No video :(

The MOST CONTROVERSIAL dismissal on the CHANNEL!

Подписаться 192 тыс.

Просмотров 61 тыс.

50% 1

I used my GoPro to film my village cricket match against Spalding Cricket Club. The most interesting part of this cricket match was Matt Carter being given out for handling the ball. Not the best match for us!
To become a SUPERFAN support the channel via PATREON - / canyoucricket
Merch & Affiliate DISCOUNT codes below:
B3 Kit - cyc10 (10% off) b3cricket.com?b3_affiliate_ref=688
Payntr Spikes - CYC20 (20% off RRP) payntr.com/
Mystery Delivery - CYC10 (10% off) mysterydeliver...
Merch - CYC25 (25% off) burst.health/e...
Burst Health Clothing - CYC25 (25% off) burst.health/
Instagram - ....
TikTok - vm.tiktok.com/...
#cricket #gopro #villagecricket #b3cricket #payntr

Опубликовано:

5 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 273

@canyoucricket 9 месяцев назад

canyoucricket.com/

@henzaaaaaaa Год назад

I'd be so embarrassed to appeal for that yet alone keep the appeal. Whilst it is legal under the law, i personally think that's disgraceful from the other team

@HarryThompson-sl9tw Год назад

Same the other day something the same happened to one of my teammates 😢

@An_Oni_Moose_ Год назад

Especially since the ball wasn't going towards the stumps. LIke for real.

@An_Oni_Moose_ Год назад

Yep, I've played against a team that had to say "He's a nice guy when he's not playing" for one of the gobbiest, nastiest pieces of shit on the field. The only thing he wasn't was bigoted - just to give some sort of idea of what kind of gobshite he was.

@saidbenrahma9129 Год назад

@@MixesAw oh so ur based near Essex yeah ?

@MattPlayz Год назад

Like you’ve said by the laws it is clearly out so what about this is unsportsmanlike

@MrJJuK Год назад

Batters pick up the ball all the time and if I appealed that, everyone would just laugh and tell me to shut up.

@jakhodgkins8806 Год назад

If that wasn't a professional player I guarantee you they wouldn't have upheld that decision. When we had Mark Vermuelen playing for us teams tried every form of controversial methods to get him out because they knew he would smack the attack to all parts.

@Stumoo Год назад

I heard Mark Vermuelen had a bit of an unstable temper, and blamed it on a couple of blows to the head he got playing top level cricket? Don't want to rely on hearsay - how did you get on with him?

@jormundgandr88 Год назад

@@Stumoo I'd also be interested in finding out

@jakhodgkins8806 Год назад

@@Stumoo Thats correct mate, he has a checkered past with his temper which he said he thought was caused after suffering an horrific injury to the head. We as a club (Newquay CC) did receive quite a bit of abuse for signing him up but everyone deserves a second chance and he came over and was absolutely brilliant; he coached the adult teams, the kids and the ladies/girls, he was at every training session, went to all the social events and was an absolute pleasure to have. I batted with him a few times (I'm a lower order batsmen) and he really copped a lot of chirp but never reacted once just got his head down and batted. I would certainly have him back. He had some wonderful stories of playing test and ODI cricket that he shared with a twinkle in his eye. Still keep in touch with him.

@Stumoo Год назад

@@jakhodgkins8806 Good to hear. I'm not good enough to play much with top cricketers! I've played against Australian international Asha Smith, who absolutely carted us, and with Chris Murtagh (Tim's brother) and Marjolijn Molenaar, Dutch international.

@rl3799 Год назад

I think there is a difference between picking the ball up and chucking it back to the opposition (normally after having asked) and catching a ball that quickly after playing it, when it is not certain where it might go. Personally I would not appeal, but your bat should have just knocked it away with his bat.

