I think The Good Place borrowed "Jeremy Bearimy" from Boyfriend from 27,000 BC. The first time I heard that title, I imagined that it was an affectionate nickname Candace would use for Jeremy Johnson. Then I watched that episode, and I knew it was likely that Candace's teddy bear with a photo of Jeremy's face taped to it gave The Good Place the idea to use the name "Jeremy Bearimy" for their nonlinear cursive afterlife time loops. 😆