THE MOST HEARTBREAKING MOMENT YET! YES OR NO?!?! - YEAR3 CHAPTER 5 - HOGWARTS MYSTERY 

Shiny: I have no siblings Jacob: am I a joke for you?

yEAh I guessed it was a Forgetfulness Potion, because one of the ingredients is Lethe water, and in Greek mythology the Lethe is a river that wipes the memory of anyone who drinks it :)

I choosed yes! She drank the potion and she forgot her friend... Actually she don't forget herself or any other things. It's sad I know, because of me she don't remember her friend anymore but I needed to know what happen If somebody choose yes

Rowan grew up in London and I don’t have any siblings 😂😂😵

6:56 Shiny did you forgot that you have a Missing Brother!? Why did you choose *"I don't have any Siblings"* lol 😂

It would be interesting If we would found out that Penny was also bitten by these werewolf. Then she would be the Remus of the Story.

12:56 You’re welcome.

I love your commentary! I enjoyed hearing the thought process behind the decisions. Especially the “cause I’m your future husband” hahaha. Thank you for this!

That prefect she stunned was Chester, my prefect in Ravenclaw. That dude is so ambivalent, he keeps telling me off and egging me on at once...

I heard we will be able to start dating in year 4... Out of curiosity? Who will you all choose to date?

How come you have no siblings? Poor Jacob 😂

I’m still on year two, but I would totally choose no...we have our memories for a reason. Poor Penny tho😰 it’s really great that we are getting some good story and character development

I think scarlet and penny saw a wolf because if that was a werewolf penny wouldn’t have said why did it look like that when the boggart came also why did scarlet run towards a wolf with nothing to protect herself with instead of going to her parents. I would love if Dumbledore actually has a voice for his start of term and end of year speech

Congrats on the growth of your channel!

Ok so I watched someone else's gameplay, and they chose "yes" to Penny drinking the potion. So basically she drinks it and doesn't remember brewing or drinking the potion but she remembers who you are

RIP Scarlett 😭😭 that's sad for Penny

The prefect that was stunned was *MY* prefect and I think that Lethe is a river in the Underworld. I think the river of dreams or the river of forgetfulness but I can't remember which.

I watched this whenever you first posted it, I found smth out actually! Beatrice Haywood is an actual student in Harry Potter's first two movies she was a 5th year whenever he started attending.

Shiny, you make this game look better! This is the most emotional end of the video I’ve seen!

For everyone that’s wondering if she’s a werewolf the answer is no her friend died during the summer when following a werewolf

Lol your videos are great, love how chill you are. Gotta laugh though, did you really tell Penny the MC doesn't have any siblings when half this plot is about finding their brother?

How did you get to level 19 on all 3. I got to level 18 and it told me I maxed out.

How do you have such high levels of courage, empathy and knowledge

Hopefully when the next update happens you're able to keep an inventory of books, potions and what not. I would love the play pranks on the student body.

I don't know why I'm thinking this, but I think that in the future your character is going to face a werewolf with Penny and if you let her drink the potion to forget about the episode with her Muggle friend she will freeze again, but if she did not forget, she will save your life or just someone's life.

yooo i did the search for fang and penny for thoughts missions just last chapter and i was only on lvl 16 for courage and 17 for both empathy and knowledge. how’d level up so fast? 😭

During the Giant Problems quest when Hagrid asked me to go over to his hut for a meal, I couldn't clicked 'Yes' because I did not have enough attribute and I'm really bumped out about that. I felt so bad for Hagrid when I had to click 'No'. Is there any way for me to redo that quest?

I think there's gonna be only one more chapter than you'll have to wait for update. Only half of year 3 is available yet!!!

I can’t play anymore for some reason it keeps asking me to sign in through Facebook and it’s on a loop I’m only in second year.

Okay how long it took to you guys to actually complete 1st year? It feels like eternity due to this stupid energy bar. And I am not even in year 2, forget about 3!!!

I'm four chapters away from the end of year 2. Is there a bonding quest with Penny? I haven't had one with her yet.

Glad your game is going well, I would have liked to start year 2

You should play more often with the volume. Dumbledore says something at the ending every chapter

i said yes bec i believe that there are memories that are worth forgetting. i cant let something horrible like that hunt them forever. not all the time, these things can make them stronger. like for example someone suffered from a traumatizing drowning back when they were a kid, sometimes that could prevent them to try swimming again. if i could erase that memory, then that could absolutely help that person.

I got a hogwarts ad before this 😂

6:11 *"Are you an only child like me?"* Say what!? You have a Brother! Why is that one of the Choses!? 😯 Unless... You or your Brother was adopted!? So... you and your Brother are not Blood Related!? 🤔

How do you get this quest

I'm only on Year 2 at the moment but when I get to that part I'll choose no because of the reasons you said!

How are you replaying this a second time?

If you say yes and let her drink the potion, she drinks it and forgets. She doesn't even remeber what you've been talking about and that's it. There's not really any change to the story it's just a little segway. Hope this helps haha :D

I love Hogwarts mystery, but i am only in year 2 Edit: Yay, finally year four

bro, how are you winning in the house cup?

This was such a serious decision to make and I really wanted to help her forget but I think it's best if she remembers. I'd wanna remember my friend no matter how painful it could be. So I said no. Hopefully this won't affect our relationship badly.