@doyadirty3804 Год назад

U supposed to use ur feet to give the ball back u shudnt pick it up or knock it back infact the best thing to do is let the opposition pick up the ball they damn self

@neilgannon205 Год назад

Any other batsman, the appeal is cancelled IMO. They see it's the big dude who can easily score a ton off 20 overs, and they continue on with it to give themselves a better chance to win the game

@thomasjones3784 Год назад

Spalding cricket club should be ashamed!! anything to get the pro out i guess? the fact they were laughing also says a lot, awful club

@Cover23Drive Год назад

Absolute brain fart from Matt unfortunately, that's out every day of the week. Umpires made the right decision and opposition well within their rights and the spirit of the game to uphold the appeal. I'd certainly expect to be given out if I grabbed a ball that was still absolutely in play out of mid air.

@SolUploadz Год назад

Just saw that you made 41 today, brilliant stuff! Good luck and hope the good form continues 👍

@canyoucricket Год назад

Thanks 🙏

@MrJJuK Год назад

They only up held the decision because he's a gunner cricketer and it's a league game.

@viewfield5 Год назад

pretty much spot on, if that's say King the captain are they upholding the appeal..... course they ain't. If the game wasn't as one sided as appeared, reckon that be a difficult game to umpire !

@GIBBO4182 Год назад

Exactly what I was thinking

@noidea-sq3fw Месяц назад

In lower level cricket he's a bully with the bat but I just looked up his professional record with notts.best score of 33 in all formats... decent with the ball though.he left notts after 9 years

@davidl63 Год назад

Correct decission - Matt is a professional and should know better. Plus the deliberate breaking of the stumps is a level 1 offence and the umpires should have reported this.

@sgxgreedx8370 Год назад

they did and he got a level 1 :)

@jamesbarwick1457 Год назад

If it was anyone else they wouldn’t have upheld their appeal. It was only because they knew Matt was a huge wicket that they were happy to have him out in that manner…

@canyoucricket Год назад

I think you're probably correct 💯

@gameguru1234 Год назад

I agree that the ball was nowhere near hitting the stumps, but I was always taught not to touch the ball until it had come to a full rest on the pitch.

@anglosaxon5874 Год назад

Agreed. Same.

@XaviersBonsaiRetreat Год назад

Regardless of the decision I think you might benefit from a couple of games without the headcam. I know it sounds tough and maybe someone else in form can wear it instead. You need to concentrate on regaining the touch you have lost. There is an obvious external pressure and that is your desire to provide great batting content as well as team content. Thanks for all the hard work you put into this channel and I look forward to seeing a century from you soon. Cheers

@canyoucricket Год назад

Thanks for the advice! Definitely something I've thought about. Managed to get a 40 odd this weekend so hopefully a change in fortune for the next few weeks 👌

@XaviersBonsaiRetreat Год назад

@@canyoucricket This is why we love and hate this game so much :)

@canyoucricket Год назад

Too right!

@saidbenrahma9129 Год назад

You know you’ve watched a lot of Canyoucricket when it’s come to a stage that you roughly know roughly how much Gareth is gonna make based off the length of the video. And Gareth, Dw the runs will come soon bro.

@canyoucricket Год назад

😂😂😂 too true! Thanks for the support Said 👌

@alpinecricketer Год назад

That's the difference between Saturday and Sunday cricket right there. Besides the quality of cricket, I feel often the balance of having fun and trying to win gets tipped too much in the way of competitiveness. Which I understand when you're playing In prem and div1, but it's still club cricket and spirit of cricket gets a kick in the teeth. If I was playing that game I would not have enjoyed the rest of that match.

@canyoucricket Год назад

Love this comment 🔥

@alpinecricketer Год назад

@@canyoucricket thanks mate hope it didn't put too much of a downer on your game.

@canyoucricket Год назад

🔥🔥🔥

@peterjohnson343 Год назад

I agree, poor form with that dismissal. Didn't look from the footage that it was going to effect the Stumps and he was just trying to hand it back to the fielder. I always make the fielders pick it up for that reason but I would feel embarrassed if I was on the fielding side and my captain upheld that appeal.

