The NEW Voyager! - USS Voyager J - Star Trek Ship Breakdown 

Unusual, yes. See Sonic Adventure, Sonic Riders, Jupiter Rising, and so on. This is basically the concept of the USS Prometheus.

I absolutely love detached nacelles, detach everything! Do it!

That is the point it: to be distinctive

I’ve tried to get behind them but it’s really such an ugly look and it kinda ruins the ability to have cool looking ships anytime during or after this century. Discovery has had so many chances to be great and they just can’t figure out how to make trek feel new. It’s interesting how good strange new worlds is. I couldn’t stand Spock in discovery but under the SNW team Ethan great. I would love to see burnahm on a 5 year mission instead of getting traumatized and fighting galaxy ending threat after another

Agreed, you'd think the fields holding the nacelles in place would be vulerable to interference or something at some point.

Replicator technology would change the world tomorrow. That would make even poorest people provide all their basic living needs

Secret Space Program. Gift Economy.

While I would like to live in star trek’s future, I would not like to live in star trek’s *present.* WWIII does not sound fun.

@@the_kraken6549 yeah london and most major cities are gone, wasnt like the east coast destoryed?

@@tsgamer7909 If I remember correctly it was the west coast. In the Voyager episode “Future’s End” they go to California and mention how it’s all going to be underwater.

What on earth would Scotty say?

I don't like any of the ship designs from Discovery!

I've said exactly the same thing since they first encountered the tech. It drives me CRAZY!

I could not disagree more, that’s making the assumption that it’s connected by something like an electromagnet and that loosing power effects the connection. I think you’re thinking to small, this is 900 years into the already future. Who says the connection can’t be invisible but still permanent. Maybe whatever materials they’re using in the nacelle construction is naturally super magnetic, they’ve found a way to extend the natural forces that keeps atoms together to a macroscopic level, some sort of subspace deformation or gravitational effect, cosmic string, idk. Or have we seen the Voyager J lose power, maybe they do connect. We see the Discovery’s switch between modes, maybe there is some sort of emergency failsafe that if power cuts programable matter automatically forms between them. But that’s the great thing about science fiction, it’s sparks imagination and thought, just saying that impossible/impractical is so boring. 🤷‍♂️

I found all the space ship designs for Discovery's future somewhat retro looking. Paramount has been so busy making prequels that we never get to witness new possibilities, new generations of progress, whether technological or artistic. Maybe the pared down look (though just a simplified, dimensionally identical copy of Voyager) is meant to convey how common place and mundane the notion of space travel has become in the far future. I get this feeling especially with regard to Booker's ship, which almost looks like an ordinary building that can fly. It's interesting that Osira's one demand when parlaying the federation was for it to accept capitalism, so one can't help but compare this to the profane designs of ships in the century depicted.

And of course TOS!!

How about Voyager A to I? We've seen the other upgrades of Enterprise.

@@Goodiesfanful I am sure future trek universe we will see the voyager A we now have the entperise J

@@wayneheyes904 yay!

So do they still have turbolists in this future or does everyone just beam where they want? What if you can't transport but need to go from the saucer to the secondary hull? Grrrrrr

and it just looks stupid too

Personal transporters. Everyone has one in their comm badge. Just don’t tell Badgey; he’ll get too many evil ideas!

We haven't seen enough of the technology in Discovery or have the characters discuss the designs flaw with detached nacelles. For all we know the nacelles and secondary hull maybe designed to to automatically create a physical connection with the hull in case of a rapid power loos or severe damage from an attack. What we need is an episode from Discovery showing the pros and cons of a detached structures on starships and not just dialogue between characters about the benefits or downsides of this tech 32nd century tech.

@@rccraig7580 Agreed. We do need an episode explaining the pros and cons of detached structures on star ships but, even the case of severe power loss, you would still need some power to initiate a physical connection between parts. But, I too feel an episode explaining all this is much needed.

I've think about the similar aspects - transporter and space delivering systems. Same opinion on if opening inner transporter control equipment, there is unnecessary to open the shuttle doors, whether to the quantum tunneling system or laser beam as portal methods.

I believe there was a episode where they went into the future and Voyager was made into a museum if I remember correctly?

The show runners of Prodigy confirmed the original ship became a museum and why Admiral Janeway is aboard a new Dauntless class ship.