3:21 Is that my in-game character at the end of the table to the right?

''Penny for my thoughts''? Is that a pun that she is going to die or kill someone? Reminds me on the lyrics: ''A penny for my thoughts, oh no, I'll sell them for a dollar, they're worth so much more after I'm a goner'' from If I die young

How much do you spend on the game ? Or have you hacked it

i am very confused, I'm only on level 3 but i have already helped hagrid find fang, are the tasks in different orders for everyone ?! i thought it weird as well, that i was in the three broomsticks with hagrid before everyone officially went to hogsmeade...

What you said about life was deep shiny reel deep

Hey is there a free energy in library?

Shiny is thirsty for penny lmao

Oh my GOSH!!! Poor Penny!!! Geeze!!! (Definitely haven’t gotten to this part yet)

Well I am in year 3 chapter 8 but I didn't get this side quest..Why?🙁🙁

How do i get a higher energy limit!??!,

Nice video, as allways. 👍 - My answer is no. 😞

Glad I’m not the only one in love with Penny 😂👌

I can’t duel with Barnaby. What can I do?

Intro song?

I love this vid

Thanks for this i dont have the patience

It was a forgetfulness potion, because in Greek mythology water from the river lethe in the underworld could wipe one’s mind

Penny has easily become my new favorite character

I didn't get this quest, but then again I did not complete a lot of side quests, which one should I finish to get it?

What if Penny was bitten by a Werewolf and she's the Remus of the story? That would also explain why she's so good at potion making!

Oh wow... This was intense and real...

I actually played my first version of this up until the end of year 3 and I chose for her to drink the potion. She forgot it and the exchange ended just like that. My name before was Scarlett too. This time playing through I will choose for her to not drink it.

can anybody here help me? :( I was on year 2 on cursed vault mission with Bill Weasley, after cast incendio it get stuck :((( i tried uninstalled the game and install again, i thought i will start over again and make new character, BUT i'm still on cursed vault mission with Bill, and once again stuck after cast incendio. What should i do?

I am in level 5 of Friendship with Penny..in Year 3 ..but why r you in level 1? You just met Penny in year 5 or wt?

In chapter 5 barnaby gonna ask you out and you only can say yes if your empathy is lvl 24

I would have said yes - she's frozen once; if she fucks up and panics again BECAUSE she remembers, someone could die. By forgetting, she won't remember she fucked up and won't be too scared to act in case she fucks up again.

If you click yes then penny drinks it and we ask her how she feels, but she doesn’t know what we’re talking about

Which level are you?

I have actually seen you on the game.Omg.I would be still playing it but my tablet broke and my phone wont let me download the game. My character name was Frisk Dreemurr btw

I didn't got that conversation but I'm already at level 3 with Penny, and chose her to go to the vaut

Just a quick fact, In Greek Mythology, the river Lethe is one of the rivers of the underworld. A drop of this river water can erase someone's memory.

Yea that was really sad

I'm only on chapter 3 on year 3 but i have already help hagrid find fang, the talk with penny is yet to come though.

Lol I’m already at year 4 but don’t remember this story (ironically)

yes

Okay this is kind of out of topic but are you from the UK? I thought you have british accent but I really don't have much idea. I'm seeing you from Spain. I came here to see what to say to her and at the end I said no.

There are two hidden energy thing on the eats tower the picture with the kid and a ghost by the ladder thing the ghost has an orange shirt on

i let her drink and she forget what we are doing but she still remember me

I’m near the end of the first year....... I’m a witch with a brother who got expelled searching for the cursed vaults..... now everyone thinks I’m mad (im also a ravenclaw)

BTW. I also said she shouldn't drink it. Curious abt what would happen if I said yes

I wonder why penny saw her friend get killed by a werewolf

I’m in the same year as this but I’m on chapter 9 I think I missed something

Hey cool we are in the same house !☺😎

Ok so i went here cuz i just pressed yes by instinct and now im regretting it

I haven’t had either of those side quests I’m in year 4

I chose to forget because Penny is so young for that guilt.

Im Bout to start year 4 but i gotta wait for an update cus its not released

I’m wayyyy passed this

Good choice Shiny. No. Suffering is quite indeed a part of life.

As someone else down here said we will be able to date in the 4th year. I hope that you will be able to date anybody you’d like cause else this game would be extremely homophobic.

Only in year two... but can you develop romantic relationships with the students there? If so who will be the romantic interest for female characters? Bill Weasley or the mysterious Slytherin student?

Penny froze my Prefect But Chester is so sweet why would she even-

Because of my bad level in empathy, i can not say yes to Hagrid 😟. Does it change something? Can you go to his house ?

I was forced to say no to Hagrid and it was soul crushing!! I couldn’t play the game again for a few days I was so angry Lol

You haven't ever help others un the game? Because I've Made several of those (i'm still un 2nd year) and I've heard Dumbledore's voice Many times after 'helping someone'.

Yo elegi que sí, pensé: hice el medio webeo para conseguirte los ingredientes y no te vas a tomar la wea? 😑 además era un recuerdo traumatico que solo la dañaba. Así que no me arrepiento de nada 😂

I said yes and penny forgot her memory about Scarlett