@thomaspreston8587 Год назад

Perfectly fine to appeal. Up the town

@CentreHalfForward Год назад

Haven’t been on the channel for sometime, been busy. I’ll be back and hopefully I’ll comment on the upcoming videos. Love it, keep it up!

@canyoucricket Год назад

Good to have you back! 🔥

@CentreHalfForward Год назад

Thanks mate

@martindunford2291 Год назад

pretty decent delivery there actually....agree shot selection not the best but your assessment of the problem is intelligent, apposite and positive....you'll be fine !

@canyoucricket Год назад

Thanks Martin 🔥

@rexreid7615 Год назад

i umpired for years,Sydney grade and other districts,ball went str8 down and back up he caught it,no one can say if or not it would of hit the wickets,spirit of the game shouldnt even come into it,he was out,sorry. :)

@richardgrant2077 Год назад

Interesting Matt dismissal. I would say that there was a chance of the ball back spinning into the stumps. Tough call but correct decision made.

@llisntcoolj2375 Год назад

They seem like a right set off bellends. The chelp you got on your way off the pitch, proves that.😊

@fromomelastocarcosa3575 Год назад

The angle was unclear. For me if there is ANY chance (even small) that the ball is threatening the stumps then the fielding team has every right to sustain the appeal. Based on the angle we have its the correct choice, but if there were fielders at the side who could see the trajectory of the ball was forwards then that would be unethical. I had thought when I saw the title that it maybe had been a misinterpretation of the Hit Ball Twice rule which I've seen wrongly given a couple of times in village.

@AndrewDenny-Tassielad Год назад

Can't be doing that, out every day of the week!

@chrisspencer2852 Год назад

And Mr Carter has a week off for Abuse of Equipment!

@Blurdage Год назад

The law is pretty clear - dont handle the ball. My feeling is the same for a mankad - leave early and you can be run out. Just dont put yourself in a position where you could be dismissed. Why have a law if you cant/shouldnt use it.

@bartsimho1192 Год назад

The Handled the Ball is out. No questions about it. Carter should have checked with the WicketKeeper if he could pick it up beforehand. In this case I don't think there can be a talk about the Spirit

@grantgarland3905 Год назад

From someone who has played cricket at a high level like he has he should know better to not touch the ball. This spirit of cricket is bullshit the ball was not dead and he handled it so simply he is out. I think the worst part of all of this is the way he smashed the stumps when given out. That was the worst behaviour out of all of this scenario.

@philburtonfrench Год назад

Agree with the Spalding team - ball could have done anything as it dropped back down. Batsman was way too eager to catch it, so fair decision in my view

@BananarulerYT Год назад

Personally, I couldn't see the ball going towardst the stumps but I would say it wasn't out because the ball bounce straight down and he caught it . But Still great video hope you get back into scoring form and hope that u and ur team get back into winning ways. Great Video!

@canyoucricket Год назад

🔥🔥🔥

@mrg-cardcollector6601 Год назад

There’s picking the ball up, and then there’s doing what he did! He caught it straight away, and even though it’s not in the spirit of the game, he’s leaving himself open to be given out! Doing what he did was a little cocky to me!

@curtisgallagher9605 Год назад

Is the opener for Spalding - Neil Attapattu? Great content as usual Gareth!!

@canyoucricket Год назад

Yes it is 👍 thanks Curtis!

@Flabogoose Год назад

I think it was a mistake of Matt to have picked up the ball while it was bouncing like that, with that sort of bounce there can easily be backspin on the ball that could have it dribble towards the stumps. It was very likely never going to hit them, but in a league game I would never have just caught the ball like that and would have knocked it aside with my bat or leg. It is one thing to pick up a dead ball laying on the ground, it is different while it is still in motion. I do think it is very cheeky of the opposition to have the appeal upheld as it is 100% not in the spirit of the game, but in league cricket there are so many teams that play to win at almost all costs that I also think Matt just took a needless risk on this occasion.

