was from Paris's orchestra. She's the one being filmed from the orchestra's point of view, and when we see the face of the actress, she's only on playback. Great movie, seriously consider it!

Eddy: "So it's not a double..." Michael: ..or is it? *cue Vsauce music*

She's so pretty I couldn't look at the instrument - wassa matta with your guys? Can't you appreciate how pretty she was?

It's actually WAY more difficult and frustrating to learn to act to play this well rather than to actually learn the instrument. As you said, how frustrating it must've been to learn just the right hand movements without the left hand. Respect for this artist!

PLEASE do "The Devil's Violinist" with David Garrett!!!

It’s cause she’s a musician. Pianist is part of her background and takes pride in getting these parts down❤️

I feel so nerdy watching this and being like "HAHAHA YEAH THAT WAS WRONG"

This is Mélanie Laurent, French actress in French movie The Concert from 2009. Imdb trivia says that she just started learning violin a few months before film production.

you should react to violin playing in a turkish show called 'Magnificent century'

The editor is a whole mood 😂

I keep hearing ""Butthole" when they say "Bow hold" and now you too! lol

What a miracle, a movie that TwoSet can't roast because it's already well done ✨

The beginning reminded me oddly enough of my middle school orchestra. Very proud to say I helped by playing out of time and tune.

I love this movie and I was waiting for you to do this!!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️

Amazing actress and drop-dead gorgeous!

Please react to more of Nodame Cantabile (original anime) since you only saw one clip!

Dam... I clicked so FAST you don’t even know I was just listening to my Japanese songs, TwoSet popped up and I literally dropped my phone because I clocked so hard. The screen cracked... but it’s all good!!

Superb violin AND cello acting in it!! You two would be shOOk

Her bow hold was like the Italian fingers meme for a second 😂😂😂😂😂