@@TIG5574 ok thanks ive not seen that show yet but makes sense turning her into a museum

@@adamraddish No worries although to be clear it hasn't been said in the show itself yet but the show runners addressed it in an interview because people wanted to know why she wasn't on Voyager.

Maybe they finally got smart a put the bridge inside the ship.

knowing them, you float in space like a torpedo for a bit

That's because the Iconians are a very very old species. They zravelled space thousands of years before mankind existed

I don't like detached components, the look or practically.

@@NALurking At the beginning, me top I didn't like 'em. But now I know why this is and I'm ok with it

That's because the Iconians travel with Warp, since thousands of years, so the improved it to the max.

@@NALurking There is nothing practical about it. Its just fantasy fluff they added in Discovery without having a logical sound explanation. It's jut not the spirit of star trek. It's like young kids who don't really understand star trek made all this and was like well they will just accept it because we made it.

Maybe in season 5

@FN-1701AgentGodzillaRangerPrime Ω i asume enterprise e is still arround and with worf in command and if we are going to see enterprise injust hope on disco parts its a beautiful and good looking ship and not like voyager j or that constitution style ship

We got a Enterprise F for a grand total of 9 seconds

@@madcap_9539 i wanted to see the d and f next to one another you know old generation and next generation and the enterprise g was a strange choise i like the ship design just wish we saw the yorktown refit from sto

@@kineuhansen8629 Agreed. The G should have been either another Odyssey or the Yorktown, not the Titan A. The Titan A should have just been renamed USS Picard IMO.

They've already addressed it :D

clear plastic

No, they stole the detached concept from Jupiter Ascending from Warchoski sisters

@@taiwansivispacemparabellum9546 They didnt steal it from that film. That film is so bad nobody watched it.,

she would have gone to Starfleet R&D to research her modifications, then put on Alcratraz island for a museum piece.

agreed. There's absolutely no way whatever they use, uses less power and is more reliable than physical nacelle pylons

Except that it doesn’t look outrageous. It looks retro.

There is only the Prime Timeline and Kelvin Timeline, no such thing as a “classic universe” or “Discoverse”. Hope that helps! - Jack

@@TrekCentral Yeah, thats what CBS says, it's a marketing ploy and a lie. There are WAY too many obvious in your face cannon violations in discovery. Least of which is the fact that in the classic universe NCC1701 has only 2 straight pilons untill the refit which happens while Kirk is captain, At no point did she ever have 4 sweaped back ones like she does in discovery; In clasic treck Pike is supposed to be the second captain and not the first; Discovery and clasic klingons look and act nothing alike.. The list goes on and on an on. Oh, and in clasic treck, the ability to scan weapons signitures predates the launch of the discovery, as the NX01 could do it. But Discovery couldn't in episode one. They couldn't even tell if the satalite had been shot or hit with a rock... In clasic treck that's something even shuttles that pre date her can work out as a trivial matter.

Maybe Voyager J will carry on the proud legacy of the Delta Quadrant in a new series and we get to see updates of the original Voyager's impact there.

You might like the ships in Halo, which are referred to as "flying bricks"

agreed

@HN It looks like you're trying to insult me but I don't think you've worked it out just yet. You should ask someone to teach you or for some advice for it because you're not doing too well. In fact, I'll feel bad if I don't help out. A good start is to say something that will hurt the other person, you're "Don't quit your day job." is a bit out dated and isn't really connected to anything; maybe based on your own ignorance but that's not really something we want to use when you're insulting someone else. That's like punching yourself in the face during a boxing match. You've got to actually do something worth while; just now all you're doing is throwing things at the wall and hoping it sticks and that's something people usually grow out of, because of it's clear ineffectiveness. Look at your comment for example, if I wanted to insult you I could look at that and see how unconnected it is from everything and that you're gambling on it landing. In response to that I could say something like "that's sounding a bit like projection there, I can see why you're struggling with work given how incompetently you communicate." or "that's probably the most relevent and interesting you've felt for a long time."; or I could look at your display pic and mention how your ability to insult is on par with your ability to give good financial advice. Thanks stranger, I found that vaguely entertaining. Enjoy the dopamine hit from getting a reply notification; I'll give you that reward.