@canyoucricket Год назад

Thanks for the comment 👏

@listey Год назад

You talk about the "spirit of cricket" regarding the opponents not withdrawing their appeal, but make no mention of Carter breaking his stumps after being given out. I know which I think is the bigger issues when it comes to "spirit of cricket".

@jamerslister Год назад

As a fellow top order batsman who is also struggling for form, it is reassuring to know I'm not alone. Last season I had my best ever season scoring over 600 runs. This season so far in about 7 games i've managed less than 50 runs. Everything you said as a factor is definitely ringing true for myself. Personally, I believe it to be a combination of them all - technique struggles, mental stresses in daily life along with the early season weather issues we had which resulted in less than ideal batting tracks. I've accepted i won't reach the same heights i did as last year but i know runs will come. Patience and going back to basics are whats required and coming to the crease with a clear and relaxed mind i think are key. Runs will come Gareth, just stick at it.

@canyoucricket Год назад

Thanks for the comment James. Hopefully we get in the runs soon 🔥

@dannyJK5946 Год назад

That is a shocker 😅lucky for the other team that no one else is going to know about it 👀

@Wardygolf Год назад

outrageous from their team, it is not out at a club level as it was never going to roll back onto the stumps, very unlucky for the batsman.

@PUR3xNinjaz Год назад

you guys get to play so many game in England were lucky to play 14 odd games in Australia

@testingsomething5961 Год назад

Waiting for your next match 🏏 Your channel is really good and your content are very interesting! 🔥

@canyoucricket Год назад

🔥🔥🔥

@JoelThrelford Год назад

In my opinion Spalding had every right to uphold the appeal everyone who has played the game knows you can"t do that. Although it may seem harsh it was dumb brain fade and deserved to be punished. Also the game looked to be played in bad spirits by your team as well only wickets taken received quite the send off

@Mulletman4 Год назад

Genuinely the audacity to appeal for that. Wrong. Foul just Foul

@scottmoody2561 Год назад

100% OUT I have no idea why a batsman would handle the ball in any situation.

@theaussiez5133 Год назад

Mate that’s the most controversial dismissal ever

@proxysp939 Год назад

I had something like this happen in one of my games before but instead it was a blatent obstruction and they ran our player out and their captain said "why would we not keep the wicket?" so we ended up losing the wicket

@Seannn1 Год назад

That's horrific they've even appealed that let alone upheld it, hope the rest of your league see this and make the rest of their season a misery icl

@dazharan Год назад

Interestingly, Louis Kimber got given out exactly in the same manner in the County Championship for Leicestershire yesterday. The law is there and it is clear... don't catch the ball with your hands when it's in mid air.

@canyoucricket Год назад

@toplad321 yes saw that. Looked like he knew he had made a mistake as soon as he did it 👍

@jamesallen712 Год назад

Sorry but Matt Carter was definately 'out' handled the ball. I agree there is spirit of the law but that was a catch by Matt and then throw the ball. In general the side look flat and low on the field. Something is missing from the performance as I see it and it's running through the side.

@canyoucricket Год назад

👍👍👍

@pasdedeux4444 Год назад

No need to hit the stumps like a spoilt brat though? That's certainly not in the spirit of the game whether the appeal should have been withdrawn or not. My skipper would have torn me off a shred for acting like a five-year-old - then yelled at me again for handling it in the first place.

@bobburroughs6241 Год назад

I hope they are ashamed looking back on that.

@hyper96.03 Год назад

I think if it was an average player and not a professional, they’re withdrawing the appeal. It is what it is though- cricket can be a funny game.

@matthewhodgson7388 Год назад

Absolutely disgraceful dismissal. I played in a match with a mankad in the first over. That team who are always a disgrace are just like that. This game was in division 19 in leinster in Ireland. Only get wickets that you deserve

@tom_curtis Год назад

I don't get the claim the appeal was not in the spirit of the game. Matt Carter handled the ball while it was still in front of the stumps, and before its bounce on landing could be determined. IMO, anytime the batsman catches the ball in the air, or even in motion (as opposed to picking a stationary ball up of the ground), appeal for handled ball is warranted and should be given.

@billyhoyle2780 Год назад

I think I’m this instance it’s a fair call. If the ball was stationary on the ground and he picked it up, I don’t think anyone would have a problem. I think the fact he grabbed it while it was still in the air is probably the reason the opposition thought it was a fair appeal.

@jdodger1091 Год назад

After the Carter wicket, im mankading every single opportunity. Absolutely pathetic from the oppo

@v4jexii145 Год назад

Ridiculous that they can give that

@1littlelee Год назад

as an former umpire, this is unfortunately out, the batter CANNOT for ANY REASON use his hands to stop a ball before the ball passes the stumps, its OUT plain and simple with the 1 exception is if the ball has ended its roll in front of the stumps

@Ingens_Scherz Год назад

Disagree. That was a bit dumb and actually a bit arrogant of the batsman. The ball "belongs" to the fielding side. The batsman should never touch it unless he asks the fielding side first to return it to the keeper when it's close and dead, for instance. In this case, that ball was very much "live" and no opinion about whether it was going to spin back on the stumps or not is relevant. The batsman took away that possibility, which is really poor judgment. The umpires were dead right, and so were the fielding side. I would have done exactly the same thing (and actually have long ago) because it was certainly the batsman's fault. Perhaps the batsman has learnt his lesson. I hope so!

@bubbagump4344 Год назад

I'm not convinced that all 11 of the opposition wanted the decision to go that way. The opposition who appealed and wanted that decision, embarrassing. I'm a new subscriber and love your content by the way. Shout out to all the good sports out there! 👊

@canyoucricket Год назад

Thanks for subscribing 🔥

@bubbagump4344 Год назад

@@canyoucricketKeep going brother!💪🏏❤

@ZohairArqum Год назад

after PJ and Carter, who is the best batsman in the team?

@canyoucricket Год назад

Oli Caswell 💪

@wademillar3302 Год назад

The correct way to handle the "Handled Ball" Dismissal would have been for the Captain to withdraw the appeal and say to the batsman "Remember you can't do that...don't do it again"

@TheMradorable100 Год назад

I think in the SA Premier League, we wouldve appealed anyway (knowing the law) and assumed it to be given out based on the rule book. I think anyone would be upset to be given out like that and Ive seen my fair share, even at premier league level. At the end of the day a lesson is learned both ways.. 1. Dont expect the other team to be "gentlemanly" when you play them again, and 2. Dont touch the ball unless youve asked permission.

@canyoucricket Год назад

👏👏👏

@JoelThrelford Год назад

seems like a bit of a brat whacking his stumps over! did he get suspended?

@notmcgreo764 Год назад

that's just embarrassing for the other team.

@ashleyrutters2086 Год назад

Hope you find form mate wil be nice to see tou back in from

@canyoucricket Год назад

🙏🙏🙏

@marc5445 Год назад

The spirit of the game’s primary focus should be to abide by the rules. They are there for a reason. It’s out and if I was the opposition captain, I would uphold the appeal and I also wouldn’t say a word if this decision was given against my team.

@marc5445 Год назад

As for “the spirit of the game”, where was that when he then hit the stumps with his bat after the decision. That was the only thing done against the spirit of the game here.

@nathanspencer7429 Год назад

We had one early in the yr my bowler bowled it went on to almost hit middle there bat picked it up there owm skipper said it was out

@canyoucricket Год назад

In that scenario I would agree 💯

@luketerry2688 Год назад

Although I completely agree with all the comments, that it isn't a good look for the opponents and that it was probably due to who the batsman is. I can't help but think, why did he do it? Someone who plays the game professionally and is more than aware of the laws, why give anyone a decision to make?

@martindunford2291 Год назад

Tough and controversial decision but the law is the law and I was taught never to handle the ball even as to picking it up from the ground and passing it to a fielder.

@mjsgolf7004 Год назад

Why did he touch the ball ? It's nothing to do with him so he's only got himself to blame. There was a lot of spin on the ball so he asked for trouble by touching it. As for the appeal, not good. However, the batter can't control that so just focus on what you can control and let the fielders field

@Mulletman4 Год назад

This team lacks so much sportsmanship.

@SmithKarnt Год назад

How embarrassing to go through with the appeal. Poor form.

@reegandavis9076 Год назад

stress less mate runs are just around the corner! Only one day away from being in form 😉

@canyoucricket Год назад

🔥🔥🔥

@Mav-dm5mb Год назад

As to the handling of the ball decision, yes well done umpires for giving it, they had no need to discuss it any further, however the umpires were playing the game with spirit and your opposition has every right to uphold it, there spirit doesn't come into question as they didn't need to be asked in the first place. You are making an assumption the ball wouldn't come back and hit the stumps or a fielder running in collecting the ball and running either batsman out, though it's a rare occurrence, the experienced batsman shouldn't handle the ball until it becomes dead, batsman error and correct outcome.

@adrianemmott2105 Год назад

Naive from the batter given the ball is bouncing but poor in spirit. I’d also be questioning law 21.5.1 for the last wicket. The bowlers back foot look albeit a poor angle to be off the cut wicket so not within the return crease and as such a no ball.

@alanwebster9699 Год назад

I would never Mankad, I'll walk if I hit it, I wouldn't appeal if the ball was stationary but I'm appealing for that in any game. Batsman was daft and should know better.

@kiwias7830 Год назад

No way was that out!!!!

@Rehaan-nr3fj Год назад

in a 40 over match, my team managed to defend 66 with bowling out the opposition for just 26!

@wasntme7647 Год назад

Definitely not cricket! Poor decision by the other team to keep the appeal

@SkinheadRooney Год назад

Rlly unlucky mate terrible sportsmanship from them don’t worry

@dg9610 Год назад

It's the type of thing that you do whilst having a net. Doubt he'll be doing that again and will just let it drop dead and make the fielding team go and pick it up. Would like to think that a bit of commonsense would have prevailed as it just comes across as sheer desperation.

@uk.clickajobs Год назад

Out or not will always be a debate. For me, the law needs to change in that situation. No danger of being out and just reacting to pass the ball back, Surely 5 penalty runs would suffice instead?

@maroberto11 Год назад

Don't think you can say their wasn't a chance that ball could have hit the stumps

@Tubbs888 Год назад

Nope - The fielder's handle the ball, not the batters. Serves him right - It's not a net session.

@conbo9rulz Год назад

That wasn't out

@nigelwatson2750 Год назад

Ball wasn't going to hit the stumps.

@Up_The_Bracket Год назад

Embarrassing for Spalding. Nothing short of scumbags, hope it doesn't affect matt.

@kukhan4886 Год назад

Just saying or opinion at best. I think regular net practice helps a lot when you are not scoring, but bowlers in nets need to be fast and bowl all possible angles, also the net pitch should not be flat or dead because the main point of practice is lost.

@canyoucricket Год назад

👏👏👏

@3puttpar14 Год назад

Correct decision made, that’s out. Dumb move from someone with as much experience as Carter to handle the ball in that fashion regardless of whether or not the ball was going to hit the stumps.

@Bighandsdown Год назад

Spalding showing poor sportsmanship here. Why he grabbed the ball is beyond me. Won’t do it again I guess.

@benwilkinson9065 Год назад

at the end of the day to avoid getting out that way dont handle the ball

@owentaylor4350 Год назад

definitely not in the spirit of the game

@sargy9586 Год назад

Its the fact that hes a county player and knew it would be hard to get him out so they took the easy option. Unsportsman like personally. Just as bad as mankading